Day 182: 🚨 THREE MORE SECOND APPEALS REGISTERED — CHIEF OF ARMY STAFF, AIR HQ & CHIEF OF NAVAL HQ #SPARSHFailsVeterans (👁️ 87,780 Views) Continuation of Day 181. Three further Second Appeals now stand registered before the CIC. 1️⃣ APPLICATION 2026211046 — CIC/DPTMA/A/2026211046 (registered 23 OCT 26) ADDRESSED TO #COAS GENERAL DHIRAJ SETH RTI DMAND/R/T/26/11827 dated 06 Jul 26 sought from IHQ of MoD (Army): • whether parent RTI 06906 was forwarded within Army HQ • notings on SPARSH & on shifting data-correction onto Ex-Servicemen • any assessment of aged & non-tech-savvy pensioners • any recommendation that PCDA (Pensions) update blank & wrong data from records it holds WHAT THE CPIO DID (letter A/810027/RTI/OL_103039 dated 10 Aug 26): • Paras 1–2: stated not held & transferred under Section 6(3); no new registration number intimated; transfer not on portal • Para 3: denied under Section 8(1)(e) • Paras 4–5: treated as clarification & outside the Act WHAT THE FAA DID: • First Appeal DMAND/A/E/26/03311 filed 21 Aug 26 (also emailed 24 Aug 26) • portal marks it forwarded on 07 Oct 26 • no speaking order on the card 2️⃣ APPLICATION 2026211127 — CIC/DPTMA/A/2026211127 (REGISTERED 24 OCT 26) ADDRESSED TO AIR HEADQUARTERS / OFFICE OF THE CHIEF OF THE AIR STAFF RTI DMAND/R/E/26/06906/3 dated 10 Apr 26 sought from Air HQ: • views before SPARSH launch • comments of the Chief & Headquarters • feedback on age, education & technical capability of Ex-Servicemen • any record of objection to shifting data-correction onto pensioners • records of the assurance given on 14 Jan 25 WHAT THE CPIO DID (letter Air HQ/25005/40633/PS(RTI) DATED 13 AUG 26): • stated information not held • transferred under Section 6(3) to PCDA (Pensions) • portal marks RTI disposed on 18 Aug 26 • no point-wise reply on records sought from Air HQ WHAT THE FAA DID: • First Appeal DMAND/A/E/26/04577 filed 28 Aug 26 (also emailed the same day) • portal marks it forwarded on 12 Oct 26 • no speaking order on the card 3️⃣ APPLICATION 2026212515 — CIC/DPTMA/A/2026212515 (REGISTERED 25 Oct 26) ADDRESSED TO #CNS ADMIRAL KRISHNA SWAMINATHAN RTI DMAND/R/T/26/13018 dated 08 Aug 26 sought from Naval Headquarters / Office of the CNS: • whether earlier Navy RTI 06906/1 was forwarded within NHQ • notings on SPARSH & on shifting data-correction onto Ex-Servicemen • any assessment of aged & non-tech-savvy pensioners • any recommendation that PCDA (Pensions) update blank & wrong data from records it holds WHAT THE CPIO DID: • portal shows RTI received on 08 Aug 26 • status remains RTI REQUEST RECEIVED • no point-wise reply & no speaking transfer • thirty days expired on or about 07 Sep 26; silence is deemed refusal under Section 7(2) WHAT THE FAA DID: • First Appeal DMAND/A/E/26/06697 filed 09 Sep 26 • portal continues to show RTI APPEAL RECEIVED • no speaking order on the card • outer date under Section 19(6) was 24 Oct 26 📍 THE LAW (ALL THREE CASES): • Section 6(3) transfers an application; it does not transfer a First Appeal • Section 19(6) requires a speaking order within 30 days (45 days only with reasons in writing) • forwarding is not a decision The records sought, if they exist, sit with the respective Service Headquarters. 🙏 THE SPARSH REQUEST IS UNCHANGED. CGDA and PCDA (Pensions), as Pension Sanctioning Authority, are requested to correct blank and wrong fields from PPO, Corr PPO and ePPO records they already hold. Jai Hind! 🇮🇳 @PMOIndia @DefenceMinIndia @DrJitendraSingh @SpokespersonMoD #DefenceSecretary #FADS @DoPTGoI #SecretaryDoPT @DefenceAccounts #CGDA @PcdaPensions @HQ_IDS_India #CDS @adgpi #COAS @indiannavy #CNS @IAF_MCC #CAS @Vedmalik1 @arunp2810 @kayjay34350 @Ptr6Vb @rakesharma15 @ColTekpal @RDXThinksThat @amitabhafirst @kkhushal9 @IndianExpress @thetribunechd @timesofindia @htTweets @BDUTT @dibang @ravish_journo

Quote to Day 182: 🚨 THREE SERVICE HEADQUARTERS (INDIAN ARMY, INDIAN NAVY & INDIAN AIR FORCE) AND THE DEPARTMENT OF MILITARY AFFAIRS — ONE PATTERN #SPARSHFailsVeterans (👁️ 87,918 Views) Day 182 tweet recorded three Second Appeals now registered before the Central Information Commission (CIC). The pattern is the same in each. 📌 WHAT WAS SOUGHT Records held with the respective Service Headquarters: • views before the SPARSH launch • comments of the Chief and Headquarters • feedback on the age, education and technical capability of Ex-Servicemen • any record of objection to shifting data-correction onto pensioners • any assessment of aged and non-tech-savvy pensioners • any recommendation that PCDA (Pensions) update blank and wrong data from records it already holds 📌 WHAT THE CPIOs DID • Army HQ / COAS (RTI 11827): letter of 10 Aug 26 — Paras 1–2 transferred under Section 6(3) with no new number intimated; Para 3 denied under 8(1)(e); Paras 4–5 treated as outside the Act • Air HQ (RTI 06906/3): letter of 13 Aug 26 — stated information not held and transferred under Section 6(3) to PCDA (Pensions); portal marks disposed; no point-wise reply on Air HQ records • Naval HQ / CNS (RTI 13018): portal shows only “RTI REQUEST RECEIVED”; no point-wise reply; silence after 30 days is deemed refusal under Section 7(2) 📌 WHAT THE FAAs DID • First Appeals filed in August–September 26 • portal marks each as “forwarded” or still “RECEIVED” • no speaking order on any card • outer dates under Section 19(6) have passed 📍 THE LAW IS THE SAME IN ALL THREE • Section 6(3) transfers an application; it does not transfer a First Appeal • Section 19(6) requires a speaking order within 30 days (45 days only with reasons in writing) • forwarding is not a decision The records sought, if they exist, sit with the Service Headquarters that were asked. ❓ THE SPARSH REQUEST REMAINS UNCHANGED. CGDA and PCDA (Pensions), as Pension Sanctioning Authority, are requested to correct blank and wrong fields from PPO, Corr PPO and ePPO records they already hold. 🎖️ An aged veteran, especially a pre-2016 pensioner, should not be made the first examiner of a file the office already possesses. Jai Hind. 🇮🇳 @PMOIndia @DefenceMinIndia @DrJitendraSingh @SpokespersonMoD #DefenceSecretary #FADS @DoPTGoI #SecretaryDoPT @DefenceAccounts #CGDA @PcdaPensions @HQ_IDS_India @adgpi @indiannavy @IAF_MCC @Vedmalik1 @arunp2810 @kayjay34350 @Ptr6Vb @rakesharma15 @ColTekpal @RDXThinksThat @amitabhafirst @kkhushal9 @IndianExpress @thetribunechd @timesofindia @htTweets @BDUTT @dibang @ravish_journo