Piers Benn (@PiersBenn) header
Piers Benn (@PiersBenn) profile picture

Academic philosopher. Member, Heterodox Academy @HdxAcademy. Author, 'Intellectual Freedom and the Culture Wars', Palgrave (2021).

London
Joined August 2010
Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)Photo by Piers Benn (@PiersBenn)
Piers Benn retweeted
I tend to agree with Tom Nagel that the philosophical discourse around AI consciousness verges on the "ridiculous". wired.com/story/just-ridicul… But there is social value in philosophers taking seriously apparently ridiculous ideas. The situation is very different when such ideas take root in, and are propagated by, largely unaccountable centres of great power, such as the tech corporations developing AI. settingoutforithaka.substack…
12
29
1
108
4,782
Piers Benn retweeted
Exceptionally clear defense of how to respond to views that we may find offensive, especially in academic settings. Listening and challenging do not mean endorsement. Canceling, abusing, and shutting down never make the views you don’t like disappear. Quite the opposite. @ObhishekSaha
‘Allowing someone to speak is not the same as endorsing their views.’ Professor of Mathematics at Queen Mary University of London Abhishek Saha explains why 170 academics have called for a talk by ‘race-realist’ Nathan Cofnas at Oxford to go ahead.
4
54
2
344
14,524
I enjoyed being a judge, employing all my usual justice and compassion, at the @DebatingMatters final in Westminster yesterday. A bunch of enthusiastic British and American Young People. @Fox_Claire reminded them all that they can't all win...
1
1
6
1,395
🚨 BREAKING: The Committee for Academic Freedom (CAF) has written to Queen Mary University of London (QMUL) on behalf of two senior academics who are refusing to complete mandatory training requiring assent to contested theoretical propositions about “unconscious bias”, potentially jeopardising their career progression and professional opportunities. The dispute concerns an assessment within What is Unconscious Bias? — part of QMUL’s Introducing Inclusion course, which is “mandatory for all staff”. The assessment requires participants to affirm that “unconscious biases help us to react quickly but can cloud our judgement”, and to identify accepting that “we have unconscious biases” as helpful. The accompanying feedback declares that such acceptance is “the first step to combating their negative effects”. Informed by their scholarly research, the academics we’re supporting dispute these propositions and have refused to complete the assessment rather than give answers contrary to their convictions. Under the assessment’s all-or-nothing marking system, refusing to affirm both propositions caps a participant’s score at 60%, below the 80% pass mark. Yet passing is a condition of eligibility for promotion, professorial review, including decisions on remuneration, and participation in recruitment and promotion panels. Although influential in social-justice-oriented scholarship, the concept of unconscious bias is contested within psychology, with researchers disagreeing about what it means, whether the processes in question are necessarily unconscious, and whether they exert a causal influence on judgement. Peer-reviewed research also questions whether acknowledging such biases improves behaviour. QMUL is of course entitled to provide training on its preferred theory of bias. But it remains just that: a theory. When such training is mandatory, requires staff to pass an assessment, and is tied to professional opportunities, there is a clear risk of compelling academics to affirm propositions they simply don’t believe. That’s why we’ve proposed a simple solution: amend the assessment so that academics who don’t all think alike can demonstrate understanding without having to endorse its underlying assumptions. Should QMUL decline to address these concerns, CAF is prepared to fund legal counsel to assist the academics, should they wish, in pursuing an internal grievance and subsequent complaint to the OfS. We believe there are strong grounds for such a complaint, given that such training may breach QMUL’s statutory duties to secure freedom of speech and academic freedom. Consistent with Article 10 protections against compelled expression, the Office for Students has also warned that universities “should not require training or induction that imposes a requirement on the person completing the training actively to endorse any viewpoint or value-judgement”. Sadly, this isn’t an isolated case. As CAF knows from its casework, universities often impose mandatory training in which the distinction between “understanding” and “endorsing” contested ideas becomes blurred. That’s why we hope this intervention marks the beginning of a wider pushback against compelled intellectual conformity on campus. If you’re an academic with similar concerns about mandatory training at your institution, get in touch. CAF can assess your case and, where appropriate, secure specialist legal advice and raise the matter with your university on your behalf. Contact us at [email protected] Full story via The Telegraph: telegraph.co.uk/gift/1060b26…
36
250
19
836
42,992
Alastair Campbell thinks a made-up word can save us all. I reviewed his new book on "persevilience" for @Unherd unherd.com/2026/10/persevili…
18
24
9
147
17,774
“Please stop adopting generalised statements of values — this inevitably encourages decision-making referring to a framework that has no relationship to the law.” Sound advice for universities and their senior leaders from @akuareindorf KC, speaking at Edinburgh’s Conflict on Campus conference. In CAF’s experience, it’s not uncommon to find a senior administrator or HR officer reminding an academic of the trite but true fact that freedom of speech is a “qualified right”, before proceeding, sometimes in the very same email, to assert that an alleged breach of the university's “values” takes the academic’s speech beyond the limits of what the law protects — thereby justifying anything from an admonition to “reflect on their tone or choice of words” to the launch of a disciplinary investigation. timeshighereducation.com/new…
1
12
27
1,924
Concerning to see what happened to @AdamWagner1 KC at City St George’s last week, where masked protesters interrupted a public lecture about his legal work representing British families of hostages in Gaza with chants of “war criminal”, “settlers go home”, and demands that he be disbarred. The Association of Student Activism for Palestine subsequently claimed responsibility for the disruption. Protesters are entitled to express opposing views, including those that offend, shock or disturb. But in the context of a university lecture, there is an important distinction between legitimate protest and a “heckler’s veto”, where protesters seek to prevent others from speaking or being heard by drowning them out. That’s why, in its regulatory advice, the Office for Students recognises that sustained shouting which prevents others from being heard or participating in a lecture may justify restrictions on the time, place and manner of protest. City’s own Freedom of Speech Code similarly requires organisers to intervene where heckling prevents others from being heard. Was this an attempted heckler’s veto? The interruption lasted approximately ten minutes, with protesters apparently leaving only when they learned security was arriving. Sloganeering denunciations delivered from behind masks are, in any case, liable to look less like an effort to debate than an attempt to intimidate and chill speech. If those involved are City students, disciplinary action may well be warranted. But disciplinary proceedings alone cannot address the underlying cultural problem, and may simply reinforce a sense of grievance among those involved. The deeper question here concerns campus culture, and how universities can foster a commitment to intellectual pluralism in an increasingly polarised climate. These protesters had researched the time and venue, and made their way into a lecture theatre where one of the UK’s leading human rights barristers was discussing a subject about which they evidently held strong views. So far, so good. Why not then listen, reflect and, having done their homework, attempt to challenge his arguments, putting difficult questions to him and seeing how he answered them? Students will inevitably feel passionately about contentious political questions. But as J. S. Mill observed in On Liberty: “He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that … if he is equally unable to refute the reasons on the opposite side, he has no ground for preferring either opinion.” For that reason, “He must be able to hear [opposing arguments] from persons who actually believe them; who defend them in earnest, and do their very utmost for them. He must know them in their most plausible and persuasive form.” So beyond regulatory guidance and the enforcement of university policies, the more pressing task is surely to cultivate the habits of intellectual curiosity, openness and serious disagreement that might help students turn their convictions into arguments, rather than slogans.
2
10
31
1,890
If you’ve got concerns about academic standards or recruitment practices at Cambridge, but are worried about what might happen if you raise them through formal channels, the independent Arday Investigation wants to hear from you. ardayinvestigation.net/
13
36
3,258
Good panel - I enjoyed it. Thanks to all who made it happen.
"The Corruption of the University?" a Battle of Ideas @acadofideas discussion with @SehgalCuthbert @NigelBiggar @Furedibyte @johnarmstrong5 @prossertj and Tess Ashen #BattleFest
1
1
4
912
🚨BREAKING: CAF has commissioned an independent investigation into Cambridge’s appointment of Dr Jason Arday as its youngest ever black professor, amid growing professional disquiet over his academic record, the circumstances of his appointment, the University’s handling of concerns raised about his scholarship and, more recently, the scope and direction of Cambridge’s own inquiry. You can find out more here: ardayinvestigation.net/ The investigation will be chaired by Professor Swaran Preet Singh, Lord Singh of Solihull, a former Commissioner of the Equality and Human Rights Commission who previously led the independent investigation into allegations of discrimination within the Conservative Party. He will be joined by a distinguished panel comprising Harvard psychologist Professor Steven Pinker, UCL sociologist Professor Alice Sullivan, Cambridge historian Professor Robert Tombs and Labour peer Professor Maurice Glasman. Award-winning investigative journalist Nick Wallis, whose work helped expose the Post Office Horizon scandal, will lead the investigation with a dedicated research team. CAF has been contacted by numerous Cambridge academics who are deeply concerned that the University’s own investigation will fail to confront the wider institutional culture in which the Arday affair unfolded. Whether these concerns are justified is for the independent investigation to determine. But Cambridge is one of the world’s oldest and greatest universities, and what happens to its academic culture has implications for higher education as a whole. So we think it’s worth going the extra mile to make sure the right questions are asked and the right lessons learned. CAF strongly encourages current and former academics, students and other members of the University community, as well as others with relevant knowledge, to come forward with information. This might include policy documents, internal correspondence or first-hand accounts concerning Arday’s academic record and appointment, the University’s response to concerns about his scholarship and its treatment of those who raised them, and the operation of institutional policies relating to recruitment, promotion, academic misconduct, research integrity and EDI. Anyone wishing to contribute can contact the Investigator directly at: [email protected] The investigation website provides further guidance on submitting information, including arrangements for particularly sensitive material: ardayinvestigation.net/
68
382
65
1,606
158,748
I chair a LOT of events, but this festival is still unequalled for serious audience engagement with such a wide range of ideas. Come join me next weekend for debates on AI, drones and statistics - and dozens of other subjects!
FIVE DAYS TO GO TILL #BattleFest 2026 Ask questions, offer anecdotes, make points - above all, DISAGREE with the speakers. We give you, the audience, over HALF of each session - the Battle of Ideas is DEMOCRACY IN ACTION. 110+ SESSIONS, 400+ SPEAKERS, 3500+ ATTENDEES 📅17&18 OCTOBER 📍London, Westminster DETAILS - battleofideas.org.uk/program… TICKETS - battleofideas.org.uk/battle-…
1
12
2
34
3,375
THE REPARATIONS DEBATE Are reparations a necessary moral response when dealing with past ‘crimes’ or are they too easy an attempt to buy absolution for historic wrongdoings – another ‘white saviour’ project, driven by guilt? Should Britain’s role in abolishing slavery and creating a universal standard of human equality in the political realm be a consideration? Or do critics of reparations fail to take seriously the legacy of the slave trade, and the link between the oppression of black people in centuries gone by and the negative impact on Caribbean countries or the discrimination suffered by some here in Britain today? W/ @ada_akpala, @PiersBenn, @RafHM, @ASCphiled
Should Britain pay "reparations" for slavery? No.
5
13
1,519
Piers Benn retweeted
Hills I will die on: Lived experience is important, but there are things it cannot tell us. It cannot tell us whether a behaviour has a neurobiological cause. It cannot tell us whether a person’s individual experience generalises to everyone else. It provides hypotheses, not conclusions. And when we are using lived experience to make decisions, we have to ask - whose voices are missing here? Is there a chance that I am hearing only the loudest voices? Is it possible that some people don’t feel able to speak up, for fear of the response that they will get? We have to ask ourselves whether there might be people who don’t have a seat at the lived experience table. Otherwise we risk perpetuating inequality in the name of progress.
41
35
10
194
11,900
The Office for Students’ new free-speech complaints scheme went live on 1 September, giving academics a new, free-to-use route for challenging restrictions on lawful speech and #academicfreedom. For the first time, eligible complainants can ask the regulator to determine whether a university has breached its statutory #freespeech duties. Where a complaint is justified or partly justified, the OfS can recommend meaningful redress, including restoration of an invitation to speak, reinstatement of a research programme, changes to university policies and financial payments to complainants. To coincide with the launch, CAF has created a new Casework Support page designed to help ensure that cases reaching the OfS are as clearly framed and carefully prepared as possible. It includes practical guidance on getting a complaint right, why identifying the relevant issues from the earliest internal university stage matters, and how CAF can help. afcomm.org.uk/afcomm-org-uk-… There’s also a quick interactive checker that takes you through no more than nine questions about your circumstances, explains why each matters, and gives an initial indication of whether the OfS scheme may apply and when it may be worth contacting CAF. For those who want to understand the law beneath the scheme, our legal guide explains the statutory duties underpinning it. If you think your freedom of speech or academic freedom is being restricted, email CAF at [email protected]. And please do spread the word. There will be academics across the country who do not yet know that the landscape changed this week, including some at institutions where the new complaints scheme may not receive quite the prominence any of us would like.
16
25
2,058
“I didn’t know what to do until somebody suggested that I go to the Committee for Academic Freedom, and ask them about it.” Great to hear Professor Kevin Yuill on Radio 4 this morning discussing his case. CAF has instructed a leading employment law firm to act for Kevin after his University warned him to “reflect carefully” on the “tone and nature” of his lawful online interventions on assisted dying — leaving him fearing that further public comment on an issue directly related to his academic expertise could put his institutional status at risk. The interview marked the opening today of the new OfS free speech complaints scheme. Kevin’s case is also a reminder of why it can be important to talk to a specialist casework group like CAF early, before a complaint is drafted. That’s because an OfS case often starts long before anything is filed with the regulator. Internal correspondence, grievances, investigations and appeals create the record on which a later complaint may depend. CAF can help identify the real free-speech or academic-freedom issue, make sure the relevant facts and evidence are put on the record from the outset, help frame the case consistently as it develops and, where possible, help resolve the problem before an OfS complaint becomes necessary. Find out more about Kevin’s case here: afcomm.org.uk/2026/08/29/caf… Our resources on the new OfS complaints scheme are available here: afcomm.org.uk/afcomm-org-uk-…
27
2
63
3,242
⏰ At midnight tonight, a new era for academic freedom and campus free speech in England begins. The Office for Students’ new, free-to-use free-speech complaints scheme comes into force on 1 September. For the first time, academics and others whose lawful speech is restricted will have access to a specialist sector regulator with real powers of redress — including the power to recommend reinstatement, changes to university policies and financial payments to complainants. Current and former university staff, applicants for academic posts and visiting speakers will be able to complain where they have suffered adverse consequences because of action or inaction by a university or college that is alleged to breach its statutory duty to secure “freedom of speech within the law”. For academic staff, that duty includes securing academic freedom. CAF has spent the run-up to the new scheme making sure we’re ready to help. We’ve launched a new Casework Support page explaining what the scheme means, when a free-speech complaint really begins, why getting the issues right from the outset matters, and how CAF can support academics through internal university processes and, where necessary, on to the OfS. We’ve also built an easy-to-use interactive checker. Answer no more than nine questions about what has happened and it will give you feedback tailored to your answers and an initial indication of whether the new scheme may apply to your case. But you don’t need to wait until you’re ready to complain to the OfS before coming to us. CAF can help identify the legal and regulatory issues, draft correspondence, help academics navigate grievances, disciplinary proceedings and appeals and, in appropriate cases, fund specialist legal advice and instruct solicitors. So if you think your #freedomofspeech or #academicfreedom is being restricted, come to us early. And if you don’t need our help yourself, please do spread the word. There will be academics across the country who don’t yet know that the landscape changes tomorrow — or that there’s an organisation ready to help them navigate it. Find out more, use our checker and get in touch: afcomm.org.uk/afcomm-org-uk-…
3
69
5
145
10,388
Dr Nathan Cofnas will return to work at Ghent University on 29 August and is expected to complete his one-year postdoctoral appointment after the US ambassador to Belgium announced an “amicable” agreement to lift his preventive suspension — even as the institution itself insists that its disciplinary investigation remains ongoing and that he must work remotely, may not teach and may attend campus only with the Rector’s prior written permission. Cofnas, whose academic work includes controversial hereditarian and “race realist” scholarship, was initially suspended on 20 August after Ghent opened a preliminary disciplinary investigation into his conduct following the death of Dr Jason Arday, Cambridge University’s youngest ever black professor, whose work and academic record Cofnas had subjected to public scrutiny. Full story: afcomm.org.uk/2026/08/28/cof…
10
13
1
48
3,008
CAF has written to Ghent University’s Rector and the Flemish Government Commissioner responsible for the University about Ghent’s preventive suspension of Dr Nathan Cofnas and its ongoing disciplinary investigation into his conduct. We take no view on Dr Cofnas’s substantive views, just as we have not when defending pro-Palestinian, Israeli, socialist, conservative or other scholars whose academic freedom has been placed at risk in the past. Our concerns are procedural. In our letter, we expressly accept that academic freedom does not place any academic above legitimate scrutiny. But we also urge Ghent to apply its own disciplinary rules precisely, including by keeping evidence of opposition to Dr Cofnas’s views rigorously distinct from evidence of misconduct by Dr Cofnas himself, by ensuring that subjective reactions to Dr Cofnas cannot substitute for the objective requirements of the applicable disciplinary rules, and by distinguishing the mere pursuit of research beyond his contractual mandate from any separate allegation that he misrepresented or improperly used his Ghent affiliation. We also ask the University to respect throughout the investigation the protections for academic freedom afforded by Belgian and European law. That is our job. CAF exists to hold universities to account for their treatment of academics across the political and intellectual spectrum, and to defend lawful #academicfreedom regardless of whose views are at issue. Full story: afcomm.org.uk/2026/08/24/ghe…
1
13
55
1,950