Maor Shani (@maorsh) profile picture

A social psychologist; politics, trance music, celiac disease, #Jewish and #Zionist

Osnabrück, Germany
Joined March 2009
Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)Photo by Maor Shani (@maorsh)
גם 50 שנה אחרי, המילים של אבא שלי, חיים הרצוג ז״ל, מהדהדות בעוצמה מול כל מי שמפיץ את השקר המוחלט שציונות היא גזענות. ההחלטה שאימצה היום המפלגה הירוקה הבריטית, הקובעת שציונות היא גזענות, היא בושה וחרפה. הציונות היא תנועת השחרור הלאומית של העם היהודי, והיא עומדת בבסיס זכותו של העם היהודי למדינה ולבית לאומי בארץ ישראל.
268
549
33
2,452
65,307
Maor Shani retweeted
The most thorough response to the actual accusations in the NAZA documentary I've read. From an IDF officer, (name/rank/unit provided) in which we can validate he was a part of and observed the processes the documentary attempts to cover. yairmiron.com/media/yair-mir…
36
519
52
1,495
81,705
UN Secretary-General António Guterres said: “I have never seen killing and destruction like Gaza in all my years as Secretary-General.” According to even the most critical reports, Guterres, 70,000 people were killed in the war in Gaza, a large proportion of them Hamas terrorists. During your years as Secretary-General: more than 600,000 people were massacred or starved to death in Ethiopia. 377,000 died in Yemen — that figure appears in reports issued by your own organization. 150,000 were killed in Sudan and 12 million were displaced. Hundreds of thousands have been buried in Ukraine. You didn’t see it? They died before your eyes. You simply looked the other way, because the Jews couldn’t be blamed.
2,388
11,363
754
44,166
882,746
לא ראיתי את הסרט ולכן אני לא מתכוון להתווכח עליו. אבל בתוך כל הסערה סביבו, חשוב לי לומר משהו בתור מי שהיה שם. אני הייתי שם. אנחנו היינו שם. בשבעה באוקטובר ראינו רוע שקשה לתאר במילים. עברנו בין הבתים, ראינו את התוצאות מקרוב ואיבדנו אנשים. את מה שהיה שם שום סרט לא באמת יצליח להעביר. שלושה שבועות אחר כך נכנסנו לעזה. שם נדרשנו להילחם באויב שלא משחק לפי שום כלל שאנחנו מכירים. אויב שלא תמיד עומד מולך במדים, שפועל מתוך מרחב אזרחי ומנצל את הערבוב בין לוחמים לאזרחים כדי להקשות עלינו להילחם בו. ובתוך המציאות הבלתי אפשרית הזאת נשארנו בני אדם. גם אחרי השבעה באוקטובר, גם אחרי שחברים שלנו נהרגו וגם אחרי שבועות וחודשים של לחימה. כמ״פ, הייתי שם כשהתקבלו ההחלטות. אני יודע כמה מאמצים עשינו כדי לצמצם פגיעה בבלתי־מעורבים. אי אפשר לספר את הסיפור של עזה בלי השבעה באוקטובר. אי אפשר לדבר על תוצאות המלחמה בלי לדבר על האויב שמולו נלחמנו ועל האופן שבו הוא בחר להילחם. שיח שמציג רק צד אחד של המציאות הוא לא שיח אמיץ או מורכב. הוא שיח מוטה. וכשהוא מוצג לעולם כאמת כולה, הוא פוגע במדינת ישראל ובלוחמים שנשלחו להגן עליה. אני הייתי שם. אני מכיר את המחיר. אני מכיר את המורכבות. ובעיקר אני מכיר את הלוחמים שלי ואני גאה בדרך שבה נלחמנו ובבני האדם שנשארנו.
1,181
3,162
169
14,440
309,870
Maor Shani retweeted
Regarding this film. 1. “Naza” (נז״א) is Hebrew for collateral damage, or unintended civilian casualties. There would be no reason to assess, count or consider “Naza” if the intention weren’t to minimize or avoid it. This is particularly difficult against an enemy like Hamas, for whom collateral damage means the same Palestinian civilian casualties Israel is trying to avoid. 2. Hamas doesn’t concern itself with assessing Israeli civilian casualties because civilians are among its intended targets. If they do count civilian casualties, it’s to measure success. To avoid any misunderstanding, its terrorists filmed their atrocities and fire hundreds of indiscriminate rockets at Israel, where a third of the population are children. 3. The film quotes one intelligence officer claiming a strike was approved that could result in 500 deaths. Yet no such strike has ever been recorded or even claimed. To date, the deadliest day of this war remains October 7, 2023. 4. I don’t blame outsiders for their ignorance. Most of the liberal world has forgotten what it means to fight a war on the home front. Its wars are fought with secret commando missions, sterile air strikes and distant battles. It is much easier to condemn the calculation that justifies an attack knowing innocent people may die when your own family isn’t under attack if you don’t make it. 5. The fact that a film like Naza can be made in Israel is itself a sign of a healthy democracy. Its writers and directors can accuse their own country and fellow citizens of grave wrongdoing and remain free to make their case. One thing is guaranteed: we will never see a Palestinian film about Hamas’s atrocities on October 7, nor even an Arab one. Everyone knows why. 6. Freedom does not confer immunity from criticism and antipathy. The director and participants made the film intending to damage their country’s reputation. They are entitled to make that choice. They are also expected to accept the opprobrium and consequences that come with it. Freedom to accuse does not mean freedom from being judged for the accusation.
167
342
54
1,491
251,732
Guardatevi “Fauda”. Altrimenti poi finite a Venezia ad applaudire stronzate per 25 minuti.
187
873
33
10,114
189,987
Maor Shani retweeted
For three years, Israel has repeated that Hamas and PIJ are disguising as "journalist", "doctors", "healthcare workers" and "paramedics", because they know that this disguise offers them some measure of protection, and that their death will cause outrage among credulous westerners. Hamas was right: all Western media just lapped up the stories about the record numbers of "journalists" and "doctors" killed, keeping almost weekly tallies and never asking any questions. And Israel was also right: Now that the war is over, Hamas and PIJ are gradually releasing lists of obituaries, identifying DOZENS of these so-called "journalists" and "doctors" as fighters. And what do the Western media do? Nothing. Just deafening silence. "Who cares? Let’s just move on to the next anti-Israel calumny." I cannot even begin to describe how angry this makes me. This is an unforgivable failure of journalism, and one that would never be tolerated in any other conflict. I approached several journalists personally and urged them to report on these revelations. To no avail. In a way, you can't blame them. The professional and social repercussions of publishing any story that is (or might be perceived as) “helping” the Israeli narrative are not to be underestimated. *** At least 18 Gazans killed during the war who were reported to be healthcare workers — including doctors, nurses, paramedics, and other employees of Gaza hospitals or the Hamas-run Health Ministry — have since also appeared in lists published by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad identifying them as members of the groups. Earlier this month, the Israeli [military provided details on 12 soccer players killed in the Gaza Strip during the war who it said have been identified as terror operatives, slamming their international portrayal as innocent athletes. Seven of the 12, including one who was a FIFA referee, were acknowledged as members by Hamas and Islamic Jihad. On June 25, 2024, Médecins Sans Frontières announced the death of Fadi Jihad al-Wadiya, a 33-year-old physiotherapist and father of three who had joined the organization in 2018. [...] Then in February of this year, Islamic Jihad identified al-Wadiya as a member of the organization, describing him as an assistant in its military manufacturing unit. [...] Al-Wadiya continues to be listed by MSF as one of its employees killed during the war, on an “In Memoriam” page. timesofisrael.com/gaza-death…
65
555
48
1,986
318,891
Maor Shani retweeted
My own rector, Petra De Sutter, turned the “Gaza genocide” into official university policy, threatening anyone who dared to question it. Multiple professors emailed the previous rector behind my back, urging disciplinary action against me. Philosopher and former friend @StijnBruers tried to get me fired and cancelled wherever he could. Invitations to give lectures were withdrawn; debates on completely unrelated topics were cancelled. I’ve never experienced this level of intolerance from self-proclaimed "progressives". And all to prop up an obscene lie that has now completely collapsed. Will any of these people ever apologize?
I haven't tweeted anything about the Gaza war for a while because I can barely contain my anger at the sheer dishonesty and irresponsibility of it all—it’s just not good for my blood pressure. Every major element of the “Gaza genocide” blood libel has now collapsed, yet there has been zero accountability, zero corrections, and zero apologies. It was all just a gleeful exercise in Holocaust inversion: accusing the Jews of the very crime they suffered eight decades ago. It was bullshit, and many of the people pushing it never believed their own bullshit anyway, as you could tell from their behavior throughout the war: substacktools.com/sharex/JIW… The gravest crime imaginable has been cheapened and weaponized as a tool of political propaganda, fomenting violence against Jews and Israelis around the world. But nobody seems to care—and least of all the Western media. Anyway, I can relate to @Mr_Andrew_Fox’s feelings: “Sometimes I think I am not angry enough, but the scale of the problem is almost too huge to be angry at, collectively. Towering rage must be split into smaller rages at each of the component parts of the blood libel machine. The whole sorry mess sickens me, and now the great indictment of Israel is coming apart, one revelation at a time. This fact is not being reported by a single damned one of the media outlets that have spent years screeching over the war in Gaza to the exclusion of almost all else. Famine, deliberate attacks on hospitals, the slaughter of journalists and children, and systematic obstruction of aid: each allegation was broadcast as settled fact and then used to prove genocidal intent. The same newsrooms and universities that thundered these charges have shown remarkably little interest in the evidence that now destroys each of these allegations. It is incredible. There is no aspect of the genocide allegation that has not collapsed.” /2 substacktools.com/sharex/M_6…
135
1,060
51
4,768
156,332
I can relate to @BoyGeorge. As one of the few journalists who worked a lot in Gaza & Israel and - based on that experience - dared to challenge the insane amount of lies and hate being spread about Israel and Jewish people, I felt the heat from the cowardly crowd. No regrets.
In the last few months, my life has changed beyond all compare. I made a decision to support my Jewish friends and without hesitation. I feel anxious almost everywhere I go but I do not regret my decision. I have seen friends that I have helped and supported turn on me without a conversation. It hurts because I know that not only do they know Jewish people but they have benefited hugely from the association with Jews. British Jews have always made London better from Philip Sallon's crazy nightclubs to the brick lane Bagel shop. More importantly and most shocking is that many of these anti Isreal people have zero political instincts. They only care because it has become fashionable to care. I would go as far to say that they are the biggest and most hideous cowardly fakes to walk this earth. Why are people who support their Jewish friends being called to account while these fakes, like Ed Sheeran, Jade and countless others get to pretend to care about a situation they could not comprehend even if they really tried. I support anyone calling for peace. That is what we should all be doing. How can Isreal be an apartheid state when Arabs and Christians live there peacefully and are part of the political system? As for Ed Miliband, clearly we know why he never because Prime Minister and Andy Burnham won't be getting my vote. In life there are people who see what's going on and others who just blindly follow the trends. Remember. Fashions change. Yes. I do mean you! open.spotify.com/track/3Sh2s…
198
647
15
5,268
109,403
Este documental abre uno de los debates mas importantes de la guerra moderna, sobretodo en guerras urbanas. Como se generan las reglas de proporcionalidad y distinción en un ambiente donde cada acto tiene acciones civiles importantes. Lo que si es distópico, es como llegan a las conclusiones absurdas y sesgadas y que el documental demuestra justamente lo contrario: Este dice que el objetivo de la guerra es el asesinato masivo e intenta mostrar estas entrevistas como evidencia de un genocidio, cuando toda y cada uno de los eventos descritos habla sobre objetivos militares claros en la forma de lideres y combatientes de los grupos armados de Gaza. El genocidio requiere una distinción muy clara sobre la intención específica de destruir del todo, o sustancialmente, a un grupo protegido como una nacion, etnia o grupo religioso. Lo que demuestra el documental es justamente lo contrario; que las acciones bélicas de Israel tienen objetivos militares claros y validos. Volviendo a lo importante sobre este documental; Hoy muchas de las guerras son urbanas y son contra ejércitos no gubernamentales, y por ende ocurren en dinámicas mucho mas complejas y mas lejanas al objetivo del derecho internacional y las rules of engagement. El daño colateral pasa a ser el tema central y el como los beligerantes actúan en una guerra: En el caso de los grupos armados de Gaza; clasificados como ejércitos no gubernamentales (Aunque realmente Hamas es el representante oficial del gobierno de Gaza), su método de actuar se basa justamente en que su opositor militar se rige bajo las normas del DI y ellos no. Que significa esto? Esto significa que todas las dinámicas de acción de estos grupos se ejecutan segun las limitaciones de Israel para actuar. Describo estas acciones a continuación: a) Lideres y combatientes NUNCA están solos si no es bajo la cobertura de los túneles. Solo aparecen en publico, rodeados de civiles, normalmente sus familias, porque históricamente esto hacia que Israel, aunque supiera su paradero, no pudiese actuar por el daño colateral que ese ataque causaría. Su dia a dia es bajar al túnel desde su edificio civil, hacer actividad militar bajo tierra, donde se incluye planear y cometer ataques contra Israel. En la noche, vuelve a su casa SOLO cuando hay un numero definido de civiles alrededor para evitar un ataque. b) Armamento: Todo armamento de estos grupos se guarda en infraestructura civil. Sean edificios civiles, hospitales, bodegas (incluso de la ONU) y mezquitas. Esto, obviamente para evitar ser destruidos en un ataque de Israel. c) Reuniones: Todo acto de comunicación entre militantes ocurre en lugares civiles, tanto mezquitas, como colegios, o durante la guerra en hospitales y lugares de acogida de la ONU y otras ONGs. d) Acciones militares: Todas estas se ejecutan sin uniforme militar y la mayoría de las veces desde lugares civiles. Todo esto obviamente es completamente ilegal bajo el derecho internacional y bajo las reglas de guerras, pero al ser grupos no gubernamentales, no se rigen bajo esta norma, generando un desequilibrio en los objetivos militares en comparación de un ejercito formal. En el caso de Hamas, estos saben perfectamente las reglas en las que se basa Israel históricamente y saben cuantos niños y civiles deben haber en un lugar para que Israel apruebe o no un ataque. Esto cambia cuando se desata una guerra existencial como es la de Octubre 7, y por ende las definiciones de proporcionalidad y distinción en Israel cambian inmediatamente: a) Los primeros dias de la guerra que son probablemente los mas letales en cuanto a civiles: Una vez se desata la guerra, el ejercito Israeli pone como objetivo inmediato y basado en su inteligencia previa, la destrucción de todo deposito de armas y bombas, pues en una guerra activa, esas armas serian (y fueron) usadas para atacar a Israel, tanto civiles como militares. Dada la urgencia de esta acción, en muchos casos no se usaron las comunes y conocidas acciones de aviso previo para evitar muertes civiles. b) En cuanto a los ataques a lideres y militantes: Es claro que Israel cambio sus reglas de proporcionalidad en estos actos, aceptando un mayor numero de muertes civiles por objetivo militar, bajo el concepto de que la amenaza inminente durante una guerra activa aumenta el potencial daño causado y por ende aumenta el potencial daño colateral a generar segun las reglas de proporcionalidad. c) Lo mas controversial en mi opinión, es el concepto de distinción: En esto me refiero a quien es un objetivo valido y quien no. Israel uso muchos tipos de herramientas para identificar combatientes y miembros de los grupos armados, donde por ejemplo, un policía civil era considerado combatiente pues es miembro de Hamas y también está armado, u politicos de la rama civil de Hamas que también fueron objetivos militares, pues segun comentarios de las IDF, estos participan en el financiamiento y planificación de las acciones armadas de Hamas y por ende son objetivos militares validos. Todos estos puntos son controversiales, y son los que van a regir que acciones de Israel serán consideradas crímenes de guerra y cuales no. Pero en ningún caso, estos aportan prueba alguna a la acusación de genocidio, si no mas bien, son prueba de justamente lo contrario; que los objetivos beligerantes de Israel son claramente militares.
הדוקו החדש של יובל אברהם ורחל שור, שחושף בפירוט את המערכות שמאחורי ההרג ההמוני והמחושב של פלסטינים בעזה בידי ישראל במהלך הג׳נוסייד, זכה למחיאות כפיים שנמשכו 25 דקות (!) בפסטיבל ונציה. היסטורי.
54
275
46
1,020
111,419
I am Omar Abd Rabou, a Palestinian journalist from Gaza. I am appealing to France to consider receiving me through its emergency reception and protection programs. I have been subjected to persecution and torture in Gaza by Hamas because of my condemnation of the October 7 attacks and my criticism of Hamas and its policies. As a journalist at risk, I urgently need safety and protection. I respectfully ask the French authorities to consider my case on humanitarian and emergency grounds. @FranceJerusalem @EmmanuelMacron
288
781
85
3,857
331,102
Maor Shani retweeted
BREAKING: Secretary-General admits anti-Israel bias among UN's human rights experts, saying “many rapporteurs are totally out of control.” António Guterres previously called UN rapporteur Francesca Albanese “a horrible woman.”
203
1,336
225
4,092
446,345
Maor Shani retweeted
Am I the only one who finds it disturbing that Dan Bilzerian received nearly a fifth of the vote? I’m glad a proud Holocaust denier and neo-Nazi didn’t win this primary, but this is still pretty worrying.
261
89
15
1,588
67,982
Maor Shani retweeted
Do you suffer from Israel Derangement Syndrome??
955
3,418
740
17,670
3,917,680
“Free Palestine” was not created by Arabs. It was stolen by them. The phrase was coined by Zionist Jews. It meant freeing the Jewish homeland from British rule. Before 1948, Jews were the Palestinians. Jewish newspapers were Palestinian. Jewish institutions were Palestinian. Jewish athletes competed as Palestinians. Arabs rejected the name entirely. They called themselves Arabs of Greater Syria. “Free Palestine” was ripped from its Jewish origin and flipped into a weapon against the very people who created it. “Free Palestine” today means the opposite of what Jews meant when they coined it. Erasure by inversion.
191
555
39
1,441
39,864
Jews aren’t looking for a daddy to protect them. American Jews are citizens of a free country, protected by its laws. Israeli Jews are citizens of a free country who govern and protect themselves. The time when Jews needed benevolent paternalistic rulers has long passed.
To all of my Jewish sisters and brothers, my commitment to your safety, to everyone’s safety, is the same commitment that I have to the safety of my own daughters.
79
79
21
580
43,037
Maor Shani retweeted
Jews don’t listen to music, we “distract ourselves from genocide” Jews don’t make food, we “steal other people’s cuisines” Jews don’t take vacations, we “colonize the world” There’s not a thing Jews can do they won’t find a sinister motive for. And the most warped part of this disgusting worldview? They think dehumanizing Jewish people is moral and good.
139
402
24
3,622
61,705
Three weeks ago, Spain held up a sign saying destroy Israel, a state that has been forced to defend itself from Islamist invasion. Today, after Spain was invaded by its Muslim neighbors, they are crying on TV asking for help. Enjoy the intifada. teapaw.org/clashreport/status/208…
957
3,360
239
17,609
412,315