Based Zionist Broad (@kessham) header
Based Zionist Broad (@kessham) profile picture
Joined April 2011
Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)Photo by Based Zionist Broad (@kessham)
Replying to @davidhazony @ooana
We should put our heads together!
Replying to @CodyLibolt
Then they are not conservatives. They need to understand that “progressive economic policies” are anti-market and therefore NOT conservative or even classically liberal. Even as a Democrat most of my life, I pushed back against the more “progressive” aka leftist elements on economics especially. 21 years as a researcher/writer/policy analyst at a nonpartisan economic research and policy organization taught me everything I needed to know. I went in with a basic understanding of economic basics, so the left never tempted me. But they I learned the details from some of the best, who represented a range of positions on particulars but all of whom adhered to first principles of economics. I finally had to disavow the Democrats but have become a Republican because I seeing too much of what you describe from the further right side of that party. Politically homeless I am, picking and choosing among candidates and hoping for the best.
2
Based Zionist Broad retweeted
Dee Snider, the voice of Twisted Sister's "We're Not Gonna Take It." When IDF soldiers made it their battle cry, he said: "Oh, hell yeah." Then: "Louder and prouder. Sing it out, boys." An 80s legend who picked his side and never blinked‼️
25
130
4
643
5,010
Replying to @breslovchosid
Sorry, but the problem is the religion of Islam, not individual Muslims who ignore many of the tenets of their own religion. We find this among Christians and Jews to varying degrees and with varying modes of expression. Sometimes good and often quite bad. Over a decade ago, when I was still working as a senior fundraiser at an Ivy League university, I hired a young man, a graduate student of psychology, as an assistant. He was an Israeli Arab. Nominally Muslim. His mother was a very prominent human rights lawyer in Israel who worked, among other things, as an advisor to the division that controls security at Ben Gurion Airport to ensure proper treatment of Arab Muslims coming into the country. My young assistant was a wonderful person, hoping to become a diplomat one day. Very pro-Israel. He went to school mostly with Jews and while his Hebrew was fluent and native, his Arabic was not. When we went for lunch together, this Jew and that Muslim would order things with bacon on them. He’d have a beer. We stayed in touch for a number of years and I followed his later career after his graduation. He got a fellowship at the UN and they insisted that on his bio he list himself as Israeli AND Palestinian. In all the time I knew him and worked with him he never ONCE called himself “Palestinian”. Only Israeli. But his UN bosses insisted he adopt this identification. His first love was actually sports (he was a junior tennis champion back in Israel) and I think he went on to work at other universities in their sports divisions. Sadly we lost touch. But I tell this story to illustrate that it is not the nominal Muslims who are a problem, but it is those that push a certain identity on them and then insist they follow the rules. And the rules DO come from the religion itself. Do not kid yourself.
11
Replying to @AnamaMOSS
Books have been written on the subject. But they do. It has been labeled at the Stockholm Syndrome, among other things. But people seem to be inclined to internalize the worst things that they are told THEY are.
5
Replying to @davereaboi
The stoopit. It burns!
1
20
What you’re describing from the historical and academic perspective is precisely what I’m beginning to recognize from the perspective of the arts and Socialist Realism/Socrealism. There is a much earlier intellectual foundation worth examining in Marxism-Leninism, particularly Lenin’s interpretation of imperialism as an expression of capitalism, the colonial theses of the Comintern, and the subsequent subordination of culture to revolutionary Purpose through Socialist Realism and Mao’s 1942 Yan’an Forum. One of the fundamental characteristics of Socialist Realism is that the Toiler is unthinkable outside the collective. The individual derives significance through participation in a prescribed historical Purpose. Jewish identity and continuity present a profound problem for such a system because their source of meaning, memory and moral obligation exists independently of that Purpose. Within the logic of Socialist Realism, this independence presents a direct challenge to the cultivation and supremacy of socialist consciousness. Consider the extraordinary contradiction of 1948. The Soviet Union supported the establishment of Israel while Stalin was simultaneously destroying independent Jewish cultural life within the Soviet Union. When Golda Meir arrived in Moscow as Israel’s diplomatic representative, thousands of Soviet Jews spontaneously gathered to greet her. Here was a visible expression of Jewish identity and continuity that the Party had neither authored nor prescribed. I suspect this moment helped crystallize the perceived threat that independent Jewish identity presented to socialist consciousness. It is also worth examining how this developing Soviet hostility toward Zionism intersected with earlier Marxist-Leninist revolutionary engagement with Muslim populations and the subsequent development of Soviet alliances with Arab nationalist movements. Furthermore, the contradictory accusations historically leveled against Jews, whether as capitalist exploiters, communist revolutionaries, rootless cosmopolitans or bourgeois nationalists, reveal something important about the architecture of totalitarian thought. The accusation can change while the designated enemy remains constant. What interests me about contemporary decolonization is not simply its misuse of historical terminology, but its apparent transformation into a teleological framework through which virtually all human experience must be interpreted. Even the Holocaust museum must now be made to serve that Purpose. It is no longer sufficient for Jewish memory to be historically truthful. It must also be ideologically useful. That is where I recognize the architecture of Socialist Realism, and why I think the implications for Jewish historical memory are so disturbing.
2
1
3
54
Replying to @ooana @davidhazony
This is all so timely as I have already started working on a think piece about how Holocaust education has already been corrupted to practically erase its Jewish particularism in favor of “fight all hate” and the equating of every “genocide” (some of which really are and some of which are certainly not) as being equal in importance and impact. Among other things, this is what has allowed the Leftist/Islamist propaganda to label the Gaza war after October 7th as a “genocide” perpetrated by Israel aka The Jews. This needs a much longer deep dive that I can do in this quick post, but that is exactly what I am working on in the editing stage now. Ironically, I was on a Zoom meeting of a 2G group I have belonged to for a long time (for those not familiar, 2G means children of Holocaust survivors). The topic of Holocaust education came up, with a couple of members discussing how to get Holocaust education mandated in their state. This raised red flags for me, as I have long been arguing that Holocaust education as it currently exists has backfired on us (as I point out above) and it is dangerous to mandate and education program when you have failed to even consider the content of that education program and who will be teaching it and with what type of pedagogy. I brought this up in the chat but no one responded or even wants to address it. This is a serious problem.
1
1
15
Consider what happened to Soviet Yiddish theater. The Moscow State Yiddish Theater was established with Soviet state support. Jewish culture was permitted and even celebrated insofar as it could be harnessed to the revolutionary project. During WWII, its artistic director, Solomon Mikhoels, chaired the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee, mobilizing international Jewish solidarity and raising millions of dollars for the Soviet war effort. In 1946, he received the Stalin Prize. In January 1948, Stalin had him murdered. Later that year, thousands of Soviet Jews spontaneously gathered to greet Golda Meir in Moscow, demonstrating a Jewish identity and continuity independent of the Party. The Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee was subsequently liquidated. Mikhoels’s successor, Benjamin Zuskin, was arrested. The theater was closed in 1949. Zuskin and twelve others were executed on August 12, 1952, in what became known as the Night of the Murdered Poets. Here we see the relationship between Narodnost and Partiinost, two fundamental principles of Socialist Realism. Jewish cultural identity was useful insofar as it served socialist consciousness. When it asserted an independent identity, memory, solidarity and continuity, it became a perceived threat. The very international Jewish relationships the Soviet regime had encouraged during the war were subsequently used as evidence of alleged treason. The Jew, in the eyes of the regime, had not sufficiently “transformed” and adopted socialist consciousness. His usefulness to Purpose had changed. Yesterday’s celebrated anti-fascist could become tomorrow’s bourgeois nationalist, cosmopolitan or agent of imperialism. I recognize a recurrence of this ideological architecture in the political culture amplified during the Obama era, in which effecting change and being affected by change increasingly acquired a moral imperative, a phenomenon later expressed through what came to be popularly called “woke” consciousness. Socialist Realism combatted “formalism.” Contemporary woke ideology combats “whiteness” and “colonization.” In each case, we must examine how these categories function, what they demand of the individual and whether their application is determined by reality or by ideological Purpose. The Jew is once again suspended in a kind of ideological usefulness limbo. We are white when it is useful to classify us as white, and not white when it is useful to classify us otherwise. We can be celebrated as victims in one context and condemned as colonizers in another. Our identity has not necessarily changed. Our assigned function within the narrative has. I think we must examine this historical precedent when considering the extraordinary demand to “decolonize” even Holocaust education. What happens when Jewish historical memory is permitted to exist only insofar as it serves an ideological purpose external to Judaism itself? We have witnessed the consequences of that before and recently.
1
1
2
50
Consider Holocaust survivor Vera Sharav, whose longstanding advocacy for medical ethics, informed consent and individual liberty preceded COVID by decades. When she continued her lifetime of challenging governmental and medical authority during COVID, she became politically inconvenient, subjected to the labels of “antivaxxer” and purveyor of misinformation. In March 2022, Sharav wrote directly to the director of the Dachau concentration camp memorial, accusing the institutional custodians of Holocaust memory of politicizing it. This brings to mind Dara Horn’s People Love Dead Jews. There is something particularly disturbing about the ideological convenience of dead Jews. The dead Jew cannot object to the interpretation imposed upon his memory. The living Jew can. The dead Jew cannot challenge the political purpose for which his suffering is being appropriated. The living Jew can. And now, through the proposed “decolonization” of Holocaust museums and education, even the memory of the dead Jew risks being subordinated to a contemporary ideological Purpose. The living Jew can be categorized as a colonizer while the dead Jew is enlisted in the ideological struggle against colonization. Once again, the Jew is suspended in an ideological usefulness limbo. It’s also, I think, no accident that all of this directly counters Kavod Hamet - respect for the dead.
1
24
Replying to @israel_advocacy
Are you familiar with Father Calvin Robinson? He used to be a Brit and a priest in the Anglican Church. He was stripped of his office for his vile rhetoric, fled to the US, and can’t seem to keep a job at any church. I’ve had his number for a long time, but this statement of his that the Jews should be expelled from the United States because “Christian nation” and all that has finally brought him and his equally vile Christian Nationalists/White supremacists buddies led by the truly odious Pastor Joel Webbon to the attention of a much wider audience who, I hope, are appropriately appalled. Perhaps Moser will become his buddy? Expect for Moser’s taint of Jewish blood, I suppose. The great irony is that Calvin is mixed race, Black father and White mother who raised him, and I have to wonder how long the true white supremacists will tolerate having him around as a mascot. Time will tell. Meanwhile, get out your barf bag. teapaw.org/danterhenderson/status…
Nick Fuentes endorsed Far-right British cleric Calvin Robinson, calls for "driving out the Jews” in America and other countries. What is the obsession with Jewish people? This clown has an 1970’s Afro and calls himself a cleric but spews hatred. Jews have been in America since the 1600’s. This is why we lose elections. Clowns like this associate themselves with the Republican Party giving all the ammo to the Dems to call us racist.
21
Already in the land about 2,000 years before his sixth-century terminology existed.
1
1
10
Replying to @bren45000
Not for no reason. Marco would squash Tucker like a bug if he had the chance. Marco is ten times the intellect that Tucker even wishes he were. Marco supports American and he supports Israel. Those are the reasons.
2
Replying to @Fair_and_Biased
And me. And most of the people both of us know.
6
Based Zionist Broad retweeted
Tucker Carlson is now attacking Marco Rubio for no apparent reason. He claims that Rubio has endless amounts of free time and essentially does nothing for the country. Says Tucker … a doomer podcaster and nicotine salesman. Tucker is officially a Leftist and should be treated as such.
498
307
72
2,086
227,164
I like your reference to “fancy terminology” aka academic obfuscating fluff! They have to work so hard to come up with jargon to obscure actual facts. 🤩
2
2
109
Replying to @ooana @davidhazony
That is exactly right. The use of “decolonize” applied to curriculum and virtually everything else in the wasteland of modern academia is an outgrowth of the framework of “settler colonialism” that first came into use back in the 50s and 60s in relation to British and French colonies in Africa. Then it was kicked into high gear by Australian anthropologist Patrick Wolfe with his 1999 book Settler Colonialism and the Transformation of Anthropology and his 2006 essay “Settler Colonialism and the Elimination of the Native”. I first became aware of the concept of “settler colonialism” applied to Israel from Palestinian-American academic Steven Salaita. His field, supposedly, was American Indian Studies. He is infamous for having been offered a position at the U. of Illinois and then having it rescinded when the president of the university realized his overt public Jew hatred. One of the few times in recent memory where a university president stood up to this garbage. Salaita is the one who applied the framework of settler colonialism to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, conflated it with the concept already applied to Native Americans, Whether one agrees with its usage with Native Americans in Canada and the United States is a different debate. Last we heard of Salaita he was driving a school bus. But I digress. This is where the academic call to “decolonize” practically everything comes from. According to Grok (and this is how I understand it): “The settler-colonialism framework treats colonization as an ongoing structure of elimination and replacement rather than a past event. This has driven the widespread academic and activist use of “decolonize” as a call to reverse those structures in knowledge, institutions, curricula, and everyday life”. The call to “decolonize” everything also elevates the “indigenous” and “indigenous ways of knowing” above Western thought, most obviously the use of the scientific method as the primary means to get to the truth of any question at hand. As Gad Saad often points out: things this stupid can only come out of academia.
1
1
47
Replying to @ooana @davidhazony
Well, what a surprise. No. Not at all a surprise. This problem with self-hating asajewforjihad “Jewish Studies” professors has been brewing for decades.
1
13
That is the truth! How the eff did we get here?
2
10