Open Command (@open_command) header
Open Command (@open_command) profile picture

Quantifying pitch execution!

Joined July 2026
I'll be using this account to publicly share the results of OpenCommand, a computer-vision based command tracker. Ideas in mind: - MLB command leaderboards - Target maps - Pitcher command trends - Pitcher tactics changes - Reply to this tweet if you have ideas!
Some news: I decided to open source my command project. It's called OpenCommand. This means anyone can see the code (and even the data)! I hope this gives more people a chance to pursue and share cutting edge baseball research. Anyways, here's how to measure command: 馃У 1/N
4
31
11,652
PSA: Open Command is at the GM meetings! We're offering a wide range of services to teams, agencies, & players. DMs & email open for inquiries
1
3
1
26
1,604
This was also kind of wrong because there IS a steep hockey stick when you look at RA9 instead of xERA. The minimum command you need to reliably be in the big leagues is around a 12-inch mean miss!
As @pitchprofiler & others mentioned, maybe there's some "minimum command" to be a viable pitcher (throw enough strikes). I managed to find *some* hockey stick going on but it looks like it's driven by K% dropping (not BB% going up disproportionately). It's hard to show in MLB because these pitchers already proved they could throw strikes in the minors!
1
14
1,536
Yeah so command is correlated to RA9 - xERA but stuff isn't This is the most absurd result I've ever seen
So turns out command is worth TWICE as much. Using xERA was a mistake and underestimated its importance. On RA9, command is 2/3 as important as stuff. Anyone have an idea on why such a big gap? I've always considered xERA to be RA9 but faster. But it's missing something?
4
1
31
6,124
Replying to @georgerlewis
The correlation gotta be tiny though
1
1
60
Replying to @georgerlewis
Sounds plausible but 2x is a pretty big difference
1
1
73
Replying to @tangotiger
Why the difference tho xERA is xwOBA
1
3
756
Replying to @georgerlewis
So something like no allowing walks when you can't afford to, and allowing walks when it's not so bad?
1
84
So turns out command is worth TWICE as much. Using xERA was a mistake and underestimated its importance. On RA9, command is 2/3 as important as stuff. Anyone have an idea on why such a big gap? I've always considered xERA to be RA9 but faster. But it's missing something?
For reference, going from worst stuff in the league to best is worth 3 ERA. So, stuff is arguably 3x as important as command (at the MLB level)!
3
1
53
10,451
Parker Messick had his 2nd worst command day of the year yesterday. He dropped from 80th to 12th percentile command, walking 4 batters in 2.1 innings.
2
38
6,850
So, if command's internal reliability is 0.5 and stuff's is 0.5, we can only observe ~30% of command's effects. Even if command 100% stabilizes at pitch 1, it still needs to wait for stuff to stabilize to be effective. 3/3
4
621
The problem is that command's influence is observable *conditional* on stuff. (Raw command is uncorrelated to ERA) It's a huge survivorship bias (good stuff guys get away with bad command) - there's a negative correlation between stuff and command. 2/3
2
7
1,089
3 things are true at the same time: - Command is worth 1/3 Stuff - Command stabilizes almost as fast as Stuff - Adding Command on top of Stuff doesn't dramatically improve ERA prediction Why? 馃У 1/3
5
4
50
6,535
Doesn't explain the K% hockey stick though
112
Yeah idk what's going on
1
1
69
Oh yeah there is, worse command pitchers have better stuff, but the hockey stick with K% (might) mean worst command pitchers have worse stuff which is weird
1
2
68
On the surface it means the opposite: the worst command pitchers also have worst stuff. This is despite removing position players. But maybe there's something in what you said, maybe there's only so much a good stuff helps you with chase
1
2
150
As @pitchprofiler & others mentioned, maybe there's some "minimum command" to be a viable pitcher (throw enough strikes). I managed to find *some* hockey stick going on but it looks like it's driven by K% dropping (not BB% going up disproportionately). It's hard to show in MLB because these pitchers already proved they could throw strikes in the minors!
2
1
34
3,935
Replying to @Ja_jacks_
馃憞
Replying to @tomdoyo
We can adjust for tendencies by offsetting the target by the avg pitcher 脳 pitch type miss pattern. E.g. Logan Webb's changeup averages 13in below the glove This is the current math behind "inferred" targets. But there are 2 huge flaws with it. Can anyone guess what they are? 10/N
1
25
Replying to @JenMineau13
There should be but I'm not sure what the y axis should be in that case
2
580