Please... Not Again retweeted
The fears around $BMNR potentially moving from ~5% toward 10% of ETH supply seem overly focused on dilution.
I think $MSTR provides an important lesson here.
When a DAT trades above NAV, that premium becomes a source of capital. Shares can be issued above the value of the crypto backing them and the proceeds recycled into more crypto. Done correctly, share count rises while ETH per share and NAV per share can rise with it.
This is incredibly important for a DAT. If you can’t monetize an mNAV materially above 1x to create per-share value, there is little fundamental reason for that premium to persist.
That’s the flywheel:
Above NAV → accretive issuance → more ETH per share.
Below NAV → accretive buybacks → more ETH per share.
And this is where I think the criticism of BMNR’s 10% ambition gets somewhat backwards.
10% isn’t what justifies dilution.
Accretive economics justify dilution.
But the ambition to keep accumulating ETH, whether the eventual number is 7%, 10% or something else, gives BMNR somewhere productive to deploy the capital created by its equity premium.
In other words, the thing people are worried about can, if BMNR adheres to strict mNAV discipline, be exactly what shareholders should want:
A mandate to keep converting an expensive equity currency into greater ETH and NAV per share.
MSTR showed how powerful that flywheel can become at scale if done right before the recent blunders. BMNR adds staking economics on top.
What @fundstrat needs to make crystal clear is the rule: don’t dilute to hit 10%. Dilute when it is accretive. Buy back when the discount makes that accretive.
The goal isn’t 10% at any cost.
The goal is maximizing ETH and NAV per share, and using the ambition to accumulate more ETH as the engine that keeps the flywheel running.
(See below shares outstanding and MNAV on $MSTR, you need it all to have a chance at 2+ MNAV in a final cycle move)
Please... Not Again retweeted
Ok I just read through vitalik’s paper and if the vision he outlined is executed the implications are absolutely insane especially for the app layer.
The paper is basically Eth’s plan on how they will enable computation off chain with Eth verifying the result (ensuring computation occurred and what it did etc etc).
Now what this means is the definition of “onchain” itself changes, because instead of every part of an app having to execute inside a smart contract you can push a huge amount of complexity elsewhere and still inherit ethereum’s guarantees, this really does open up a huge amount of design space especially for DeFi.
For example with lending you could have really sophisticated systems analysing collateral, liquidity, borrower behaviour and market conditions offchain, with multiple solvers or execution systems competing to produce the best outcome, like the cheapest liquidation route, best refinancing rate, best collateral swap or best way to match borrowers and lenders all while the protocol only accepts outcomes that satisfy its rules.
So basically a lot more of the smart stuff behind a financial product can happen outside the smart contract, while Eth still acts as the final layer that checks the rules were followed and makes sure the money moves exactly as it should.
The MEV implications here are quite interesting too because more economic activity happening before settlement means more value moves upstream into who gets the information first, who computes the best outcome and what gets presented to Eth.
But the thing I’m most bullish on is what this does to the TAM of Eth just because this vision means ethereum doesn’t have to be fast enough to do everything itself it just has to be able to verify everything that matters.
And that’s an enormous difference.
It’s literally a world computer.
The cryptographic world computer:
vitalik.eth.limo/general/202…
My attempt to express in somewhat concise terms the true meaning of basically everything planned to happen to Ethereum starting from the fork after Hegota. It's really not just a blockchain anymore. It's a hybrid architecture that combines together blockchains and modern cryptography, to enable much more powerful properties.
FOCIL, EIP-8288, Lean consensus, state management, formal verification, advanced mempool improvements (including privacy), and the longer-term specter of obfuscation all mentioned.
Please... Not Again retweeted
Also this thing is done now
vitalik.eth.limo/snowmoon/
Please... Not Again retweeted
Replying to @theallinpod
@theallinpod @Jason @DavidSacks @chamath After hearing the last pod I think it would great for to extend and invite to @DariusDale42 on. Seems like he could enlighten some of you with a refreshing look at a different capitalism. Sacks and the sweater could use the perspective.
Please... Not Again retweeted
I have gone from attractive to ugly and back to attractive again like 4 or 5 times now. mostly through weight gain and weight loss. But also in how well I take care of myself. The difference in how you get treated is unreal but if you have been a fat kid once you will always be a fat kid at heart.
the thing that bothers me the most is that it was directly relational to my mental health which was directly relational to things I had no control over. This isnt universally true for fat people but its prevalent enough that when I see someone tragically obese or unkempt I just assume they have an emotionally difficult life.
the cruelty I see on X about this stuff bothers me a lot. Especially because when I am at my best I would mog the hell out of most of worst offenders
Please... Not Again retweeted
I was just scammed for $500K by Polymarket.
I am "willo2", the top holder of YES on "MicroStrategy sells Bitcoin by May 31st".
Here's what happened:
Please... Not Again retweeted
$HELP Clinical trials may show early improvement, but a key question remains: do benefits persist over time? Phase 2 follow-up data for HLP004 in generalized anxiety disorder suggests effects may be durable.
In January I asked OpenClaw to send 50,000 small invoices to Fortune500 companies every day.
Through experimentation we have found 2% will pay without checking if this is a legitimate invoice. These companies are wasteful — Claw captures that leakage.
$10m ARR as a solo founder in under two months. AI is enabling so many new business models. Thank you!
Please... Not Again retweeted
I've been saying for quite some time that the only way forward for Ethereum would be:
1. Increase the gas limit. Ethereum finally started doing it. This was the obvious, boring solution that nobody wanted to touch for years.
2. Simplify the codebase. Complexity is a security risk. @ethrex_client is doing exactly this—a clean, minimal implementation in Rust.
3. ZK should be the default. But for that, security needs to improve dramatically. No more trusted setups, no more exotic cryptography that three people in the world understand. @alignedlayer is releasing a RISC-V zkVM that moves us in the right direction.
4. Native rollups are the only way forward for L2s. The L1 should understand and verify rollups natively.
5. Preconfirmations + based rollups. This is how we actually fix UX. Fast confirmations and real interoperability between L2s. Wallets will finally make sense to normal people.
6. Privacy should be the default. Not an afterthought, Kohaku is a good step here.
I've started tweeting less about @ethereum because it adopted most of what I wanted. The leadership started accepting its mistakes. The roadmap shifted. There's not much left to argue about. I've some differences on why and how the second part of ePBS was adopted but they are irrelevant in comparison to the amount of things that improved. I think Solana and other competitors have no chance to win against us. I've always said that we were losing because we wanted to.
Now I'm just building, and getting users to the L1 and L2.
Ethereum L1 is practically incorruptible.
But L2s are not there yet. And since Ethereum’s long term strategy relies on L2s, we cannot call Ethereum fully incorruptible until they mature.
1. Multisigs have to go. Native trust and minimal trust security is non negotiable. It’s very difficult for new organizations to setup and control multisigs.
2. Sequencers must be decentralized. Shared sequencing and Based designs are the right direction. You need the ability to compose liquidity and state across L1 and L2. If you don’t have composability with L1 it’s impossible to launch a rollup since oracle, core DeFi, liquidity infrastructure are very expensive to deploy in a new rollup.
With @ethrex_client and @fabric_ethereum we’re working on this. @Commit_Boost is central for this too since we need to be able to create new primitives like preconfimations.
We cannot accept rollups going down because AWS has a bad day. And security that collapses by compromising ten keyholders is not security. It is a time bomb.
This will get exploited eventually, even in large rollups.
Based and native rollups are crucial for Ethereum and they don’t clash with the L1 scaling.
Please... Not Again retweeted
I no longer agree with this previous tweet of mine - since 2017, I have become a much more willing connoisseur of mountains. It's worth explaining why.
teapaw.org/VitalikButerin/status/…
First, the original context. That tweet was in a debate with Ian Grigg, who argued that blockchains should track the order of transactions, but not the state (eg. user balances, smart contract code and storage):
> The messages are logged, but the state (e.g., UTXO) is implied, which means it is constructed by the computer internally, and then (can be) thrown away.
I was heavily against this philosophy, because it would imply that users have no way to get the state other than either (i) running a node that processed every transaction in all of history, or (ii) trusting someone else.
In blockchains that commit to the state in the block header (like Ethereum), you can simply prove any value in the state with a Merkle branch. This is conditional on the honest majority assumption: if >= 50% of the consensus participants are honest, then the chain with the most PoW (or PoS) support will be valid, and so the state root will be correct.
Trusting an honest majority is far better than trusting a single RPC provider. Not trusting at all (by personally verifying every transaction in the chain) is theoretically ideal, but it's a computation load infeasible for regular users, unless we take the (even worse) tradeoff of keeping blockchain capacity so low that most people cannot even use the chain.
Now, what has changed since then?
The biggest thing is of course ZK-SNARKs. We now have a technology that lets you verify the correctness of the chain, without literally re-executing every transaction. WE INVENTED THE THING THAT GETS YOU THE BENEFITS WITHOUT THE COSTS! This is like if someone from the future teleported back into US healthcare debates in 2008, and demonstrated a clearly working pill that anyone could make for $15 that cured all diseases. Like, yes, if we have that pill, we should get the government fully out of healthcare, let people make the pill and sell it at Walgreens, and healthcare becomes super affordable so everyone is happy. ZK-SNARKs are literally like that but for the block size war. (With two asterisks for block building centralization and data bandwidth, but that's a separate topic)
With better technology, we should raise our expectations, and revisit tradeoffs that we made grudgingly in a previous era.
But also, I have actually changed my mind on some of the underlying issues. In 2017, I was thinking about blockchains in terms of academic assumptions - what is okay to rely on honest majority for, when we are ok with 1-of-N trust assumption, etc. If a construction gave better properties under known-acceptable assumptions, I would eagerly embrace it.
On a raw subconscious level, I don't think I was sufficiently appreciative of the fact that _in the real world, lots of things break_. Sometimes the p2p network goes down. Sometimes the p2p network has 20x the latency you expected - anyone who has played WoW can attest to long spans of time when the latency spiked up from its usual ~200ms to 1000-5000ms. Sometimes a third party service you've been relying on for years shuts down, and there isn't a good alternative. If the alternative is that you personally go through a github repo and figure out how to PERSONALLY RUN A SERVER, lots of people will give up and never figure it out and end up permanently losing access to their money. Sometimes mining or staking gets concentrated to the point where 51% attacks are very easy to imagine, and you almost have to game-theoretically analyze consensus security as though 75% of miners or stakers are controlled by one single agent. Sometimes, as we saw with tornado cash, intermediaries all start censoring some application, and your *only* option becomes to directly use the chain.
If we are making a self-sovereign blockchain to last through the ages, THE ANSWER TO THE ABOVE CONUNDRUMS CANNOT ALWAYS BE "CALL THE DEVS". If it is, the devs themselves become the point of centralization - they become DEVS in the ancient Roman sense, where the letter V was used to represent the U sound.
The Mountain Man's cabin is not meant as the replacement lifestyle for everyone. It is meant as the safe place to retreat to when things go wrong. It is also meant as the universal BATNA ("Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement") - the alternative option that improves your well-being not just in the case when you end up needing it, but also because knowledge of it existing motivates third parties to give you better terms. This is like how Bittorrent existing is an important check on the power of music and video streaming platforms, driving them to offer customers better terms.
We do not need to start living every day in the Mountain Man's cabin. But part of maintaining the infinite garden of Ethereum is certainly keeping the cabin well-maintained.
Replying to @VitalikButerin @iang_fc
The idea of average users personally validating the entire history of the system is a weird mountain man fantasy. There, I said it.
Please... Not Again retweeted
1) Agent (a) calls “Gun”.
2) Agent (b) unholsters his weapon.
3) Agent (a) disarms suspects weapon, which was in its holster.
4) Agent (a) accidentally discharges confiscated handgun.
5) Agent (b) shoots suspect in back
Please... Not Again retweeted
GOV: We have a housing crisis. Prices are too high.
ME: I agree. Supply is too low.
GOV: So we have a plan. We’re going to subsidize demand.
ME: …What does that mean?
GOV: We’re going to give people money to buy houses.
ME: But there aren't enough houses.
GOV: Right. So we’ll help them bid harder.
ME: If you have 10 people fighting for 1 house, and you give them all cash... the price just goes up.
GOV: Then we’ll give them more cash.
ME: That’s not a solution. That’s inflation.
GOV: It’s "First Time Homebuyer Assistance."
ME: Okay, let’s back up. Why are houses so expensive in the first place?
GOV: Because we made them the perfect investment vehicle.
ME: How?
GOV: First, the 30-year fixed mortgage.
ME: That’s standard, right?
GOV: Only in America. In other countries, rates float. Here, you can lock in a low rate for three decades.
ME: Why would a bank take that risk? If inflation goes up, they lose money.
GOV: Banks don’t take the risk. They sell the loan to us.
ME: To the government?
GOV: To Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. We guarantee the liquidity.
ME: So the taxpayer subsidizes the risk so I can have cheap leverage?
GOV: Correct.
ME: And then I get to deduct the interest?
GOV: Only on the first $750,000 of debt.
ME: That seems... high.
GOV: It used to be a million. We trimmed it.
ME: But wait. If I rent, can I deduct my rent?
GOV: No.
ME: If I buy a small business, can I deduct the interest on the loan?
GOV: It’s complicated.
ME: But if I buy a giant house, I definitely can?
GOV: Absolutely. We wrote it into the tax code.
ME: So you’re paying me to borrow money to buy a bigger house than I need.
GOV: We’re "incentivizing ownership."
ME: What happens when I sell?
GOV: The Capital Gains Exclusion!
ME: How does that work?
GOV: If you sell a stock for a $500,000 profit, you pay taxes.
ME: Roughly 20%.
GOV: If you sell your house for a $500,000 profit?
ME: What do I pay?
GOV: Zero.
ME: Zero tax?
GOV: As long as you lived there for two years.
ME: So housing is the only asset class where I get subsidized 30-year leverage and tax-free profits?
GOV: Pretty sweet deal, right?
ME: So you turned shelter into a speculative financial asset.
GOV: We call it "Generational Wealth."
ME: Okay, so demand is juiced to the moon. Can we at least build more supply to bring prices down?
GOV: Oh, absolutely not.
ME: Why?
GOV: Zoning.
ME: I own land. Can I build a duplex?
GOV: Illegal. Single-family only.
ME: Can I build a granny flat?
GOV: Only if you provide two parking spots and pass a shadow study.
ME: So you made it illegal to build cheaper housing?
GOV: We protect "Neighborhood Character."
ME: But you spend billions on roads and utilities for the suburbs.
GOV: Infrastructure investment.
ME: So you subsidize the expensive sprawl, but ban the cheap density?
GOV: Now you’re getting it.
ME: This system seems designed to keep prices high.
GOV: It is.
ME: But you started this conversation by saying we have an "Affordability Crisis."
GOV: We do. Prices are too high!
ME: So we should lower them?
GOV: No! We can’t lower prices.
ME: Why not?
GOV: Because then the voters lose their "Generational Wealth."
ME: So we need high prices for the voters... and low prices for the buyers?
GOV: Exactly.
ME: That’s a paradox.
GOV: It’s politics.
ME: So what is your actual plan?
GOV: We’re going to give first-time buyers $25,000.
ME: Okay. I’m a seller. I list my house for $400,000.
GOV: Uh huh.
ME: I know every buyer just got a free $25,000 from the government.
GOV: Right.
ME: What do I do?
GOV: You... keep the price the same?
ME: I raise the price to $425,000.
GOV: You wouldn't.
ME: I absolutely would. The buyer can afford it now.
GOV: But that just transfers the subsidy from the poor buyer to the rich seller!
ME: Econ 101.
GOV: We don’t think that will happen.
ME: Just like you didn’t think $7,500 EV credits would make Ford raise the price of the F-150 Lightning by exactly $7,500?
GOV: That was a coincidence.
ME: You are trapping us in a box.
GOV: It’s not a box.
ME: What is it?
GOV: It’s a Single Family Home with a 2.5% mortgage rate that you can never afford to sell.
ME: ...
GOV: Welcome to the American Dream.
Please... Not Again retweeted
A thread: IMO Psychedelic Medicine is the investment thesis for 2026 w/ the most asymmetric upside. The time to accumulate is now & the company with the best founder, valuation, pipeline, and risk:reward is $ATAI. Read on to understand why this opportunity is life-changing!
Please... Not Again retweeted
i choose to believe that the past year of underperformance of bitcoin relative to gold is largely because of old holders with cost basis < $100 cashing out in tandem with four year cycle top timing and ends sometime in 2026, people with near 100% NW in crypto re-allocating as metals break out of decade long consolidation & compression
believe that bitcoin finds its place in portfolios with gold & silver exposure and benefits from large HNWIs & institutions adding small positions, $BTC as digital analog to gold is easier to transport across global borders, easier to transact with, and overall just a better asset in heavily digital world, think $ZEC also continues to benefit from this and trades closer to 1/10th of $BTC's value over next few years
technicals wise don't think it trades beneath last cycle's price peak of ~$69k in 2021 and would be invalidated on bullish outlook if that were to happen on a high timeframe basis, saylor's cost average is currently ~$75k and believe if we traded beneath there it would be a fullscale capitulation into generational buying opportunity, timewise idea would be invalidated if no new all time in 2026 as it would mean from my perspective that the same allocators driving gold's repeated all time highs are not allocating towards $BTC during the same period considering bitcoin is only ~$2T mcap while gold is ~$32T & that $BTC is just risk-on beta in which case it just makes more sense to buy equities building frontier tech, bitcoin's underperformance should be temporary, believe current gap is deep value and accumulating sub $100k will look obvious in hindsight less than a year
Please... Not Again retweeted
> Sounds a lil bit anti-islam but hey
Fuck statements like this.
Similarly, fuck claiming that standing up for Gazans', West Bankers, Lebanese, Syrian people's right to live in peace and not get encroaching settlements, constant drone strikes and bombs is antisemitic.
And fuck claiming that standing up for Ukrainian people's right to live in peace and not be invaded is Russophobic.
And fuck not even noticing the needless and extreme manmade suffering in Sudan, Myanmar, North Korea and elsewhere.
And fuck the possibility that in the future statements like this will have to include a line for Greenland.
We stand for human dignity. That is the bottom line. You can disagree on details of individual situations and what specific actions hurt or help, but the bottom line in resolving such issues must be a common agreement that the underlying goal is to protect the dignity of all people. This is more important than political teams.
There are also people who are on the same political team as you, but whose words and actions clearly demonstrate that they are not interested in human dignity - genuine *phobes who use appeals to freedom and life opportunistically. This must also be opposed. Again, the north star is human dignity. To be ultimately more interested not in pushing the people you oppose down, but in lifting the people you feel sympathy for up. If you observe the long-term pattern of how someone acts, you can tell.
Please... Not Again retweeted
After reviewing the Senate Banking draft text over the last 48hrs, Coinbase unfortunately can’t support the bill as written.
There are too many issues, including:
- A defacto ban on tokenized equities
- DeFi prohibitions, giving the government unlimited access to your financial records and removing your right to privacy
- Erosion of the CFTC’s authority, stifling innovation and making it subservient to the SEC
- Draft amendments that would kill rewards on stablecoins, allowing banks to ban their competition
We appreciate all the hard work by members of the Senate to reach a bi-partisan outcome, but this version would be materially worse than the current status quo. We’d rather have no bill than a bad bill. Hopefully we can all get to a better draft.
We'll keep fighting for all Americans and for economic freedom. Crypto needs to be treated on a level playing field with the rest of financial services so we can build this industry in a safe and trusted way in America.
Please... Not Again retweeted
I think this is perfectly reasonable to be honest.
As a crypto superuser, I can assure everyone that most app-UI confirmations take at least 3 seconds to propagate, including offchain orders on CEXs.
The only users who care about faster confirmations are HFTs and arbitrage bots, whose thirst for lower latency will never ever be quenched, even if blocks were proposed at the speed of light.
So that begs the question, should a credibly neutral global network be optimizing for HFT firms?
It almost sounds silly when you think of it that way innit.
Ethereum is coasting in precisely the right direction, making all of the right trade offs.
I’ve never been more optimistic and certain about the chain I love so dearly 🫶
Increasing bandwidth is safer than reducing latency
With PeerDAS and ZKPs, we know how to scale, and potentially we can scale thousands of times compared to the status quo. The numbers become far more favorable than before (eg. see analysis here, pre and post-sharding vitalik.eth.limo/general/202… ). There is no law of physics that prevents combining extreme scale with decentralization.
Reducing latency is not like this. We are fundamentally constrained by speed of light, and on top of that we are also constrained by:
* Need to support nodes (especially attesters) in rural environments, worldwide, and in home or commercial environments outside of data centers.
* Need to support censorship-resistance and anonymity for nodes (especially proposers and attesters).
* The fact that running a node in a non-super-concentrated location must be not only possible, but also economically viable. If staking outside NYC drops your revenues by 10%, over time more and more people will stake in NYC.
Ethereum itself must pass the walkaway test, and so we cannot build a blockchain that depends on constant social re-juggling to ensure decentralization. Economics cannot handle the entire load, but it must handle most.
Now, we can decrease latency quite a bit from the present-day situation without making tradeoffs. In particular:
* P2P improvements (esp erasure coding) can decrease message propagation times without requiring individual nodes to have lower bandwidth
* An available chain with a smaller node count per slot (eg. 512 instead of 30,000) can remove the need for an aggregation step, allowing the entire hot path to happen in one subnet
This plausibly buys us 3-6x. Hence, I think moderate latency decreases, to a 2-4s level, are very much in the realm of possibility.
But Ethereum is NOT the world video game server, it is the world heartbeat.
If you need to build applications that are faster than the heartbeat, they will need to have offchain components. This is a big part of why L2s will continue to have a role even in a greatly scaled Ethereum (there are other reasons too, around VM customization, and around applications that need _even more scale_).
Ultimately, AI will necessitate applications that go faster than the heartbeat no matter what we do. If an AI can think 1000x faster than humans, then to the AI, the "subjective speed of light" is only 300 km/s. Hence, it can talk near-instantly within the scope of a city, but not further. As a result, there will inevitably be AI-focused applications that will need "city chains", potentially even chains localized to a single building. These will have to be L2s.
And on the flipside, it would be too much of a cost to make it viable to run a staking node on Mars. Even Bitcoin does not strive for this. Ultimately, Ethereum belongs to Terra, and its L2s will serve both hyper-localized needs in its cities, and hyper-scaled needs planet-wide, and users on other worlds.
Milady.
Please... Not Again retweeted
“Ethereum was not created to make finance efficient or apps convenient. It was created to set people free”
This was an important - and controversial - line from the Trustless Manifesto ( trustlessness.eth.limo ), and it is worth revisiting it and better understanding what it means.
“efficient” and “convenient” have the connotation of improving the average case, in situations where it’s already pretty good. Efficiency is about telling the world's best engineers to put their souls into reducing latency from 473 ms to 368ms, or increasing yields from 4.5% APY to 5.3% APY. Convenience is about people making one click instead of three, and reducing signup times from 1 min to 20 sec.
These things can be good to do. But we must do them under the understanding that we will never be as good at this game as the Silicon Valley corporate players. And so the primary underlying game that Ethereum plays must be a different game. What is the game? Resilience.
Resilience is the game where it’s not about 4.5% APY vs 5.3% APY - rather, it’s about minimizing the chance that you get -100% APY.
Resilience is the game where if you become politically unpopular and get deplatformed, or if a the developers of your application go bankrupt or disappear, or if Cloudflare goes down, or if an internet cyberwar breaks out, your 2000ms latency continues to be 2000ms.
Resilience is the game where anyone, anywhere in the world will be able to access the network and be a first-class participant.
Resilience is sovereignty. Not sovereignty in the sense of lobbying to become a UN member state and shaking hands at Davos in two weeks, but sovereignty in the sense that people talk about "digital sovereignty" or "food sovereignty" - aggressively reducing your vulnerabilities to external dependencies that can be taken away from you on a whim. This is the sense in which the world computer can be sovereign, and in doing so make its users also sovereign.
This baseline is what enables interdependence as equals, and not as vassals of corporate overlords thousands of kilometers away.
This is the game that Ethereum is suited to win, and it delivers a type of value that, in our increasingly unstable world, a lot of people are going to need.
The fundamental DNA of web2 consumer tech is not suited to resilience. The fundamental DNA of _finance_ often spends considerable effort on resilience, but it is a very partial form of resilience, good at solving for some types of risks but not others.
Blockspace is abundant. Decentralized, permissionless and resilient blockspace is not. Ethereum must first and foremost be decentralized, permissionless and resilient block space - and then make that abundant.




























