Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal) header
Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal) profile picture

Husband | Father | 1788 WCF | OPC Layperson | Podcaster

Joined June 2014
Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)Photo by Tony Arsenal (@ReformedArsenal)
This is particularly aimed at Reformed theology and incorrectly attributes to our system that we think that man could not have willed otherwise. We distinguish.
80. If God decreed a man's sin and he could not have willed otherwise, how is the man guilty? Protestant Error: God decrees men's sins, so that the sinner could not will otherwise. Refutation: (1) No one who could not have willed otherwise is guilty of what he wills. (2) But every sinner is guilty of what he wills. (3) Therefore no sinner is one who could not have willed otherwise. Read all 95 Antitheses: classicalliberalarts.com/blo… Learn to reason with the Church at the Classical Liberal Arts Academy. Begin within 24 hours: classicalliberalarts.com/enr…
88
Most Protestants would agree that men do not ordain themselves to ministry. This is a classic example of a straw man argument.
Protestants: Provide an example in the New Testament of a man who takes a position of Church leadership to himself as Protestant pastors do. No such example exists in the Bible, yet you agree to follow men who do so. Shame on you.
5
15
509
Yeah, except in Acts 15 where Peter speaks first, but it is actually James who provides the final judgment. If Peter was the first pope in the Papal sense, why was James delivering the judgment and sending out the letters to the churches?
71. Why is Peter named first in every list of the Apostles, and why does he speak and act first throughout the Acts of the Apostles? Protestant Error: Peter was merely the equal of the other Apostles. Refutation: (1) Whoever is constantly placed first by Scripture and set apart from the rest is chief among them. (2) But Peter is constantly placed first by Scripture and set apart from the rest of the Apostles. (3) Therefore Peter is chief among the Apostles. Read all 95 Antitheses: classicalliberalarts.com/blo… Study Scripture and the Fathers at the Classical Liberal Arts Academy. Enroll today: classicalliberalarts.com/enr…
11
19
720
Faith is not the basis of justification, which is what Mr. Uzoma seems to believe we thing. The basis of justification is the propitiatory work of Jesus Christ on behalf of his people. The benefit of this work is applied to his people by the Holy Spirit, received through faith.
God: "So why should I allow you into into heaven?" Protestants: Because I believe in your saving grace. I believe you died for me. I believe it is your works that saved me, not my works. Because I have faith alone in you. I believe my works cannot save me, but by my faith alone in you. That is why I want you to accept me into your kingdom." Catholics: Dear Lord, because I'm a baptised Christian. 👍🏾
3
176
Cause there has NEVER been a moral scandal in Papal Church…
The Sola Scriptura influencer who got caught plagiarizing will fade from memory and nobody will ever say “the Protestant Church believes in plagiarism”. A new guy will take his place, with an equal amount of accountability.
2
7
525
The Roman Catholic Church does not dogmatically define when the Gospel of John was written, so his whole argument rests on an invalidated presupposition that it was written after 67 AD.
The Gospel of John reveals Peter's unique privileges and instructions from Christ, which clearly place him in a position of privacy among the apostles. But that's not what's most important. John wrote the Gospel AFTER the death of Peter, so John was perpetuating Peter's authority after he had already departed. John never taught that he himself, the last living apostle, inherited that role over the Church. So, either (a) Peter's role was temporary and unnecessary after his death, (b) Peter continues to lead the Church from heaven after his death, or (c) Peter's primacy among Church leaders was passed to his successor who leads in Peter's place. Protestants will argue (a), but this makes no sense of John's teaching of Peter's privileges and primacy after his death. Why would the Church need this earthly ministry in the first century but not thereafter, especially if the New Testament says that times will get worse? There is no evidence anywhere in Scripture or tradition of (b). Church history recognizes only (c), which makes sense of John's writing after Peter's death.
6
6
738
Catholic Answers, for example, says it was before 65 AD which would put it before the traditional date the Papists use for Peter's martyrdom.
3
104
Remember when Lawson was booked to speak and we were told we were jumping to conclusions when we objected? Remember when Lawson published a book and we were told we were jumping to conclusions when we objected?
Exclusive: Steve Lawson RESTORED TO MINISTRY Nearly ONE YEAR Ago. One year, two months, and six days after Trinity Bible Church announced that Steven J. Lawson was disqualified from ministry for having a "sinful relationship" with a woman nearly 45 years his junior, he was restored to ministry by his new church elders, according to documents obtained exclusively by Protestia. On September 19, 2024, Trinity Bible Church announced the removal of Steve Lawson after discovering he was having an “inappropriate relationship” with a woman he had grown close to over a period of many years and eventually crossed physical boundaries with. Following these revelations, Steve left the state and moved to Nashville, where he began attending Stephens Valley Church. Lawson, 75, shared in an update letter half a year after his original implosion: "I have been undergoing extensive counseling for the last five months to face the hard questions I need to address. I have dealt with sin issues that have been painfully exposed in my heart. I have submitted myself in weekly accountability to two pastors and to the elders of a local congregation, who have shepherded my soul. I am also under the oversight of an accountability team who monitor my progress and give me wise counsel in the decisions I have to make. I am growing in grace, reading and absorbing the Word of God, putting it into practice, praying, and meeting with other believers. I am involved in the life of the church, attending and participating in prayer meetings, Sunday school, the worship service, and taking communion weekly. I am being fed the Word in the mid-week Bible study. Please pray for my spiritual growth into Christlikeness as I follow Him moment by moment during this recovery season." Seven months later, his elders restored him to ministry. A letter from the elders given to commend Lawson to any potential churches or Christian organizations and associations that might have him speak, reads: "We, the Elders of Stephens Valley Church, a Biblical and Reformed congregation, have observed the life of Dr. Steven Lawson for the last 15 months. Several of us have met with him individually on a weekly basis. He has also attended our weekly Elder's prayer meetings. As a member in good standing of our church, he has been faithfully attending our adult Sunday School classes, worship services, and Wednesday night Bible studies. We have seen him make a positive contribution to the church and the lives of others. Based upon our direct interaction with him and his own written statements, we believe him to be genuinely repentant and walking in close fellowship with the Lord. Together we grieve his past sin, as he has and the consequences he has brought upon himself and others. Now however we rejoice in his present repentance and God's work of grace in his life. In particular we applaud his pursuit of and patience toward his loving wife, Anne. In light of Steve's "broken and contrite heart" and all we have observed these past months we deem him spiritually fit for ministry opportunities that the Lord may open to him. The Elder Counsel Stephens Valley Church Nashville, TN Nov. 25, 2025." Lawson details the journey of repentance in his book Mercy in the Wilderness and will soon release another book based on the life of King David. According to sources, the Elder Counsel has declined to make this restoration letter and judgment from a year ago public, even though doing so would help Lawson and allow him greater freedom to be publicly promoted and reintegrated into ministry with prospective churches and conferences. We reached out to Stephens Valley Church but they chose not to comment.
3
5
4
70
9,620
Remember when received an apology after it was demonstrably proven that we were 100% correct? Yeah, you don't. We will never receive that apology.
1
7
471
They want us to believe that a man who had a significant affair, one that was arguably abusive and exploitative, while in ministry, while actively preaching against lust and adultery, has somehow recovered from that spiritual destruction, in less than 2 years. No.
2
12
406
Nearly every Protestant confession of faith acknowledges the distinction between the visible Church which may contain those who are not saved, and the invisible Church, which is only known by God.
13. If the Church consists only of the elect, how can anyone know which pastors belong to it, since no one knows who is predestined? Protestant Error: The Church consists of the elect alone, whose number is known to God only. Refutation: (1) No society whose membership is hidden is a society whose pastors the faithful can know and obey. (2) But the Church is a society whose pastors the faithful can know and obey: "Obey your prelates" (Heb. 13:17). (3) Therefore the Church is not a society whose membership is hidden. Read all 95 Antitheses: classicalliberalarts.com/blo… Study Logic and theology at the Classical Liberal Arts Academy. Enroll today: classicalliberalarts.com/enr…
1
4
244
No Protestant confession of faith argues that personal reading of Scripture is a condition of salvation.
35. If salvation depends on reading Scripture, how are those who cannot read to be saved? Protestant Error: Each believer's reading of Scripture is a condition of his salvation. Refutation: (1) No condition of salvation is beyond the reach of the unlettered, for God will have all men to be saved (1 Tim. 2:4). (2) But reading Scripture is beyond the reach of the unlettered. (3) Therefore reading Scripture is not a condition of salvation. Read all 95 Antitheses: classicalliberalarts.com/blo… Learn to read Scripture with the Church at the Classical Liberal Arts Academy. Enroll today: classicalliberalarts.com/enr…
1
6
319
"The Protestant "minister" had no idea what he's talking about -- nor does he have any interest in learning what the truth actually is." This is the richest thing I've seen coming from this guy who has been ignorantly misrepresenting and misquoting Protestants for a month.
I heard a Protestant "minister" ask, "If confession is so important for Catholics, why is it only available on Saturdays?" He asked this as if it was a clever objection. It only revealed his ignorance. First, there are two kinds of confession in the Catholic Church: general and sacramental. General confession is made by all Catholics at the beginning of every Mass. All common sins of human weakness are absolved at Mass. Mass is celebrated every day at every Catholic church. Second, scheduled Confession times are for sacramental confession only. Catholics are rquired to make sacramental Confession only once per year. Priests are available for sacramental Confession at stated times and by private appointment -- so the scheduled times are not the only times for Confession. Third, sacramental Confession is necessary when a Christian has committed a serious (mortal) sin, after which they may not receive Communion. They must make confession, do penance and receive absolution before receiving Communion again. This can be done any time one needs to do so. Contrary to Protestant lies, Catholic priests determine whether one shows contrition and wishes to amend his life. The Act of Contrition provides the words prayed by the one making confession. Fourth, Catholics are welcome to make sacramental Confession more frequently to confess venial sins and receive "spiritual direction" from the priest. I, for example, as a Lay Dominican, am required to make sacramental Confession monthly. Fifth, when a great number of people make sacramental Confession and times are not sufficient, more times are added. My parish, for example, offers 5 hours for Confession every week, on Wednesdays and Thursday evenings. Some parishes offer time for Confession before every Mass. So, it is perfectly reasonable why a Catholic Church has simple regular Confession times despite the fact that the sacrament of Confession is central to the Christian life (and always has been). The Protestant "minister" had no idea what he's talking about -- nor does he have any interest in learning what the truth actually is.
2
3
396
More dishonest posting
Jesus said that false teachers will be known by their fruits, that is, their actions. Protestant teachers proposed "salvation by faith alone" so that they might not be evaluated by their fruits. A man can declare himself to be saved, start his own church, declare himself its pastor, teach whatever he wants and then criticize anyone who questions his behavior. Anyone who questions his personal life is called a legalist, or Pharisee, is accused of despising Jesus, distracting from the Gospel, etc. The people in Protestant churches are not allowed to do this. Once in the church, they are accountable to the rules of the pastor. He preaches on tithing, volunteering, bringing people into the church, etc. The people in the pews are judged by their actions. Only the pastor is actually saved by faith alone.
1
1
360
This. The passage most often associated with this error is immediately followed by a command to abstain from what is evil. The principle isn’t to take what is good from evil sources, it is to test sources and only rely on the good ones.
Trying to eat the meat and spit out the bones of disqualified leaders is not maturity, it is a lack of discernment. If you are not a man of character, you have nothing I want and nothing I need.
3
270