
“They muddy the water, to make it seem deep.” @pagd_vic
Melbourne, Victoria
Joined September 2009
- Tweets15.5K
- Following1.6K
- Followers1.2K
- Likes376K
Melanie retweeted
The Australian Human Rights Commission has included the below quote in a new report under “non-traditional breastfeeding arrangements” naming males who say they are women among those who may induce lactation. humanrights.gov.au/resource-… (p 21)🧵
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @crikey_news
I'm assuming this out of context and unexplained focus on Harry Potter is an attempt to link her to 'she who must not be named' (by you)? Of course in considering Rowling's crimes, which also must not be named (mostly because they're shared by the majority teapaw.org/crikey_news/status/212…
Opinion | There is something infuriating about the fact Victoria’s likely first Gen Y leader will be a Harry Potter-loving former Young Liberal president, writes Rachel Withers.
crikey.com.au/2026/11/18/jes…
Replying to @IsntWorkingPod
This week a biological man was named female software engineer of the year (one of two men who won female engineering awards at the @wid_australia). Can you imagine being at a women in engineering event and having to clap as this 'lady' accepted the award. womenindigital.org/women-in-…
Please provide the evidence that I have a 'gender' and it's separate to my sex. Also that if it's 'incongruent' my endocrine system needs to be damaged beginning from when I'm a child.
The NHMRC has released for public consultation its conditional recommendation for the use of puberty suppressants […] in the care of young people with gender incongruence. “A conditional recommendation is made in cases where shared decision-making is essential because different options may be appropriate for different individuals and they might make different choices, or where the overall certainty of available evidence is low”.
After an initial review, we believe the NHMRC has failed to produce guidelines that meet its own standards of providing trusted evidence-based health advice. Of fundamental concern is the assumption underpinning the guidelines that everyone has a gender identity, an unsubstantiated and unscientific concept that we reject completely.
This advice defines ‘gender’ as “a social and cultural concept” based on “expected norms, behaviours, relationships and roles”. The report fails to explain how a purely "social and cultural concept" can be an innate part of who someone is and form the basis of a medical intervention.
“Gender incongruence with or without distress” is defined as “an inconsistency between an individual’s gender and their sex recorded at birth”. Considering these definitions, this advice is explicitly stating that what they are treating is gender non-conformity. It is extremely troubling that the NHMRC considers this something requiring medical intervention.
The advice states that adopting a 'wait and see' approach as puberty progresses "may not improve distress and can affect the young person’s physical and mental health, wellbeing, and ability to function." However, many families, including some in our group, and non-affirming therapists, report that such an approach, combined with loving support, is highly effective at resolving distress. The weakness of the evidence for puberty suppression and the known high rates of natural resolution of childhood gender distress, are a glaring contradiction in the guidelines that the NHMRC has failed to address.
The advice also lists “outcomes [that] were prioritised as critical or important to the decisions of young people seeking care for gender incongruence and their parents or carers”. However, the fact that “Body image” is prioritised over “Quality of life” “Functioning” and “Mental health” highlights the immaturity of thinking from these young people, and their vulnerability. With a focus on desired aesthetics over long term health outcomes, the recommendations are serving consumer-driven demand cosmetic medicine, not healthcare.
“Body image” and “gender dysphoria” are considered “critical outcomes for decision making”, yet the supporting systematic evidence review concluded that there was little to no evidence of meaningful change in these outcomes. Given that, it is difficult to understand how a recommendation for puberty suppression can be made.
We are highly disappointed in both the rigour and quality of this advice. Considering that the weak evidence has once again been confirmed it is concerning that puberty suppression has still been recommended over safer options.
@ABCmediawatch @Mark_Butler_MP @mbachelard @PatrickElligett @rachelbaxendale @IngridStitt @nhmrc
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @free_equal
Stop suggesting to children that they will be harmed in some way by playing sport with other children of the same sex. It's cruel. And it's false.
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @KelseyTuoc
If these gender clinics could provide this high quality evidence i.e neutral indicators of improvement, why don't they do it? They have years of data now. You seem to be challenging people on being sceptical and suspicious of a group of people who've spent years behaving
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @tracewoodgrains
I think regret here, in such a vulnerable and young population, is the wrong measure for such serious and irreversible interventions. There is an enormous psychological pressure on these young people to believe they have not made a bad choice (I've seen it myself in my own son,
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @SenRaffCiccone
You want the know the really dangerous online communities? They're the ones that @AustralianLabor protect.
The ones that tell vulnerable young people their bodies are wrong and need 'fixing'.
Here, I'll make it easy for you. reddit.com/r/transgenderau/
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @washingtonpost
Why are gender clinics continuing to produce these extraordinarily weak studies? They could easily make an effort to follow up with all, or most, participants, they could measure neutral, objective outcomes, employment, sexual health, relationships, mental/physical health.
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @pagd_vic
@Mark_Butler_MP It's an experiment on the young and the vulnerable. Are you happy for it to continue? teapaw.org/pagd_vic/status/212040…
" The Dutch Protocol, once presented as a carefully constructed and evidence-based system of care, has proven to be riddled with methodological, ethical and clinical weaknesses. What was exported to the world as solid medical practice turns out, on closer inspection, to have been full of holes from the beginning."
Melanie retweeted
Of course the article finds that the included individuals broadly approve of their treatment. This is going to be headline news around the world. But is it true? Without including those 493 people, you simply cannot say.
Melanie retweeted
Wij zouden afgelopen donderdag 5 nov spreken namens onze groep van meer dan 100 ouders voor de Kamercommissie VWS over onze ervaringen met de NL transgenderzorg voor jongeren. Maar @radboudumc
en @amsterdamumc zegden af #transgender #dutchprotocol
genspect.nl/artikelen/kritis…
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @OldRoberts953
He's a con man, like Trump. Neither of them believe what they say. They just think it's going to get them something in that moment, praise, money, votes..
Melanie retweeted
Steve, a tiny dibbler at Perth Zoo, reportedly helped save his endangered species without ever becoming a father. Female dibblers prefer larger mates, and Steve was too small and apparently didn't smell appealing. Keepers used him as the first male females encountered during breeding trials. After meeting Steve, females found the next males more attractive and were more willing to mate. According to the zoo, Steve lived a long life as an unlikely conservation hero.
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @00001_Agent @estherzelda0514
I don't think Nishant understands feminism. Plenty of women opposed female emancipation, this doesn't mean that opposing women's right to vote is a feminist position. Supporting the patriarchy, even when done by a woman, is not feminism.
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @Lachlan_Edi
'the GC movement' what's that? If there's people who can move the Labour Government, where are they? If the Labour Government can't see the 'merit in some of the arguments', that's on them. This is just another version of the 'women were too toxic' argument.
Melanie retweeted
Replying to @edtchirp
Trans identified men are on massive doses of cross sex hormones, are you not aware of this? What do you think the risk is if a child is ingesting this directly vs skin contact, particularly a tiny baby. What parent would take that risk?














































