
ALT I examine a dispute over RDFa, a proposed extension to the HTML standard intended to ease the authoring and publishing of linked data by allowing it to be embedded in Web pages. I begin by summarizing the theoretical motivation for examining disputes in order to find clues about the moral frameworks informing technical practice. Next I provide historical context for the dispute, specifically the transfer of control over the HTML standard from the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) to a consortium of companies developing Web browsers—a conjuncture that significantly shaped the subsequent development of the Web and the rise of the platforms that consume it. After describing the traces left by the dispute in public mailing list archives and how I analyzed them, I present the results of that analysis, showing that distinct and incompatible visions of the common good—not disagreement over technical issues—underlay the dispute.














