N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis) profile picture

A white collar criminal defense lawyer and advocate for free speech and due process.

Joined November 2022
Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)Photo by N. Richard Janis (@NRichardJanis)
#Commanders Sainristill simply can’t cover. He’s so bad that he’s making me miss St. Juste!
6
339
That is an exceptional, unemotional and balanced analysis of the US- Canada trade relationship. Really worth reading and passing along.
Canada is having a difficult conversation with itself about its economic relationship with the United States. Much of the current Canadian political narrative treats access to the American market almost as an acquired right. When an American administration talks about reshoring manufacturing, imposing tariffs or favouring American production, Canadians often frame the issue as an affront to Canadian sovereignty. I think that fundamentally misunderstands how our industrial economy developed. For much of the post-war period, Canada prospered by becoming an extraordinarily effective extension of the American industrial economy. Southern Ontario did not independently develop an automotive ecosystem disconnected from Detroit. Windsor, Oshawa, Oakville, St. Thomas and communities throughout Southwestern Ontario became deeply integrated into an industrial machine whose centre of gravity was across the border in Michigan, Ohio and the broader American Midwest. American manufacturers established Canadian factories and supply chains for many reasons: access to the Canadian market, tariff and content rules, exchange rates, labour economics, geographic proximity and, eventually, increasingly integrated North American trade. Canada became exceptionally good at this. We built cars, stamped metal, machined components, produced chemicals, assembled machinery and supplied American factories. Canadian companies also became enormously successful suppliers to that system. Magna is perhaps the greatest example of what could be built from Canada's position inside the North American automotive supply chain. The 1965 Auto Pact accelerated that integration. Free trade in 1989 and NAFTA in 1994 took it much further. But then something else happened. Beginning in the late twentieth century and accelerating dramatically after 2000, North American manufacturing capacity increasingly moved offshore. China became a manufacturing superpower. Global supply chains replaced many domestic ones. American industrial communities lost factories and employment, while corporations discovered that enormous amounts of production could be sourced from lower-cost jurisdictions. For decades, Canada operated within that globalization model while retaining extraordinarily favourable access to the world's largest consumer economy. Now the United States is reconsidering the model. Washington increasingly views industrial capacity as more than an economic issue. Semiconductors, steel, aluminum, automobiles, energy, pharmaceuticals, chemicals and critical minerals are being treated as matters of national security and strategic resilience. That creates an uncomfortable question for Canada: If the United States wants its industrial production back, on what basis does Canada believe that production belongs to us? Imagine a manufacturer that has outsourced substantial production to a subcontractor for decades. The subcontractor builds its business around that work, invests in equipment, hires employees and becomes highly successful. Then circumstances change. The manufacturer's own facilities have unused capacity and its own employees need work. The subcontractor may understandably be unhappy when the manufacturer brings some of that production home. But the subcontractor cannot reasonably argue that decades of receiving the work created a permanent entitlement to it. That, in simplified form, is the uncomfortable position Canada now faces. This does not mean Canada lacks sovereignty. Quite the opposite. Canada is completely sovereign and has every right to establish whatever trade, industrial, environmental and foreign policies Canadians choose. But sovereignty works both ways. Canada has the sovereign right to determine its economic policy. The United States has the sovereign right to determine how much access foreign producers receive to the American market. Those are two different questions. Canada has also spent decades diversifying its trading relationships, including developing a substantial economic relationship with China. There are legitimate American concerns about transshipment, rules of origin, Chinese overcapacity and goods entering the United States through third countries. Canada should take those concerns seriously rather than simply assuming that our historical relationship exempts us from American scrutiny. That does not mean every American tariff is justified, nor does it mean Canada should simply accept whatever Washington demands. It means Canada needs to understand the leverage in the relationship. Nearly 40 million Canadians live beside an economy of roughly 350 million people. Geography gave us extraordinary access to that market. Generations of Canadian workers and entrepreneurs then turned that geographical advantage into one of the world's most integrated cross-border industrial relationships. But proximity is not ownership. Our automotive plants, stamping companies, machine shops and parts manufacturers have succeeded because they are very good at what they do. They should compete aggressively to retain that business. Canada should make itself the most compelling place in North America to manufacture. What we should not do is confuse historical integration with entitlement. Instead of asking, "How can the Americans do this to us?" Canada should be asking a much harder question: Why should an American manufacturer choose to put its next factory in Ontario rather than Michigan, Ohio, Indiana or Tennessee? If our answer is productivity, engineering talent, energy, logistics, taxation, regulatory efficiency, currency advantage and a highly capable workforce, then Canada has a compelling case. If our answer is simply that American companies have manufactured here for the last 70 years and therefore should continue doing so, we have a problem. The old Canadian model depended heavily on being an exceptionally attractive extension of American industrial capacity. America is now rebuilding that capacity at home. Canada's challenge is not to demand that history stand still. It is to make ourselves indispensable enough that, even when America has the choice to bring the work home, American companies still choose Canada. @ronmortgageguy @StephenPunwasi @FoodProfessor
2
554
N. Richard Janis retweeted
The Gaza peace plan is just aspirational. There’s actually no process to disarm Hamas and co. This is very similar to the Vance peace plan with the IRGC. So unrealistic it’s hard to imagine someone finding it a plausible solution.
9
29
3
153
4,375
Isn’t it interesting that Iran still feels perfectly free to send missiles and drones at Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Oman, Jordan and the UAE, but has not directed a single missile or drone at Israel. Obviously, they fully understand that if they did do, Israel’s response would be immediate and overwhelming. That’s what deterrence looks like. #Israel #IDF #Iran #EpicFury
5
278
At some point, the Democratic "leadership" needs to show some integrity and give up this ""big tent" mantra. There should be no room in the tent for American-hating antisemitic extremists. The failure of the party to condemn and expel these people is an extreme act of moral cowardice.
1
2
13
424
Everyone in the world, with the apparent exception of Trump, can see he’s being played and made to look like a fool. This inexplicable delay in finishing the job has allowed Iran to rearm and it has seriously weakened Trump’s domestic and international support, while allowing Iran’s totalitarian government to obfuscate and prevaricate so as to cling to power.
1
2
14
570
President Trump deserves credit for staying the course on Iran when so many around him are losing their nerve. on.wsj.com/4n2uf8N
332
600
56
3,011
138,127
I simply don't understand the use of the term "Progressive" to describe far left politicians who would censor speech with which they do not agree, insist on implementation of racial identity politics, pander to anti-American activists and antisemites in order to court their vote, push for confiscatory taxes, and try to stack the deck by gerrymandering Congressional districts to disenfranchise half of their citizens. There is nothing "progressive" about their policies and using that term to describe them provides them a legitimacy that is not deserved.
4
569
N. Richard Janis retweeted
Amazing letter by @Cornell President rejecting the resolution. Should be read by all: Dear Zora, Thank you for conveying SA Resolution 61: Calling for the Termination of Cornell University’s Partnership with the Technion – Israel Institute of Technology While Preserving Cornell Tech. I reject this resolution, which fundamentally conflicts with Cornell’s principles of academic collaboration and our core commitment to academic freedom. Cornell Tech is not a political entity. It is an academic partnership, created through shared investment by Cornell University, the Technion, and the City of New York for the benefit of the city and the state, according to a negotiated set of conditions that govern its development and the terms of its 99-year ground lease on Roosevelt Island. As one of Cornell University’s many international partnerships and collaborations, Cornell Tech deepens, enriches, and strengthens the ability of our students, faculty, and staff to pursue knowledge and advance the university’s academic mission. The Joan and Irwin Jacobs Technion-Cornell Institute, the core international partnership upon which Cornell Tech is based, is an extraordinarily valuable collaboration focusing on education and research in health tech, media tech, and urban tech, and supporting the development of new startup companies. Severing our relationship with the Technion—or with any entity affiliated with governments, institutions, or enterprises with which some of our community members disagree—as a statement of political protest, would not only hinder our research, teaching, and public engagement; it would imperil our academic principles. Our university, like all of our peer institutions, regularly faces pressure—from across the political spectrum, from within and beyond our own community—to make academic decisions according to political priorities. The phenomenon is not a new one: universities have grappled with such pressures from governments and societies for as long as the institution of the university has existed. When we yield to these pressures and proscribe specific collaborations or collaborators on grounds other than merit, we compromise our principles of academic freedom, undermine our own institutional excellence, and damage public trust in our work.   Moreover, this resolution inaccurately asserts that “the continued operation of Cornell Tech as a Cornell University campus does not require an ongoing partnership with the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology.” Cornell Tech, while part of Cornell, is a joint effort of the university, the Technion, and the City of New York. It is no more possible for Cornell to unilaterally terminate that effort and claim full control of the campus than it would be for the Technion or the City of New York to do the same. Finally, I am deeply troubled by the selective manner in which this resolution singles out the Technion, alone of Cornell’s many international partners, for censure. Cornell currently maintains 159 active agreements with institutions in 59 nations and regions; all of these institutions have some government affiliation, and many conduct research with military and security applications. Cornell itself has military research contracts, conducts research with potential military applications, and has relationships with companies whose products are used in military contexts. Cornell also has relationships with institutions in countries whose governments have been accused of human rights violations—as our own has been.  None of these publicly available facts are mentioned in the resolution; only our partnership with an Israeli institution is targeted for erasure. The political bias evident in this selective approach is deeply disturbing, and the resolution is incompatible with both the Student Assembly’s purpose and Cornell University’s core values. I reject it fully and forcefully. Sincerely,   Michael Kotlikoff President and Professor of Molecular Physiology Cornell University
Cornell rejects anti-Technion BDS resolution. And tells ⁦@ZohranKMamdani⁩ not even to think about ending the Consortium: “It is no more possible for Cornell to unilaterally terminate…than it would be for…the City of New York to do the same.” assembly.cornell.edu/resolut…
137
841
100
5,481
948,761
N. Richard Janis retweeted
My post on Friday regarding the estate tax proposal in New York got 600,000+ views, so clearly this struck a nerve. Some individuals asked me to back up what I said so I am going to discuss what happens when states push tax policy past the breaking point. Here is what the data shows and it’s worse than most people realize. According to IRS migration data, New York has lost $111 billion in net adjusted gross income over the last decade from residents moving to other states. That’s not hypothetical, that’s $111 billion in taxable income that used to fund schools, subways, police, and infrastructure that is now funding those things in Florida and Texas rather than New York. California lost $102 billion over the same period. Florida gained $196 billion. Texas gained $54 billion. That’s not a coincidence, it’s a pattern. Between 2018 and 2024, 561 companies relocated their headquarters across the country. The San Francisco Bay Area lost 156 corporate headquarters. Los Angeles lost 106. New York City lost 27. Meanwhile Dallas alone gained 100, Austin gained 81, and Nashville gained 35. This didn’t come to a halt in 2025 or 2026. Palantir $PLTR which was the largest publicly traded company in Colorado, announced in February that it was moving its headquarters from Denver to Miami. It was PLTR’s second move in six years after leaving Silicon Valley in 2020. The governor of Colorado said he found out through a social media post. ExxonMobil’s $XOM board unanimously recommended that shareholders approve reincorporating the company from New Jersey to Texas after 144 years at the vote in May. Exxon has physically operated out of Texas since 1989, and its CEO said Texas has created a policy environment that allows them to maximize shareholder value. Chevron $CVX completed its move from California to Houston. In-N-Out Burger is opening a 100,000-square-foot eastern headquarters near Nashville and is leaving California. These aren’t outliers anymore as this is becoming the new normal. It’s not just corporate headquarters moving. Entire financial ecosystems are relocating. Citadel, one of the most profitable hedge funds in the world, moved its headquarters from Chicago to Miami in 2022 and has been building out aggressively ever since. They’re constructing a massive new waterfront headquarters in Miami’s Brickell financial district. Elliott Management moved to West Palm Beach. Carl Icahn moved Icahn Enterprises from New York to Sunny Isles Beach. Cathie Wood’s ARK Investment Management relocated to St. Petersburg. Goldman Sachs $GS is building a $500 million campus in Dallas designed to house over 5,000 employees. JPMorgan Chase $JPM and Wells Fargo $WFC have both invested hundreds of millions into massive new campuses in the Dallas-Fort Worth area. Wells Fargo is also moving its wealth management division from San Francisco to West Palm Beach. NYSE Texas a reincorporation of the 143-year old Chicago Stock Exchange officially launched in Dallas in early 2025. The Texas Stock Exchange which is a brand new national securities exchange backed by over $160 million from BlackRock $BLK , Citadel Securities, and Charles Schwab $SCHW is set to begin trading by the end of this year. Nasdaq has also expanded its Texas presence with operations in Irving. When you have that level of financial infrastructure being built in a single metro area, that’s not a trend it’s an ecosystem being constructed from scratch to compete directly with New York. Each of these moves represents not just a company but thousands of high-paying jobs, billions in local economic activity, and a signal to every other firm still on the fence that states with competitive rather than restrictive policy are creating enticing operating environments. Currently over 1 million residents have left New York for other states since 2020 according to the latest Census estimates. International immigration has partially offset the population headcount, but it hasn’t replaced the tax base. The people leaving earn significantly more on average than the people arriving. Almost 1,700 millionaires changed their address out of New York in 2024 alone. Millionaires paid 44.6% of all personal income tax collected in the state last year. The proposed response to this fragility is to drop the estate tax threshold from $7.1 million to $750,000, raise the top rate to 50%, add a new 2% income tax surcharge on millionaires, increase corporate taxes, and add a capital gains surcharge. Under these proposals, the combined federal, state, and city top marginal rate on high earners in New York City would approach 54%. That’s a policy framework that ignores everything the last decade of data has told us. The Dallas mayor just publicly predicted an “avalanche” of NYC financial firms heading to Texas under these policies. Florida realtors are seeing a surge of inquiries from wealthy New Yorkers. Cities like Miami, Austin, and Nashville are building entire ecosystems including schools, cultural centers, and financial services clusters which are designed specifically to attract the people New York is pushing out. Ken Griffin and Stephen Ross just launched a $10 million campaign called “Ambitious Accelerated” to recruit more businesses to what they’re calling Florida’s “Tech Gold Coast.” They’re not waiting for New York to figure it out. They’re actively recruiting our talent, our capital, and our tax base. That’s what makes this moment so critical. We are in the middle of the most competitive environment for jobs, businesses, and investment that this country has ever seen. States are actively building infrastructure to attract employers and high earners. This is the time to compete, not to double down on the same policy approach that has been pushing wealth and businesses to lower-tax states for a decade. Texas entered its latest legislative session with a $24 billion surplus while having no personal or corporate income tax. Think about that for a moment, no personal or corporate income tax and they have a $24 billion surplus. Florida added more new businesses than any other state in 2024, with over 266,000 formed in a single year. These states didn’t create an attractive business landscape out of thin air. They made deliberate policy choices to create environments where businesses want to operate, where employers want to hire, and where working people can actually build something without the ground shifting underneath them every budget cycle. This matters because of what it means for everyday people. When a company relocates its headquarters, it doesn’t just move a sign, the entire company leaves, from the executive team to the support staff. It doesn’t stop there because that's only internal. Externally, all of the trades that may do work for the company will no longer receive those phone calls. The restaurants will no longer see those repeat customers. The tax revenue from those paychecks won’t be collected, and future job growth in the community from that company will cease to exist. When Dallas gained 100 corporate headquarters over six years, that meant tens of thousands of new jobs, new residents spending money, new homes being purchased, new small businesses opening to serve those people. That’s how local economies actually grow. That’s how neighborhoods stay alive, and when a corporate headquarters leaves a city, the exact opposite happens. The jobs thin out, the spending dries up, the small businesses that depended on that foot traffic start closing, and the tax base that funded public services shrinks. New York has every natural advantage in the world. The talent, infrastructure, culture, and institutions are all here, but it won’t be enough if the policy environment drives away the employers and investors who create opportunities for everyone else. The states that are growing right now aren’t growing by accident. They made a decision to be competitive. They kept tax burdens manageable, they created regulatory clarity for businesses, and they built an environment where employers want to expand and hire. New York has every tool to do the same thing. The question is whether the people making the decisions recognize that we’re in a competition and right now, we’re not acting like it. Here’s the part nobody in Albany wants to hear. The people who leave don’t just take their tax returns with them. They take their fundraising networks, philanthropy, job creation, and spending to a new economy. A city that once attracted the world’s most ambitious people risks becoming a place they leave once they’ve made it, or worse, a place they never lay down roots. That’s not ideology. It’s an economic reality that the IRS, Census, and corporate relocation data have been telling us. I said it in my first post, and I’ll say it again. When you tax people past the point where the math makes sense, they leave. When they leave, the burden falls on everyone who doesn’t have the resources to relocate. It’s time to take a common-sense approach to policy and make the great state of New York competitive again. New York has a decision to make. Either it continues down this path and alienates more taxpayers or it becomes more competitive. I love this state, but I am extremely worried for it’s future. We should be building a thriving ecosystem with an abundance of opportunities for New Yorkers, but instead we are pushing entrepreneurs and businesses to states that are more competitive with policy. Is this really the path we want to take not only for the current residents but for the next generation? @amitisinvesting @basispointpod @chamath @Jason @BillAckman @kevinolearytv @patrickbetdavid @PBDsPodcast
264
752
139
3,265
852,102
N. Richard Janis retweeted
Replying to @BasedMikeLee
Here’s the unfortunate reality. While it is understandable—even commendable—that there are Republicans who are institutionalists that want to preserve an important rule protecting minority rights, they are engaging in an exercise in futility. Their efforts will be for naught the moment the Democrats take control of the Senate. The Democrats have made it crystal clear that they will not be so restrained and will have no compunction about blowing up the filibuster entirely in order to implement their agenda. That agenda includes exploiting immigration to preserve and increase the voting power of blue states, expanding payments from the federal budget to individuals and organizations that they view as part of their base, adding two reliably Democratic Senators by awarding statehood to DC, and packing the Supreme Court with blatantly partisan justices as unqualified as Ketanji Brown Jackson in order to ensure no judicial oversight of its extreme agenda. What they really want—and are fully prepared to blow up the filibuster to achieve—is permanent one party rule. Those institutionalists on the Republican side of the aisle are being naive not to recognize this.
1
6
591
N. Richard Janis retweeted
Replying to @elonmusk
@elonmusk “Amathia”—the perfect term for the lack of critical thinking plaguing our institutions of higher learning and describing the woke virus that is endemic to people who call themselves “progressive.” From Grok: Amathia (Ancient Greek: ἀμαθία, pronounced roughly as “a-MATH-ee-uh”) is a philosophical concept from classical Greek thought, particularly associated with Socrates and Plato. It is often translated simply as “ignorance,” but that misses the key nuance. Unlike ordinary ignorance (agnoia — a simple lack of knowledge or information), amathia refers to a deeper, more culpable form: willful ignorance, intelligent stupidity, or a deliberate refusal to learn, understand, or acknowledge the truth — even (and especially) when someone has the intelligence, education, or access to know better. Key characteristics of amathia • It involves a conscious or semi-conscious choice to remain ignorant, often driven by pride, arrogance, self-satisfaction, fear of discomfort, ideological commitment, or resistance to anything that threatens one’s identity, status, or worldview. • The person may appear intelligent, articulate, or even highly educated, yet they stubbornly cling to false beliefs, misapply their reasoning, or ignore evidence. • Ancient thinkers considered it morally blameworthy — a defect of character and soul, not just intellect — because it leads to harmful actions, poor judgments, and ethical failures. • Socrates viewed it as particularly dangerous, even calling it the root of much evil: people do wrong not primarily because they are inherently wicked, but because of this kind of “intelligent ignorance” that prevents genuine self-knowledge and virtue. Modern discussions often revive the term to describe phenomena like: • Highly credentialed experts endorsing obviously flawed ideas. • Smart people falling into groupthink, cognitive dissonance, or ideological rigidity. • The confident embrace of misinformation despite abundant counter-evidence. • “The blindness of the soul” in an age overflowing with information. In short, amathia explains why intelligence alone doesn’t guarantee wisdom — and why some of the most damaging errors come from capable minds that refuse to question themselves. It’s the ignorance that thinks it’s knowledge.
1
1
2
867
It is unbelievable to hear anyone claim that President Zelensky “hasn’t even read the peace plan.” This is the same man who has led a country through the largest war in Europe since World War II, slept in bunkers while ordering evacuations, and briefed every major world leader sometimes twice a day. He reads everything. He studies everything. He understands that one bad agreement can cost tens of thousands of lives. To suggest he’s uninformed is not only false, it disrespects the reality of what Ukraine has been fighting through for almost four years. And here are the facts that matter: Russia has violated every major agreement it has ever signed with Ukraine. - Budapest Memorandum, violated. - Minsk I, violated. - Minsk II, violated. - Ceasefires, broken within hours every single time. When a country shows a pattern of deception for decades, you do not hand them territorial rewards and call it “peace.” Because it will not be peace. It will be a pause. We saw it in 2014. Russia used that pause to build the largest invasion force Europe has seen since 1945. They will do it again. A real peace requires accountability. Not a free pass. War crimes were committed in Bucha, Irpin, Mariupol, Kherson. Thousands of Ukrainian children were kidnapped and deported. Entire cities were erased. Under international law, the aggressor is required to withdraw, compensate victims, and face justice. That is how peace works. Anything less only guarantees another war. Zelensky pushes back because he knows exactly what this region looks like when Russia is rewarded for violence. Ukraine tried trusting Moscow before. The result was a full scale invasion. A peace plan that does not secure Ukraine’s borders, sovereignty, and safety is not a peace plan. It is a surrender wrapped in polite language. And Ukrainians will not die for that. Slava Ukraini Heroyam Slava 🇺🇦
Trump - “Zelensky hasn’t even read the peace plan” Meanwhile President Zelensky
225
1,208
72
4,070
134,413
N. Richard Janis retweeted
🚨 WHAT A LEADING U.S. LAW PROFESSOR JUST REVEALED 🚨 A major warning was issued this week—not by activists, not by commentators, but by one of America’s leading constitutional law professors. He was just in Berlin, and what he described is chilling. He said only TWO people at the World Forum were defending free speech… and the rest of the room was demanding coordinated censorship—not just across Europe, but against Americans. And here is what he testified: European regulators want U.S. speech controlled by EU law Platforms are being threatened with ruinous fines International bodies now expect enforcement against U.S. citizens Silence is being globalised through regulation, not debate He also stated that Hillary Clinton personally intensified this push—calling on the EU to weaponise the Digital Services Act when Elon Musk acquired Twitter. Think about that: A former U.S. presidential candidate urging a FOREIGN authority to pressure an American company into censoring U.S. citizens. According to this professor, what is happening is not organic—it is strategic. He said the Berlin gathering was “the most anti-free-speech event” he had ever attended. He warned that: “This is how censorship becomes internationalised.” Not through law in Washington. Not through court rulings. But through transnational regulatory power overriding domestic rights. As he put it: “Free speech isn’t falling—it’s being dismantled.” This is not speculation. This is testimony—firsthand—from someone who was in the room. Defending free expression is no longer optional—it is urgent. @JonathanTurley
1,385
18,343
1,502
30,836
834,766
Great speech by the President of the University of Austin: uatx.substack.com/p/in-defen…
5
153
Replying to @Commanders
@Commanders Our defense is awful. Once again, stupid penalties and chunk plays.
1
2
9
719
N. Richard Janis retweeted
I have no problem with Jimmy Kimmel's show being cancelled. I have a HUGE issue with the government bullying his bosses into taking him off the air.
968
640
89
8,593
439,485