Manish Taneja retweeted
0ral herbal sprays to build immunity, to improve gut health, or to cure allergic rhinitis is completely illogical, scientifically baseless, and potentially dangerous for children below five years of age.
When a doctor uses their credentials to push these unproven products, they are trading clinical science for commercial success.
The human body does not build systemic immunity or realign a complex gut microbiome via a daily micro-mist of herbs sprayed into the mouth. It is a marketing gimmick wrapped in medical jargon.
In children under the age of 5, shooting a sudden blast of liquid spray into the back of the throat can rarely trigger laryngospasm.
Young children have highly sensitive gag reflexes. Forcing a daily herbal spray into their mouths is a recipe for choking, vomiting, and severe respiratory distress.
Dealing with a child suffering from chronic allergic rhinitis or constant daycare sickness is exhausting. Exploiting this exhaustion, and selling an expensive "natural shield" that actually puts the child at immediate physical risk is unethical.
There is no science here—only profit. An ethical doctor prescribes evidence-based treatments, not potentially dangerous, unproven sprays that potentially risk closing off a toddler's airway.
Making influencers say that probiotics from curd don't reach the gut and hence the sugary sweet yakult be given to the children daily, is so misleading!
Lollipops as immunoboosters??! Even flat lollipops are choking hazards for young children, by the way!
Marketing Enterogermina through influencers for every stomach upset??!! So misleading! Absolutely no role in vomiting and stomach pain. The evidence for its use during diarrhoea is mixed and controversial.
Don't get me going about gummies, milk mixes, and protein mixes. A genuine paediatrician or a genuine parent influencer will encourage parents to give whole some food for the children.
How can herbs help with children falling in Autism spectrum?
The list goes on!
Preying on parental anxiety to do business!
#primerrykids #yakult #brainify #wellopia #gummies #milkmixes #proteinmixes #enterogermina #misleadingads #mominfluencers #mominfluenzas #misleadingpromotions #immunoboosters #probiotics #stomachupset #ADHD #Autism
@fssaiindia @MoHFW_INDIA @JPNadda
Please protect our children! Pls stop these misleading branding, labelling, and marketing asap!
Manish Taneja retweeted
Same medicine. ₹4 crore a year vs ₹2.5 lakh a year. 💔
A helpless mom came to me with her child, who has Allan-Herndon-Dudley syndrome (MCT8 deficiency). It was very painful to see them so helpless. I tried to find a solution as if it were my own child. I couldn't rest otherwise.
Tiratricol wasn't available in India. Dr Santosh and I wrote to doctors. Dr Praveen and others directed us to the Erasmus team, who did the trials for Tiratricol. After many emails, they suggested Egetis Therapeutics might be able to support the child. I teared up. But our happiness was short-lived: Egetis said it could not give us the medicine.
I wrote to many journalists. I posted on Instagram and tagged the PM. Someone told me Tiratricol was available in Germany. The mother bought it, paying ₹12 lakh for just one month. That's impossible to keep up for life, for this child or for the five other children with the same condition under Dr Praveen's care at CMC Vellore.
Finally, Toufiq, a senior journalist, wrote about it, and it reached the Pharmaceutical Accountability Foundation in the Netherlands. They said Tiratricol can be made available at ₹2.5 lakh per child per year, against ₹4 crore per child per year by Egetis!
I raised funds, and the Pharmaceutical Accountability Foundation raised funds. Now 7 children are getting the medicine free of cost for one whole year. (The 7th child was added after my Instagram post.) 🙏
Thank you to Access to Medicines India and Organization for Rare Diseases India for their important role, and to geneticist Dr Kishore, who helped us reach the diagnosis.
India can compound the Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient here and make it available to every child with this condition at a reasonable cost.
👉 Please tag @narendramodi @JPNadda @MoHFW_INDIA
People of India, you can make it happen! Please share. 🙏
All the paediatricians, endocrinologists, paediatric endocrinologists, and paediatric neurologists, if you are currently caring for a child with confirmed or suspected MCT8 deficiency, please share the details below. Our team may contact you for further clinical information and coordination regarding diagnosis, treatment and access to tiratricol.
Please do not upload or share unnecessary patient-identifying information at this stage.
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1F…
#AllanHerndonDudley #MCT8Deficiency #Tiratricol #Triac #Emcitate #RareDiseases #RareDiseaseIndia #AccessToMedicines #PharmaHijack #ChildHealth
Emeset is a shit drug in Emergency but brilliant in cancer patients or patient with Gastroenteritis, learn why and understand vomiting..
#medtwitter #foam #foamed #foamcc
I had told @MedCrisis a few days back that I think about calcium, this is what I meant.
Your body does this weird thing with it.
Critical care medicine and emergency medicine are not just background specialties anymore; they form the face and backbone of the hospital.
If you hospital doesn't understand and appreciate it, you can always look for places that will, and sooner than later, everyone will start understanding.
Manish Taneja retweeted
𝗕𝗥𝗨𝗧𝗔𝗟𝗜𝗧𝗬 𝗔𝗧 𝗧𝗛𝗘 𝗧𝗢𝗣. 𝗣𝗥𝗢𝗠𝗜𝗦𝗘𝗦 𝗟𝗢𝗦𝗧!!
Why are young doctors being BRUTALLY dragged away by force, while the promises made to them are LEFT TO DIE?
Is this how the @UPGovt treats the doctors who serve its people?
#MedTwitter
Vitamin C increases mortality in my patients (LOVIT trial). Amla is a good citrus fruit. See I say the right thing gobar nahi bechta.
While conveniently ignoring my rebuttal to it 😂
teapaw.org/resusdoc/status/211202…
Dear Mr "QUACK" Taneja 🦆,
I got your agenda when I read the part "Saffron Government". I don't need to say anything further.
I'm quoting my reply for which you asked for.
Get well soon.
teapaw.org/vdnehals__08/status/21…
This is why quacks dont understand simple things the claim is it is as old as the rust in in their brain and they haven't found anything worthy of addition in recent times with thousands of crores infused by this saffron goverment.
Only quacks can claim that their medicine works based only on a protocol which a paid news article published. Mind you, the results are not even out yet, but these guys have paid a news media which has saved itself by saying dont trust us and consult a real doctor under this paid article.
Replying to @resusdoc
Here it is :
ndtv.com/health/family-healt…
Classical Ayurvedic formulation Punarnavadi Mandoora was found more effective in anemia patients.
Fools think that they spent money to find something as ancient as psyllium. Give me one new discovery that the budget has helped achieved which is helping people.
Manish Taneja retweeted
यहाँ भूख हड़ताल के दूसरे दिन (Day 2) की शाम की स्थिति को दर्शाते हुए एक विस्तृत, अत्यंत प्रभावशाली और तथ्यपरक सोशल मीडिया ड्राफ्ट दिया गया है:
"ढलता सूरज, गिरती सेहत... लेकिन न्याय का संकल्प अडिग!" 🕯️🩺
शाम के 5 बज चुके हैं। लखनऊ के इको गार्डन में उत्तर प्रदेश के बॉन्डेड MBBS डॉक्टर्स की अनिश्चितकालीन भूख हड़ताल (Amran Anshan) का आज दूसरा दिन (Day 2) है।
40 दिनों से अधिक के लगातार प्रदर्शन और 2 दिनों से अन्न-जल त्यागने के बाद डॉक्टरों की शारीरिक स्थिति चिंताजनक हो रही है। लगातार भूखे रहने के कारण हमारे कई साथियों का ब्लड शुगर (RBS) और ब्लड प्रेशर (BP) का स्तर गिर रहा है, जिसकी नियमित मेडिकल निगरानी की जा रही है।
अत्यंत दुखद है कि स्वास्थ्य सेवाओं की रीढ़ माने जाने वाले इन युवा डॉक्टरों की इस गंभीर स्थिति के बावजूद अब तक शासन या प्रशासन की ओर से संवाद का कोई भी सकारात्मक प्रयास नहीं किया गया है।
हमारी मांगें पूरी तरह संवैधानिक और न्यायसंगत हैं:
1️⃣ एक ही बॉन्ड और एक ही सेवा, तो फिर मानदेय में भेदभाव क्यों?
2️⃣ हम वेतन वृद्धि नहीं, बल्कि समान बॉन्ड के तहत समान मानदेय (₹1 लाख/माह) के लंबित GO को तुरंत जारी करने की अपील कर रहे हैं।
हम शांतिपूर्ण तरीके से अपने अधिकारों की मांग कर रहे हैं। माननीय मुख्यमंत्री @myogiadityanath जी और उपमुख्यमंत्री व स्वास्थ्य मंत्री @brajeshpathakup जी से नम्र निवेदन है कि भूख हड़ताल पर बैठे युवा डॉक्टरों के गिरते स्वास्थ्य का संज्ञान लें और ₹1 लाख वेतन का GO तुरंत जारी कर न्याय प्रदान करें।
#OneBondOneSalary #HungerStrikeDay2 #EqualPayForEqualWork #UPBondedDoctors #JusticeForDoctors #DoctorsProtest
📍 स्थान: इको गार्डन, लखनऊ
⏰ स्थिति: अनिश्चितकालीन भूख हड़ताल (Day 2)
@upgovt @cmoffice_up @CMOfficeUP @SureshKKhanna @NEWS18UP @ANINewsUP @thelallantop @bbcnews @nmo_awadh_prant @thenewspinch @ndtv
#onebondonesalary
@upgovt
@cmoffice_up
@brajeshpathakup
@SureshKKhanna @CMOfficeUP
@myogiadityanath
@NEWS18UP
@ANINewsUP
@thelallantop
@bbcnews
@nmo_awadh_prant
@thenewspinch
@ndtv
@DrDhruvchauhan
Manish Taneja retweeted
आश्वासन के 40 दिन तो काफी होते हैं।
"कोविड में जो 'फ्रंटलाइन वारियर्स' थे, आज सड़कों पर हक़ माँगने पर बदसलूकी झेल रहे हैं!"
लखनऊ में प्रदर्शन कर रहीं महिला डॉक्टरों का गुस्सा फूट पड़ा। 40 दिन बीत जाने के बाद भी शासनादेश जारी न होने और पुलिस द्वारा घसीटे जाने पर डॉक्टरों ने तीखे सवाल खड़े किए। "ग्रामीण इलाकों में बिना बिजली-पानी के सेवा देने वालों के साथ यह बर्ताव क्यों?" डॉक्टरों की माँग है कि जल्द से जल्द शासनादेश जारी कर वेतन असमानता दूर की जाए।
#bondeddoctors #doctorsprotest #payparity #uttarpradesh #lucknow
















