
Head of @GHS Europe. Tweets mainly health, politics, business and Leeds United. Thought origins difficult to pin down.
London
Joined June 2009
- Tweets8.4K
- Following1.3K
- Followers2.2K
- Likes9.4K
Good way to end a debate that should never have been.
Spectacular Nature piece on why AI is not conscious and probably will never be.
Three arguments:
1) Intelligence is not consciousness.
Intelligence is about solving problems. Consciousness is about having subjective experiences.
AlphaFold can solve super difficult problems. By contrast, our brains performs complex operations entirely outside awareness.
Problem-solving and consciousness are two separate things.
2. Biology is essential.
Our brains are alive, down to every cell. Their activity is inseparable from the living tissue that produces it.
The idea that consciousness can be reproduced simply by running the right computations on silicon components who do not fight for their life is a very far fetching and, I would add, almost religious, assumption.
3) The physical organization may matter more than the computation.
According to integrated information theory, consciousness requires specific causal relationships between a system’s physical components.
The computer architectures running today’s AI lack this organization.
The comparison with AlphaFold is particularly revealing:
Almost nobody things AlphaFold is conscious, despite its inner working is very similar to an LLM
Why?
Because it does not speak.
LLMs do speak like us and therefore we fall into an illusion:
Since they speak like us, they must be like us.
But this inference is wrong.
LLMs are just a series of matrix multiplications.
They are not conscious, and they will never be.
*
Paper in the first reply
1
297
This is all very well, but could it help bad actors do it....can't see why not?
I must be among an extremely small group of people (n=1?) that have both 1) trained a frontier LLM and 2) designed and synthesized custom viruses in a lab with my own two hands.
And I think that the takes on AI killing us all by creating dangerous viruses is total bogus.
1
319
I was young (23) when I was lucky enough to volunteer at @TAC. I witnessed Zackie and comrades fighting and winning the right to health.
Post the Iraq War, I learned that there is always hope for a better tomorrow but we've got to fight for it...
Enjoy the day, mate!
Socrates and I pondering the future in 2005
On 2 September 2026, I will remember my first day as a political activist at Salt River High School and my socialist journey with thousands of comrades and friends over the last 50 years.
Above all, although I did not finish school, my education is the best anyone anywhere could have hoped for because of my mentors and peers.
To the mentors who have died - long life in our memories and histories.
Jean Naidoo
Theresa Solomon
Dullah Omar
Lettie Malindi
Zohra Mehlomakulu
Johnny Issel
Martin Legassick
To those mentors who live still
Jack Lewis (also the great love of my life)
Marcus Solomon
Rob Petersen
Paula Ensor
Jane Taylor
Edwin Cameron
Nathan Geffen
Geoff Budlender
Ann Grant
Jonathan Pollak
Alaa Abd El Fattah
My comrades present and past, lost and loved are too many to mention. They will find their names on a scroll when I draw my last breath.
Tonight, I am content to live or to die but as long as I live and I will, we can work for justice, equality, freedom and dignity with solidarity, reason and conscience.
All of us. Together.
Zackie
1
89
For the first time in the four-decade fight against HIV there is a “miracle” drug that can all but eliminate the risk of infection, but in the Latin American countries where it was tested almost no one can get it.
Trials show that Lenacapavir, made by Gilead Sciences, is almost 100 per cent effective in preventing HIV infection. With just two shots a year, those taking it will avoid contracting the virus even when frequently exposed.
The drug, which many believe could bring an end to the global HIV pandemic, costs $14,000 a dose in the United States.
Gilead has agreed to licence generic versions of the pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) medication at around $40 a dose in 120 low-and middle-income countries, but almost all of Latin America is excluded.
Brazil, Mexico, Argentina and Peru are among those with serious HIV epidemics that are shut out, despite having run some of the clinical trials that proved the drug works.
Their status as “upper-middle income countries” means they are too rich to qualify for the cut price generic version and yet they remain too poor to pay the US price....
John Butler retweeted
A new study from England, #UK, has recorded zero deaths from #CervicalCancer among young women who were vaccinated against #HPV as girls.
Since @WHO made the call to action in May 2018, countries across the world are rolling out the WHO Global Strategy to Eliminate Cervical Cancer — by scaling up vaccination, screening and treatment.
And today, 165 countries have now introduced this lifesaving vaccine.
In fact, a single dose of the vaccine is now proving to be protective towards almost zero risk of cervical cancer.
When science, political commitment and dedicated health workers join forces, #HealthForAll becomes a reality.
bbc.com/news/articles/c621z2…
John Butler retweeted
The Republic of #Korea is one of only four countries in the world that has reached a #hypertension control rate above 50%.
Globally, every hour, over 1000 lives are lost to strokes and heart attacks from high blood pressure, while hypertension control is one of the most cost-effective interventions in public health. This is why I call on world and health leaders to heed ROK's experience:
How South Korea cracked its blood pressure crisis – and what other countries can learn
As blood pressure spikes globally, the East Asian nation is leading the way on how to buck the trend
✍️@sneweyy has the latest
telegraph.co.uk/global-healt…
John Butler retweeted
Briefing 194 Member States @FAO on Nigeria’s 5th High-Level Ministerial Ministerial on AMR. Big focus on agriculture and livestock. For the first time, Ministers of Agriculture /Livestock will be in the room alongside Health & Environment. That's the shift we need. #AbujaAMR2026
This is a critical piece. The underlying message is that cutting aid to countries like the DRC undermined global health security....Brilliant!
A big one from @jwgale @jessicanix_ & the team: The world’s outbreak defenses were rebuilt after the 2014 Ebola epidemic. Now a new crisis in Congo is testing what remains after deep aid cuts & health program rollbacks bloomberg.com/news/features/…
44
John Butler retweeted
NOW‼️ I’m now in the Global Coordination Meeting on this, we continue to hear about vaccines and treatments but yet there are no RDTs 17 years after this specie of Ebola was discovered - it is not NEW. Yet we still have no tools, because the people are poor and lives undervalued.
There is no rapid test for the current Ebola strain in eastern Congo. Because early Ebola symptoms are the same as for typhoid or malaria, and all people with those symptoms are isolated together, some people end up being infected with Ebola at the place they came for care. That discourages people who fall ill from seeking care and increases the chance they will infect others. nytimes.com/2026/06/02/healt…
John Butler retweeted
Resistance to antibiotics is a major threat to human health. We do we continue then to use them routinely to promote the growth of intensively farmed livestock? theguardian.com/environment/…
John Butler retweeted
Abuja is hosting the first ever High-Level Meeting on AMR in Africa, and it is also bringing together leaders in agriculture, trade, foreign affairs, as well as health, which is absolutely critical considering the challenge facing the world. @AMRAbuja2026
Productive meeting w Nigeria's Global Envoy on #AMR, Dr. Ayoade Alakija. We discussed advancing #OneHealth agenda & translating global commitments into transformative action ahead of 5th Ministerial Meeting on AMR in Abuja.
@yodifiji
@FAONigeria
#AMRAbuja2026
@AMRAbuja2026
John Butler retweeted
Productive meeting w Nigeria's Global Envoy on #AMR, Dr. Ayoade Alakija. We discussed advancing #OneHealth agenda & translating global commitments into transformative action ahead of 5th Ministerial Meeting on AMR in Abuja.
@yodifiji
@FAONigeria
#AMRAbuja2026
@AMRAbuja2026
📢 Call to diagnostic developers! FIND & @IPPS are mapping the diagnostic landscape for the Ebola outbreak caused by Bundibugyo virus.
If you have existing or pipeline technologies for decentralized testing & outbreak response, we want to hear from you.
Submit your Expression of Interest: finddx.org/wp-content/upload…
#DiagnosisForAll #Ebola
John Butler retweeted
Congo is seeking access to an experimental antibody treatment targeting multiple #Ebola strains as confirmed infections and deaths continue climbing. DRC confirmed 121 cases and 17 deaths; suspected cases climbed to 1,077 and suspected deaths reached 238 bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
I’d never heard of preeclampsia before Aleks was told she may develop it.
It’s onset, so quick yet silent, makes me grateful for the care we had in Switzerland but motivated to demand that all women (and babies) have access to quality care.
Proud of your advocacy, Aleks.❤️
At 36 weeks 🤰, a sudden spike in blood pressure sent me to the hospital with #preeclampsia within hours.
What stays with me most is how fast it happened & how many 🤰 face this without access to timely care.
Know the symptoms. Trust yourself. Take action. #WorldPreeclampsiaDay
2
139
The most important thing to know about the Ebola epidemic in DRC is this: bringing it under control will rely almost entirely on health workers winning the TRUST of local communities.
This may sound dull, even woke, when compared to talk of experimental vaccines etc. But it’s true, not to mention hugely difficult, resource intensive and dangerous.
The logic is this: you have one of the most frightening infectious diseases spreading in a huge uneducated population that has been subjected to horrific poverty and violence for many years. Yet there are no vaccines or special treatments. The only way to stop it is to break the chains of transmission and this requires the full cooperation of the population.
Winning trust won’t be easy.
More than 2m have been displaced by a conflict that has frequently been marked with mass rapes and village massacres — violence that seemingly occurs without rhyme or reason. There is no understanding of science or politics, and superstition and paranoia understandably fill the gap.
This is what hundreds of local health workers employed by the Red Cross, WHO, MSF and others are walking into.
To slow and eventually end the outbreak they must convince people with symptoms to come forward so they can be isolated away from their families and treated by people clad head to toe in PPE.
Even in death, of which there will be much, they must explain that victims must be separated from their loved ones and forego burial and grieving rites that are central to their faith and understanding.
When we think about the Ebola outbreak in DRC we should think about what we would do in such a situation. How we would win the trust of terrified families were we charged with doing so.
We should think too about the resources that are needed to pay for and support those putting their lives on the line on our behalf.
As things stand, the money needed for the emergency response is only about 40% funded and yet it must last for many months, probably years, if the epidemic is to be successfully brought under control.
John Butler retweeted
The AMR High Level Ministerial Troika meets at #WHA79 in Geneva. With Minister Alexandre Padilha of Brazil 🇧🇷 and his team - we have reviewed the near final agenda and the Abuja Accord outcome document. Now for external consultations. #AMRAbuja2026 #5thHLMM
Selamat datang, Pak Bonanza! 🌏We're delighted to welcome Mr Taihitu P. Bonanza to the FIND Board. His decades of global health diplomacy and leadership at Indonesia's Ministry of Health will help us build the partnerships we need to expand equitable access to diagnostics, for everyone, everywhere. finddx.org/publications-and-…
In case you don't read to the bottom, thought Paul's last line was critical:
"Look again at that map and consider where we would be if the virus was more infectious, or had mutated to become so. It is why the World Health Organization and pandemic planning is so important."
One of the clear lessons of the hantavirus outbreak is that *chance* makes a huge difference to how a disease can spread.
The Andes strain of the virus causes 100s of human infections every year, but most burn out almost immediately.
Occasionally, there is a bigger outbreak fueled by human-to-human transmission but these are rare.
The pattern is a feature of almost all zoonotic spillover events, millions of which happen each year involving thousands of different pathogens.
Mercifully, most go nowhere. They flare then vanish.
Now enter *chance* – a series of unforeseen but often predictable environmental circumstances or events.
A wet market, a trunk road, a game of beer-pong … or in this case, a hop-on-hop-off international cruise with connecting flights.
The map below shows the 12 countries that passengers flew to after disembarking one leg of the cruise in St Helena in late April.
30 passengers disembarked there, one dead, but no one knew then about the disease to which they had been exposed.
The outbreak has been serious, with three dead and at least five suspected cases so far.
About 150 remain on the ship, while hundreds of potential secondary contacts are being traced and asked to isolate around the world.
Nevertheless, the chances are that *this* outbreak will die out too.
The virus does not appear to spread efficiently enough to sustain itself, even with the circumstances it has been handed.
But here’s the thing: it’s a numbers game.
Look again at that map and consider where we would be if the virus was more infectious, or had mutated to become so.
It is why the World Health Organization and pandemic planning is so important.
John Butler retweeted
The outbreak of Hentavirus on a cruise ship is a stress test and is exposing the diagnostic gaps we @FINDdx have been warning about for years.
#Hantavirus hasn’t respected borders. Neither can our response. Diagnostics are the missing infrastructure for global health security.




























