Michael McAteer (@Monetarius) header
Michael McAteer (@Monetarius) profile picture

Questioning in the spirit of rationality and freedom the habits and tendencies of the zeitgeist. Looking through Kondratiev's lens.

Saskatoon, SASK
Joined December 2008
Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)Photo by Michael McAteer (@Monetarius)
Michael McAteer retweeted
If a Sorkin script had “secretly razes the historic East Wing of the White House, deliberately built not to be Versailles, and then added a gilded giant ballroom with uh, “donations”, and taxpayer money in the middle of wars, tariffs and crypto”, we’d say too heavy in symbolism.
Wow the Whitehouse Ball room is….quite something. To put it mildly
14
53
6
560
35,944
Conservatives have governed BC under the names “Social Credit” and “BC Liberals” for 52 of the last 74 years. Uninformed people should stop portraying this as the first time BC has had a right wing govt in 100 years.
10
363
39
2,112
36,154
Michael McAteer retweeted
1/2 A very important book that illustrates how rising debt and trade imbalances in the 1920s were resolved in the 1930s. Simmons discusses what happens when a country has an external imbalance under a fixed exchange-rate system, how painful the adjustment costs are and how they shared among the deficit and surplus countries. She argues that domestic political institutions determine how governments respond to external pressure. Countries facing similar international constraints made very different choices about currency levels, tariffs, domestic demand, unemployment and deflation.
Replying to @michaelxpettis
I can’t help but think of Beth Simmons’s, Who Adjusts? Under the interwar gold standard the burden fell on deficit countries, which were expected to deflate. And whether a govt accepted that was determined by domestic politics. Countries w/ strong unions refused to deflate wages and devalued or imposed capital controls. While countries w/ weak labor and an insulated central bank took the deflation. Instead of gold and deflation it’s now about debt and unemployment, but it’s ultimately still the same question. Surplus countries w/ weak labor export the adjustment and everyone else either absorbs it through wages or breaks the link through tariffs.
5
20
3
105
17,048
Michael McAteer retweeted
If you can watch only one video to understand current geopolitics, make it this one by George Yeo, one of Singapore's longest-serving cabinet ministers (23 years!) As Yeo explains, current global geopolitics is fundamentally driven by US "retreat" and "decline", forced by a financial reality that no US administration can reverse: its debt servicing already exceeding its entire defense budget. To Yeo, this explains why the US insists so much that its "allies" in Europe and Asia spend more of their GDP on defense - to basically pick up the tab for an empire America can no longer afford - but it also means that, inevitably, "once your allies begin to have their own military capabilities, they will think differently, and they will not follow you in everything that you want to do." As such, American decline becomes self-reinforcing: the more it asks allies to carry their own weight, the less reason they have to follow its lead. Still, Yeo says that a similar dynamic to one that happened after the fall of Rome could occur where America - like Byzantium did - sheds its empire and consolidates around its own hemisphere, allowing it to remain self-sustaining and powerful for a very long time. He believes it's the direction things are heading - which would also explain Trump's obsession with Canada and Greenland. It remains however obviously an open question whether an American "Byzantium strategy" is even achievable: Canada, for one, clearly wants no part of it. Full video available here: youtube.com/watch?v=NY2Vgiuh…
163
2,108
152
6,432
347,895
Michael McAteer retweeted
It was never hard to predict that most Venezuelans would oppose this deal. Most Americans should too. Putting Chevron in control of a substantial portion of the development, production and commercialization of Venezuela's oil reserves may be great for Chevron's shareholders, but it does nothing for American workers or the middle class. As it is, most Venezuelan oil is already processed in the US. The point is that the only sustainable way to make Americans collectively richer is to increase the productivity of American workers, and unless Chevron sells all this oil to Americans at well below world prices (which I doubt either Caracas or Chevron's shareholders will allow), its control over Venezuelan reserves will not increase the value of goods and services produced in the US. In fact to the extent that the resulting net inflows strengthen the dollar, it might actually further undermine manufacturing in the US. The administration should be focused on building industry at home, and not on boosting the foreign profits of American companies. ft.com/content/b3c98ca2-fe67…
73
139
14
535
54,786
Michael McAteer retweeted
Canada’s Conservatives are pressing Mr. Carney to release the text of the agreement he refused to sign. Our NYT reporting shows that the two negotiating teams signed confidentiality agreements (a requirement that is apparently standard in Trump administrations).
Il y a un moyen de mettre fin à toutes ces spéculations. Le premier ministre doit commencer par publier l'entente et s'adresser au Parlement canadien. Se rendre en France pour s'adresser au Parlement européen ne devrait pas être sa priorité : conservateur.ca/cpc/rappelon…
63
115
7
333
21,872
Michael McAteer retweeted
32
415
24
6,100
151,695
Michael McAteer retweeted
We can't predict a double pendulum, but we can predict the climate. Or so we are told.
This quoted post is unavailable.
142
386
20
3,638
228,365
Michael McAteer retweeted
Only coal, gas - or nuclear - can provide the essential continuous, synchronous 'spinning inertia' to keep the world's electricity grid running. Only oil can keep the world's 1.3 to 1.4 billion internal combustion vehicles on the roads, or the naval or vast merchant fleets plying the oceans. Marine heavy fuel oil and marine gas oil have no current, viable renewable energy substitute for long-haul maritime freight. These giant container ships remain the ultimate testament to the indispensable energy density of liquid hydrocarbons. Wind and solar were just not designed to integrate with the existing global grid, and building a second alternate grid carries an estimated price tag of $21 trillion. Dense hydrocarbon power always works. It doesn't matter if the wind is blowing or if it's night-time; dispatchable thermal generation produces crucial, dense, reliable power on demand, 24 hours a day. This remains the physical foundation of any, and every, modern industrial society. A single commercial DC fast charger can pull as much instantaneous power as an entire block of homes. As the grid's foundation shifts toward intermittent renewables—which lack natural physical inertia—the system faces severe frequency risks and voltage instability. The end result is a dodgy energy system where the electricity itself is becoming prohibitively expensive.
84
468
27
1,182
14,622
Michael McAteer retweeted
Horrible decision. His victory helps confirm what the Democratic Party has become in several U.S. states as of late. Far left, out of touch, intolerant and, at times, openly hateful.
10
22
55
1,219
Honestly, Pulitzer worthy photo. One light from nature. One from man.
Forest fires and aurora borealis in Canada’s Yukon.
253
7,473
29
84,796
1,746,632
Michael McAteer retweeted
Lionel Messi on why he broke down in tears after Argentina’s victory over Egypt: 🗣️ “People saw me crying and probably thought they were tears of happiness. The truth is… they were much more than that. When the final whistle blew, every emotion I had been carrying for years came crashing down at once. The pressure, the expectations, the fear of letting my country down it all exploded inside me. There are moments in football when your heart simply cannot hold everything anymore. After missing the penalty, I felt like I had failed my teammates, my family, and every Argentine who believed in me. I couldn’t stop replaying that moment in my head. I kept asking myself, ‘What if that miss costs us everything?’ Those were the longest minutes I’ve ever lived on a football pitch. My teammates never stopped believing in me. They kept telling me to lift my head, to keep fighting, and they gave everything to turn the match around. Watching them sacrifice for me made the final whistle even more emotional because I knew I wasn’t carrying this dream alone. When I looked into the stands and saw my family crying, I completely lost control of my emotions. They have lived every criticism with me, every defeat, every sleepless night, every sacrifice that nobody sees. Those tears were for them as much as they were for Argentina. People only see ninety minutes on the pitch. They don’t see the years of pain, the sacrifices, the injuries, the doubts, or the fear that every World Cup could be your last. At this stage of my career, you understand that every match could be the final chapter of a lifetime’s dream. I cried because I realized how close football can bring you to losing everything you’ve worked for. One moment can change history forever. Tonight, we survived, but emotionally it felt like I had lived an entire lifetime in just one match. These were not tears of weakness. They were tears of relief, gratitude, love for my teammates, and love for my country. I will never forget this night for as long as I live.”
132
1,518
184
10,944
1,037,815
Michael McAteer retweeted
The United States has roughly two dozen people who know how to run rare earth solvent extraction at commercial scale. The Chinese Society of Rare Earths has over 100,000 members. In 2023, American mining engineering programs graduated 162 students. China graduated about 3,000 from 45 programs. Twelve US universities have shut down their mining engineering departments, including UC Berkeley and Ohio State. The Bureau of Mines, the federal agency responsible for mining research and training, was dissolved in 1996. Chinese pricing drove Western rare earth operations out of business through the 1990s and 2000s. The people who knew how to run those plants retired, changed industries, or died. Rare earth separation requires understanding how 17 chemically similar elements behave across hundreds of interconnected mixer-settler stages over months of continuous operation. That knowledge is accumulated through years of hands-on work in facilities the West stopped running. The average US mine worker is 46. 221,000 are expected to retire by 2029. Building an entirely new critical minerals supply chain means rebuilding the workforce that was eliminated a generation ago. The operational knowledge only comes back by running real plants.
145
605
97
2,871
250,690
Michael McAteer retweeted
Most people miss an important thing in the automation debate, whether it is robots or AI agents. These machines make things. They do not buy them. And consumption is what turns a productivity gain into actual growth. The argument can be heard in two different places. One is the AI gospel, loudest in the US, preaching that AI will take most of the jobs. The widely praised @citrini memo gave it a name: an "Intelligence Displacement Spiral". AI displaces workers, those workers spend less, firms under margin pressure buy more AI, which displaces more workers. The output still shows up in the national accounts. It just stops circulating through the real economy. Citrini calls that "Ghost GDP". But as @timoreilly puts it, you cannot sustain trillion-dollar valuations on a customer base that is going broke. The other place is China, making spectacular inroads in robotics, partly because it is about to fall off a demographic cliff. It installed more industrial robots last year than the rest of the world combined. So let's ask the question that everyone skips. What happens if the productivity gains from robots and AI never turn into extra consumption? The sequence goes as follows. Output rises. The wage share does not keep up. Demand lags supply. Capacity sits idle, or debt piles up behind it. At that point a country has two exits: sell the surplus abroad, or correct at home through falling output and lost jobs. China takes the first exit. It runs household consumption at around 40% of GDP, against 60 to 70% almost everywhere else, the legacy of years of repression that move income from savers to industry. China cannot buy what it builds, so it exports the gap. That lets it appear as a manufacturing powerhouse rather than a consumption laggard. But the export surplus is camouflage. It holds up the growth figures while hiding the demand problem underneath. The US sits in a different spot. Wages there stopped tracking productivity decades ago, but consumption kept going, propped up by household debt and rising asset prices. The political scientist Colin Crouched once called it privatised Keynesianism: borrowing does the work that pay cheques used to. America can run this longer than anyone because it issues the reserve currency, so steady demand for dollars lets Washington carry deficits no one else could. It works until the borrowing does not. Europe is slightly better placed, but keeps trying to make itself worse. Germany is the model everyone wants to copy. The Hartz reforms of 2003 to 2005 held wages down while GDP kept growing, so the household share fell and business profits surged. Lower domestic consumption, larger export surplus. The trouble is that not everyone can be Germany at once. When the whole continent represses wages to defend "cost competitiveness", the South ends up stuck below potential on weak demand, whilst the North ends up repressing domestic consumption, which fuels discontent and harms economic growth. As stated by @michaelxpettis, a country that externalises its internal imbalances forces the adjustment onto its trading partners. They absorb it as higher debt or higher unemployment, and either way they lose manufacturing, whether they like it or not. Left alone, this ends in one place, which is well known because America already ran the experiment once. Through the 1920s, output per manufacturing worker rose 43% while wages barely moved. The income that never reached workers funded overbuilt capacity, speculation, and finally the market bubble. By 1928 sales lagged and factories cut output. The crash turned a distribution problem into a decade-long depression. What broke the loop was FDR's Second New Deal: the Wagner Act, Social Security, and a deliberate move to align wages with productivity. For the first time the income captured through the 1920s flowed back to households. Demand recovered. The imbalance resolved. That is the lesson for the robot and AI age. Productivity makes growth possible, but consumption is what actually delivers it (cc @CarlotaPrzPerez). The task now is to get the gains to households, through wages that track output and institutions that give people the security to spend, or through newer ideas like handing displaced workers an equity claim on the machines that replace them (cc @izakaminska). Automate all you like. Someone still has to be able to buy the output.
Financial Times: "Beijing now sees AI-enabled machines as a way out of the demographic trap. Last year the country installed more industrial robots than the rest of the world put together." This very interesting FT article claims that because its aging population "is China’s biggest economic headwind" (I am a little skeptical about this claim), and that because its declining population makes a bad debt problem even worse (I agree), Beijing wants to increase worker productivity by investing heavily in automation and robot technology. This sets off at least three, perhaps unrelated, points. First and most obviously, mainstream economists have long argued that manufacturing jobs are no better than service jobs, and because the former are declining anyway, we should avoid a manufacturing "fetish". But this might only show just how poorly they understand the economy. It is precisely because manufacturing productivity can rise so rapidly (which also explains most of the decline in manufacturing employment) that countries like the US and the EU should do all they can do encourage domestic manufacturing. Second, China has among the lowest unit labor costs in the world, i.e. wages are lower relative to productivity than they are in most of its trade partners. It also has a very high underemployment as gig work absorbs a huge number of workers who would otherwise be unemployed. With such low labor costs, you would expect Chinese growth to be very labor intensive at this stage. But it is instead very capital-intensive, as demonstrated by the extraordinarily high investment share of GDP, and illustrated by the huge push into the labor-saving automation described in this article. This is pretty strong evidence than in China labor may be cheap, but capital is even cheaper. Third, many analysts worry that automation and robot technology will lead to a rise in unemployment. This is only true, however, if overall demand fails to keep pace with overall supply, in which case production facilities would have to close down and workers fired. But this may be a misplaced concern. In an economy in which investment growth depends on growth in consumption, overall demand will fail to keep pace with overall supply only if household income fails to keep pace with productivity growth. This returns us to China's original problem. while Chinese productivity has been rising, especially until the late 2000s and early 2010s, wages haven't kept pace with productivity growth. So what really matters to overall Chinese and global growth, at least in the medium term, is not the rate at which China automates and expands robot technology, but whether or not wage growth is able to keep pace with the resulting increases in productivity. Given the extent of unemployment and underemployment in the economy, however, this seems pretty unlikely, at least in the next few years, in which case the impact of automation in Chinese manufacturing is likely to be even bigger domestic imbalances and trade surpluses. The key, as I see it, is whether China can continue to subsidize the cost of capital to such an extent that, even with very low labor costs Chinese businesses still prefer capital-intensive growth over labor-intensive growth. This in turn probably depends on how much longer Chinese debt can grow faster than China's real debt-servicing capacity. With debt so high and rising so rapidly, I suspect we will only get a few more years of this at best. ft.com/content/c8731833-10ca…
23
29
6
118
24,190
Michael McAteer retweeted
He walked backward so perfectly, the world looks reversed [📹 robinchanning]
467
2,352
167
46,323
13,839,114
Michael McAteer retweeted
“The real surprise from the OECD’s subsidy numbers is that it cost China less than $18bn in sectoral support over 15 years to build an industry that can now provide more clean power than the world can readily absorb.”
"Since when were solar panels just another commodity? They are a technological miracle. They make us into farmers of the sun"
31
617
26
3,103
234,950
Michael McAteer retweeted
🟥 Trump is blocking the opening of the new Gordie Howe International Bridge between Windsor, Ontario and Detroit, Michigan. As Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg explains here, it’s all about CORRUPTION. 😒 And by the way, lest we forget… 🔳 PETE BUTTIGIEG: “Canada actually paid for the bridge! THEY paid for it!” That fiend, Donald Trump, needs to open our bridge, forthwith. 🤌🏼
75
860
22
2,183
57,792
Michael McAteer retweeted
How much do countries reduce income inequality through taxes and transfers? Most countries reduce income inequality through taxes and transfers — taxing higher incomes more, and redistributing through benefits like pensions, unemployment support, and family allowances. But how much each country reduces inequality varies a lot, as you can see in the chart. This data comes from the OECD Income Distribution Database (IDD), one of the few internationally harmonized sources that measures income inequality both before and after taxes and transfers. Our colleague @parriagadap recently updated our charts with the latest release from the OECD. It now covers 45 countries (OECD members plus select non-members) with annual data going back to 1976. The OECD updates the IDD on a rolling basis, and we plan to refresh our charts annually.
6
84
7
202
29,734
Michael McAteer retweeted
Shark Tank Billionaire Kevin O'leary says 2 people fighting data centers in Utah are Chinese agents. Turns out its just 2 local girls in Utah, they make a hilarious video calling him the fuck out
2,408
26,610
1,645
121,793
5,322,957
Michael McAteer retweeted
For anyone wondering whether the fossil fuel crisis in the Middle East is driving interest in clean energy technologies: China's exports of batteries, EVs and solar products shot up in March to $21.9 billion! This is an all-time record and a 70% increase over March 2025.
NEW | Record exports of solar, batteries and EVs last month 📈 China’s exports for the ‘new three’ industries reached a record high of $21.9bn in March 2026, up 70% year-on-year, in the wake of the US-Israel war with Iran and changing export rebates for solar and batteries.
19
406
42
1,196
148,579