Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
I am a millenial, Carrick, rooney, giggs, scholes holds a special place in my heart. The way MC got treated is a disgrace, has disheartened me quite a lot. Also for the first time @lauriewhitwell @Ankaman616 are upset too. Call them out.
#GlazersOut
#IneosOut
#ManchesterUnited
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
Michael Carrick sacked by MUFC.
Top lad, got the team in the Champions League against expectations. Gave it his all, night and day. Protected others, never threw anyone under a bus. Worked in difficult circumstances. Leaves with head held high. I wish him and his staff the very best.
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
Michael Carrick has to take his share of responsibility for the mess at Manchester United - and may pay the price with his job sooner or later - but he’s not the real problem there. Yes, there was some fighting spirit, the late rally and point against Aston Villa but still … shocking starts to both halves, four goals shipped, second bottom, humiliating, why not the fearless Shea Lacey on earlier? It can’t go on like this, stumbling, slip, sliding away, briefly regaining footing. International breaks are an obvious opportunity for a board to act and players may open up on United woes when away with their national teams.
The Stretford End sang Carrick’s name. They know how much he cares about the Club, and how well he served them as a player with far more determination than the current woeful generation. Fans know their plight is as much on Ineos, the Glazers and the recruitment “experts”. No defence. Really, they have no defence.
Whoever follows Carrick whenever he goes inherits a mess not of his making but of the club’s: a squad of signings long on cost but short on strength of character. They fought back against Roma and Villa but why start so sluggishly? It will take a few windows and proper focus on mindset as well as technical skill-set to sort out.
The contrast with Villa’s smart recruitment under Unai Emery (Nicolas Jackson, Alysson and, earlier, Morgan Rogers etc) is very obvious. Villa lost good players (Rogers, Ollie Watkins etc) but replaced well. If they hadn't got a bit complacent, and hadn't sat off, Villa would have beaten United.
United need a new defence before a new stadium. The back-four on the hour was Noussair Mazraoui, Leny Yoro, Ayden Heaven and Diogo Dalot. That's a rickety fence. At a club where they once had such warriors and talent as Gary Neville, Nemanja Vidic, Rio Ferdinand and Patrice Evra as a back-line. That's a wall.
Dalot is an average right-back playing painfully out of position at left-back. He works hard but his decision-making is so suspect. His naive challenge on Alysson, and his presence at left-back, summed up the skewed recruitment at United. Every United fan said they needed a new left-back in pre-season. Dalot was replaced by Patrick Dorgu who rescued a point but has been injured and hardly impressed overall since joining in 2025. He's no Evra or Denis Irwin.
Yoro is a 20-year-old centre-back who cost £50m in 2024 and he’s hardly trained on. Another 20-year-old, Heaven, has promise but still has so much to learn. Mazraoui is nothing special. The keeper Senne Lammens is left exposed by his defence too often but he, too, is culpable: he's pushing the ball out in front of him, still in traffic, rather than wide.
And Harry Maguire should have left by now. The club has to make stronger decisions. Look at Arsenal who overhauled their squad, starting with paying off Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang with a reported £7m. Then rebuilt. United’s squad, added to over the years with no consistency of thought, needs clearing out. How many United players would get in Arsenal's starting XI? None.
Money has been spent but so badly. And it will be Carrick who pays the price rather than underachieving players, detached owners and those responsible for such wretched recruitment. And the whole cycle of doom will begin again. #MUFC
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
Michael Carrick will doubtless pay the price with his job for this deserved defeat to an excellent Bournemouth side and another lifeless display by his Manchester United team. Some of his selections and tactics have been questionable, United were again so open in the centre. But Carrick was not responsible for recruiting Youri Tielemans, who lacks physicality and mobility (and Aston Villa haven’t missed him) and Andrey Santos, a Chelsea reserve.
Carrick was not responsible for the board’s damaging failure to strengthen at centre-back and left-back. Carrick was not responsible for his main striker Benjamin Sesko being injured and the board’s failure to provide him with cover. Carrick was not responsible for the club he loves being in the grip of co-owners like the Glazers whose priorities are focused more on business than the sport. The direction from the top has been negligible, arguably negligent. No real leadership. No expertise.
Carrick may be out of his depth but many United fans sang his name during the painful demise to Bournemouth because they know he cares and they know the problems lie elsewhere. The Stretford End again sang in protest at the wretched Glazers.
Noticeable that there were few songs in support of Bruno Fernandes. He is supposed to be captain, rallying the players, Footballer of the Year, Player of the Year, not arm-waver of the year, underachieving and complaining. Yet Bruno will be at United longer than Carrick.
Carrick was praised for United finishing third last season and getting in the Champions League. But he will doubtless go partly for his own failings and mainly the failings of others. And United will be trapped in this doom loop again. And again until the core problems are addressed in the boardroom - and the Glazers sell up - and flaws in the recruitment department. #MUFC #MUNBOU
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
"Sell United and f*k off home" sing MUFC fans, the only good thing about the club right now.
And it's right. The Glazers have made their money many times over for 21 years. Fans never wanted it and that takeover should never have been allowed. Do the right thing: sell up and go.
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
Como 4 Comatose 0. Embarrassing by Manchester United. No fight, no concentration, no tracking, no marking. This is down to the board for poor recruitment, to players for not working hard enough and to Carrick for not inspiring or organising them. Woeful. #MUFC
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
He isn’t alone, but Martinez isn’t good enough for #MUFC. He gets stuck in. Fans love that. Imagine Stam/Bruce/Pallister/Vidic/Rio allowing Solanke to score that goal this evening. Never in a million years.
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
It doesn’t matter who United hire, I’ll back him 100% & want him succeed. From Moyes to Amorim. That’ll never change.
I’m fed up of seeing them fail, but the club have gotta give Carrick the best possible chance. The squad needs big investment or he’ll fail. It’s that simple.
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
The human cost of reporting on Man City’s cheating for 15 years. It’s on the Mail website today and will be in the MoS paper tomorrow (Sunday) but they backed my reporting 100%. That reporting continues on my Substack. Google it for details. dailymail.com/sport/football…
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
"The biggest team to benefit from this is Man United..."
@MarkOgden_ makes a compelling case for why Man United are the club that benefits the most from Man City's current alleged charges...
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
OLIVER HOLT: Man City have been exposed as the most famous cheats in English sporting history. The gory details revealed by the Premier League leave no doubt - nothing less than relegation will suffice for this sinister, dishonest club trib.al/9kpRxri
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
It's official. The statement released today by the Premier League ultimately confirms, unequivocally, the truth of everything that was revealed through Football Leaks. The Independent Commission is also particularly harsh in the way it characterises the actions taken by Manchester City executives, who, without a shadow of a doubt, acted with complete impunity, challenging everyone and everything. From the very beginning, they have demonstrated a complete lack of respect for the rules, for the bodies responsible for overseeing and regulating the game, for the integrity of the competition, for the other clubs and, above all, for the fans.
Years and years of cheating, lying and manipulation will finally have consequences.
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
Manchester City’s reiteration of their “confidence and intent in proving the club’s innocence” given their “comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence” is incredibly at odds with their own behaviour and the intensity in which they blocked the Premier League’s process of investigation at every step since December 2018.
The scale of their obstructing was revealed in a July 2021 British court judgment. City simply refused to supply information and documents requested by the league, which then issued a disciplinary complaint in August 2019. The club challenged the disciplinary process and the commission that was set up.
The league proposed an ad hoc procedure of appointing a new commission, but City objected to that too. The PL were forced to bring legal arbitration against the club, to be decided by a tribunal of three senior lawyers.
City countered the PL had no power to do that, and challenged the impartiality of the tribunal. That was rejected and the club were again ordered to submit all the documentation and info.
City then appealed to the high court to strike the tribunal down. In March 2021, a judge ruled against the club and that her findings should be published.
City unsuccessfully fought against it being made public knowledge; the judgement published in July illustrated just how hard and long they resisted providing information.
With all that confidence, intent and irrefutable evidence, why the YEARS of non-cooperation and active, intensive blocking?
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
I hate the idea of asterisks or spaces where winners’ names should be. It feels like a desecration of football’s history. But after the guilty verdicts, I don’t see any other way - City should be relegated from the PL and stripped of titles won since 2009 dailymail.com/sport/football…
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
⚖️ 𝗘𝘅𝗽𝗹𝗮𝗶𝗻𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝘄𝗵𝘆 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗠𝗮𝗻 𝗖𝗶𝘁𝘆 𝗽𝘂𝗻𝗶𝘀𝗵𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁 𝗺𝘂𝘀𝘁 𝗯𝗲 𝘀𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗿𝗲
Here are the arguments that I expect the PL legal team will make for why the Independent Commission must apply the most severe punishments possible.
1) 𝙋𝙤𝙞𝙣𝙩𝙨 𝙙𝙚𝙙𝙪𝙘𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣𝙨 𝙩𝙤 𝙧𝙚𝙡𝙚𝙜𝙖𝙩𝙚
The typical points deduction baseline for a regular PSR breach is 6 points for the breach and a further point for every £5m over the limit. These are then varied for mitigating and aggravating circumstances.
By my calculations, Man City breached PSR by at least £120-140m each year over 2015/16-2017/18. In aggregate, that would mean a baseline of 96 points deducted. But this was not a regular PSR breach either. It was historic, hidden, the platform for all success and future growth and what’s more, they then sought to evade / fight justice for years.
So the points deduction should probably be larger than 96. The simple reality is they must go down.
Anything less would be egregious (when viewed alongside precedent) and subject to not only appeal, but almost certainly Section X arbitration and judidical review on the basis it was a perverse outcome.
2) 𝙃𝙪𝙜𝙚 𝙛𝙞𝙣𝙖𝙣𝙘𝙞𝙖𝙡 𝙞𝙢𝙥𝙡𝙞𝙘𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙤𝙣𝙨, 𝙧𝙚𝙙𝙪𝙘𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙈𝙖𝙣 𝘾𝙞𝙩𝙮’𝙨 𝙛𝙪𝙩𝙪𝙧𝙚 𝙨𝙥𝙚𝙣𝙙𝙞𝙣𝙜
Given precedent of other fines applied by Commissions, the scale of the offences, and the length of time taken from discovery to sanction (mostly due to Man City’s non-cooperation), Man City can expect the largest ever fine in football history.
I will do a more detailed thread on this soon, but I suspect a fine of up to £100m (justified on the basis of damage to the PL brand) and compensation claims to the 4 clubs of more than £1bn in total.
Normally, fines and compensation claims are not counted when assessing FFP / PSR because to include them would be considered “double punishment”. However, excluding them might be considered unfair in this specific case.
Man City smuggled in more than £800m of equity, disguised as sponsor income. In today’s prices, that would be worth billions. They have built an empire on the cheating and still benefit from it to this day. Their valuable squad (which they can sell to raise funds) exists because of it. It’s why their “net spend” isn’t that high. What’s more, valuable long-term commercial deals only exist because of it too.
The sanctions must also “make good” the damage that Man City cause but they must also mitigate for any undue sporting advantage they have gained. As such, that massive spending power that they gained through cheating must be restricted to compensate. Including the fines or compensation would not achieve this In the PL now that the rules are SCR-based rather than PSR-based. As such, I suspect the Panel will be asked to achieve this by applying a mark-down to their SCR allowance. Uefa may be asked to include the fines and comp claims in any assessment of their Football Earnings (I doubt they’ll comply).
3) 𝙏𝙞𝙩𝙡𝙚 𝙨𝙩𝙧𝙞𝙥𝙥𝙞𝙣𝙜
Every single major player acquisition from the summer of 2011 onwards can be tied to the illicit funds. Directly or indirectly. These players were absolutely critical to their ill-gotten success. It is impossible to argue that they would have won their titles without them. As such, there is a strong argument for why titles should be stripped. It is also a needed outcome for the purposes of deterrent against future cheating by other parties.
And even through they only breaached PSR from 2015/16 onwards (they breached Uefa FFP two years rules earlier), they started getting the benefit of their scheme much earlier than that. Had they not devised it, with the intention to defraud the league, then they likely would not have spent nearly as much as they did on players in Summer 2011 onwards.
So there is an argument that everything they won from 2011/12 onwards is tainted (i.e., all of it). That is the argument I would make. All of it must be stripped.
The counter-argument is that only titles won from the first PSR breach (in 2015/16) should be stripped by suggesting that sporting advantage did not apply until that year. I feel this argument is weaker but this is subjective. The Panel could go either way.
4) 𝙁𝙤𝙧𝙘𝙚𝙙 𝙨𝙖𝙡𝙚 𝙪𝙣𝙙𝙚𝙧 𝙩𝙝𝙧𝙚𝙖𝙩 𝙤𝙛 𝙚𝙭𝙥𝙪𝙡𝙨𝙞𝙤𝙣
The cheating was on a massive scale. But what’s worse is how it was undertaken. It required a hidden criminal conspiracy on an enormous scale. What’s even worse is when it was discovered, the owner and club execs did everything they could to deny justice. They refused to comply with the investigation, dragging it out for years. They supplied false documentation and committed perjury at CAS, as well as having eminent business leaders do the same. They demonstrated a total disregard for the rules and the league’s integrity. They demonstrated a clear belief that they are above any and all rules.
The rule breaches were only discoverable due to an email hack that will likely never be possible again (all malign actors will be more careful now). And they have so much power to falsify records, silence whilstblowers and force individuals to lie. They are an existential threat to the league.
You simply cannot allow individuals like that to remain in a competition if you want it to maintain integrity. They pose too great a threat.
The Panel cannot expel the club directly but it can recommend that the clubs vote to do so. But I suspect no-one will want to destroy the club. That is unfair to many employees and fans. They would rather just excise the ownership instead. As such, the Panel should recommend that the club be expelled if it is not sold to completely unassociated parties within a year, with a sale likely undertaken on a competitive basis and managed by an independent third party (similar to Chelsea’s).
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
Fantastic post on Red Issue. Should read.
The divs summed up perfectly…
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
And the final one in Manchester United’s greatest players: No 1, Sir Bobby Charlton.
Thanks for reading this summer.
For @TheAthleticFC
nytimes.com/athletic/7523566…
Wilcock’s Red Army 🇾🇪 retweeted
Had to be. Manchester United's greatest. Also England's greatest. The greatest sportsman this country has ever produced. Sir Bobby Charlton. Legend. Great series, Andy, so much work, thought and heart gone into it 👏👏
And the final one in Manchester United’s greatest players: No 1, Sir Bobby Charlton.
Thanks for reading this summer.
For @TheAthleticFC
nytimes.com/athletic/7523566…

















