Plus the history teacher is a ghost who died awhile ago. He has probably not been keeping up on his Continuing Education Credits for recent events.
Came to appreciate a part of Harry Potter I used to think was faulty.
Just a few thoughts about a story that has accompanied me since I was nine years old (for the last 22 years).
I first read Harry Potter when it was published in my country and have reread it several times throughout my life. Every time, I discover new details or look at things differently. But there's one thing I've always found a little unnerving, especially since rereading it as an adult: how little the characters seem to know about the world around them.
For example, Harry knows about Voldemort and his parents from the first book, yet he learns some very basic facts about the whole Voldemort episode in wizarding history surprisingly late. In book four, he first learns what Death Eaters are. In book five, he discovers that his parents were part of an organisation called the Order of the Phoenix. And so on.
I always thought, "Come on, he's 13, 14 or 15 by now. He should know at least this much about history, especially when it's such an important part of his own life. Surely he would have researched it or asked someone?" The same goes for other basic aspects of the wizarding world that only get explained much later.
Of course, the explanation is that these things simply weren't important to the plot until Rowling needed them, so there was no reason to introduce them earlier. Still, it always felt unnatural to me that a 12, 13, 14, 15 or 16-year-old would know so little about the world he lives in. I always thought there had to be a better way to introduce these facts than having Harry, or even Ron, who grew up in a wizarding family, ask seemingly basic questions about history, the Ministry and so on.
Then last year, I started teaching at a school instead of a university, and I realised something: that's exactly how most kids are.
They might have heard certain terms, but they're often clueless about history (unless they've specifically studied it at school), how the economy works, or the political systems they live under. I've taught children who came from war zones as babies or toddlers but still had very little understanding of what happened there or who the parties involved were. They might recognise certain terms, but ask them to explain the details and they struggle. Even children born and raised here often have a very limited understanding of how the world around them works.
I think my adult perspective had made me forget that completely.
So when I reread Harry Potter this year, after starting to teach, I found that this aspect of the story felt much less unnatural than it used to. In fact, it struck me as a pretty solid depiction of how some preteen and teenage boys actually think and interact with the world.
Just wanted to share because I enjoy discovering a new perspective on a story I've read so many times.
2
245
So you know how there are BBQ chips and sour cream and onion chips? What if you made a chip that had different flavors on each side and ranch inside the potato batter?
28
They have enough people that every American can have their own personal spy. Because I do not have any secrets I imagine my spy is retired and bored.
中国は14億人の人口がいることから全ての好みに応じたハニートラップが準備できるという。因みに、安倍氏が総理時代に訪中した際、安倍氏は女性スキャンダルが皆無だったことから中国側は「安倍は男色…」と思い込み選りすぐりの美男子たちをズラりと用意したのは有名な話
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
この話は2022年『週刊現代』での井川意高氏の単一証言に基づく未確認の逸話で、他の独立した証拠や公式記録はない。
gendai.media/articles/-/100…
news.tvbs.com.tw/world/4047729
2
307
How is this even possible canon law wise? I am a third order Dominican and they are very clear that the obligations we take are promises not vows because they do not bear the pain of sin if broken and adamantly are not the evangelical counsels to do otherwise is to leave the lay state.
I really don’t think you should be taking any kind of vow of poverty if you have or plan to have a family…
1
1
64
I do not know about Hermione but Ginny needs to be with a muggle because:
1. It makes sense from her father's profession which she should also inherit.
2. All the talk about half bloods but there is barely any contact between muggle and magical for the mixing to happen.
3. It gives her role in the war more impact since she does not have the Harry focus.
My plan originally was for Ron to get with Hermione. But I really like the Ron X Pansy stuff. I don't want Hermione to be on her own. But man... I am yearning.
41
The date I begin to tolerate Advent music is November 11th because I heard somewhere that it used to be the start of Advent when Advent was longer which is also why it was chosen as the end date for WWI because there was a European tradition of ending wars then for Penance and winter. Christmas music must wait for Christmas but also can go the full older longer Christmas season.
8
Apparently what I like is tall foreheads, which explains why I support Malfoid.
I'm not sure "gym girl" is discernible from these photos tbqh; my type is girls who look like they have worthless graduate degrees and are about to ask "would you still love me if, hypothetically, I just hit a pedestrian? Do you have a shovel? Hypothetically, would you bury a body for me?"
1
22
Harry then gets in trouble because "British" since he does not have a license to make unserialnumbered wands nor the ownership of a second "fighting wand." He has to pay 1,000 galleons in fines which makes his winning the tournament much more needed.
“Whomping Willow… unyielding… and a basilisk heartstring core?” Ollivander questioned, his voice catching as he stared at Harry in astonishment. “This… this is not the wand I sold you.”
Harry shifted awkwardly. “Er, well, I… made it.”
Ollivander examined the wand again, his eyes gleaming with curiosity. “Acceptable craftsmanship, I must say! And an excellent choice for fighting.” He seemed to be restraining a smile. “But… Whomping Willow wood and a basilisk heartstring? Those aren't materials one simply finds.”
“Yeah, about that,” Harry said, scratching the back of his neck, seemingly oblivious to the whispers spreading among the other champions, judges and journalists. “After the Willow broke my Nimbus 2000, I might have… pruned it. Quite aggressively, actually.”
“And the core?” Ollivander asked, his voice filled with almost reverent wonder.
Harry glanced at the reporters, who were now buzzing with questions, before answering steadily. “You know the thousand-year-old basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets that I killed a couple of years ago?”
The muttering grew louder. Fleur, Cedric and Viktor all stared at Harry in disbelief. Rita Skeeter, quill and notebook at the ready, began pushing closer, clearly desperate for details.
Ollivander ignored them all. His attention remained fixed on Harry and his creation. “You harvested the basilisk yourself?”
“Well, yeah,” Harry replied, looking a little bashful. “It seemed a shame to leave it to rot, and the heart was just right there. I figured, to the victor go the spoils, you know?”
Ollivander nodded, his hands trembling with excitement as he examined the wand. “Quite the saying, indeed, Mr Potter. Whomping Willow wood is rarely used, given its incredible resilience and unwillingness to cooperate. But paired with a basilisk heartstring? Brilliant. A highly aggressive wand, exceptionally powerful… and dangerous.”
Fleur crossed her arms, frowning thoughtfully. “So you 'ave created a wand from scratch?” she asked, her usual aloofness giving way to open astonishment.
“Oh, it took ages,” Harry said, warming to the subject. “Getting the Willow wood was tricky. I had to keep dodging branches, so I ended up learning the Summoning Charm ahead of time. But the basilisk was harder. Getting a heartstring from a dead serpent that size was more… complicated than I expected. Not to mention yucky. I had to burn those clothes afterwards. They stank.”
Ollivander nodded knowingly, examining the slight asymmetry in the wood's grain. “And yet you managed. Remarkable. What wand-lore did you study? Self-taught, I presume?”
Harry beamed, scratching his head. “I found a few books on wand-making in the Restricted Section, and a really old one that was a gift from…” Sirius. “A friend. The Willow wood had to be carved very specifically to stop it lashing out at anyone who wasn't its master. And getting the core settled properly… I probably redid it four times.”
The crowd grew louder, several people trying to interrupt, but Ollivander and Harry were completely absorbed in their conversation.
---
“Now, Mr Potter — Harry. It's easier to match a wand to a child when you get a feel for their magic. The wand is easy; you simply hold it. With the child, you have to bring it out. A strong emotion does that,” Ollivander explained.
It had been a while since he'd had such a receptive audience. The boy was practically lapping up every word!
Harry rubbed the back of his neck and frowned. “Is that why you act all creepy? To bring out our magic? I honestly thought you just enjoyed scaring children.”
Ollivander smiled. “Oh, I do. Multitasking, Mr Potter.”
46
I do not want to "fly" I want independent command and for that there are only two options for a long term independent patrol Constitution Class or an Imperial Star Destroyer.
1
50
You thought the Parable of the 99 was about you wandering off into sin but really it was because you fell asleep (apathy) into sin.
17
Yes it is but love is not butterfly feelings in the stomach, not an emotion, not even attraction. Love is "to will the good of the other" the emotions serve to indicate goods and are given by God for a reason but love itself is a choice. Marriage is a reflection of the love of God, it is the place children first experience love and every failing of love in the family damages the children's view of God. Marriage is a radical exclusive love saying "I chose your good over every other good other than God who is the supreme Good and especially over my own good." The love between man and woman in marriage is foundational and the emotions that go with it are good but just like any emotion can be fickle so love must trump them. Therefore at certain points the emotions are not necessary but in those moments love is all the more a necessity for marriage.
32































