Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes) profile picture

Historian and former diplomat, foreign policy analyst, and think tank executive.

Stephens City, Virginia
Joined March 2010
Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)Photo by Kim R. Holmes (@kimsmithholmes)
There is wisdom in this. Once you realize that the state should not be considered as the end-all “good” in society, that in fact it has the potential of becoming a source unspeakable evil and tyranny, you come to realize that limiting the power of the state should be an objective— pause—of the “common good.” Let me be clear. That is necessary. But it’s not sufficient. Civil society must fill the moral gap left by the state.
Actually, that bad men can become President should make it all the more clear that all the conservative and libertarian legal projects are not just good but necessary. Why would you come away from the last 10 years and think what we need is less federalism, more deference to the executive?
3
193
So let me get this straight. Politically speaking, I mean. The voters favored the Democrats because they opposed US involvement in the Iran War, but anti-war Republicans, who agree with the Democrats on this point, think the way back for the GOP is to oppose the war? Which is a vindication of the Democrats? How does this work exactly? Politically? In partisan politics, I mean? Let me guess: A new majority populist consensus which the GOP will rule will somehow emerge? No way. That ship has sailed. From now on the “consensus” dissident Republicans say they favor will be the political equivalent, at least in terms of foreign policy and economics, of joining the Democrats as a minority partner. Are they going to out do the Democrats in opposing the Iran War? Are they going to outdo the Democrats in curtailing the supposed abuses of the “neoliberal” free market? Are they going to overturn the progressive welfare state idea by creating a New Deal for the right? The mistake the dissident right made is that it did not realize that the progressives and Democrats were the original populists. It was not a world of their making, and they did not realize it.
Truth. You might think the war was the right thing to do, but most voters disagree, and that's a big reason why we are going to have a Democratic Congress.
2
8
1,021
This is an interesting take. Democrats for a very long time wanted to increase the power of the federal government because they assumed they would mostly or eventually control it. Now they discover that is not necessarily true. What to make of this? Not sure the skepticism of state power will last. Old habits are hard to break.
Whether you are a Republican or a Democrat, we should all favor reducing the power and scope of executive orders. This country was not meant to be ruled by one president regardless of their party.
5
266
Ok but meanwhile he is Secretary of State. Which requires more than giving speeches. What is he doing about Iran, Russia, and China? He is our chief foreign policy officer and diplomat after all. But he clearly is not a key player on these issues.
Judeo-Christian values defined:
1
3
286
The lines have been drawn. At some point Trump will have to choose.
Weird that he doesn’t say he wants to win the war.
1
13
374
We should never ever forget that Iran, Russia, and China are big players on our social media. They figured out a long time ago that online Americans are manipulatable. Just a reminder. That list includes Putin’s Russia which is about as anti-American a regime as you can get.
Bear with me on this one, folks: Yesterday, a friend called and said he'd heard that the pilot for a corporate CEO was told there's going to be a 3+ day nationwide power outage this week and the pilot needed to load his plane with supplies for the CEO and family. Today, my sister called. Her daughter is a nurse at a major hospital and the daughter said the hospital employees are being told there's going to be a major power outage that is going to last 3+ days and everyone needs stock pile water, etc. This afternoon is an emergency broadcast test. I'm beginning to wonder if some group of people online are seeding this story to cause a panic when the EMS triggers this afternoon. It's just too odd for two separate groups of people to hear the same story in separate parts of the country and it's all a vague "powers that be said" sort of framing.
4
18
698
Yes, and the key to why it survives as an aspirational ideal is the unshakable belief that what has been tried was not actually the real thing. In other words, in practice every failure perversely is a proof of principle. In logic it’s called the fallacy of the self-sealing argument. It’s correctness is supposedly proven by its assumptions. What a deal. Since it cannot be proven wrong by its assumptions, it can always possibly be right in practice.
“It’s always worth noting how people who never lived under socialism adore it while everyone who lived under it hates it.” — Garry Kasparov
2
4
331
Kim R. Holmes retweeted
Russia’s Ukraine negotiation claims that where a Russian soldier steps, there lies Russia. Other countries can play that game and Poland is having wry fun with it.
🇵🇱🇷🇺🇩🇪🇮🇹🇫🇷🇬🇧🇺🇦🇷🇺 Podobno polska delegacja na rozmowy pokojowe z Rosją ma zażądać zwrotu Smoleńska, powołując się na pokój w Polanowie z 1634 r. Argumentacja prawna jest mocna. Pokój był wieczysty, a wieczność jeszcze nie upłynęła. Rosyjskie zastrzeżenia dotyczące późniejszych traktatów zostaną odrzucone jako wybiórcze podejście do historii. Skoro o granicach mają decydować dawne mapy, Polska również przyniesie swoją. Mamy ładną, z XVII w. Delegacja zapewni przy tym, że rozumie rosyjskie obawy o bezpieczeństwo. Dlatego po zwrocie Smoleńska Rosja otrzyma pisemne gwarancje, że Polska nie zamierza posuwać się dalej. Gwarancje będą dokładnie tyle warte, ile rosyjskie. Rosja otrzyma też zapewnienie, że przyłączenie Smoleńska nie jest wymierzone przeciwko niej. To wyłącznie odpowiedź na polskie obawy o bezpieczeństwo. Liczymy, że w Moskwie docenią znajome sformułowanie.
59
259
10
1,996
56,004
You are most welcome, Grant.
Replying to @kimsmithholmes
Thanks, Kim! It can't be reiterated enough - the word capitalism has no substantive meaning or explanatory value. It is simply a pejorative; nothing more.
1
301
Populist nationalism, especially any version grounded in a European model of the confessional state, could not be more different than the republic our founders established 250 years ago. It not only constitutionally limited government but intentionally avoided establishing an official church in order to protect the religious liberties of the people. Commerce (what we today call the economy) was largely assumed to be free (the word capitalism was not in vogue in those days) And the idea of the Nation as embodying a Volk awaited the French Revolution and its various aftermaths. In other words, it didn’t exist at that time in America. More importantly, it was resisted for the next 250 years precisely because it was antithetical to the principles of the American founding. This is what needs to be conserved, not the various imposters we see on the post-liberal nationalist right.
So many of the Christian Nationalists also call themselves “Heritage Americans.” It’s all very European — they want a state controlled church and an aristocracy of white people who resent their own decline at the hands of more capable people. DSA for the white right where all are equal, but some are more equal than others. Also, if you’ve paid attention, you’ll note how many at the top have inherited their wealth and come from upper middle class and wealthy backgrounds and are using their positions to protect themselves and manufacture grievances they promise to protect others from so long as they get to be in charge. They’re like Mamdani and Chevalier, but Zack instead of Zohran, and Dianne instead of Darializa.
5
16
1,007
Occupy Wall Street. Do we remember under which president this movement emerged?
Rep. Roy: "The Republican Party must be the party of people, small business, Main Street. We can't be the party of the corporate boardrooms and Wall Street."
2
1
16
1,430
To my conservative friends. When you use the word capitalism in a critical way, like adding an adjective “crony” to tap into economic populism, do you realize that you are using language developed by socialists? The term “capitalism” emerged in the 19th century from socialists Louis Blanc and Pierre Proudhon, and it was later taken up by Marx. Before that Adam Smith called it “commercial society” and “a system of natural liberty.” If you are so adamant on standing up to the left, why do you use their language, which frankly encompasses their worldview?
1
1
12
528
Kim R. Holmes retweeted
Thomas Piketty built a global reputation on a single, seductive claim: capital accumulates faster than the economy grows, causing wealth to concentrate permanently at the top, and only aggressive redistribution fixes this. His 2013 book "Capital in the Twenty-First Century" sold over three million copies. Politicians treated it like scripture. But the entire foundation is rotten. Piketty's central formula, r > g (the return on capital exceeds economic growth), relies on projecting historical capital returns forward indefinitely. This ignores capital consumption, entrepreneurial loss, and the constant destruction of old fortunes through bad investments, generational spending, and market competition. Andrew Carnegie's grandchildren did not control U.S. Steel. Vanderbilt money scattered within two generations. Markets punish miscalculation without mercy, so the aristocratic permanence Piketty fears keeps failing to materialize. Somehow, that isn't even the most intellectually dishonest part of the book. Piketty treats capital as a static pool sitting on top of society, extracting rent from you while doing nothing useful. Capital is deferred consumption channeled into productive tools, which is why real wages in market economies rise alongside capital accumulation, not despite it. Every factory, every server farm, every distribution network that employs you and cheapens the goods you buy exists because someone saved instead of spent. His proposed solution? A global wealth tax reaching up to 80 percent on high incomes, requiring an international enforcement apparatus with no exit option for capital. Yet another manufactured crisis, built on dishonest numbers, and the solution is always to give globalists more of your hard-earned money.
177
545
80
1,993
101,775
Does that “moral right” include defense and security against a Russia that targets US cities with nuclear armed ballistic missiles?
Rubio: “The ultimate question of our time is whether Americans have a moral right to exist as a distinct nation and a distinct people, and thus to demand a government that defends and pursues our interests above all else.”
2
8
631
Everyone is talking about Mercedes' announcement to stop all investments in Germany and close some factories. Why the surprise? Germany has done everything humanly possible to destroy its industry. Look at the list of mayor layoff announcements: - Volkswagen 100,000 - Thyssenkrupp Steel 11,000 - Bosch 13,000 - Schaeffler 8,160 - Porsche 9,000 - BMW 8,000 - DHL / Deutsche Post 8,000 - Audi 7,500 - ZF Friedrichshafen 7,600 - Commerzbank 6,900 - Siemens 5,600 - Daimler Truck 5,000 - Lufthansa 4,000 - SAP 3,500 - Evonik 3,200 - Vodafone 2,300 - MAN 2,300 - Zalando 2,700 - Voith 2,500 - O2 Telefónica 1,100 These are only the large companies, each job cut there costs up to five more at suppliers. Germany buys some time to mask the industrial collapse with more debt and higher government spending. A country of government workers and welfare recipients will not recover to its former strength though. Most Germans do not yet understand what is coming. Prosperity is not given forever, bad left-green choices and policies have consequences.
The comparison with Switzerland makes the demise of German industry even more remarkable, while also explaining one of the main reasons really well. Germany simply stopped becoming more productive while wages kept rising under powerful unions, making German products and services relatively more expensive and less competitive. Switzerland, despite even higher wages, has steadily raised its productivity, and its industry has flourished as a result. Germany suffers from grotesque overregulation, bureaucracy, a 1970s-style unions and works council model, all of which throttle productivity growth. The AI revolution will only widen this gap. While others rush to use AI to boost efficiency, in Germany measuring employee productivity is not even legal without works councils’ approval. Yep, you read that right. Prosperity is not guaranteed forever. Germany will one day be studied as the largest self-sabotage of a once-leading developed country. Buckle up, it won’t be pretty.
93
743
93
2,713
126,238
Try having a nation without an economy. What utter nonsense.
GOP Rep. Chip Roy: "No one stood on the wall of the Alamo shouting, 'I want 3.9% economic growth!' We are a nation, we are not an economy. None of the Founders were running around talking about earnings per share."
9
8
1
59
8,687
The dissident right that wants people to think it is conservative adopted the language and style of a leftist youth rebellion a long time ago. Talk of the establishment. Boomers. What time is it? Old ideas. Reagan zombies. It was talk taken out of the left’s dictionary of revolution, and yet somehow people bought it as conservative. They thought it was clever. And it did work for a while. But not anymore.
I’m old enough to remember when conservatives revered our elders rather than mocking them.
4
355
It comes down to what we mean by “tough.” Is it standing for principle or an aggressive assertion of ego? This is the difference between a gentleman and a brute, a distinction that used to be central to what defined civilization.
For almost my entire adult life I've heard elements of the GOP base blame failure on not being tough or aggressive enough. In the first two years of the second Trump term, they got all the aggression they could ever want, and the party got crushed at a level we haven't seen in more than 50 years. So what happens next? With Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan, they double down on aggression. Nothing about those picks suggests the slightest sense that the MAGA base understands or even cares about what actually happened.
2
10
1,413