Replying to @VictoryRiderMO @ASithLawd
It is reasonable, though I prefer something a little closer to original sequence of events.
For me, I have her personal heel realization after the Battle with the Basilisk. Her hand in putting Ginny in danger makes her open her eyes to the suffering she causes when Molly thanks her.
Year 3 after causing Buckbeak to be sentenced to death, she realizes how horrible she had been to Hagrid. This is when she recruits Pansy down the path of Redemption.
Year 4 she goes to the ball with Harry, possibly blackmailing Pansy and Ron into going together (unpunishment for Pansy in her role regarding the bet). They have about 6 months of lovey-dovey before Voldemort's return starts to derail their romance.
Year 5 is when she is playing double agent. Neither Umbridge nor Harry truly trusts her; she plays both sides still unsure of where she stands. If she is fully in love with Harry, it is Cho who betrays the DA. If her relationship sours, she is the one who shows Umbridge how to get into the Room of Requirement.
Year 6 is the head-on collision. Pressganged into being a Death Eater, the near deaths of Katie Bell, Ron, and many others who were close to both Harry and her cause their confrontation in Myrtle's Bathroom, above the very place they had once fought side-by-side.
Year 7 is much more uncertain. There are so many possible paths, from her joining in the Horcrux Hunt to her being with the Death Eaters near the end and drawing the Sword of Gryffindor. About the only guarantee is her helping the golden trio escape Malfoy Manor, and "Two Hearts, one Wand" defeating Voldemort.
1
35
Replying to @USAbetterthanEu @edu_andy24
You are looking at it without context.
Remember, she almost killed Ron with poisoned mead. Katie Bell was almost killed by her actions.
She is working for the Death Eaters. No amount of love is going to overcome the stress that will put on Harry.
7
Replying to @OswaldSilverton @edu_andy24
And I am okay with that.
I do like the kissing her scars images because of the idea that a man will still love his woman after her beauty fades.
My problem is that those against it have completely forgotten the whole point of even gender flipping Draco. The bathroom brawl is practically the single biggest factor as to why the meme exploded. The whole scene changes with a girl instead of a hated male rival.
1
15
Replying to @tintillo @edu_andy24
"For enemies" is a red herring. There is nothing in the actual casting of the spell that limits that.
Besides, that was the Half-Blood Prince's notes. And it did not do ANYTHING to indicate why. Hence Harry went in blind as to its effects. He had an itchy trigger finger and found out the hard way.
4
Replying to @frCharlesfi @edu_andy24
Yeah, the Bathroom Brawl sets up nicely for a Shakespearian three act romance.
1
Replying to @CloseupCafeCup @edu_andy24
And that defeats the whole point of the meme and thought experiment. It shows they never really understood the character.
5
Replying to @5Mambano @edu_andy24
But that is the thing, you CAN make minimal changes and still get there.
I did the Basilisk Battle with minimal changes beyond her participation as a co-belligerent. Harry still kills the monster, Ginny is still the victim of the Diary, and yet she is still able to shine.
I would suggest that if you do read it, have the original novel open and cross-reference to see what I mean.
teapaw.org/NeilCell/status/212136…
14
The problem is that most of the critics of the bathroom brawl have taken it to the point where his video is the only acceptable version.
They miss the point that having Draco as a girl in that situation was one of the major motivators for the malfoid meme.
1
24
Replying to @WaryMest @edu_andy24
It did. And the critics of the bathroom Brawl refuse to acknowledge that.
1
Replying to @vijeomasher2 @edu_andy24
I think you are confusing the people who are more for consistency with the original novel with the fan-ficiton writers of Alchemized and Manacled. THOSE are gore fetishers.
10
Replying to @aapugh3093 @edu_andy24
Yeah, the Ronsy supporters and the critics of the Bathroom Brawl have a lot of overlap. They both can't tolerate anything that doesn't support their exclusive view.
It is the kind of stuff that make Steven Universe such as toxic fandom. It is the same energy ad Reylo.
1
17
Replying to @vijeomasher2 @edu_andy24
"Domestic abuse"? You do realize they are not married?
Have you forgotten that she hexed Katie Bell and almost killed Ron with poisoned mead?
It is as if the people arguing against it have completely forgotten all of the other events leading up to it. How about Harry knowing she is in league with the Death Eaters? How about her using Crusio against him?
There is CONTEXT which is blatantly ignored by those who are agaisnt the Bathroom Brawl.
1
52
Replying to @IronHeart817876 @edu_andy24
I agree. They are loud, but they don't necessarily have the arguments, particularly narrative justification supporting them.
I have noticed those who are against the Bathroom Brawl are the same folks supporting Ronsy.
11
Replying to @edu_andy24 @Topovn
Except, Voldemort's control over Malfoid's parents means all conflict has NOT ended. That is simply an argument by people who are missing the bigger picture of the War between the Death Eaters and those who stand against them.
3
Replying to @TheGyropath @ASithLawd
No, it just means you don't understand how build-up and foreshadowing works.
You have consumed so much Tinsletown slop that you don't understand what the hero's journey is all aobut.
1








