Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar) header
Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar) profile picture

Retrieving from oblivion the antiquities of the old kingdom, where the sun sets and the divine awakens. Personal account: @FCMart1n

Joined March 2025
Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)Photo by Lethe scholar (@Lethescholar)
Reasons to lump Callaecian and Lusitanian together: >Same onomastics. >Same toponymy. >Same gods. >Same Celtic and pre-Celtic strata. >Same recorded pre-Latin language. Reasons to differentiate Callaecian and Lusitanian: >"Bro, Galicia sounds like Galatian/Gaelic/Gaulish."
Replying to @EzKordem
>There is zero evidence of a "Gallaecian language" distinct from Lusitanian. Neither was Hispano-Celtic, as neither was Celtic to begin with. >Cantabria as a mixed Celto-Vasconic area makes no sense at all. teapaw.org/Lethescholar/status/20…
11
18
3
186
8,188
Lethe scholar retweeted
Celto-Italic ethnogenesis vibes.
The mystery of the Unetice formation. As the Bell Beaker culture forms and spreads, can see a mosaic of Bell Beaker and Corded Ware settlements all intermingled across this region. This is, quite frankly, bananas. The Bell Beakers didn't just take over like in other areas of Europe. Look at the first two maps. Two different belief systems, pottery styles, burial customs functioning side by side for centuries. They were genetically related but culturally distinct. The Bell Beaker side slowly started taking over and then a synthesis emerged, combining elements of both into a new way of life - the Unetice culture. But how did this happen in practice? I don't know. But then you see powerful chiefs emerging who were buried in splendour. Maybe their ancestors were feted because they had unified these cultures. These images are from Harald Meller's 2019 paper on Unetice culture called Armies, Princes, and something something etc.
1
4
37
736
Lethe scholar retweeted
Few things have more Iron Age vibes than bogs: >Bogs spread massively in the Iron Age. >Bogs were a source, well, for iron. >As the Iron Age ended, civilization drained bogs. >Iron Age lasted longer in bog-rich lands. Not only Ireland--much more so in the Baltic! Bogs are cool.
Here, a major reason for the Irish (and wider Atlantic) Late Bronze Age collapse. Bogs. The colder and wetter conditions that set in by 800 BC expanded the bog's realm. Agriculture, herding, communication, accumulation--all became harder, and tribes scattered. (+)
2
5
1
68
1,811
Lethe scholar retweeted
The language of the SW Iberian stelae (more often, and perhaps improperly, known as Tartessian) is undeciphered. As for the Turdetani, they retained very little pre-Latin material besides toponymy. It's possible, but far from clear, that they were related… (+)
Replying to @Lethescholar
What's the relationship of Turdetanian with the unidentified SW language? And how much do we know about a separate Turdetanian language?
5
10
56
3,022
Lethe scholar retweeted
Even Iberians could be seen as non-indigenous, as they most likely came from the EEF that displaced the WHG. And if not, from the Epigravettians that displaced the Solutreans. And if not, from the modern humans who displaced the Neanderthals.
Because celts, greeks, phoenicians, and romans are not indigenous to Iberia
7
7
2
82
2,082
Lethe scholar retweeted
Since Éber Finn and Éremón, Ireland has had a recurring tendency to be divided into two north-south halves: La Tène (3rd century BC), Leath Cuinn-Leath Moga (2nd century AD), Synod of Ráth Breasail (1111), and, well, the 1921 partition--undoubtedly the most imperfect of them all.
Foclóir Ó Dónaill (Leath Cuinn) agus Foclóir Ó Duinnín (Leath Moga).
1
7
1
50
1,873
Lethe scholar retweeted
Ok, Iberia was not as diverse as the Balkans or Anatolia during the Iron Age, but lumping it all together under the category of "Hispanians" is utterly ridiculous, especially when the point is to highlight religious diversity… (+)
The good Europe. The diverse, polytheist Europe of the Iron Age.
4
8
206
7,544
Lethe scholar retweeted
A substantial change involving what was known as Albion in the 6th century BC becoming Prettaniké (Britain) by the 4th? Well, pretty obvious. Gallo-Brittonic Celts occupying long-lost Gaelic realms > the Gaelic name gives way to the Gallo-Brittonic one.
The first known use of the word Pretannia/Prettanikē comes from Pytheas (4th C. BC), while Avienus, drawing on 6th/5th c. BC sources, refered to the British isles as "the islands of the Iernians and the Albiones", suggesting that a substantial change had occurred in the meantime.
5
10
62
3,040
Celto-Italic ethnogenesis vibes.
The mystery of the Unetice formation. As the Bell Beaker culture forms and spreads, can see a mosaic of Bell Beaker and Corded Ware settlements all intermingled across this region. This is, quite frankly, bananas. The Bell Beakers didn't just take over like in other areas of Europe. Look at the first two maps. Two different belief systems, pottery styles, burial customs functioning side by side for centuries. They were genetically related but culturally distinct. The Bell Beaker side slowly started taking over and then a synthesis emerged, combining elements of both into a new way of life - the Unetice culture. But how did this happen in practice? I don't know. But then you see powerful chiefs emerging who were buried in splendour. Maybe their ancestors were feted because they had unified these cultures. These images are from Harald Meller's 2019 paper on Unetice culture called Armies, Princes, and something something etc.
1
4
37
736
Few things have more Iron Age vibes than bogs: >Bogs spread massively in the Iron Age. >Bogs were a source, well, for iron. >As the Iron Age ended, civilization drained bogs. >Iron Age lasted longer in bog-rich lands. Not only Ireland--much more so in the Baltic! Bogs are cool.
Here, a major reason for the Irish (and wider Atlantic) Late Bronze Age collapse. Bogs. The colder and wetter conditions that set in by 800 BC expanded the bog's realm. Agriculture, herding, communication, accumulation--all became harder, and tribes scattered. (+)
2
5
1
68
1,811
The language of the SW Iberian stelae (more often, and perhaps improperly, known as Tartessian) is undeciphered. As for the Turdetani, they retained very little pre-Latin material besides toponymy. It's possible, but far from clear, that they were related… (+)
Replying to @Lethescholar
What's the relationship of Turdetanian with the unidentified SW language? And how much do we know about a separate Turdetanian language?
5
10
56
3,022
Here you can see the Turdetani settlements mapped by the renowned late Spanish scholar Javier de Hoz. The Algarve region (where the SW stelae are concentrated) appears as Turdetani territory. Great for our issue, but uncertain. teapaw.org/Lethescholar/status/20…
Ethnicities in SW Iberia Protohistory, per J. De Hoz. The Turdetani stood out, firmly rooted on the lower Guadalquivir. Heirs to Tartessos, they were praised by Greeks and Romans for their manners, their riches, and their historical records said to span 6,000 years.
1
1
11
353
Lethe scholar retweeted
Ancient inscriptions containing indigenous languages of Iberia, sorted by writing system (Tartessian excluded): 🔵Levantine script 🌲Southern script ⭐️Greco-Iberian script 🟥Celtiberian script ⚠️Greek alphabet 🟨Latin alphabet Source: Hesperia database.
Languages attested through epichoric epigraphies (in bold) and other languages of the Iron Age Iberian Peninsula, according to N. Moncunill, 2024. Nice map, but it’s a shame the underrepresentation of indigenous Callaecian texts.
10
59
9
300
22,568
Even Iberians could be seen as non-indigenous, as they most likely came from the EEF that displaced the WHG. And if not, from the Epigravettians that displaced the Solutreans. And if not, from the modern humans who displaced the Neanderthals.
Because celts, greeks, phoenicians, and romans are not indigenous to Iberia
7
7
2
82
2,082
(I mention the Iberians because they seem to have been the ethno-linguistic group with the longest-standing presence in Protohistoric Iberia--the proto-Basques were clearly Iron Age migrants from the northern Pyrenees imo) teapaw.org/Lethescholar/status/19…
Bell Beaker items distribution again insists on the French Massif Central as a refractory area to foreign influences at crucial times. Since the Beakers were a vector of the Indo-Europeanization of western Europe, the Massif Central appears to have escaped it too…➡️
2
10
281
Ancient inscriptions containing indigenous languages of Iberia, sorted by writing system (Tartessian excluded): 🔵Levantine script 🌲Southern script ⭐️Greco-Iberian script 🟥Celtiberian script ⚠️Greek alphabet 🟨Latin alphabet Source: Hesperia database.
Languages attested through epichoric epigraphies (in bold) and other languages of the Iron Age Iberian Peninsula, according to N. Moncunill, 2024. Nice map, but it’s a shame the underrepresentation of indigenous Callaecian texts.
10
59
9
300
22,568
I don't know why the map's makers excluded Tartessian, BUT clearly Tartessian stands apart, as it is older and has no continuity into the fully historical period or with the other script categories. teapaw.org/Epicgravettian/status/…
Why is Tartessian excluded?
1
12
1,156
Ok, "indigenous" is vague, as every human group arrived from abroad at some point and bla bla bla. But clearly the map is not about just "ancient" stuff, as it does not include the most attested ancient language in Iberia, Latin. Nor Greek or Phoenician. teapaw.org/tatanzai/status/212280…
Replying to @Lethescholar
Ancient, not indigenous.
6
814
Lethe scholar retweeted
(Visto en FB): "Mapa dos Estados do Conde de Monterrei", por X. R. Fernández-Oxea. Friendly reminder de que, malia a alerxia cartográfica da nosa historiografía medievalista e modernista, a Galiza foi coma eses mapas tan vistosos que tod@s coñecemos do Sacro Imperio ou Francia.
1
10
1
63
1,696
Lethe scholar retweeted
Here, a major reason for the Irish (and wider Atlantic) Late Bronze Age collapse. Bogs. The colder and wetter conditions that set in by 800 BC expanded the bog's realm. Agriculture, herding, communication, accumulation--all became harder, and tribes scattered. (+)
Doesn't look glad. No wonder. Around his time (7th-6th c. BC), Ireland collapsed. Atlantic trade, riches and aristocracies vanished. Tribes dwindled and reverted to savagery. Even pottery was forgotten. AND barbarians began setting foot on the island they'd soon call their own.
3
16
1
178
9,954
Here, a major reason for the Irish (and wider Atlantic) Late Bronze Age collapse. Bogs. The colder and wetter conditions that set in by 800 BC expanded the bog's realm. Agriculture, herding, communication, accumulation--all became harder, and tribes scattered. (+)
Doesn't look glad. No wonder. Around his time (7th-6th c. BC), Ireland collapsed. Atlantic trade, riches and aristocracies vanished. Tribes dwindled and reverted to savagery. Even pottery was forgotten. AND barbarians began setting foot on the island they'd soon call their own.
3
16
1
178
9,954
Yes, that was a major issue throughout the Atlantic Late Bronze Age collapse, although peat bogs were not the whole story everywhere, as they were in Ireland: (+) teapaw.org/Lethescholar/status/19…
THE FALL OF ATLANTIC BRONZE 2⃣ CLIMATE DRIFT The passage from the Bronze Age to the Iron Age was not abrupt anywhere. In the Atlantic, rather than a specific date, we have an interval — the 8th to the 5th centuries BCE. This coincides with significant climate changes… ➡️
1
1
13
792
A nice Galician caption on the issue: teapaw.org/Lethescholar/status/19…
Lagoa de Cospeito, Galicia. At the end of the Bronze Age, Europe’s climate turned cooler and rainier. Forests flourished, and wetlands spread across the plains, hindering communication, raising malaria risk, & pushing people into the highlands. The Castro culture was being born.
1
13
630