subalterndesi (@subalterndesi) profile picture

dehati biomass, dimaghi naxal Interests: South Asia, political economy, geopolitics, Islamicate world. Happy to engage with anyone but would block slurs.

barre-sagheer-e-hind-o-pak
Joined February 2026
Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)Photo by subalterndesi (@subalterndesi)
subalterndesi retweeted
Replying to @southasia_times
You are underestimating the extent to which Muhajirs have already packed up and left Karachi. Pakistani diaspora in the US, Canada, and even the GCC is disproportionately Muhajir. Muhajirs continue to do well wherever they are. They don't need Pakistan for long-term success and building generational wealth. In my original apartment building in Johar, 60-70% of the families are now living outside of Pakistan. 80-90% of my high school class now lives outside Pakistan. Muhajir exodus was Karachi and Sindh's loss. Karachi Sooba is for those who unfortunately cannot leave.
1
5
86
subalterndesi retweeted
There is this Christian girl I know who did her XYZ degree in ISB & applied for a job at an institute related with Abdus Salam, but they rejected her for "religious reasons". She then left Pak for Italy, where she is doing great. This seems to be a blessing in disguise.
Remembering Pakistan’s first Nobel Laureate, Dr. Abdus Salam, on his death anniversary 30 years ago today (Nov 21, 1996). We've never been too kind to our heroes.
2
2
6
594
subalterndesi retweeted
The heart of darkness ...
15
10
9
138
6,167
Javed Akbar is lying through his teeth.
Out of hatred, Urdu speakers have spread the lie that Punjabi is the language of the uncouth and the illiterate. During Akbar's era, no language by the name of Urdu existed, and he used to speak vernacular folk languages, including Punjabi. Upon hearing this statement from Javed Akhtar, the Urdu-speaking elite immediately began arguing how Akbar could possibly speak the language of the uncultured. The mind and the hands that built the Taj Mahal were also Punjabi. Punjabis were never told that the Taj Mahal was also built by Punjabis. The chief architect of the Taj Mahal, Ustad Ahmad Lahori, was a Punjabi. The master craftsmen who built the Taj Mahal were also brought by him from Punjab. In particular, the name of Chiniot, a city in West Punjab, is highly renowned, from where many skilled craftsmen performed the intricate work that breathed life into the stones of the Taj Mahal.
1
118
subalterndesi retweeted
The world is catching on to the excellence of Pakistani dramas, culture, and art ☆
45
17
517
22,727
Centres of Urdu Tehzeeb in the Subcontinent Lahore Delhi Lucknow Hyderabad
9
9
58
1,416
subalterndesi retweeted
A bit disingenuous to reduce Pakistan’s most powerful art form to a “conservative idiot box”. Pakistan’s writers are far more nuanced and explore human complexity than most stuff Bollywood produces en masse. This is why the Indian prism on Pakistani society and our art is so primitive and limited. They watch that odd hit from Pakistan and take a “viewpoint” on our culture & art. I need to remind the world that India has ALWAYS banned our artists & content WAY more than Pakistan has banned Indian content. Indians did not grow up on Pakistani culture compared to how easily accessible and watchable Bollywood was in Pakistan. Takes like these are proof. Indian analysts and Bollywood focused journalists must take a breather before passing judgements like these. Enjoy the dramas and make the memes with us, sure. But you don’t know our society & our culture enough to make comments like these.
1
4
1
12
1,568
subalterndesi retweeted
We need more Provinces. Turkiye is much richer than Pakistan because it has 81 provinces for 85 mil ppl. We need a directly elected President, directly elected Governors, & directly elected Mayors, one for every city and a cluster of a few villages. LET THERE BE TRUE DEMOCRACY!
6
4
1
44
1,266
"The truth is, that when the country passed under our rule, the Musalmans were the superior race, and superior not only in stoutness of heart and strength of arm, but in power of political organization, and in the science of practical govt." —WW Hunter on the Musalmans of Bengal
"A hundred and seventy years ago, it was almost impossible for a well-born Musalman in Bengal to become poor; at present, it is almost impossible for him to continue rich." — W. W Hunter PostPlassey Company policies explicitly targeted the Musalman elite. As Hunter himself put +
1
7
25
778
Yes, but we can't come after the establishment unless we have our own wins first Inshallah all DHAs and Cantts would be under KMC soon
It is very disingenious of pro-establishment mohajir to put all the blame on ppp alone for the destruction of karachi and mohajirs. Punjabi establishment is as guilty and responsible for the destruction of Karachi and mohajirs as PPP.
66
subalterndesi retweeted
The first Eid Milad unNabi under Zia ul Haq’s dictatorship, pictured here with Ahmed Raza Kasuri, the man whose accusation against Zulfikar Ali Bhutto for his father's murder became the centerpiece of the regime's trial. 📍Lahore — 12th Rabiul awal, 1978 🇵🇰
Q: If you were Prime Minister, what would be your first action in connection with the East Pakistan now? Interview just days before the all out war. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto: Answer 👇 📍Islamabad — 28/11/1971 🇵🇰🇧🇩
3
24
60
5,533
subalterndesi retweeted
Train from Mirpur to Srinagar after the nigtmare is over
15
8
1
117
3,622
we have seen this reel before
right now, no Muslim ethnic group produces taqqiya-maxxers like the Punjabi Mussalman do, you just can't see this guy or General Asim Munir, etc among Arabs, Afghans, etc. these days, not even Persians surprisingly, that nuke-level tactical Machiavellian predatory linguistics
1
15
919
subalterndesi retweeted
Lol, you're just jealous that Pakistan is about to undertake its biggest reforms, with Karachi set to be the biggest beneficiary. Meanwhile, you'll still be a second class, paperless citizen in India who perpetually has to prove his loyalty. I feel for you. 😂
Mohajirs must understand, they r “immigrants”, not sons of the soil U cannot cling to ur Hindustani identity while demanding ownership of prime sindhi land Adopt local culture, learn their language & assimilate Don't become a threat to the indigenous pop. That never ends well.
2
16
189
subalterndesi retweeted
People are not ruling themselves, as is required in a democracy. We are still a colony. Before, it was the British colony; now it is the colony of the Generals and super-elite political families. They rule with the help of DMG/PAS officers, as did the British. When will it END
5
6
20
490
Ali Tareen is funding scholarships at Oxford to whitewash his family's name, otherwise known for sugar mafias. Meanwhile, the constituency where his father has been an MP more than a decade, has a literacy rate of 50%.
Tata Group gave $50m to Harvard Business School, the biggest foreign donation in the US school's 102-year history back in 2010. HBS built 'Tata Hall' with it.
66
Tata Group gave $50m to Harvard Business School, the biggest foreign donation in the US school's 102-year history back in 2010. HBS built 'Tata Hall' with it.
the worst rich Indian behaviour is funding chairs in foreign univs while local school doesn't have a fan.
15
45
1
839
19,555
Musadiq Malik is pushing all the right buttons, playing on India's civilisational anxieties and challenging its perceived monopoly over the subcontinent's historical and cultural heritage 😜😎 "We are the custodians of the Indus Valley Civilisation." "Gandhara University is a few kilometres from where I live." "All our roads lead to Central Asia and Persia." "The prayers I offer are in Arabic." "Ghalib's grandfather came from Samarkand. He considered himself a poet of the Persian language, but the world remembers him for his Urdu poetry." He's essentially laying claim to everything Indians have long considered their uncontested civilisational inheritance. This is going to give the Sanghis sleepless nights for weeks. Brace yourselves for the inevitable barrage of abuse, my fellow countrymen. 🤣🤣
17
104
9
414
15,868