
Head Mathematician at Fnord technologies, 0.5 German, Trade Unionist. Agent 39919. Views my own. Online maths tuition, free from trans ideology. #RepealTheGRA
Joined February 2009
- Tweets14K
- Following3.3K
- Followers3.4K
- Likes274K
Pinned Tweet
The Labour Party manifesto at the next General Election should contain:
93%Repeal the GRA
7%Modernise the GRA
480 votes • Final resultsI have a lot of respect for Sonia, but this tweet conflates substantive consent(whether a third party can grant consent - the law already says they cannot) with ‘reasonable belief’ (whether a defendant can legally rely on a third party's claim as their defence).
The precise point is that it is NOT “already unlawful” to rely on a third party's assurance as the basis for a claimed reasonable belief in consent.
Because the judge was legally required to leave this "reasonable belief" question to the jury in the Joanne Young case, rather than ruling out third-party assurances as a matter of law, two jurors accepted that defence—or at least found reasonable doubt—on three counts (involving two defendants). Had one more juror agreed with them, those charges would have resulted in a hung jury rather than convictions.
As the 10–2 verdicts demonstrate, calling an amendment "utterly pointless" ignores how trials actually play out: while a third party cannot legally give consent, the current law still allows a jury to acquit a defendant if they accept that the third party's lie made the defendant's belief in consent "reasonable”.
Following Pelicot, Young, the current Manchester case and the others we know are in the pipeline, this gap in the law must be addressed.
#IStandWithJoanneYoungIn
Replying to @Cordeli43872191
It’s utterly pointless and not a good precedent to set that Parliament should spend time making already unlawful things unlawful, because it would lead to even more demands to do this and would leave even less time to achieve more meaningful legislative reform.
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Dispiriting exchange between @DannyBeales MP & @matildagosling in today’s #ConversionBill committee. Has Beales really not yet understood the significance of the correlation in young ppl between transgender identity & mental ill health, autism, sexual assault & being in care? /1>
Congratulations to SEGM founding board member Julia Mason, MD, whose article on puberty blockers and the Dutch protocol is one of Physician's Weekly's 10 most-read features of 2026.
She argues that blockers may worsen gender dysphoria and that the supporting studies are flawed. ⬇️
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
No man should ever have been placed in NHS female ward accomodation
No man should ever have used female changing rooms or toilets
No man should ever have been led to believe by NHS medics he could transition out of his sex
Trans people in Scotland are becoming so fearful about new single-sex guidance that some are refusing to go to hospital against medical advice with fear being 'stoked', MSPs have heard
Mary-Ann Stevenson, chairwoman of the EHRC, argued some of the fears surrounding what the guidance means had been fuelled by the way it had been discussed
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
A Green councillor in Solihull shared a video calling Holocaust remembrance “pornography” and likening the Star of David to the swastika.
I’ve demanded she lose the whip and be expelled.
This is what “Zionism is racism” looks like on the ground. Your move, @TheGreenParty .
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Thank you Rebecca De Mornay and every single non-Jewish person standing with the Jewish community during such a dark time
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Btw, if you’re applauding Joanne Young’s courage while still working to abolish women-only spaces, you’re part of the problem of appropriating consent
“Consent has to come from the person themselves. No one should be able to give it on your behalf .. ”
apple.news/AI7yPPEKYSbm9gscu…?
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Replying to @LoudBonnet
I think the people who told everyone this years ago were labelled as "Ultras" and condemned as far-right or some such ostracising term.
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Replying to @LoudBonnet @theadoracleaver
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Replying to @LoudBonnet
Pronouns cannot function as correction fluid for those dissatisfied with reality. However, they are an effective tool of coercive control when used by people in positions of authority. A reminder that 'those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities'.
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
It is propaganda- and really crap at that- masquerading as education. So so boring for the average child.
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Replying to @prof_curiosity1
We used to teach children to listen to their gut instinct and not to worry about upsetting others by saying 'no' to something they felt uncomfortable about.
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
If you want to see what transactivists really think of children, here you are. Cartoon characters uttering adult sentiments in a manner that is convincing and lifelike only to the person who wrote it. This is the "mini adult" personified. Wholly idiotic.
Replying to @RooneyRachel @IsntWorkingPod
Are they really using this with 9 year olds? The shaming/ostracising of the little girl who questions… telling her not to listen to her family member… It feels incredibly manipulative (and potentially dangerous re safeguarding?)
Cc @prof_curiosity1
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
It seems back in 2009 Olivia Bailey was leading the charge for “no debate”, and succeeded in getting Julie Bindel banned by the NUS. That “no debate” policy has proved to be an unmitigated disaster.
Why I despise Olivia Bailey MP, the architect of gender ideology in the Labour Party: juliebindel.substack.com/p/w…
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Replying to @roisinmurphy
Róisín is right. Young people are being harmed in the service of a male misogyny fetish
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Replying to @roisinmurphy
Yup 👏👏👏👏
Q:”How and why have we got here so quickly with transgenderism?”
A: “this is a men’s sexual rights movement...”
#NewMisogyny
I really hope you can engage with this important point @soniasodha
Quite frustrated with this.
Of course there is no concept of third-party consent to sex in law.
But there is also NO provision in the Sexual Offences Act 2003 that says says that a third party's statement cannot be relied upon as the basis for a defendant's 'reasonable belief' that a woman consented to sexual activity. (There *was* such a provision in the original draft of the bill but it was withdrawn - see following comment).
It is entirely up to the jury whether they think this belief is 'reasonable', given all the circumstances.
And, given that two of the defendants in Joanne Young's case were only convicted on a 10/2 majority, we know that some jurors will accept this as a defence.
Which is why the law must be changed.
1
125
Quite frustrated with this.
Of course there is no concept of third-party consent to sex in law.
But there is also NO provision in the Sexual Offences Act 2003 that says says that a third party's statement cannot be relied upon as the basis for a defendant's 'reasonable belief' that a woman consented to sexual activity. (There *was* such a provision in the original draft of the bill but it was withdrawn - see following comment).
It is entirely up to the jury whether they think this belief is 'reasonable', given all the circumstances.
And, given that two of the defendants in Joanne Young's case were only convicted on a 10/2 majority, we know that some jurors will accept this as a defence.
Which is why the law must be changed.
Replying to @soniasodha
Sonia, third-party consent and reasonable belief in consent are two entirely different legal concepts.
A third party cannot consent to sexual activity on behalf of another person. Consent must come from the individual herself.
However, under the Sexual Offences Act 2003, a defendant *can* argue that he reasonably believed a woman consented because a third party assured him she had agreed - which is exactly what the defendants did argue in Joanne Young's case.
That assurance does not constitute the woman's consent. It is simply evidence the defendant may rely upon when arguing that his belief in consent was reasonable. It is then for the jury to decide whether it was reasonable in the circumstances.
There is NO explicit provision in the Sexual Offences Act 2003 which says that a third party's statement cannot be relied upon as the basis for a defendant's 'reasonable belief' that a woman consented to sexual activity.
That is what Joanne would like amended; she wants an explicit provision that reliance on third party assurances can never be considered as a 'reasonable belief'.
Interestingly, such a clause (77) was in the original draft of the bill but objections were raised and it was withdrawn from the final legislation. It needs to be re-instated (with a specific defence that takes into account Lord Carlile's reasonable concern).
(P.S. Two of the defendants in Jo's case were only convicted on 10/2 majority verdicts - so there were two members of the jury who accepted their defence. That is why we need an explicit provision, as above).
publications.parliament.uk/p…
hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/…
Victorian KPSS Ultra 🦕🦖 🕸 retweeted
Replying to @alexmassie @SydneyAllMoore
I agree, I used to be very naive about anti-semitism in the UK I just didn’t think it existed. The last few years have opened my eyes.




























