The 3NR (@the3nr) header
The 3NR (@the3nr) profile picture

The 3NR is a blog about high school (mostly policy) debate. It is written and edited by @BillBatterman. We also have a new podcast called Burden of Rejoinder.

Joined July 2009
Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)Photo by The 3NR (@the3nr)
I'm rebooting this account after a long hiatus. Because it has been dormant, many followers have likely moved on from high school debate. If so, please unfollow. If you're still interested in debate-related content, I'll be using this account to share it. (—@BillBatterman)
1
3
The @NFHS_Org held its annual Policy Debate Topic Selection Meeting this past weekend in Kansas City. For the 2023-2024 season, students will debate Agricultural Subsidies, Climate Change, Economic Inequality, Latin America, or South Asia. Voting will take place this fall.
1
1
7
New content, finally: Analyzing The NATO Topic Using Justification Burdens: Strategic Considerations and An Affirmative Case Selection Checklist I hope this will be useful for students working on summer research (at home and at camps). the3nr.com/2022/06/15/analyz…
1
2
New Post: Breaking Down The Final Two 2022-2023 Topic Choices: Why I Am Not Voting For The NATO Emerging Technologies Topic I don't feel great about either of the final choices. Despite my (many) concerns, I think you should vote for the climate topic. the3nr.com/2021/12/10/breaki…
1
2
New Post: Breaking Down The Final Two 2022-2023 Topic Choices: My Concerns About The Multilateral Climate Change Regimes Topic I did some research into the wording of the (topic paper-less) climate topic. I think it might be bad. Here's why: the3nr.com/2021/12/07/breaki…
1
4
If you think I'm wrong about any of the wording issues, please @ me or post a comment. In particular, please share any topicality "support" cards you've found. It only takes a few good ones to make a neg T argument winnable, but I came up empty.
2
New Post: An Updated List of TOC Qualifying Tournaments in Policy Debate, 1992-1993 to 2021-2022 Want to know which tournaments were TOC qualifying tournaments in policy debate — and at what bid level — dating back to the early '90s? Here you go. the3nr.com/2021/12/06/an-upd…
1
5
New article about why DBT songs can help explain debates about dams. Teachers/coaches could create a pretty cool little water topic-related lesson plan out of this.
To understand the complexity of #rivers, people & #hydropower dams you could study law, engineering & geomorphology. or you could listen to the insights of @drivebytruckers @JasonIsbell @pattersonhood & MikeCooley. New @Forbes @WWFLeadWater @WWFscience forbes.com/sites/jeffopperma…
1
New Post: National Circuit High School Policy Debate Participation is Cratering I'm sorry to be the bearer of bad news. If you're a coach, you probably already knew this — at least anecdotally. Unfortunately, the data is even worse than I thought. the3nr.com/2021/11/26/nation…
5
3
4
51
I think this @Patrick_Wyman quote from the latest episode of Tides of History (an interview with @dgjones) is a good way to think about "debate work" (whether you're a student or a coach). There's always more to do, but you should do the best you can on the work you're doing now.
7
Despite the reduction/elimination of tournament travel, I think debate coaches experienced a similar increase in working hours last year (and this year) — typically on top of their "regular" teaching responsibilities, which also increased. And few (if any) got paid more for it.
Teachers worked more hours than usual in the '20-'21 school year, and saw their hours rise more than those in other professions. journals.sagepub.com/doi/ful…
1
ICYMI, the third episode of Burden of Rejoinder was posted last weekend. If you're not subscribed to our feed in your podcast app, you can still download/play it here: the3nr.com/2021/11/06/burden…
1
3
This is why Zoom/Campus cross-examinations are awkward. Turn-taking is hard even when both speakers are legitimately trying to take turns. And in CX, sometimes one of the speakers needs/wants to interrupt the other. That makes turn-taking even more complicated/difficult.
Why Zoom feels stilted: Struggling to figure out when it’s your turn to talk disrupts the natural flow of conversation. Due to the ambiguity of turn-taking cues, it takes us ~3x longer to respond remotely than face-to-face—even after accounting for audio transmission delays.
In a new Jacobin interview with Garrison Lovely, Michael Stipe once again confirms that R.E.M.'s "It's the End of the World as We Know It (And I Feel Fine)" is not about policy debate. Alas. jacobinmag.com/2021/10/rem-m…
4
Lawrence Zhou (an assistant coach and grad student at Wyoming) wrote a lengthy case for high school debate in Current Affairs. It won’t appeal to “non-partisan” (scared-of-anti-CRT-backlash) administrators, but it is a well-argued article that most debate coaches will appreciate.
Should high schoolers be taught how to debate? currentaffairs.org/2021/10/w…
2
3
15
New Post: What If? The High School Policy Debate Topics That Finished In Second Place, 1995-2021 Ever wonder what debate seasons would have been like if the runner-up topics had been selected instead? Me, too. Here's a list to spark some conversations. the3nr.com/2021/10/22/what-i…
1
6
The Minnesota Urban Debate League has some cool debate merch available in their Bonfire store, including this cool new version of the classic "Debate Like A Girl" t-shirt. Consider buying something for yourself or a friend and support the MNUDL in the process.
We've got a brand new way to support debate- shop our @Bonfire store! bonfire.com/store/mnudl/ Just in time for the holidays- wear your support (or give merch as a present!) Profits from your purchase will support our growing programs. #nonprofit #fundraising #merchdrop
1
1
Today, the NFHS announced the final two policy debate topics under consideration for the 2022-2023 season: Climate Change and Emerging Technologies. I broke down the results and shared a few takeaways here: the3nr.com/2021/10/22/the-fi… We'll find out the winner on January 10th.
1
3
Want to know what debates are about on the water resources protection topic? Want help identifying "to do" lists for your research and preparation? Check out this survey of the elims at St. Mark's, and repeat the process yourself for other tournaments. the3nr.com/2021/10/20/a-surv…
We'll find out which two topics will appear on the final ballot for the 2022-2023 season very soon. If your school is an NSDA member and you haven't voted yet, get your ballot in today.
Member students and coaches! Don't forget to cast your vote for the 2022-23 Policy Debate topic. Voting ends tomorrow, so log in and cast your vote soon! speechanddebate.org/topics/
1