Theo Lester (@theolester42) header
Theo Lester (@theolester42) profile picture

Barrister at The 36 Group. Public law, human rights (immigration & asylum). Musician on the side. Organist of St John's Eltham. Opinions are my own.

London, England
Joined November 2013
Photo by Theo Lester (@theolester42)Photo by Theo Lester (@theolester42)Photo by Theo Lester (@theolester42)
Theo Lester retweeted
Column in today's Times on how court backlogs are undermining the rule of law everywhere from the criminal justice system to the employment tribunal. And while the govt has scrapped the worst aspect of its jury reforms, what's left still risks more miscarriages of justice.
6
41
4
102
19,597
Theo Lester retweeted
Ministers could extend judge-only trials for MPs ‘with a stroke of a pen’ By @emilydugan in the Sunday Times page 2 and online @thetimes Explaining the democratic risks, shadow Solicitor General, Dr @KieranMullanUK said “We could see all sorts of offences added, and as far as I’m aware there has never been a power for ministers quite like this before — to bypass the full scrutiny of parliament, the way in which we pass the most important laws, when deciding what comes on and off a list of who gets a jury trial.” “Andrew Thomas KC, chairman of the Criminal Bar Association, said the trial without-jury clause in the bill was an “anti-democratic measure” that would “create a system of two-tier justice in our crown courts”. He said: “Judge-only trials could be extended to cases of bribery or misconduct in a public office, where politicians and other powerful people are under scrutiny. ‘Complex’ is not defined.” “Ministers could introduce judge-only trials for politically damaging cases without a vote in parliament because of a clause buried in a bill that has been approved by MPs.

The unprecedented law would mean any type of trial in England and Wales deemed complex or lengthy, other than rape or homicide, could be recategorised as judge-only without the need for a new vote.” Page 2 of the Sunday Times and Full article here thetimes.com/article/dac2265…
1
5
1
5
6,799
Theo Lester retweeted
Ministers could extend juryless trials ‘by a stroke of a pen’ Sunday Times page 2 @thetimes by @emilydugan A new power to switch crimes to judge-only hearings without parliamentary scrutiny could be abused by future governments, leading barristers fear “Flora Page KC, who represented victims of the Post Office Horizon scandal in the public inquiry, said: “It’s the power, without any proper parliamentary scrutiny, to create new offences which will have juryless trials that really worries me. It’s bad enough getting rid of juries in serious fraud cases, which troubles me already, but at least that’s out there, that’s in the legislation. What I find really troubling is the idea that any serious or complex case could, by a stroke of a pen and a statutory instrument, become another judge-only trial.” “Let’s say officials or ministers were involved, and the police bring charges because they think that’s appropriate, and then the government could probably do pretty quickly a statutory instrument to say, ‘Right, that’s a judge-only trial’. And then you’ve got a political trial being heard without the sort of public scrutiny it otherwise would have, and without members of the public deciding on guilt or not guilt.” thetimes.com/article/dac2265…
Ministers could extend judge-only trials for MPs ‘with a stroke of a pen’ By @emilydugan in the Sunday Times page 2 and online @thetimes Explaining the democratic risks, shadow Solicitor General, Dr @KieranMullanUK said “We could see all sorts of offences added, and as far as I’m aware there has never been a power for ministers quite like this before — to bypass the full scrutiny of parliament, the way in which we pass the most important laws, when deciding what comes on and off a list of who gets a jury trial.” “Andrew Thomas KC, chairman of the Criminal Bar Association, said the trial without-jury clause in the bill was an “anti-democratic measure” that would “create a system of two-tier justice in our crown courts”. He said: “Judge-only trials could be extended to cases of bribery or misconduct in a public office, where politicians and other powerful people are under scrutiny. ‘Complex’ is not defined.” “Ministers could introduce judge-only trials for politically damaging cases without a vote in parliament because of a clause buried in a bill that has been approved by MPs.

The unprecedented law would mean any type of trial in England and Wales deemed complex or lengthy, other than rape or homicide, could be recategorised as judge-only without the need for a new vote.” Page 2 of the Sunday Times and Full article here thetimes.com/article/dac2265…
10
29
6
49
15,934
Theo Lester retweeted
WARNING Under proposals before House of Commons the Government wants to be granted power to extend the scope of Judge-only trials to other forms of complex cases at their discretion. This is important. The removal of the right to trial by jury remains under threat. The power to widen that removal to many serious criminal offences would be granted to the executive by a SI. Please share with your MPs. This is being debated TODAY at the report stage and from 230pm at the third reading of the Courts and Tribunal Bill. This is what our Chair Andrew Thomas KC has to say:
4
34
4
52
5,788
Theo Lester retweeted
Andy Burnham should appoint inquiry (tricky as he was briefly Treasury minister). Much of worst Libor rigging - far worse than those convicted - was by Bank of England (with Treasury & No 10 urging) during 2008 financial crisis. We need to hear from PM at time, Gordon Brown.
Andy Verity deserves sainthood for exposing & especially explaining the Libor scandal, one of greatest British scandals of my lifetime. It implicates several huge names from City, Treasury, Bank of England & politics, who should go to their graves with throbbing consciences.
10
78
2
245
35,156
Theo Lester retweeted
My Times piece: There was nothing in the latest figures for the public finances to suggest that the UK is heading for a fiscal crisis, which some people seem to be desperate for: Panic over borrowing shows the silly season is alive and well thetimes.com/article/f114dd6…
11
41
2
64
8,481
Theo Lester retweeted
On the physics funding crisis in the UK - there are some issues of nuance, shall we say, in the attached article below. The reason STFC had 'no choice' but to cut so many projects (Jodrell and many more) was NOT the government's spending review settlement. It was a deliberate choice by UKRI (as confirmed by a UKRI board member on X, you'll find it in my replies) to refocus spend away from STFC science and labs and towards other areas which, it asserts, will lead to more ‘impact’. UKRI have the power to do this. However, as the HoC Select committee pointed out, we have not been able to see a detailed record of the process, impact assessment or consultation that led to such a seismic shift in UK science policy. Who made the decision? As @ChiOnwurah wrote in an open letter to UKRI / STFC in March: ‘What is clear is that, despite your assertions to the contrary in evidence to my committee and our counterparts in the House of Lords, widespread cuts have been proposed before adequate consultation with those affected was undertaken. This is wholly unacceptable and represents a failure for which DSIT, UKRI and STFC leadership must bear responsibility, and act urgently to address.’
48
399
15
1,328
111,410
Only 8 / 27 hearing rooms @ central London (Taylor House) immigration tribunal in use today. @Court_Stats Appeals backlog recently rose to 150,000, up from ~30k in mid-2023 (500% increase) HMCTS's plan: 1. replace immigration judges with non-lawyers; 2. somehow decisions faster??
3
81
Our new report demonstrates the "endemic" delays at court caused by the late delivery of prisoners. Instead of focusing on juries, which do not cause delays, we are calling on the government to urgently reform the prison delivery system that is a significant contributor to inefficiency. Thank you to all of the barristers who have made reports so far. This work is ongoing so please continue to report each time you experience a delay to us. Read the report➡️ bit.ly/4aSgtRk #JusticeNeedsJuries
3
9
5
18
7,185
This is the most extraordinary judgment I’ve read all year. If there was not about to be a reshuffle - I suspect it might have been a resigning matter for the Attorney General.
23
78
9
319
97,061
The Home Office wants to clear the asylum appeals backlog not by resourcing the existing appeals system better. It wants to abolish the current judicial appeals body and build a new one staffed largely by non-legally trained adjudicators (members of the public who’ve done a training course). At the Justice Committee this week, I asked our expert witnesses whether this would just move the backlog into the Upper Tribunal (which would hear appeals against adjudicators). Prof Tomlinson rightly suggested that the Home Office should focus on getting the decision right first time (around 40-50% of Home Office decisions are reversed after appeal).
7
14
2
35
13,057
David Lammy’s proposals to restrict the right to jury trial have been examined by the Justice Committee of the House of Commons. And. Well. Um. It’s *quite* the report. I think it’s actually worse than politely scathing. It’s embarrassing 👇🏼🪡🧵
86
1,756
99
6,390
341,301
Sunday @ 3pm: a free jazz concert, part of our annual summer festival. The fantastic saxophone quartet Quadrophonia will be playing classic numbers by Glenn Miller, Gershwin, plus a few surprises no doubt! Strawberries, scones, and (hopefully!) sun ☀️🎷 @ThisisEltham @SEninemag
3
3
108
Theo Lester retweeted
This is indeed a superb letter from The Astronomer Royal of Scotland. “Someone, somewhere, has taken the decision to defund astrophysics research in the UK, but no-one seems quite sure who that was, or why.” I agree - my colleagues in particle physics have also tried, without success, to discover who owns the decision to damage physics research in the UK, perhaps irreparably, at a time when our economy desperately needs the skills and knowledge we develop and teach. @UKRI_News need to get a grip urgently and fix the problem someone, somewhere, has created.
79
734
26
2,637
229,241
Theo Lester retweeted
“The independence of juries and their liberty to pass a verdict according to their conscience, whatever the law or the authorities may demand… is important not only for justice but for democracy, too.” My @ObserverUK column: observer.co.uk/news/columnis…
1
16
1
16
2,259
Theo Lester retweeted
On the role of the Bank of England, I think these comments from Louise Haigh earlier in the week are indicative of where Labour party thinking might go. Discussions about monetary-fiscal coordination feel likely. Leaves all of the crucial details to be filled in, of course.
"Whoever wishes to talk about the bond market, should not be silent about the central bank" One week in Britain - what a week - and I am already seeing ghosts! Voldemort on Threadneedle street. The Bank of England and the "haunted house" of English politics. The latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Sign up below for more.
9
15
8
73
56,857
Got a minute? Listen to barrister and Bar Council Chair Kirsty Brimelow KC on why reducing jury trials will not reduce delays in the criminal justice system (and what the government should focus on instead). #JusticeNeedsJuries
4
71
5
125
19,172
Theo Lester retweeted
I was a judge. We must not be silenced over the vandalism of juries Sir Stephen Mitchell was senior treasury counsel at the Old Bailey and then a High Court judge A must read in the Sunday Times #JusticeNeedsJuries thetimes.com/uk/law/article/…
2
33
1
51
6,725
Theo Lester retweeted
We can cut the backlog and improve the experience of victims in our courts without compromising due process - proud to stand with Charlotte Nichols in advocating for labours manifesto pledge for specialist courts for sexual abuse cases.
EXC: Labour MPs have tabled an amendment which would scrap the government's planned cuts to jury trials - and bring in specialist rape courts instead Backers are convinced this will be more effective at cutting the backlog, and better for victims thetimes.com/uk/politics/art…
5
26
3
91
38,453