Ralph retweeted
Other similar models have Pr{right-wing majority} ranging from 22% to 71%. None of these are wrong. They're just making different assumptions. czlee.substack.com/p/special…
Ralph retweeted
Example of the kind of false precision I warn about with simulation-based models of special votes. 38% is not "far more likely" than 28%. Also, these numbers almost certainly reflect model parameter choices, not data. I advise against taking such numbers too seriously.
Ralph retweeted
Replying to @marks298933 @dpfdpf
No. The difference is one induces less disproportionate results, and the other increases disproportionality
Ralph retweeted
Fun 2008 piece from @dpfdpf warning against deliberately engineering overhangs - taking issue with some advice Matt McCarten provided.
And correctly noting the unravelling of the game.
kiwiblog.co.nz/2008/11/mccar…
Ralph retweeted
Good to see these experts coming together to urge politicians to fix the immediate problem before it becomes an arms race
rnz.co.nz/news/politics_elec…
Ralph retweeted
The wasted vote normally strongly predicts the degree of distortion: The more wasted vote, the higher the share of seats every party that makes it to Parliament gets
Can you spot the 2026 election?
This is a nonpartisan reform proposal intended to resolve electoral system flaws by good-faith consensus from behind a veil of ignorance, so naturally a lot of the ideologues involved with producing the overhangs are already negatively polarised against it rnz.co.nz/news/politics_elec…
Ralph retweeted
I think the recommendation here is probably the right way to go.
We've already had a Royal Commission, an Electoral Commission review and an Independent Panel review.
What matters is the politics. There's a real problem, but only MPs can fix it.
rnz.co.nz/news/politics_elec…
Ralph retweeted
According to WR ranking points Wales beating the All Blacks yesterday is the biggest upset since they were introduced.
Also somewhat amazingly the Springboks beating the All Blacks is in the top 10
Ralph retweeted
Remember and honor Andrew Goodman, James Chaney and Michael Schwerner and the price they paid when they were murdered for voting rights in Mississippi, 1964:
Ralph retweeted
Replying to @FrankMcRae @pennymarienz
this is laughable. Qiulae Wong is real. It's actually the Auckland Marathon that she staged for votes. Please keep going Penny, you are so close to cracking this
Ralph retweeted
politics expert here! parties only do this when they are very distressed
This quoted post is unavailable.
Ralph retweeted
I completely agree with @cjsbishop
"Outgoing senior National MP Chris Bishop says the overhang campaign run by the Māori Party, billionaire Harry Mowbray and others was bad for democracy."
Ralph retweeted
Chris Bishop going hard at the overhang campaign on RNZ. Says TPM and Harry Mowbray “have a lot to answer for”. He says MPs always go hard in electorates but it was a huge distraction.
Ralph retweeted
Seen a lot of analysis on special votes that is just wrong today.
In this scenario parliament is 129 seats as Wairarapa and Hamilton East are no longer overhang.
Ralph retweeted
MMP has *always* had incentive to create overhangs.
A sense of propriety and worry that voters would punish for it always constrained.
Until TPM made it a deliberate strategy.
One party doing it is not a stable equilibrium.
Unravelling should not be a surprise.

























