Errol Lord (@elord) header
Errol Lord (@elord) profile picture

Philosopher. Associate professor at @penn.

Princeton, NJ
Joined December 2008
Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)Photo by Errol Lord (@elord)
I want to send this final paragraph from @Tyler_A_Harper's essay on the humanities @TheAtlantic to every professor and administrator as we wind up the first semester. Exactly my experience as a student and now as a prof.
5
69
8
220
32,283
Okay, very unpopular opinion here, but while the university presidents in question handled this very poorly from a public relations perspective there is nothing fundamentally wrong with their answers and Stefanik should be much more ashamed of herself than any of them. First, while I'm sure it has occasionally happened because there are lots of university students in the US and some of them are bound to be lunatics, I haven't seen any evidence that many people on campuses were "calling for the genocide of Jews". When the president of MIT says the same thing at the beginning, Stefanik replies that people have been calling for "intifada", but I think it's totally disingenuous to claim that most of the students who shout slogans calling for a "global intifada" or whatever want to genocide the Jews, however stupid they may be and to be clear I don't have a particularly high opinion of their intelligence or knowledge about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Anyway, while this ubiquitous confusion between very different things annoys me, that's not what I want to talk about here, so let's assume for the sake of the argument that many people on American campuses have literally called for the genocide of Jews. Stefanik asked a precise question, namely whether this was a violation of their university's code of conduct regarding bullying and harassment, not whether they condemned calls for genocide of Jews or even whether they were a violation of their university's rules in general. And while I haven't reviewed the codes of conduct at Harvard, MIT and Penn, not only am I pretty confident that the presidents of the universities in question are correct given those codes, but I also think that it would not really make sense to change the codes of conduct so that calls for genocide per se are treated as bullying or harassment. It seems obviously right that, as they said in their reply to Stefanik, it depends on the context. For instance, if someone writes a blog post defending Hitler and the Holocaust, I obviously agree that it's vile but how on earth does that constitute bullying or harassment? Surely, as the university presidents correctly said in that hearing, bullying or harassment should be targeted at specific individuals. If the person who wrote such a blog post then proceeded to send it to Jewish students, then I agree that it would constitute bullying or harassment, but otherwise it seems clearly not to be the case and to say otherwise is to engage precisely in the kind of concept creeps that many right-wing people I see retweeting this video correctly denounced in previous years. If someone wrote a blog post arguing that French people should be killed as payback for colonization or whatever, I certainly wouldn't think that he thereby harassed or bullied me. I think that this is what the presidents of those universities should have explained, so again I agree they handled this very badly, but to be fair with them Stefanik also made it as hard as possible for them by demanding a "yes or no" answer, even though she surely knew or at least should have known that her question did not admit of a simple "yes or no" answer. It just seems wrong to attack the university presidents for not handling that situation well, because this is public relations and not a moral failing, whereas Stefanik is definitely morally culpable here for setting them up in this way and deliberately turning this hearing into a clown show. It's very clear that, despite what she pretends, she wanted them to embarrass themselves and maximized the probability they would by trying to leave them no choice between giving what they knew was a false answer and replying accurately but in a way that would make them look bad.
The presidents of @Harvard, @MIT, and @Penn were all asked the following question under oath at today’s congressional hearing on antisemitism: Does calling for the genocide of Jews violate [your university’s] code of conduct or rules regarding bullying or harassment? The answers they gave reflect the profound moral bankruptcy of Presidents Gay, Magill and Kornbluth. Representative @EliseStefanik was so shocked with the answers that she asked each of them the same question over and over again, and they gave the same answers over and over again. In short, they said: It ‘depends on the context’ and ‘whether the speech turns into conduct,’ that is, actually killing Jews. This could be the most extraordinary testimony ever elicited in the Congress, certainly on the topic of genocide, which to remind us all is: “the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group” The presidents’ answers reflect the profound educational, moral and ethical failures that pervade certain of our elite educational institutions due in large part to their failed leadership. Don’t take my word for it. You must watch the following three minutes. By the end, you will be where I am. They must all resign in disgrace. If a CEO of one of our companies gave a similar answer, he or she would be toast within the hour. Why has antisemitism exploded on campus and around the world? Because of leaders like Presidents Gay, Magill and Kornbluth who believe genocide depends on the context. To think that these are the leaders of Ivy League institutions that are charged with the responsibility to educate our best and brightest. On the bright side, our congressional leaders deserve accolades for showing tremendous leadership and moral clarity in their statements, by the questions they asked, and the respectfulness with which they conducted the hearing. It was a masterclass of how our government and democracy should operate. If you have time, please watch the entire hearing. Throughout the hearing, the three behaved like hostile witnesses, exhibiting a profound disdain for the Congress with their smiles and smirks, and their outright refusal to answer basic questions with a yes or no answer.
367
239
82
2,156
1,309,120
2010: Spain's Men's team won the World Cup with 7 Barcelona players in the starting eleven. 2023: Spain's Women's team won the World Cup with 7 Barcelona players in the starting eleven.
71
1,346
227
6,724
311,728
Earps pretty off her line to me… 🤔 #fifawwc
8
5
5
48
7,557
Errol Lord retweeted
Replying to @Allegiant
@Allegiant hitting a new low tonight. My 16 year old and his two teen cousins were flying to PA from Denver. Flight gets cancelled for "weather" even though all other flights were merely delayed. They provide no real help at all, only offer a refund or a rebook 3 days from now.
2
2
1
358
Hmmm. I just had a bizarre experience, involving a global news organisation and a trillion dollar corporation. (I got caught in the middle, so... owch.) It’s not the sort of experience the people involved usually talk about in public… so I think I’ll talk about it in public. 🧵
226
15,442
1,858
34,514
7,472,019
That is NOT a penalty and is literally in the IFAB directory of what ISN'T a penalty. It can only be a penalty if it's a deliberate act. This image is from the IFAB.
397
2,418
901
12,446
Errol Lord retweeted
lose focus in this tournament and you realize you're accidentally watching undisputed with skip and shannon
36
184
28
2,860
Harry Kane is willing to risk yellow cards when it really matters 👇
107
449
91
4,093
And the Academy Award for the best World Cup Roster Reveal goes to… 🎥 Incredible piece of work from Uruguay.🇺🇾🇺🇾🇺🇾
41
170
69
1,740
JESP is going to temporarily pause new submissions starting November 1 for up to six months, to allow us time to bring on new copyeditors and catch up from the copyediting and publication backlog that we have accumulated as the journal has grown. jesp.org/index.php/jesp/anno…
1
2
5
listen to her explain the Van Gogh soup protest. she’s got a point, no?
6,188
23,285
6,039
146,050
Errol Lord retweeted
There is no day worse than the second day of school.
1
1
2
Prof. Errol Lord of @UPennPhilosophy was named to the Marc Sanders Foundation’s (MSF) inaugural class of Media Fellows. The 2021-2022 fellows were selected by a committee consisting of academic philosophers and media industry professionals. https://teapaw.org/t.co/4iHC6y0gXl @Penn @elord
2
3
Errol Lord retweeted
Replying to @GuyLongworth
I find it odd that the distinction between studies about mask design effectiveness and studies about mask policy effectiveness is not emphasized. Obviously lots of good evidence that medical grade masks are well designed to deal with droplets/aerosols.
1
1
1
Sally Rooney books but they're Wayne Rooney tweets.
72
1,402
109
11,062
Everyone from Facebook coming to Twitter and getting their jokes a month earlier than usual
6
217
16
1,616
Errol Lord retweeted
Replying to @dan_star
Life is like a joke and the philosopher is that person who insists on trying to explain the thing.
1
2
Not even yellow for Casemiro.
Descubre las 7 diferencias…
5
32
251
The fact that Sidney Powell looks like every guilty person on all 12 seasons of Murder She Wrote should have been a red flag.
36
93
9
786