⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg) header
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg) profile picture

HCI PhD working on AI tools at @tryramp. 🦋@turadg.net

San Francisco
Joined September 2006
Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)Photo by ⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ (@turadg)
Wouldn’t trade this NFT for anything! Just can’t get enough but my toddler is extremely non-fungible.
8
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ retweeted
I've been buying an envelope for the past couple weeks and its been insanely healing
2
1
49
1,486
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ retweeted
Eventually, all of us will be fooled by AI.
173
1,525
285
10,175
2,030,590
Both grounded and provocative. Important perspectives to consider.
This is perhaps one of the great ironies of our time: China is increasingly shaping the future of AI, yet very few people in the West have the faintest idea how its key thinkers see it - its philosophers, sociologists or ethicists. As is too often the case, we - much like the frog in the well - assume our own AI debate covers every possible view, when much of it springs from the same cultural soil, built on assumptions about what defines us that we don’t even know we’re making. Take for instance the assumption that intelligence is a key part of what makes us human. It’s so intuitively obvious to us that we literally named our species after it - Homo sapiens (Latin for "wise man"). If you think about it, just this assumption explains a large share of the anxiety: if intelligence is what makes us human, then artificial intelligence - or super intelligence - threatens the very thing that makes us us: we’re about to compete with artificial or super “us”. No wonder this feels existential. But China has a tradition of thought as old as ours, if not older, and every bit as rich and sophisticated, which never placed intelligence at the core of what makes us human, and so meets the thinking machine from a completely different starting point. Have you, for instance, ever heard of Zhao Tingyang? Probably not, and yet he may be the most original thinker on AI you’ve never read. He’s one of China’s most prominent philosophers, at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. While Silicon Valley spends billions trying to make AI share our values, he for one argues that doing so “may very well be a suicidal mistake”. Sounds pretty important to hear him out, don’t you think? Or take Liu Yongmou, a philosopher of technology at Renmin University in Beijing. His thinking is almost the opposite of ours. Where we fear machines that become more and more like us, he says that “humanity’s biggest problem is the machinization of humans, not the humanization of machines.” You could even go back to antiquity, when, in many ways, we started asking questions about AI. Did you know, for instance, that Aristotle, in the Politics, imagined a world where “the shuttle would weave and the plectrum touch the lyre without a hand to guide them”, and wondered about the social order consequences of this (mostly whether slaves would still be needed)? There are Chinese equivalents to this. For instance, in the Zhuangzi, a foundational Taoist classic, you’ll find a similar thought experiment, with a completely different worry attached. An old gardener is watering his vegetables by hand, hauling water out of a well jar by jar. A visitor shows him a labor-saving device, and the gardener turns it down for the reason that whoever uses machines ends up with 机心 (jīxīn), a “machine-heart” - a mind that schemes, calculates and loses its simplicity. “It is not that I do not know [the machine],” he says, “but I should be ashamed to use it.” Two labor-saving machines, two very different questions: where Aristotle wondered what automation would do to the social order, the Zhuangzi wondered what it would do to us, on the inside. Which, you’ll notice, is exactly Liu Yongmou’s worry, more than two thousand years earlier. In fact, as we’ll see, 心 (xīn), the heart, is a motif that runs deep through the Chinese AI debate. It appears both in the fear, from Zhuangzi to Liu Yongmou, that machines could give us a “machine-heart” and its mirror image: the ambition to give machines a heart of their own. Zhu Songchun, who heads the Beijing Institute for General Artificial Intelligence, wants “to set a heart for machines” (为机器立心, wèi jīqì lì xīn). “Heart” in the Chinese sense, that is, which differs totally from the Valentine's Day fluff we’ve reduced it to. 心 (xīn) means heart and mind at once: it’s where we feel but also where we think, tell right from wrong and care for others. And, crucially, it’s in the heart that the quality Confucianism sees as the very definition of a human being takes root: 仁 (rén). We need two words to translate it, “benevolence” and “humaneness”, but in Chinese they’re one and the same: to be benevolent is to be human. It’s not about intelligence. This is the entire point of my new article: to step out of our well for a moment and peer over the edge of China's. What you’ll find there will, I think, surprise you, with questions you’d never thought to ask: from Zhao Tingyang warning that AI’s bad consequences can at least be fought, but that “humanity may die of all the good things AI creates”, to whether the fear that AI will make us “useless” rests on the false premise that a person is worth what they’re useful for. A premise that a 2,300-year-old Taoist tree, which survived precisely because it was useless, demolished long ago. Could our predicted uselessness turn out, much like that tree’s, to be our saving grace? Chinese thinkers’ answers to these questions are, I think, among the most interesting anyone has given to the defining question of our time. Whether or not you agree with them, they’re the intellectual backdrop of a country shaping much of AI, and with it our future: you might as well know what they think. Enjoy the read here: arnaudbertrand.substack.com/…
57
I've started leaving my typos uncorrected, so people know I used my fingers to produce the text #artisinal
1
2
102
Co-signed. Compete on inference, not captivity.
A post of ours on vendor lock in and LLMs. We don't like the growing trend of AI companies quietly hiding your data while stripping away your control. We think that's bad for users and bad for the ecosystem. Here's are our thoughts: earendil.com/posts/session-p…
150
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ retweeted
A post of ours on vendor lock in and LLMs. We don't like the growing trend of AI companies quietly hiding your data while stripping away your control. We think that's bad for users and bad for the ecosystem. Here's are our thoughts: earendil.com/posts/session-p…
37
131
56
840
160,810
conjectures droppin' like flies
Dinitz-Garg-Goemans conjecture is false. This graph theory problem was open for ~30 years. The graph below has fractional flow cost 58. Any unsplittable flow (with capacity violation <=15) has cost at least 60. Chat with GPT 5.6 Pro where this was found: chatgpt.com/share/6a60b2eb-0…
1
109
Entry to a long thread of balanced takes and first person reporting
I work at Google DeepMind. This won't make me popular. But it's all public reporting: 2014: DeepMind reportedly sold to Google on conditions: no military use, independent oversight 2026: a Pentagon contract for "any lawful government purpose" Not one safeguard survived intact
1
1
292
Cognition is becoming a fungible utility. When excited by the power you now wield with AI it’s easy to forget that everyone else has it too. Black spy and white spy.
It's not. Why ? Because 25 pct or more of a doctor's time is spent dealing with conglomerates that do all they can to make the doctor's care more difficult, and expensive, for both the doctor and patient. For every future agent we give AI doctors to deal with this friction, and to improve the quality of care, the conglomerates will have multiple adversarial agents doing all they can to delay and deny, to minimize their cost and maximize their float We see this already as the conglomerates use AI to find every possible way to manipulate contracts, and find ways to mislead, while hospitals hire companies for Revenue Cycle Management, who charge as much as 10 pct of revenue to have their agents try to do the reverse. It's the agentic version of Mad magazine Spy vs Spy I'll give you a further example. There isn't a single company, including yours, that knows the actual cost of the care they purchase for your employees and families. Not one. Cost is an important component of health care decision making. @a16z includes costs in defining its benefits. But you are blind to all but the total bill you pay. Your carrier, your ASO, your PBM, any company that touches the economics of care for your company is going to do everything they can to prevent you from using AI doctors or agents successfully If you want to see that change, stop working with the healthcare conglomerates. Write agents that define , optimize and contract directly with providers, to eliminate the uncessary middlemen. Feel free to use costpluswellness.com to train them. Until the conglomerates are disintermediated , HC in this country will continue to be fucked
1
123
Social media is not reality, unless it’s sharing hard data
Overwhelmingly, Americans say that obeying the law, supporting the Constitution, believing in the Declaration of Independence, being a citizen, and voting in elections are what make you a real American. Overwhelmingly, they say it's NOT about race, religion, or family heritage.
42
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ retweeted
Just listened to a clip of Jason Calacanis talking about how most tech companies now "support Trump on various endeavors" with the exception of Anthropic and "this is america you're allowed to have an opinion BUT! This administration takes things personally, and they're full contact." The overall thesis of the clip as I understood it was "Anthropic is a bunch of Democrats, they hate Trump, Trump hates them back. Why isn't Dario doing the thing all the other tech leaders are doing? Of course Trump is fucking with them." OK. I think it's fair to say that the average person would say that Jason Calacanis is more of a capitalist than me. Certainly he's made much more money than me and his job title contains the word "capitalist." But what Jason is talking about being the new structural quality of the American economy here is not capitalism. If the President of the United States picks OpenAI to win the AI race even though Anthropic's tech is better, that's not "Oh, y'know, this administration takes things personally!" shrug. That's actually not capitalism anymore...it's a pretty well-understood different system called oligarchy. That becomes very obvious if you just replace any of the characters in the story with names you don't recognize. Just in case it needs saying, oligarchy sucks. It is bad for innovation and bad for economies and bad for consumers and ultimately also often (eventually) very bad for the oligarchs! This is why we're supposed to be apalled when our leaders start actively encouraging oligarch-like behavior. Because, look...funny thing about capitalism that I've noticed...most capitalists (there are some exceptions) have no real ideological allegiance to capitalism. They don't /want/ to compete. Competing is annoying, it's hard, you can very easily lose! If they can make more money by getting the state to protect them than they can by innovating and competing, they will absolutely pick state protection. Most capitalists will happily become oligarchs. Their allegiance isn't to any particular system, it's to margin. Now, people to my left will say that oligarchy is, in fact, the final form of capitalism...it's where capitalism will inevitably ends up. I don't believe this because of how we have lots of examples of capitalist countries that are not oligarchies. But watching it happen in my country (and watching influential capitalists shrug as it does) doesn't strengthen my position! It is honestly kinda astounding to see such a staunch pro-market guy just say, "the administration is full-contact, Dario needs to play ball." We all get that that's not a defense of markets, right? It's a defense of one guy distorting a market because he dislikes any power that is not his power. If you find yourself defending that, it is possibly because you, yourself, strive to be an oligarch. Be real careful with that. You can follow your incentives into an evolutionary dead-end. It happens all the time. I've just been thinking about it all morning. Just a real jaw dropper. You can watch the video here: youtube.com/watch?v=jkfwv9N_…
51
83
12
844
74,813
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ retweeted
Fred Rogers met with a child psychologist every week for 22 years to build his show. She shaped everything: every script, prop, and song. The whole point was to give a child's nervous system time to slow down. In 1984, a single regulatory decision ended all of it. The psychologist was Dr. Margaret McFarland, who co-founded the Arsenal Family and Children's Center alongside Benjamin Spock and Erik Erikson. She and Rogers understood that the prefrontal cortex in children, the part of the brain that controls impulse, emotion, and attention, takes decades to fully develop. At the start of every episode, Rogers tied his sneakers and changed his sweater while children settled in. Those pauses were intentional, designed to help a child's nervous system shift into a calmer, more focused state. What ended it had nothing to do with child development science. In 1984, Reagan's FCC chairman Mark Fowler abolished the advertising limits that had protected children's programming from commercial pressure. Toy companies moved within months. Between 1984 and 1985, cartoons tied to toy lines increased by 300%, from a handful of shows to more than 40 animated series. In almost every case, the toy was designed first. The cartoon was built to sell it. Researchers later put numbers to what parents were already noticing. A 2011 study in Pediatrics from the University of Virginia tested 60 four-year-olds across three groups: one watching SpongeBob, which cuts scene every 11 seconds; one watching a slow PBS show, which cuts scene every 34 seconds; and one drawing. Nine minutes later, all three took tests on attention, impulse control, short-term memory, and problem-solving. The SpongeBob group scored significantly worse across every measure. In the 1970s, children began watching television around age 4. Research from pediatrician Dimitri Christakis found that by 2009, the average age of first screen exposure had dropped to 4 months, as the content got faster and the audience got younger. Researchers separately found that each additional hour of daily screen time at ages 1 or 3 raised the risk of attention problems at age 7 by 9%.
We didn’t realize it then, but kids’ shows used to be this calm on purpose.
232
10,039
242
50,979
2,473,138
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ retweeted
In medieval times, within the arms race of ever more demonic torture devices, some sadistic genius came up with the idea of the Little Ease. This was a prison cell built so small in every dimension that a grown man could not stand upright in it nor lie down at full length nor properly sit. The pain is relentless and without relief and inflicted by one's own body. Prisoners were known to go insane within a few days. A stay at the Little Ease was considered even more cruel than the rack, the thumbscrew, and the other ghoulish machinery of the Tower of London. A breeding pig will spend her whole life in a version of that box. These are social, roaming creatures (more intelligent than dogs) who will never leave this corset of steel. They have been selectively bred to be bigger than their frames can support. Yet we put them in cells so confined that they cannot comfortably sit, and their attempts to do so (for example, by sneaking their limbs into adjacent stalls) reliably lead to fractures and sprains. They cannot sweat, yet have nothing to roll around in to cool themselves off. Except their own manure, which (contrary to the common misconception) they are so averse to (thanks to their strong sense of smell) that new sows will often suffer from constipation to avoid soiling the space from which they eat and sleep. Here is how the writer Matthew Scully described what saw at one of Smithfield’s “gestation barn”: > “Sores, tumors, ulcers, pus pockets, lesions, cysts, bruises, torn ears, swollen legs everywhere. Roaring, groaning, tail biting, fighting, and other “Vices,” as they’re called in the industry. Frenzied chewing on bars and chains, stereotypical “vacuum” chewing on nothing at all, stereotypical rooting and nest building with imaginary straw. And “social defeat,” lots of it, in every third or fourth stall some completely broken being you know is alive only because she blinks and stares up at you … creatures beyond the power of pity to help or indifference to make more miserable, dead to the world except as heaps of flesh into which the [insemination] rod may be stuck once more and more flesh reproduced.” — The Save Our Bacon Act is trying to unroll the few state protections we have against this barbaric cruelty - for example California’s Prop 12 - which banned the sale of pork from pigs kept in gestation crates. It’s incredibly important we don’t end up with this sort of federal preemption. SOB will not only kill the most important animal welfare related laws in the US of the past decade, but more importantly, it will also restrict ALL future legislative progress (aka how the animal welfare movement has gotten its biggest wins). The Senate is currently deciding whether to add the SOB Act to the Farm Bill. With relatively little money now, we can discourage the most pivotal senators in the Ag committee from backing this amendment. Defeating this bill is even more important given the amount of philanthropic funding I expect to come online in the next year or two. It will plausibly be over 10x more expensive to repeal SOB than to prevent it from passing in the first place. All that money that could be spent transforming our society's relationship to mass animal suffering will instead have to be spent just getting us back to where we are right now. That's why money spent now fighting this bill (and I mean right NOW) is so effective. If you’re in a position to donate six figures, please DM me.
99
773
72
4,508
542,458
As companies transform to AI orchestrators they must invest in their "verification stack". Over the longest time horizon they can manage, what counted as "right". That's proprietary intelligence and execution edge.
Everyone got the economic implications of the Bitter Lesson backwards. A little awkward for the labs: the theory they cite to explain their dominance is the same one that says their core product can't be a defensible prize. The lesson gets quoted as if it were universal — enough compute, and general methods win, everywhere. The fine print is that this only works where "good" is cheap to verify. Point compute at a crisp objective with a reasonable feedback loop and it eats the task, which is why math and code fell first. And "the lesson applies here" turns out to be the same as "this domain has no margin left in it" — compute isn't scarce enough to lock anyone out (every hyperscaler will have enough of it), and open source distills the frontier on a short lag regardless. Capabilities converge, and the pressure shifts to better routing across models to minimize cost. Winning a verifiable domain comes with the curse of being commodified on the other end of the race. But here is where things get interesting, and why @satyanadella is playing one move ahead of many: the other half of the economy is less accommodating. Is this the right strategy, the right early-stage investment, the right hire, the campaign that actually captured a new trend — here "good" is expensive, contested, and slow to learn, so there's no cheap objective to point compute at, and the Bitter Lesson isn't binding. Hard-to-verify domains stay valuable for an almost embarrassing reason: nobody can tell, cheaply, what counts as a good answer. Compute will hand you a thousand of them and do a sloppy job at telling you which one is the one you should ship. Taste, judgment, curation based on experience: that's the surface where the Bitter Lesson, verification being the true bottleneck, delivers defensible businesses. Which tells you where value will accrue. The models — mostly compute, data, and increasingly tooling and architecture — are the inputs that commoditize first, so putting your moat there is choosing, deliberately, the race with no margin. The interesting move is one level down, in the sectors the lesson can't reach, and there the only durable asset is whatever defines "good" where good isn't easily verifiable: your own verification stack. The proprietary record of what actually counted as right — the "this was wrong, here's why" that has to come from outside the loop, or the model will Goodhart itself into confident, sycophantic nonsense. That moat is two things, and the second is load-bearing: the ground truth your work generates, and the expertise that keeps improving it. The trace is a record — copyable, perishable, only as current as your last correction. The expert is the renewable source: the standing ability to look at the model's next thousand answers and say which one is right, in a domain where that expertise lives in nobody else's head. Compute can't automate a signal it can't measure, and open source can't distill weights that are still inside your people. What stays scarce is the firm that can keep climbing up the intelligence value chain. @satyanadella makes the operating version of the case below — your own hill-climbing machine, with the models learning inside it. The polite way of saying: bet where there is no cheap verifier yet (and ideally there never will be), and hire and retain the experts who are the top verifiers in their domain. Which leads us back to the labs and that awkward spot. They can't defend the model — the theory they live by commoditizes it first, and competition is thorough that way — so they have to come for your eval and verification layer instead: a complement worth absorbing, the kind that arrives bundled into the platform as a thoughtful free feature, for your benefit, naturally. "the model alone is no longer the product"— Greg Brockman To succeed, the one input they have to quietly fold in is the ground truth your own operation throws off every day. Your moat was always the private traces — your failure cases, your taste, the benchmarks only your own work produces. Outsource your traces and you've outsourced judgment, which was, the job.
1
45
⟨tuɾɑdʒ⟩ retweeted
Is GenAI causing the relative decline in early-career hiring? Our latest research finds that these effects may be conflated with another important driver: the rise of WFH arrangements (1/N)
29
255
55
956
554,384
AI ⇏ chat box uiforai.figma.site good stuff from #CMU #HCII Masters students
115
Reading scores, 3rd graders to 8th graders, 2015 to 2025. This is a national tragedy.
679
2,003
772
10,800
2,678,792