Anthony Roberts

The behaviour in Gordon House yesterday was disgraceful and must be unequivocally condemned. Opposition MP Phillips unleashing unbecoming language, moving aggressively toward a colleague, and requiring physical restraint is unacceptable. It brings Parliament into disrepute and cannot be tolerated. If we look to our leaders for leadership, is this the best we have to offer? What example do we dare set for our younger ones? While the Government’s reference to Standing Order 38 to close the debate was within the rules, it must never use its majority unduly to shield itself from scrutiny. An explanation of Jamaica’s abrupt shift to abstain on the Cuba embargo resolution, subject to rigorous scrutiny, is needed - and the legislative chamber is the proper place for that. The Government would do well to reflect on this and on whether it exercises its majority and procedural powers fairly, even when acting within the letter of the standing orders. That does not, however, justify disorder, threats or conduct that undermines the institution. The Opposition must continue to challenge what it sees as the unfair use of numbers - through substantive and reasoned argument and proper procedure - not by descending into scenes that disgrace the House.