
International Relations, Politics, Policy, Dharma, Law •• Anekāntavāda •• @SwarajyaMag
Joined June 2013
- Tweets21.9K
- Following1K
- Followers1.9K
- Likes24.5K
Pinned Tweet
IMP THREAD ON 2024 ELECTIONS🧵
Last year, I began tweeting about 'mandate denial' and 'stolen elections' narrative (check pinned tweet). This is the fallback strategy or rather main strategy for 2024 in case PM Modi secures another clear mandate, which is highly likely.
They've been laying groundwork to label 2024 as stolen elections. I've been compiling it but it got too cluttered. So here's a reiteration in this thread 🧵. Do like and repost.👇
This is very serious work. Will take up this exercise myself very soon. Great job @rohitshinde121.
I decided to audit Audrey Truschke's recent book - India: 5,000 years of History, with AI.
Through this exercise I wanted to see if Audrey was actually biased. The goal was to:
1. Check citations for accuracy.
2. Find patterns in her bias and discretions, if any.
Both are hard to do by hand, but easily verified if the work is done by AI.
I classified the inaccurate ones into 4 levels. Severity 1 and 2 are nitpicks and minor mistakes, that don't hide or change anything that the primary source says.
But severity 3 is if the sentence changes the meaning of what the source says. For example, if a monastery is said to be "sacked", but the source says that the monks were killed.
Severity 4 is where it's an omission or her cited source says the opposite. For example, she says that Akbar banned enslaving war captives. But her cited source says that the war captives could be enslaved, but not their families.
And here's the headline result in this screenshot:
1. Of her 2,310 endnotes, I checked about 1807 because that's what sources were available to me.
2. About 68% of the notes were accurate. But that's a very low number.
3. There are 185 serious finding of severity 3 and 4. This is material omission or serious change in what her source says.
4. Almost 200 findings where she says the exact opposite of what her source says! Of these 12 are at severity 4 and 46 are at severity 3.
Clearly, Audrey hasn't paid much attention to detail in this work.
Keep watching this space - I'll be tweeting out more examples of my findings!
Anmol Jain retweeted
I decided to audit Audrey Truschke's recent book - India: 5,000 years of History, with AI.
Through this exercise I wanted to see if Audrey was actually biased. The goal was to:
1. Check citations for accuracy.
2. Find patterns in her bias and discretions, if any.
Both are hard to do by hand, but easily verified if the work is done by AI.
I classified the inaccurate ones into 4 levels. Severity 1 and 2 are nitpicks and minor mistakes, that don't hide or change anything that the primary source says.
But severity 3 is if the sentence changes the meaning of what the source says. For example, if a monastery is said to be "sacked", but the source says that the monks were killed.
Severity 4 is where it's an omission or her cited source says the opposite. For example, she says that Akbar banned enslaving war captives. But her cited source says that the war captives could be enslaved, but not their families.
And here's the headline result in this screenshot:
1. Of her 2,310 endnotes, I checked about 1807 because that's what sources were available to me.
2. About 68% of the notes were accurate. But that's a very low number.
3. There are 185 serious finding of severity 3 and 4. This is material omission or serious change in what her source says.
4. Almost 200 findings where she says the exact opposite of what her source says! Of these 12 are at severity 4 and 46 are at severity 3.
Clearly, Audrey hasn't paid much attention to detail in this work.
Keep watching this space - I'll be tweeting out more examples of my findings!
Anmol Jain retweeted
Every Indian census asks for your mother tongue.
If your parents speak different languages, the Census has a fixed rule for which one is written down as yours.
Which one counts?
43%Mother's language
11%Father's language
21%Main home language
25%Whatever you choose
56 votes • 9 hoursEvery Indian census asks for your mother tongue.
If your parents speak different languages, the Census has a fixed rule for which one is written down as yours.
Which one counts?
43%Mother's language
11%Father's language
21%Main home language
25%Whatever you choose
56 votes • 9 hoursThe answers are messy. For scale, 2011:
19,569 names returned
→ rationalised into 1,369 mother tongues
→ grouped under 121 languages
So the 2020 National Education Policy uses four terms at once: home language, mother tongue, local language, regional language.
1
41
The word matribhasha sounds Vedic. Yet Sanskrit's commoner word, deshabhasha, tied a language to a place, which belongs to everyone who lives there.
In an 1873 Sanskrit encyclopaedia, you can watch one word replace the other in a single gloss.
swarajyamag.com/ideas/india-…
Anmol Jain retweeted
At the @indiaBUILDwiki @NFPRC_Ind event in precision manufacturing and additive manufacturing. Some really great points being discussed and highlighted and the recipe for future policies. @amargov
Anmol Jain retweeted
Wonderful to know @BJP4India communications head @anil_baluni invited rape and child rape normaliser Abhinandan Sekhri to his Diwali Milan. Absolutely wonderful @narendramodi @PMOIndia @AmitShah @AmitShahOffice @HMOIndia. Glad the BJP now officially endorses pedophile rape.
Someone said @anil_baluni, co-ordinator of communication , has read my tweet. 🤣
Baluni, co-ordinator of communication department of @BJP4India invited at his home @AbhinandanSekhr.
He is a co-founder of @newslaundry and,
of course, pucca ‘secular’ as we classify in New Delhi.
Many journalists were surprised to see him at home of ‘Modi’s man.’
It was a private event, arranged annually, where many journalists are invited.
Baluni ji 👍!
Excellent reportage.
Reporter’s diary
I was in Manila for the ASEAN and the Quad Summit. Here is what I saw, felt and thought
firstpost.com/world/modis-ma…
1
1
305
Anmol Jain retweeted
Replying to @therealp0litik
Plus he is Ahimsa-vaadi.
Anmol Jain retweeted
Uttar Pradesh's per capita income, as a share of the national average:
2012-13: 50.5%
2024-25: 53.5%
Over the same years, did the gap in rupees between the average UP resident and the average Indian grow or shrink?
47%It grew
30%It shrank
23%About the same
225 votes • Final results Anmol Jain retweeted
While Pakistan plugs the many holes in it’s system and the Chinese march on with modernisation, glad to see the Indian military bureaucracy getting busy with reclaiming its ornamental preferences and golf courses, while resisting and scuttling every reform needed to modernise.
Senior officers of the Gorkha Rifles, Special Forces & Armoured Corps return to signature headgear. Regimental lanyards, belts back too. Army Chief Gen Dhiraj Seth will now sport a black beret, & the distinctive brown shoes of select Armoured regiments.
hindustantimes.com/india-new…
Anmol Jain retweeted
The “post-Shenzhen” world will not be tripolar, but it has already taken an important step toward multipolarity. Dmitriy Trenin on the meeting of the leaders of #Russia, #China, and the #UnitedStates on the sidelines of the #APEC2026 summit in #Shenzhen russiancouncil.ru/en/analyti…






























