Semlang Udon (@SemlangU) profile picture
Joined June 2020
Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)Photo by Semlang Udon (@SemlangU)
Semlang Udon retweeted
Have you ever heard the claim that the Qur'an has 250,000 manuscripts, versus only 5,800 for the Greek New Testament?
21
55
6
422
35,618
Semlang Udon retweeted
A new prayer from a pre-Islamic Paleo-Arabic inscription "I am Ṯabit son of {al-Ḥasan}; to Banī al-H̲azraj, may you be at peace; so let me enjoin piety upon you towards Allāh and to feed the guest and to fight the enemy and to show determination and bravery; may your Lord give you life for Allāh is the best at that"
5
8
53
4,021
Semlang Udon retweeted
UPCOMING AMA! In a few days, on May 13th, the linguist Dr. Marijn van Putten @PhDniX will answer ANY question from the community on r/AcademicQuran. Get your questions ready — questions will be submitted the day before, on May 12th.
5
12
1,310
Semlang Udon retweeted
Hello everyone! r/AcademicQuran is happy to announce a NEW AMA ("Ask Me Anything") event coming on March 14th, with none other than Daniel Beck ( @DanielABeck9 ) himself. Start preparing your questions for him!
2
5
1
18
1,912
Semlang Udon retweeted
DEBUNKING "GABRIEL REYNOLDS PSEUDO SCHOLARSHIP EXPOSED PART 7" by Muslim apologist @Deenresponds According to a recent thread by Deenresponds ( teapaw.org/Deenresponds/status/19… ), Deen argues that Gabriel Said Reynolds does not understand what a "kitāb" is in the Quran, especially in the context of the revelation of the injīl (Gospel) to Jesus. Deen assures us that Reynolds believes, in the Quranic view, that God sent Jesus a physical written book called the "Gospel". In reality, the kitāb Jesus receives is not a physical book, but a form of celestial divine revelation. Deen doesn't explain why this mistake is tantamount to "pseudo-scholarship" but let's set this major glib aside for a moment. So, where does Reynolds make this mistake? Apparently, in this tweet: teapaw.org/GabrielSaidR/status/18… The attentive reader will have already noticed that Deen doesnt actually link to Reynolds' tweet. He screenshots it, preventing you from clicking on the screenshots Reynolds included. More on this in a moment. Deen's proof that Reynolds has made this mistake is that he translates "kitāb" into "book". Unfortunately, Deen is either being deceptive or he's incompetent. Reynolds is re-using the word "book" from the way it appears in his screenshots. I KID YOU NOT, Reynolds highlighted/marked the following passage in one of the screenshots he included in his tweet, which you literally cannot see because Deen screenshotted Reynolds' tweet instead of linking it: "The angel Gabriel presented to him as it were a shining mirror, A BOOK, WHICH DESCENDED INTO THE HEART OF JESUS, in which he had knowledge of what God hath done and what God hath said, and what God willeth" There is literally no way to argue yourself out of this. The word "book", in the SPECIFIC part of Reynolds' screenshot that he HIGHLIGHTED, is being used in the sense of a celestial divine revelation. I pointed this out to Deen teapaw.org/chonkshonk1/status/193… and he just ignored it. Not only that, but if Deen wanted to know what Reynolds actually thinks the word kitāb means, formally, why not ever mention what his peer-reviewed scholarship says about the subject instead of a brief tweet where Reynolds has to simplify and summarize? Another fact I pointed out to Deen, which he completely ignored, is that Reynolds repeatedly translates kitāb as "revelation" in his work, such as in his paper "On the Qurʾanic Accusation of Scriptural Falsification (taḥrīf) and Christian Anti-Jewish Polemic". In this one paper, he translates it as "revelation" (not even "book") three times. And if there is ANY REMAINING DOUBT that Reynolds knows what this word means, here is something he wrote in a book he published SEVEN YEARS AGO, in his commentary on Quran 2:53, in The Quran and the Bible: Text and Commentry, page 44: > 2:53 “The Book” is a translation of al-kitāb. This term indeed means “book” in modern standard Arabic, but in its Qurʾānic context it means “divine revelation” (“written” in heaven but not necessarily a book on earth). I found this reference in under five seconds by just word-searching "kitab" in the PDF of the book. If Deen is interested in fair criticism, he'll delete his thread after seeing this.
GABRIEL REYNOLDS PSEUDO SCHOLARSHIP (Part 7) 🧵 “The Injil was sent Down as a Book” @GabrielSaidR
4
7
27
4,876
Hey all! I've started a Substack. My first year will be doing a in-depth study of the Gospel of Mark. I'd be honored if you read it and gave me some feedback, or even sign up, or perhaps let others know about it? Thanks for any support! churchcoffeeccc.substack.com…
1
1
4
1,244
Academic Islamic studies professors believe that the Quran was written by a committee of scholars in the deserts of Arabia fluent in several languages, including Greek & various Aramaic dialects, with access to the Talmud & the collected works of the early Church fathers.
2
8
31
5,671
We don't.
Academic Islamic studies professors believe that the Quran was written by a committee of scholars in the deserts of Arabia fluent in several languages, including Greek & various Aramaic dialects, with access to the Talmud & the collected works of the early Church fathers.
16
23
3
302
78,579
Semlang Udon retweeted
HELLO everyone! r/AcademicQuran is happy to announce that we are having an AMA ("Ask Me Anything") event with Dr. Hythem Sidky on May 18! Start thinking about the questions you want to ask him! Please find more information here: reddit.com/r/AcademicQuran/c…
3
12
31
8,916
Semlang Udon retweeted
Reminder that when apologists demand you have live debates with them, this is the attitude they have towards it (same guy declined my suggested written conversation on r/AcademicBiblical or r/AcademicQuran)
3
3
22
4,956
Semlang Udon retweeted
Nicolai Sinai on translating mushrikūn as "associator" (not "idolater" or "polytheist)
2
3
1
18
3,005
Semlang Udon retweeted
Rabbinic texts portraying Pharaoh as believing in his own divinity
4
9
5
29
23,681
Semlang Udon retweeted
It's funny how in Semitic studies the a-insertion for segolate nouns, e.g. Hebrew mɛlɛḵ pl. məlåḵim < *malk pl. *malakīm is considers "one of the major distinguishing isoglosses of Northwest Semitic", while it's literally the regular rule for Arabic (which isn't NWS) as well.
1
14
2
52
10,005
A discussion came up on the origin of the word قران qurʾān. It is popularly viewed as a Syriac loanword. This is not particularly convincing. Let me elaborate on how to evaluate loanwords, and why we should probably see qurʾān as a native formation. teapaw.org/DanielABeck9/status/10…
Can you walk through how that derivation would work? I’m interested in what context would produce it. Deriving qrn from the term for a book of liturgical readings of scripture does not make much sense to me. The usage seems to be invocational.
2
65
12
140
One of the interesting things that the Karaites used to do in their Hebrew Bibles (besides writing it in Arabic script with Hebrew vocalisation) is to avoid writing God's holy name by writing it as aḷḷāh! Number 14:41 ويومر موشا لاما زا اتام عوريم اث في الله وهي لا تصلاح
7
45
280
26,240
A great irony of the whole "Muhammad is in the song of songs!" debacle, is that in basically all early sources that write vowels (Greek, Coptic, Sassanian, Syriac) but also in many modern languages (e.g. Turkish) his name appears to have been commonly been pronounced Maḥma/id.
8
14
2
150
27,272
Semlang Udon retweeted
Apologists are saying ridiculous things about Biblical Hebrew time again! This time: The Song of Songs mentions Muhammad and calls him an Arab. As usual, it's a bunch of handwaving comparing vague lookalikes by people who don't know any Hebrew. teapaw.org/AbuKittenTweets/status…
25
41
10
216
80,705