PSA: Open Command is at the GM meetings!
We're offering a wide range of services to teams, agencies, & players.
DMs & email open for inquiries
This was also kind of wrong because there IS a steep hockey stick when you look at RA9 instead of xERA.
The minimum command you need to reliably be in the big leagues is around a 12-inch mean miss!
As @pitchprofiler & others mentioned, maybe there's some "minimum command" to be a viable pitcher (throw enough strikes).
I managed to find *some* hockey stick going on but it looks like it's driven by K% dropping (not BB% going up disproportionately).
It's hard to show in MLB because these pitchers already proved they could throw strikes in the minors!
1
14
1,536
Yeah so command is correlated to RA9 - xERA but stuff isn't
This is the most absurd result I've ever seen
So turns out command is worth TWICE as much. Using xERA was a mistake and underestimated its importance.
On RA9, command is 2/3 as important as stuff.
Anyone have an idea on why such a big gap? I've always considered xERA to be RA9 but faster. But it's missing something?
Parker Messick had his 2nd worst command day of the year yesterday.
He dropped from 80th to 12th percentile command, walking 4 batters in 2.1 innings.
The problem is that command's influence is observable *conditional* on stuff. (Raw command is uncorrelated to ERA)
It's a huge survivorship bias (good stuff guys get away with bad command) - there's a negative correlation between stuff and command.
2/3
2
7
1,089
3 things are true at the same time:
- Command is worth 1/3 Stuff
- Command stabilizes almost as fast as Stuff
- Adding Command on top of Stuff doesn't dramatically improve ERA prediction
Why? 🧵
1/3
As @pitchprofiler & others mentioned, maybe there's some "minimum command" to be a viable pitcher (throw enough strikes).
I managed to find *some* hockey stick going on but it looks like it's driven by K% dropping (not BB% going up disproportionately).
It's hard to show in MLB because these pitchers already proved they could throw strikes in the minors!
For reference, going from worst stuff in the league to best is worth 3 ERA.
So, stuff is arguably 3x as important as command (at the MLB level)!
Fastballs are almost twice as command dependent as Breaking balls. Anyone have an idea why?
2
6
1,708
Going from worst command in the league to best is worth 1 ERA!
There's a strong correlation between xERA (unexplained by Stuff+) and command.
And it gets really interesting because some pitch types are way more dependent on command than others (see below)
Let's be liberal and assume it's 2 big jumps away from ground truth: a true mean miss of 10.5in.
This means OpenCommand's target estimate is 3.72in away from true target *on average*!
1
109
2. Estimating Target Error
OpenCommand made 2 jumps (pitch type offset & glove dependence), dropping mean miss 12.19 → 11.55 → 11.14in
These were BIG jumps, just look at the target map:
1
1
109
1. The tracker with lowest avg miss is most accurate.
Intuitively, miss is scatter around target, so more noise added to target makes measured miss bigger.
Every source of error in the pipeline therefore increases avg measured miss.
1
1
145




















