Paul Robinson retweeted
Why does Canada suddenly need foreign companies to buy up our new homes to increase our housing supply?
Because new home prices are unaffordable for Canadian households. 5/
Paul Robinson retweeted
Replying to @MikePMoffatt
Homes should be for shelter and not as a place for foreign investors to speculate or park their money. Taxpaying Canadian residents do not want to compete with global capital to buy a home. The way to attract talent is to lower home prices to be affordable on local incomes. – at Blaine, WA
Paul Robinson retweeted
Replying to @Prominent_Bryan
What are you confused by? 2016 prices were wildly unaffordable relative to local incomes and still are. – at Blaine, WA
Paul Robinson retweeted
The Foreign Buyers won't be Permanent Residents or Citizens why do they want to own individual Canadian properties?
The most obvious reason is MONEY LAUNDERING
That was a huge part of Foreign Buying before
Or just move money out of my country because of fear of government
5/
Paul Robinson retweeted
Replying to @MarkKahn2
I think there is a reasonable debate be had as to whether NYC and other global cities (e.g. London) really benefit from having their residential housing markets used as a store of value for absentee ultrarich (oligarchs, oil sheiks, CCP princelings).
Replying to @CBCEarlyEdition
@CBCEarlyEdition did I just hear your guest say that the typical real estate sales model for a new condo building is to sell to end users? Someone should pull up the stats on what percentage of condos were actually being sold to end users verse flippers or investors.
Paul Robinson retweeted
Jen Keesmaat is not a city planner anymore, nor a mayoral candidate - she's the CEO of a real estate developer. Her success is directly tied to housing being expensive. She has abandoned views she used to espouse. The company she leads has displaced tenants for redevelopment.
Paul Robinson retweeted
Someone asked me what young US citizens want, if not a 50 year mortgage?
Most want what their parents had.
That is, a housing market where they only compete against other American families for single family homes to live in. Not LLCs. Not foreign buyers. Not Airbnb operators. Not wealthy people’s 5th vacation home left vacant 3/4 of the year
Paul Robinson retweeted
People often ask why Canadians are so obsessed with owning a home
It’s because our governments treat renters like second-class citizens
Stripping away security and dignity in the name of “making the market work more efficiently.” 8/
Paul Robinson retweeted
Let’s be clear
There’s zero evidence that taking away tenants’ housing security will “unlock” rental supply
The idea that landlords are sitting on hundreds of thousands of vacant units because leases last too long is absurd. 6/
Paul Robinson retweeted
Hardly any young people at all will be able to afford to buy a home in 2040
As it is today we have already entered into a kind of neo-feudal system of parental assistance or no hope of Homeownership in half of Canada
Which leads us back to: Own Nothing & Be Happy
6/
Paul Robinson retweeted
If the theory was right, we’d be cheering this moment.
More supply = lower prices, right?
Instead, the entire system flinches when prices drop.
Why?
Because the system isn’t designed for affordability. It’s designed for price appreciation.
Paul Robinson retweeted
The recent housing report by Realosophy President John Pasalis is a masterclass on speaking the truth, when financial & political forces keep most housing 'experts' quiet.
"Canada has built an economy where the best way to get rich isn’t to invent, create, or build anything—it’s to own houses and wait for prices to rise."
Here are some truths every Canadian should know:
- More supply alone won't make homes affordable, when investor demand grows faster than we build. Anyone who says it will is promising disappointment.
- Expensive housing is a deliberate policy choice—Canada actively encourages homes as investments, concentrating stock into those already with wealth
- Young families' wages have no shot against megacorp capital, who use sophisticated algos to scoop up 10,000s homes and extract max rent
- Unlike previous generations, prices are no longer anchored to incomes, but global investment demand and how much banks are willing to lend. Unlimited credit seeking tax-sheltered returns means unlimited prices.
- But investors aren't just megacorps, they're mom and pops that leverage against existing properties to buy even more, outbidding families in the search for tax-sheltered leveraged gains
- Banks are pouring fuel on the fire: they have more incentive to lend aggressively for mortgages than to businesses looking to grow
- We can and should change incentives to make housing a less lucrative investment, bringing down prices and prioritizing real economic activity over unproductive extraction.
Read on for choice quotes from Pasalis' report "The Great Sell Off" 🧵
Paul Robinson retweeted
So it appears foreign investment was powering condo purchases and housing prices in Vancouver market, now that is flat & developers need to find way to build when markets just local.
"Canada's population standstill rattling Vancouver's housing industry" as told by @DouglasTodd via @VancouverSun
#cdnpoli #bcpoli #vanpoli #vanre
vancouversun.com/opinion/col…
Paul Robinson retweeted
#VanRE @DouglasTodd Peer-reviewed paper by Gordon, Ley & @Ayan604 shows foreign capital, especially from China, has been a striking factor in raising B.C. housing values, often “celebrated behind closed doors by the real estate industry.” theprovince.com/opinion/colu…
Paul Robinson retweeted
Lots of changes in the last 30 years are just technology but 2 things
- A new Feudal System for Home Ownership
- Bizarre levels of Income Disparity
Are NOT fair to Young People or good for society & should be fought by Governments
But that's not what's happening
6/
Paul Robinson retweeted
Replying to @MKupperman
YIMBYism is a developer psyop to oppose the building and funding of functional public housing.
Paul Robinson retweeted
Replying to @JohnPasalis
1. I don’t believe that anyone was genuinely basing their retirement on their home value inexplicably outpacing any fundamental metric (in some cases up more than 2000% since purchase).
2. So what if they were? Does that obligate society to now sacrifice housing affordability?














