So just to circle back to the whole @BulwarkOnline vs @thedispatch intraspatting this week. This is exactly where I can reliably expect The Dispatch writers to tackle how Mamdani has the economic comprehension of a 5 year old whereas from The Bulwark I can anticipate crickets.
It feels demeaning to even have to explain this, but:
Amazon is *valued by investors* at about $2.8 trillion, which means they’re willing to buy, say, a 1% ownership share for $28 billion. It does not mean they have a $2.8 trillion pile of gold coins. It’s based on the value of expected future profits. It’s a prediction, not a tangible thing.
Amazon’s *profit margins* are extremely low. The consumer marketplace (how most people interact with amazon) has margins around 4%. (Amazon Web Services has a much higher margin, but almost all their customers are other giant corporations that Mamdani also hates). Furthermore, much of that marketplace revenue is advertising. Stripping this out, direct, conventional margins on Amazon sold products are essentially zero. Think about what that means: Amazon found a way to run a business delivering goods to consumer’s doors at cost. They’ve already achieved the communist dream for regular consumers: giving you what you want, overnight, at cost. And they make a profit at the same time!
How can they be worth so much on margins that thin? Scale! They serve hundreds of millions of consumers, so making even small amounts per consumer translates into a giant total figure.
But that also means that any reduction in their tiny margins tanks the entire business overnight. If government regulation turns the tiny fraction of profit they skim off their huge gross revenue from positive to negative (which, again, would require only a couple-percent tax) then suddenly that entire fraction of their business becomes worthless overnight. Investors leave, amazon shrinks to being just a cloud services provider, and Americans can no longer get overnight delivery of literally anything on Earth - AT COST - overnight. The reason for the investor valuations -expected future profits - collapses, and their is no dragon hoard of gold coins to loot anymore. Poof. You won’t have redistributed trillions. You’ll have deleted it from existence.
It’s not that Mamdani doesn’t understand this, or that he does. He doesn’t have a worldview at all. He is a rhetoric machine designed to optimize his personal power. He doesn’t know or care about the concepts of “outcomes” or “consequences”. The final form of a politician in a mass democracy.
30
Sarah retweeted
It feels demeaning to even have to explain this, but:
Amazon is *valued by investors* at about $2.8 trillion, which means they’re willing to buy, say, a 1% ownership share for $28 billion. It does not mean they have a $2.8 trillion pile of gold coins. It’s based on the value of expected future profits. It’s a prediction, not a tangible thing.
Amazon’s *profit margins* are extremely low. The consumer marketplace (how most people interact with amazon) has margins around 4%. (Amazon Web Services has a much higher margin, but almost all their customers are other giant corporations that Mamdani also hates). Furthermore, much of that marketplace revenue is advertising. Stripping this out, direct, conventional margins on Amazon sold products are essentially zero. Think about what that means: Amazon found a way to run a business delivering goods to consumer’s doors at cost. They’ve already achieved the communist dream for regular consumers: giving you what you want, overnight, at cost. And they make a profit at the same time!
How can they be worth so much on margins that thin? Scale! They serve hundreds of millions of consumers, so making even small amounts per consumer translates into a giant total figure.
But that also means that any reduction in their tiny margins tanks the entire business overnight. If government regulation turns the tiny fraction of profit they skim off their huge gross revenue from positive to negative (which, again, would require only a couple-percent tax) then suddenly that entire fraction of their business becomes worthless overnight. Investors leave, amazon shrinks to being just a cloud services provider, and Americans can no longer get overnight delivery of literally anything on Earth - AT COST - overnight. The reason for the investor valuations -expected future profits - collapses, and their is no dragon hoard of gold coins to loot anymore. Poof. You won’t have redistributed trillions. You’ll have deleted it from existence.
It’s not that Mamdani doesn’t understand this, or that he does. He doesn’t have a worldview at all. He is a rhetoric machine designed to optimize his personal power. He doesn’t know or care about the concepts of “outcomes” or “consequences”. The final form of a politician in a mass democracy.
Sarah retweeted
An underrated element of understanding Trump is that he just really likes and thus wants to be admired by dictatorial strongmen, which informs all his actions. Seems bad!
I am in charge of the bespoke cranberry sauce for Thanksgiving and this is regrettably true.
Friendly reminder that whatever bespoke cranberry sauce recipe you’re wanting to make for Thanksgiving will never be as good as the jelly blob that comes out of a can, so don’t even waste your time with that. Make a different side.
1
58
Sarah retweeted
Irving Kristol used to say there’s no such thing as non -capitalist economic theory. I’ve never been wholly convinced of that. But when I listen to this bilge it becomes hard to deny. Non capitalist economic theory is just politics, redistribution and/or theft by another name.
Sarah retweeted
Welp by selective demand….
thedispatch.com/newsletter/g…
Sarah retweeted
In the debate over principles in the "conservative" media world, it bears noting that conservative and libertarian legal world have repeatedly opposed things coming from the Trump administration that they believed were wrong. Often taking quite a lot of flack for it.
I'm aware of one amicus brief filed by a left of center org against Biden on student loan forgiveness. I'm grateful for that, but there were plenty of opportunities.
This!
Replying to @billybinion
There may be a lot of blame to go around, but Sean Duffy has been relentlessly arrogant as transportation secretary. He jumps at any opportunity to trash his predecessor. Yet he's presiding over an actual catastrophe with no answers. It's all so insulting.
Sarah retweeted
Maybe Sean Duffy should've spent less time filming a reality TV show and promoting airport pull-up bars, and more time actually fixing the FAA's infrastructure and backup systems.
But we live in an age where bureaucrats want to be celebrities, so.
A lot of the attacks on the Bulwark feel very emotionally fueled but this right here is spot on and pretty inarguable.
Never said she didn’t. I just don’t think she’s conservative anymore, if she ever was. That’s fine. Tim and Sarah were always political operatives. They switched sides because Trump is awful. That’s fine. But they want to have it both ways and pretend they’re not political operatives for the other team now. I don’t have a team that way. They do but won’t admit it or acknowledge the distinctions I think are vital.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
As a mom, somehow this hits harder than the many little poems etc the algorithm has served up to me. Absolutely beautiful and so so true. Those small, completely ordinary, moments that make you stop in your tracks breathless from gratitude.
This morning, there was no school for the big kids, and all my kids were up early. I poured a cup of coffee. We have a reno project going on so the house is discombobulated and everyone’s routine is a little off. I was talking with the big girls at the bottom of the stairs when the littles emerged from their room.
I looked up to see their little heads silhouetted at the top of the stairs by the hallway light. “Mom, can you check my lip?” Our 5-yr-old had busted it yesterday by running smack into a railing, being currently in the unfortunate stage of life and height where standard installment measurements of counters and such are hazardous to the face.
I walked up and sat at the top of the stairs with my coffee, still in sweatpants. The big girls joined on the steps in front of me. Her lip looked a little rough. I told her to chew on the opposite side of her mouth today to avoid chomping it. “If I chomp it, it will get bigger and grow way, way high to the sky??” “Yes, and it will hurt.”
She nodded and went back to pretending to be a cheetah, as is her wont. My little boy curled up on my lap. We had a discussion about ticks, as we had seen one on him yesterday (super late in the season!). “But Dad got it?” “Yep, we got it.” It wasn’t there long enough to be dangerous but we talked about the problems they can cause, including the meat allergy one. They were all four aghast. “A tick that makes you vegan?!” We joked about how Dad is probably immune to ticks at this point bc of all his time as a dog handler.
We chatted about the logistics of the big girls’ Invisaligns. I remarked, as I do at least once a week, how responsible they are about them and how much we appreciate it. Not one tray lost in this family in two years of treatment combined. I’m amazed. It couldn’t be me!
This conversation was punctuated by the littles exclaiming, “I’m so ‘cited for Halloween,” as they had found some recently stored-away Halloween decorations and aren’t clear on calendars yet.
We talked about trying to see a community theater production of Elf their friend is part of, and how both girls would like to do more plays if possible.
My oldest walked downstairs to let the dog in from his morning constitutional. My second walked downstairs, as she announced she wanted to make breakfast for her siblings. The littles roared theatrically and went to play Cheetah and Lion in their room.
I sat at the top of the stairs thinking of all the times I’ve seen all of their little silhouettes here, all the times I’ve carried them up, spotted them as they crawled, or seen them waiting for us at the bottom when we get up in the mornings.
It’s nothing at all. Just a cup of coffee, a conversation about braces and bugs and busted lips. But it is everything. A mundane miracle. Just thought I’d write it down to remember it.
1
170
Sarah retweeted
It’s not works-based (piling up good deeds to earn Heaven)
To love Christ is to become like Christ. When we are conformed to Him we make the choices He makes through His grace.
Sarah retweeted
Douthat being able to get those answers out of Trump is a testimony to why true intellectual diversity is needed in mainstream media. He was able to ask the religion question in a way that was sincere and open, while extremely cunning, only because he is a believer and conservative
This is a perilously wrong distortion of the faith. If you believe in Christ then you seek, however imperfectly, to follow His teachings. You ache in how you fall short, repent, and strive to do better - every day. Dismissing His teachings because you somehow believe His perfect sacrifice means you can live however you want so long as you claim Christ is so brazenly ungrateful and profoundly wrongheaded it’s extraordinary these people say it aloud.
What a ridiculous question. You don’t have to forgive your enemies to go to heaven. People who hate God and reject what Jesus did on the cross are going to hell. They will not be forgiven, because they rejected it. The only way to go to Heaven is to accept the free gift of salvation and be covered by the blood of Jesus. There is no “good” thing you can do.
“Enter by the narrow gate; for wide is the gate and broad is the way that leads to destruction, and there are many who go in by it.”
Matthew 7:13
“I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.”
John 14:6
“for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, whom God set forth as a propitiation by His blood, through faith, to demonstrate His righteousness, because in His forbearance God had passed over the sins that were previously committed, to demonstrate at the present time His righteousness, that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus.”
Romans 3:23-26
2
60
Sarah retweeted
Just saw someone claim that the requirement to forgive is "works righteousness".
There are a lot of people out there who somehow think Christianity is unrelated to Jesus except in as much as Jesus was necessary for the mechanism of the substitutionary atonement to work.
What a ridiculous question. You don’t have to forgive your enemies to go to heaven. People who hate God and reject what Jesus did on the cross are going to hell. They will not be forgiven, because they rejected it. The only way to go to Heaven is to accept the free gift of salvation and be covered by the blood of Jesus. There is no “good” thing you can do.
“Enter by the narrow gate; for wide is the gate and broad is the way that leads to destruction, and there are many who go in by it.”
Matthew 7:13
“I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.”
John 14:6
“for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, being justified freely by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, whom God set forth as a propitiation by His blood, through faith, to demonstrate His righteousness, because in His forbearance God had passed over the sins that were previously committed, to demonstrate at the present time His righteousness, that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus.”
Romans 3:23-26
Sarah retweeted
Watching so many of my fellow believers in Christ insist this man would somehow bring about a resurgence of biblical values has been one of the most bizarre and disturbing things I’ve ever witnessed


























