Good thread on super and the conceptual complexities of talking about “funding retirements”.
So much about super “saving the government money” or “helping future generations” is built on wrong assumptions or muddy thinking!
Ben's right, government-owned stock is a great way to build public ownership. That's why the superannuation system is so criminal - $3 trillion of privatized wealth that could have been publicly owned.
Every time a Greens Party activist calls a sovereign wealth fund “gambling on the stock market” I wonder if they ever bothered to ask mummy or daddy how they paid the fees for private school…🤔
And if they’ve ever actually looked at a long term investment returns graph.
#auspol
With a $3 million super cap being discussed in the media, it's worth remembering the median super balances at retirement are only:
$136k for men
$86k for women
And that the median over-65 Australian has no super whatsoever.
Really enjoyed chatting to the @Fakefasters this morning about inequality in the super system.
(@operation_rosie's thread below is a great recap)
The Workers Against Super agenda is spreading!
this morning on @3RRRFM @Fakefasters we spoke to Robert Lechte about the very excellent article he wrote in Crikey about how superannuation is bad, entrenches inequality & needs to be replaced. follow him & @superisverybad immediately!!!
(stats/info in thread below)
👇👇👇
Labor and the union movement are proud of superannuation – it's their pride and joy.
But as Robert Lechte @djrobstep writes today, the superannuation system makes any progressive outcome impossible. In fact, it merely replicates and amplifies inequality.
crikey.com.au/2023/01/19/sup…
Paying super on parental leave will close the super gender gap by ~$200 million a year.
But the total super wealth cap between men and women is (roughly) $400 billion - about 2000x as much.
Adding super to Govt paid parental leave is a good idea and should happen. But the impact on retirement incomes will be very small. Super is a simple function of working-life income so doesn't have meaningful equity policy levers.
smh.com.au/business/companie…
Fact Check: FALSE.
Super isn’t just good for workers – it's a keystone of our country’s economic success.
It’s just another way that unions are working for all Australians #UnionsForAll
It's what you've all been waiting for: our 2022 Year in Review: workersagainstsuper.org/post…
Includes shout outs to @TomCBallard @cadelucas and others for covering us. Less positive mentions for @SwannyQLD and for @percapita, who we've added to our Super Statistics Hall of Shame.
One of the many problems with super is that it’s sexist by design - it deliberately replicates the sexism of the labour market, leaving women in poverty.
It seems this was well known by lawmakers all along.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
There's very little to celebrate in super statistics - unless you're already wealthy of course.
The median retiree has zero superannuation, and the median adult roughly $20k.
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
While we're on the subject of Per Capita's board, why is one of your board members a superannuation industry lobbyist?
Is this why Per Capita routinely overstates super balance statistics and consistently minimizes super's pernicious role in creating inequality and poverty?
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
Who's going to tell him about "the Accords"?
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
2
Nareen Young just blocked us without any interaction. Disappointing that some people are so afraid of debate or any criticism of their sacred cows.
3
If this is true, why not simply make the age pension universal, and raise the age at which superannuation can be accessed to the same age as the pension?
This report, which contains flagrantly incorrect statistics on median superannuation balances*, was released on Oct 5.
It still hasn't been fixed.
*the statistics are copy/pasted verbatim from a KPMG report which itself overstates the medians by excluding zero balances
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
Wish this were true. In actual fact, Labor’s model retains 49% privatisation.
While 51% is much better than zero, the plan is to continue privatising nearly half of the new assets - hardly a rejection of privatisation.












