Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu) header
Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu) profile picture

#Electronics & Telecom Engineer. Manager, #IT Department at AADM @AniruddhasADM & SAUF @CompassionACSR

Mumbai, India
Joined August 2009
Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)Photo by Shantanu Natu (@nshantanu)
5 REASONS WHY #RAMAYANA PART 1 #FAILED TO EXCITE INDIAN AND GLOBAL AUDIENCES Lessons for Part 2 — and for the makers of future Mahabharata adaptations Now that the box office free fall has started, one can safely say Ramayana Part 1 will never recover the claimed budget, given 50-55% of revenues get taken away by exhibitors. Here are the 5 reasons why it failed: 1. You cannot make the villain look like he belongs to a 2026 high-tech fantasy universe and the hero look like he belongs to the early days of filmmaking in 1926. Audiences have just watched The #Odyssey. There is a similar bow-lifting sequence in it, and it is an absolute edge-of-the-seat spectacle. In Ramayana, the equivalent moment looks almost sissy. If Ravana is being presented at the level of #Thanos, Rama needs to be presented at the level of Odysseus. You cannot have a technologically advanced villain and a visually outdated hero. 2. You cannot have the villain speaking in today’s language, with today’s pace and attitude, while the hero sounds as if he has stepped out of a century-old theatrical production. The contrast in dialogue, delivery and body language is jarring. What was #Rama doing walking around gardens with Sita and speaking like a pansy? The hero needs to command the same screen presence, linguistic confidence and contemporary cinematic energy as the villain. Grandeur cannot be reserved for the antagonist. 3. You have to practically rule out the older generation from your box-office calculations. You cannot make Ramayana and #Mahabharata primarily for an older generation that has already watched these epics on television. They remain deeply fascinated by those versions, and all the CGI in the world cannot necessarily change their expectations. The reception from this audience has therefore been understandably cold. 4. Rule Gen Alpha and GenZ out as well! Today’s youth have seen enough Spider-Man, Superman, Thor and The Lord of the Rings to be impressed with yet another fantasy spectacle— that too a mythological. They need compelling characters, not just larger-than-life imagery and familiar names. #Ravana was established as a powerful, fascinating character. Rama and Lakshmana, however, were not established with the same cinematic conviction. The audience needs to feel the hero’s power, charisma and extraordinary abilities rather than simply being told about them. 5. So such films will find a market only with those who aren’t elderly and aren’t young. But even the remaining ones aren’t insane. They aren’t excited about Part 2 at all and Part 2 could actually be an even bigger disaster if the makers repeat the same mistakes. The idea of establishing an army of monkeys led by Hanuman and expecting people to flock to cinemas is a risky proposition. A monkey-man can certainly work, but he needs to look more like a man and less like a monkey. Going by Hanuman’s entry at the end of Part 1, and what the makers did with #Jatayu, there is little indication that they are willing to take the necessary creative risks. Trying to convince today’s generation that a realistic-looking bird can speak is almost as difficult as expecting them to accept ten literal heads on Ravana. The larger lesson: You cannot simply take an epic that has been told for thousands of years, add expensive CGI, and expect a global cinematic phenomenon. You have to understand the cinematic language, visual expectations and imagination of today’s audience. Global audiences loved #RRR but stayed away from Ramayana because the story was put together mindlessly. The same lessons will apply even more to anyone attempting to make the Mahabharata. Its scale, characters and conflicts offer extraordinary cinematic possibilities. But reverence for the source material cannot become an excuse for unimaginative filmmaking. #DareToThinkBeyond with #ArindamChaudhuri Also read my previous article #RAVANAYAM ROCKS, RAMAYAN #FLOPS teapaw.org/drarindam_iipm/status/…
RAVANAYAM ROCKS, RAMAYAN FLOPS! By-#ArindamChaudhuri Just walked out after watching #NiteshTiwari’s Ramayan and #NamitMalhotra’s Ravanayam. While I do understand that the copybook approach to building a two-part epic often revolves around first building up an almost invincible villain, so that the eventual pleasure of defeating him is multiplied manifold, that’s how the Batmans and Supermans of the world are made. But in its attempt to follow that playbook, #Ramayan has ended up becoming a film of crazy contradictions! On the one hand, this is perhaps the most flawlessly visually impactful Indian film ever made. On the other, its makers seem to have been too scared to challenge the decades-old #RamanandSagar mould of how a Ramayana should look and feel. Every scene in which Ravana (#Yash) enters is a fascinating, electrifying, mind-numbing combination of #GameofThrones, #Avatar, the #Marvel universe, The #Odyssey and The #LordoftheRings. The scale, the visual imagination, the grandeur, the sheer cinematic spectacle — absolutely breathtaking! It is a great reminder to the world of just how richly imaginative our mythologies were. In fact, one is reminded that what the West celebrates through its Odysseys is only a small part of the much grander imaginative universe of our Ramayana. On the other hand, almost every scene in which Ram (#RanbirKapoor) enters looks straight out of Ramanand Sagar’s Ramayan. Complete with 1980s television sensibilities, ancient-looking aesthetics and a visual vocabulary that, at least for me, simply doesn’t work anymore. The makers seem to have been so afraid of breaking the mould of the previous #Ram that they have even made #ArunGovil, the iconic television Ram, play the father of the current Ram! Almost as if they needed the reassurance of the past to legitimise their present. And the contrast extends to the supporting cast. The entire supporting universe around Ravana, with #Shobhana, #RakulPreet, #VivekOberoi and #KajalAggarwal, absolutely rocks. They look like they belong to a grand cinematic universe. The supporting cast around Ram, meanwhile, seems to have been randomly picked from the production house’s office boys and a bunch of unknown faces from low-budget television serials. There is little visual distinction, charisma or cinematic presence. Every happy scene around Ram looks as if it has been shot in the 1970s Lodhi Gardens in Delhi. Those childish-looking flowers, those unimaginative greens, those artificial-looking happy settings! It is almost as if two different production houses, working in two completely different decades, have made the same film. The dialogues are another story altogether. Ravana’s dialogues are powerful, impactful and commanding. They have the weight and authority that the character demands. Ram’s dialogues, on the other hand, sound as if they have been lifted straight out of the 1950s Mughal-e-Azam and are delivered in much the same theatrical fashion. There is a certain datedness to the entire treatment. It is almost as if two cinematic worlds have been created within the same film, and they simply refuse to meet. They finally seem to come together only in the last scene, when, suddenly, one gets a glimpse of what the second part could potentially become. As of now, the first part belongs entirely to Yash. It works because of him, his extraordinary screen presence and the spectacular visual effects in almost every scene in which he appears. In fact, the film should perhaps be renamed #RAVANAYAM! Hopefully, the second part will finally become #RAMAYAN. Unless, of course, it turns out to be #HANUMANAYAM
42
13
137
37,373
If you wish to read authentic story of #Ramayana - you may read this concise & beautifully illustrated 240pg book "Ramrasayan" written by Sadguru #AniruddhaBapu We can complete the entire book in just a few hrs – making it a perfect companion for Ratra Pathan (overnight reading)
1
45
113
1,082
Shantanu Natu retweeted
Propaganda exposed victimizing Evil...
37
248
3
507
23,006
Shantanu Natu retweeted
🥺After watching the Ramayana movie, this is the conversation that happened in our family. Just listen to these questions and understand what kind of impression the movie is creating among the next generation. 👇👇👇🥺 I watched this movie with my family the day before Diwali. We have Gen Alpha kids, Gen Z, 90s and 80s kids in our family. After watching the movie One Gen Alpha kid asked: "What exactly did Ravana do wrong? Why are Rama and Lakshmana fighting a war against him? Ravana doesn't look like such a bad person!" 🥺🥺 Our elders started explaining, but the questions kept coming. Then came another question.🙄 Actually this dual hero subject .. Rama and Ravana are two heroes with different character. We asked how? The kid said .. both respect women both stand with poor people .. See.. like Ram Ravana too cared about women .. We asked where ? When? Kid said he punished his own sister's husband for behaving wrongly with the maid right?? Ram is fighting because something wrong happened to his wife. Same Ravana is also fighting because something wrong happened to his sister. So what's the difference between them?🙄🙄 The Devas are rich and powerful, while the Asuras are poor and suffering. If someone is treating poor people badly, shouldn't a hero question it? Isn't that what Ravana did? Whats wrong??? There is also a scene where Ravana says that if he lives in a golden house, his people will also live in a golden house. Whatever he eats, his people will also eat. Why you say Ravana is wrong? The children see this as equality! See Ravanan like Hero 😢😢 Now imagine what impression all this creates in young minds. If these things are actually in Valmiki Ramayana, I have no problem with showing them. But if things that are not in Valmiki Ramayana are added to make Ravana look like a hero, shouldn't we question it? It took our family elders a very long time to explain the story to the children. Honestly, I couldn't sleep properly thinking about this. Now my question is to all those right-wing reviewers who are praising this movie and saying wow, wow! How can you support a movie without even thinking about how it presents our own Ramayana? If our own children are getting this impression, just imagine how many others will get the same impression! Isn't this something we should seriously think about?🙄🥺
367
679
91
1,833
103,434
Shantanu Natu retweeted
Watch this clip from Japanese adaptation of ramayan How accurately sita haran is depicted here But our own Indian director needed to make it controversial Apologitic hinduism will lead it to its grave
45
375
13
3,161
241,297
Shantanu Natu retweeted
Namit Malhotra’s #RamayanaMovie, is a Left-Abrahamic project to distort, hijack & butcher our Itihas #Ramayana. @Satya01258773 Ji has perfectly exposed the ecosystem, including Hindus blindly praising or defending this movie with L-level logic. This deserves a MASSIVE boycott!
31
231
7
438
6,249
Shantanu Natu retweeted
RAMAYANA or RAVANAYANA?? 😤 Ban Namit Malhotra's #Ramayana #RamayanaMovie
395
1,667
33
4,599
278,031
Silver prices in India. 📈📉 October 2025 - ₹1.6 lac/kg January 2026 - ₹4.12 lac/kg October 2026 - ₹1.79 lac/kg
2
158
Shantanu Natu retweeted
🚨 WHAT IS GOING ON? 🇬🇧 UK tells citizens to keep 3 days of emergency food and water. 🇺🇸 Pentagon wants military bases ready to survive 90 days without outside support. ⚡ Power grid failures 🌐 Cyberattacks ⚔️ Major war disruptions
25
212
6
1,102
111,764
Shantanu Natu retweeted
#France protests were also started for the sake of so-called ‘students’, exactly as #CJP started in India. Had the #ModiGovt not foiled their plans, they too would have spread the same street violence and anarchy in India, as already openly acknowledged by Prashant Bhushan.
Friends, just look at the situation in France! Dipke and Neha Bora wanted to replicate something similar in India. Gyanesh Kumar was merely a pretext, not the real issue. But they forgot one crucial thing, India is not a country where chaos can be engineered at will. Narendra Modi and Amit Shah are firmly in the picture.
4
14
252
#RegimeChange ? Evil intentions revealed! When you cannot defeat them by the way of democracy, you want anarchy in entire nation ?
🚨 Biggest Admission: Prashant Bhushan Says It on Camera! => "I say it here, YES. WE ARE DOING THIS FOR REGIME CHANGE. WE WANT REGIME CHANGE. What's wrong in that?"🤯 Wow! Trying to overturn the clear verdict of India’s voters through STREET ANARCHY. Gather a mob of 5,000 in Delhi. > Vandalise properties. Storm the secretariat, Lok Bhavan, PM’s residence and ministers’ houses. > Pull people out, burn their vehicles and beat them on the road. Any neutral person who still supports this is enabling a direct THREAT to it. The mask is off🤡
3
4
20
294
#Ukraine pres #Zelensky "begging" elon musk to switch on the "#Starlink Internet" which Musk has turned it off in the middle of War.
Zelensky literally begs Elon Musk to switch on STARLINK or thousands of Ukrainians will die! He accuses Trump and Musk of betraying Ukraine, claiming Starlink's overnight disruption crippled interceptor drones that rely on the satellite network, putting Ukrainian lives at risk. The same Starlink they wanted in India and Rahul & opposition were all out supporting!
1
2
7
145
Shantanu Natu retweeted
Oh dear @abhijeet_dipke, the truth sets everybody free. Even you. And here’s the truth: these US donors will drop you like a hot cake when you don’t succeed. And you won’t, because lawlessness never wins. Instead, take your U.S. education, talent, and use it for good. Sit down with the PM @narendramodi and be a positive voice to advance India. The truth of your courage to do what’s right lies in your next steps. And the PM doesn’t need American support. He has 1.5 billion beautiful Indian citizens who support him and have for 25 years, 12 years as PM, three consecutive terms. And will again in 2029. That’s the truth.
Why is Modi seeking the support of Americans to discredit his own countrymen? Who gave foreign nationals the right to interfere in India’s internal affairs? We are more than capable of dealing with our own issues. We don’t need outsiders interfering in our country’s affairs.
3,000
13,713
620
52,063
999,365
Very Imp Post: American singer Mary Millben has urged young Indians to speak up, alleging that certain US-based donors opposed to PM #Modi are trying to destabilize India by the way of so-called pressure group #CJP Current Indian Govt is elected by due process of #IndianDemocracy
American singer Mary Millben has urged young Indians to speak up, alleging that US-based donors opposed to Prime Minister Narendra Modi are funding Abhijeet Dipke and the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) #MaryMillben #CockroachJantaParty @MaryMillben
3
12
183
Shantanu Natu retweeted
I cancelled my Tesla booking after seeing Elon Musk’s tweets. Sometimes, the person behind the brand makes you rethink the purchase.
1,272
744
76
7,047
261,756
Salute to @DelhiPolice for keeping absolute cool head while handling weird protesting people. This is what happens in other countries 👇
Salute to the brave hearts of Delhi Police! 🇮🇳👏❤️
1
4
12
162
President #Elon, Many American companies - including your Tesla, X & Grok do business in India. If #Starlink faces regulatory hurdles over serious national security concerns, that’s no excuse to attack India, Indian leadership & Indian businessmen India’s national security (1/3)
2
10
32
325
and business interests are for Indians to decide. Stay out of our internal affairs and focus on your own businesses. Your repeated baseless rants against India have consequences. (2/3)
3
30
Shantanu Natu retweeted
Indians are going all guns blazing at US. After a direct retort at their VP Vance followed by backlash against Musk, India is setting new benchmarks of how you bash American ego. US has clearly lost its pole position and credibility. The day of fall of US is not far.
No official US offer for the F-35, says IAF Chief ACM AP Singh. Sitting right beside the US PACAF Commander, he quipped: “Your people don't even let us go near the aircraft, and you talk about selling it to us”. A Russian offer for the Su-57 is pending evaluation, he said.
6
15
204
Shantanu Natu retweeted
Care for yourself & your US, Elon. We Indians can decide for ourselves. Had great respect for you when you named your company after the great Dr Nikola Tesla. But your cheap & low-level tweets show you are nothing more than a regime-change agent peddling for the deep state.
Replying to @elonmusk
Also, Starlink has proven to be essential for saving lives during natural disasters throughout the world, when all other communications systems have failed, so you would also be helping save men, women and children throughout India. 🇮🇳
1
4
25
466