Alex Fox retweeted
"Hamas kidnapped me from the Nova music festival on Oct. 7 and held me in Gaza for 505 days, much of that time in apartments in active combat zones. There was much to fear in captivity. Hunger. My captors. Never seeing my family again. But I also feared the Israeli air force. The Israeli pilots overhead had no idea where I was. Sometimes when my captors expected an Israeli attack was coming, they fled and left me behind. If an Israeli bomb killed me, Hamas would win twice: I would be dead, and Israel would be responsible."
"One of my captors told me his mother had received a phone call warning her to leave her home because an Israeli strike might put her in danger. The call came from the Israel Defense Forces. Hamas knew where I was and left me to die. Israel didn’t know my location, but it knew where my captor’s mother was and called to make sure she wasn’t killed accidentally. There I was—kidnapped, starved and tortured by her son—while my army was trying to keep his mother alive.
Israel desperately wanted me home. But not at any price. There were Palestinian civilians between ”
"If Israel had cared less about NAZA, perhaps I would have come home sooner. Fewer Israeli soldiers might have died. Fewer hostages might have died. But more Palestinians would have."
Alex Fox retweeted
Motaz Azaiza is forcing a reckoning the “pro‑Palestine” movement never anticipated. Because he’s celebrated by activists, politicians, and journalists and can’t be smeared as a “Zionist shill,” his admission carries weight: Gaza’s journalism space functioned under Hamas’s control, and any reporter who deviated from the group’s narrative risked “disappearing behind the sun.” That single truth reshapes how we understand the stories pushed out of Gaza since October 7 and explains why dissent against Hamas’s rule never surfaced publicly. Western journalists and outsiders, unaware of this coercive ecosystem, ended up amplifying Hamas’s information warfare rather than scrutinizing it.
Alex Fox retweeted
Replying to @TheBeanEyesOpen @MelanieLatest
Umm… When the Arabs conquered the land between the river and the sea there were 1 million people there including 200k+ Jews. Over the next 1200 years the population steadily declined, hovering static around 250k or less for most of this period.
Jews returned, bought land, cultivated that land and eradicated Malaria. This, plus the arrival of the Brits who further improved sanitation, infrastructure and commerce, cut infant mortality by 60+ percent leading to a massive natural population increase.
Additionally 100k folks arrived from Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, etc…Relative to the 1.2 million Arabs in the land in 1945 it’s not significant but relative to the 1200 year population of 250k it is a massive number.
Further, 60%+ of the land set aside for Jews in the partition plan, was Negev desert. There were maybe 5k nomadic bedouins there in the mid 1800’s. One person per sq mile, if that. The Ottomans legal term for the land was dead/wasteland.
The Arabs came in slapped mosques on top of the holiest sites of the indigenous people of the land (Al Aqsa on the Temple Mount, A Mosque in Hebron’s Cave of the Machpelah) then, besides the crusades, allocated their resources to other cities, Cairo, Damascus, Baghdad for the next 1200 years.
To recap, Jews returned, bought land, developed the land and accepted a partition of the land based mostly on Jewish population centers and barren land.
The opportunity to return was made possible by the collapse of an empire that had won the land via conquest. The new conquering powers made the rules just like the preceding empires/caliphates had made the rules prior.
The difference under British rule vs Arab/Turkish rule and the real problem for the Arabs was that they had enjoyed legal privileges over non-Muslims (basically religious Jim Crow) for over a century. The Ottomans, forced by Europe, had ended legal privileges in the mid/late 1800’s but it still existed in practice. Just like slavery did and still does exist in parts of the Islamic/Arab world.
The Arabs rebelled against the idea of non-Muslim equality/self determination and have been fighting it ever since.
Alex Fox retweeted
Remember: genocide means a deliberate attempt to exterminate a group, simply for being members of that group. That’s what “genocide in Gaza” alleges: that Israel is unsuccessfully attempting to exterminate every last Palestinian.
Now, stand fast the fact that the only really high rate of Gazan deaths happened in the first months of the war and dropped to barely registering after the ceasefire (see graph below). One might suggest that had Israel been intent on wiping out everyone indiscriminately, they would have maintained their rate of killing.
But what about the overall population of Gaza? If Israel had wanted to wipe out every Palestinian, you’d expect that overall total to fall, right?
At some point, the word genocide has to survive contact with arithmetic. Gaza’s own records now sit in open contradiction with the claim that Israel attempted to destroy its population: approximately 121,000 live births since 7 October 2023, against a reported direct war death toll of just over 73,000.
The extermination narrative looks increasingly absurd. More babies have been born in Gaza during the war than Gazans have been recorded as killed, including both civilians and combatants.
The usual escape route is to say that genocide need not succeed. That is legally correct and intellectually evasive when deployed to make every contrary fact disappear. Genocidal intent still has to be proved, and the ICJ has held that, where it is inferred from conduct, the destruction of the group must be the only reasonable inference available.
In Croatia v Serbia, it examined whether civilians had been spared, evacuated or allowed to survive when their supposed destroyers had the opportunity to kill them. Conduct preserving members of the protected population counted against genocide.
Now apply that reasoning to Gaza.
Start with polio. In September 2024, while Israeli troops were still fighting across the Strip, Israel agreed daily, area-specific pauses so Palestinian and international medical teams could vaccinate Gaza’s children. The first round reached 559,161 children under ten, around 95 per cent of the eligible population.
Israel then agreed to do it again. The second round reached 556,774 children, with 448,425 children between two and ten also receiving vitamin A. The campaign required the delivery of 1.6 million vaccine doses, refrigerators, freezers, ice boxes and hundreds of vaccine carriers. WHO and UNICEF planned for the vaccines and cold-chain equipment to transit through Ben Gurion Airport before entering Gaza.
A third campaign followed in February 2025. It vaccinated 602,795 children under ten, reaching 102 per cent of the estimated target because medical teams found children missed during earlier rounds.
The combined figure is 1,718,730 administered polio doses. (That represents repeated protection of roughly 600,000 individual children, rather than 1.7 million different children.) Almost the entire under-10 population was reached again and again.
These vaccines were administered by Palestinian health workers, WHO, UNICEF, UNRWA and their partners. Without Israeli cooperation, the campaigns could not have happened.
UNICEF’s end-of-year report says the outbreak had been interrupted by July 2025. It also records 49,000 children under two receiving catch-up vaccinations, with coverage exceeding 80 per cent. BCG vaccinations rose from 37,471 in 2024 to 47,556 in 2025.
It was an enormous public health enterprise, run over several months, involving thousands of workers and protecting nearly every child in Gaza from paralysis.
That is the physical reality of what Israel enabled: the children it was supposedly trying to destroy were repeatedly protected against a disease that could disable or kill them.
A coherent programme of genocide cannot be inferred by treating every Israeli action that preserved Palestinian life as irrelevant.
The birth figures deepen the problem for the accusation. A reconstruction using Gaza Ministry of Health and civil registration records suggests approximately 12,000 babies were born during the final quarter of 2023, around 38,000 during 2024, 49,267 live births during 2025, and roughly 21,000 so far in 2026. The latest portion is necessarily estimated because complete July and August registrations have not yet been published.
Many babies born during the first months had been conceived before 7 October. That explanation expired nine months into the war. Tens of thousands of children were subsequently conceived and delivered while Israel supposedly pursued the biological destruction of Gaza.
Births fell below their pre-war level, hardly surprising amid displacement and combat. Miscarriages, premature births and maternal complications also rose. Nothing about those conditions was humane or desirable.
However, the comparison remains devastating. Approximately 121,000 live births against just over 73,000 reported direct war deaths leaves a difference approaching 48,000. The number killed includes combatants as well as civilians, of course.
Gaza’s overall resident population fell because the calculation includes outward migration, the missing and other demographic changes. The Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics estimates that around 100,000 people left Gaza during the war. A decline driven substantially by people leaving a war zone cannot simply be relabelled as physical destruction.
No Israeli advocate needs to pretend that civilian life in Gaza was tolerable. It was an urban war fought against an enemy dug into hundreds of miles of tunnels beneath neighbourhoods, hospitals, schools and camps. Hamas designed that battlefield to make civilian deaths unavoidable and politically useful.
Israel issued evacuation warnings, created corridors and humanitarian zones, admitted food and medicine, coordinated medical evacuations, paused military operations and enabled almost 600,000 Palestinian children to receive repeated protection against polio. Around 121,000 babies were born during the war, far exceeding the reported direct death toll.
The genocide allegation survives only by declaring every piece of exculpatory evidence meaningless. Births supposedly tell us nothing. Vaccinations tell us nothing. Food deliveries tell us nothing. Humanitarian pauses tell us nothing. Failed famine predictions tell us nothing. The absence of measured famine mortality tells us nothing.
Such reasoning insulates the genocide accusation from reality. Every Palestinian death becomes proof of genocide, while every Palestinian life preserved through Israeli cooperation is dismissed as public relations.
The simpler explanation: Israel fought a devastating war against Hamas, accepting extraordinary military and political costs while repeatedly undertaking measures to preserve Palestinian civilian life. Those measures were imperfect and sometimes failed, as measures do in war.
Gaza’s own birth records, vaccination figures and famine evidence have hollowed out the allegations. A country attempting to destroy a people does not enable more than 120,000 births, facilitate 1.7 million childhood vaccine doses and support humanitarian operations feeding virtually the entire population.
That is war, with all its brutality and tragedy. It is not genocide.
Bottom line: they’ve spent three years shrieking about genocide, backed by academic fraud. Now it’s collapsing, they’re throwing smoke to cover tracks.
The Lancet papers claiming hundreds of thousands dead, the IPC and UN panels loaded with anti-Israel activists claiming famine (now conclusively disproven) and genocide, made-up testimony and faked x-rays by doctors taken to Gaza by a charity connected to an actual terror group, the staged vids, AI images and beheaded doll photos put out by Hamas themselves… all bullshit. All of it. The “Gaza genocide” is the greatest hoax of all time, enabled by social media, antisemitism, and gullibility.
Now we know that the population of Gaza *increased* since the war began and a comparatively tiny proportion of non-combatants died. What you are seeing now from people like Mehdi is nothing but rhetorical sleight of hand to keep the hoax going, even as it falls apart.
Alex Fox retweeted
Alas, Mr. Congressman, I'm not lying. And I started this line of questioning assuming you were telling the truth. I've written long essays on extremist Israeli violence in the West Bank. I know it happens. I was ready, at first glance, to believe it happened here. But it didn't. This wasn't Israeli violence. This was agitprop for your American audiences.
I said explicitly that I'm not familiar with the details of that area. It took a lot of effort for JPost to find out what it found out -- which was that it was a closed military zone only recently opened.
But if you'd coordinated your visit with Israeli authorities, this would have been sorted out from the start. Those soldiers weren't angry or aggressive, they seemed mostly just confused about the status of the area and how to handle your visit.
Because, you know, there was no coordination.
JPost suggests all that in the article you yourself shared.
And what of the violence? Your group had cameras -- a professional photographer and at least one bodycam -- yet you've produced no evidence that I've seen of the violence you claim to have experienced.
Remember that you claimed the violence was sufficient to demand that Netanyahu order the prosecution of those soldiers.
I've seen that sort of violence before; if you produce that footage, I'll join your demand for prosecution. That's not rhetoric. I really will, wholeheartedly.
But if you don't, I think it's safe to assume you blew up a small inconvenience caused by your own refusal to talk to Israelis.
In a similar vein, you used the word "detained" as if you were unlawfully held against your will -- and hide behind its second meaning, that you were a bit delayed in driving forward into the area. The first is on the spectrum of kidnapping crimes, the second is the sort of problem you'd encounter at the entrance to a federal building as you search your pockets for an ID. Which was it?
Anyway, you were angling for some domestic political brownie points, and congratulations, you got 'em.
You are lying @havivrettiggur. The Jerusalem Post, which leans right, concluded that it was not a closed zone & vigilante settlers had no right to detain Americans. Stop gaslighting Americans. jpost.com/israel-news/articl…
Alex Fox retweeted
When you are endorsing candidates with covered-up Nazi tattoos because you cannot afford to be outflanked on the left, you clearly are not setting the terms of debate. All of this is happening inside the ecosystem that Emanuel and his generation of Democratic operatives built, staffed, and funded, and he cannot even talk about it because that would require him to indict his own coalition, which would end the presidential campaign before it begins. So instead, the entire causal architecture of the speech is organized around Netanyahu as the independent variable: remove Bibi, restore the managerial relationship, and the problem resolves. Netanyahu is the scapegoat — and in fairness to Emanuel, what is politics if not the supreme art of finding the proper scapegoat? It is time for Bibi to go anyway. Khalas, enough is enough — but the problem is not Netanyahu, and scapegoating him for the deterioration of the U.S.-Israel relationship, or for the rise of antisemitism inside all the institutions that the Dems control, is a maneuver that is just too much for any person who wants to remain sane.
Let us consider a counterfactual. Had Netanyahu been replaced in 2021 by a Labor-Meretz coalition that froze settlements, pursued negotiations, and conducted the Gaza operation with maximal concern for proportionality (whatever that would mean in practice against a lunatic group of terrorists embedded in civilian infrastructure), would the DSA wing have moderated? Would Mamdani — Mandani? — have recognized Israel as a Jewish state? Would the Columbia encampments not have happened at all? No professor would have justified the murder of Israelis because, you know, decolonization? Would BDS not have become the litmus test in Democratic primaries? The answer to every one of these questions is obviously no, because the ideological framework that drives the anti-Israel position inside the Democratic Party is indifferent to Israeli behavior and responds to the category of Israel as such, as a settler-colonial ethnostate whose existence is the offense. “From the river to the sea” is not a critique of settlements or of Netanyahu; it is a demand for elimination. Emanuel quotes the phrase in the speech and says he will fight it, but he cannot fight it because the people chanting it are the voters his party needs, and the machinery that trained them to chant it — the universities, the activist organizations, the identitarian epistemology that underwrites “Palestine as colonized people” — is machinery his political generation built, imported from the Third World, funded, and deployed as the operating system of the Democratic coalition.
link to rest of article below
Alex Fox retweeted
I co-founded Wikipedia, but an anonymous mob runs the show—and now I’m banned.
I told the story in the Washington Examiner, out this morning:
washingtonexaminer.com/op-ed…
Alex Fox retweeted
Oops
🚨Major admission by @pressfreedom. CPJ is finally conducting a full review of its Gaza “journalist” fatality database after Hamas & PIJ themselves exposed many listed “journalists” as their own fighters. Israel said this all along and Hamas/PIJ's own martyr notices proved it.
Alex Fox retweeted
Dear U.S., UN, Western, and humanitarian officials and leaders: Please visit the Al‑Ahli Hospital in Gaza City and see the situation firsthand. Hamas’s intelligence operatives, internal security, and al‑Qassam fighters are using parts of the complex to interrogate and torture anyone they suspect of supporting the upcoming June 26 anti‑Hamas protests. Medical facilities in Gaza are not meant to be sanctuaries for Hamas. They are provided with necessary supplies and equipment, funded with Western taxpayer dollars, to treat civilians, not to provide cover for an Islamist organization that the international community designates as a terrorist group. Get them out of the hospital. Stop allowing a place meant for healing to be turned into a site of fear and abuse.
@UNRWA @UNReliefChief @UNICEF @uninvhrc @UNICEFinArabic @WHO @UNOCHA @ICRC_ilot @ICRC_ar @ICRC @RESCUEorg @amnestyusa @amnesty @UNHumanRights @UNDP @USUN @UN_News_Centre @antonioguterres @MSF @UN_HRC @MSF_USA @msf_arabic @UNICEFinArabic @UNarabic @OCHAFunds @UNHCR_Arabic @Refugees @UNGeneva @UNESCOarabic @UNNewsArabic @Oxfam @OxfamAmerica @oxfamgb @usembassyjlm @USEmbassyJLMPal @RapidResponse47 @PressSec @SecRubio @CENTCOM
Exposing Hamas’s Use of a Primary Gaza Hospital for Repression: Hamas’s intelligence and internal security services are in full fascist mode across the Gaza Strip, beating, interrogating, and threatening anyone they suspect may join the June 26 protests against their rule. A few friends of mine in Gaza City have already been summoned. They were told explicitly by al‑Qassam Brigades operatives, Hamas police, and internal security officers that if they post anything supportive of the protests on Facebook or offer any help to protestors, they will be executed under “revolutionary conditions” and treated as collaborators with Israel; no trial, no process, just immediate death.
And where were some of my friends interrogated, threatened, and placed on house arrest? Inside Al‑Ahli Arab Hospital or the Ma'amadani/Baptist Hospital in Gaza’s Zeitoun neighborhood. Yes, the same hospital that grabbed global headlines early in the war after a faulty Islamic Jihad rocket fell and caused an explosion, which killed hundreds of people. That hospital is now a central hub for Hamas’s intelligence, militancy, and internal repression.
This is criminal on every level. And it raises a basic question: if overwhelming, well‑corroborated evidence shows Hamas using Gaza’s medical facilities to hide among civilians and enforce its armed rule, violating the October 2025 ceasefire, why have the UN and international medical and humanitarian NGOs and charities remained silent? Why has no one suspended operations until Hamas withdraws from the hospitals they support?
I want every follower and every official who sees this to contact and tag the World Health Organization, UNICEF, UNRWA, the United Nations, Doctors Without Borders, the International Committee of the Red Cross, and any organization supplying Gaza’s hospitals. Demand that they confront Hamas’s presence in the Al-Ahli Arab Hospital/ Ma'amadani / Baptist Hospital and every facility they fund, staff, and sustain. Even though the Episcopal Church/Anglican Diocese of Jerusalem manages Al‑Ahli, every medical facility in Gaza depends on international aid, equipment, and expertise, during the war and even more so since the ceasefire.
It is time to get Hamas out of Gaza’s hospitals. It is time to support Gazans risking their lives to protest the Islamist fascists who have destroyed their society for twenty years. And it is time for the international community to finally recognize that Hamas cannot be trusted to uphold any agreement. The group is committed to a last‑stand ideology – much like Hitler in his bunker – regardless of how many civilians in Gaza suffer or die as a result.
Alex Fox retweeted
Hezbollah is a direct proxy of Iran through the Quds force.
Hezbollah attacks against Israel from Southern Lebanon recently:
June 8–13: over 130 attack waves against Israel and IDF forces.
June 13: Multiple UAVs launched from Lebanon and intercepted.
June 14: Multiple UAV infiltrations, rockets, and explosions.
June 15: 21 verified waves of rockets, ATGM fire, and mortar fire.
June 16: Multiple rockets fired.
June 17: 2 FPV explosive drone attacks.
June 18: 63 rocket attacks, 7 explosive UAV attacks, 2 IED attacks, 1 missile attack, and 1 infiltration attempt (by 5 terrorists).
June 19: Multiple barrages of rocket and artillery fire, as well as explosive drone attacks and anti-tank guided missiles.
June 20: More than 50 projectiles fired overnight including rockets, artillery, and explosive drones.
Is it making sense yet?
Iran signed an MOU including Lebanon and then used their terrorist proxy to attack Israel viciously and repeatedly, then they pushed propaganda blaming it all on Israel.
Stop falling for Muslim terrorist propaganda.
Alex Fox retweeted
“No glory to martyrs, NEVER!”
Zoya’s bitterly revealing satire is necessary. Is this what we want to incubate in modern society? No.
No glory to suicidal sprees of violence targeting uninvolved civilians.
No.
No to the culture of autonomous ideologically motivated violence and no to political violence.
No to vigilantism, no to mob justice, and
No to apologists and their ‘grey zone’ cultivation of hate that feeds stochastic acts of terror.
All of it. Just no.
Alex Fox retweeted
The first time I was flying to Beirut, the desk officer at London Heathrow asked before checking us in, “have you been to Israel?”
We had rehearsed the answer to this question before. But Winston can't lie, so he said yes. I gave him the dirty look. There goes our vacation!
"Well, you don't have the stamp on your passports so just make sure you tell the officer in Beirut that you haven't," she intoned.
I was stressed out for the next 5 hours, and even more so when we had to face the border officer who, by the grace of God, did not ask us THE question (even though he took our passports to a secondary office for extra checks).
Spending time in Beirut, you realize that it's the same Mediterranean light that bathes Tel Aviv; the sea is the same shade of shimmering blue because... well, it's the same sea.
In both places, young people spill out of clubs at sunrise, the bass still thumping from rooftops that overlook the same ancient coastline. Both cities pulse with the same Levantine hunger for life: the clink of arak glasses, endless plates of hummus swirled with olive oil, the sudden eruption of dabke or house music that pulls strangers into a circle. Parties start on the rooftops of Gemmayze in Beirut and tumble down into Mar Mikhael’s narrow alleys; in Tel Aviv they begin on the sand at Gordon Beach and migrate to the warehouses of the Florentin district. These are both stylish people who love life, and who love to party. The energy is truly infectious. The accents may differ but something about this weird combination along with a deep sense of rootedness in community and the extended family really underscore how similar they were.
And yet, there's been a wall between these two peoples. There are no flights stitching the 45 min hop across the water. No commercial trucks rumbling between the ports. Lebanese law forbids its citizens - inside the country or in the diaspora - from so much as speaking to an Israeli, a rule so absolute that some Lebanese friends of mine who live in Europe still glance over their shoulders before typing a reply to any Israeli even outside the country, whether for business or pleasure.
I spent evenings in Beirut listening to Lebanese friends speak of Israelis not as the enemy but as people caught in the same endless loop of fear and longing.
Decades of Hezbollah’s shadow have hollowed out parts of Lebanon, turning the south into a garrison and the economy into a ruin. Yet in the cafés of Achrafieh and the mountain villages above the city you hear it more and more: a quiet, exhausted recognition that the real hostage-takers are not across the border but inside it.
I keep imagining the day the question at Beirut airport changes. I keep picturing the first flight from Rafic Harari to Ben Gurion. One day the music will be louder than the fear. One day the Lebanese and the Israelis will throw the party the rest of the world has been waiting for.
I hope this is the first step:
Alex Fox retweeted
On the heels of the JCPOA, under Obama in mid 2016 Iran began using the deal’s ambiguities to preserve and advance its centrifuge infrastructure while receiving sanctions relief. It resumed manufacturing of rotor tubes, removed their first gen IR1 centrifuges from Fordow for unauthorized R&D, conducted extra mechanical testing on IR8s, and fed uranium into an IR6 cascade, all in violation of JCPOA centrifuge R&D limits. That same year, there were repeated heavy water stockpile breaches and exploitation of quality assurance loopholes.
Then in Jan 2018 Mossad exfiltrated the half ton of documents that revealed the AMAD Project. It was definitive proof that Iran lied, and that program was never halted but merely corporatized and dispersed under SPND. That haul was the proximate trigger for Trump’s withdrawal. The fact is JCPOA never fully dismantled Iran’s enrichment capability or its weapons related infrastructure. Once the US withdrew from the deal, Iran accelerated its installation of centrifuges in 2019 and by July they’d crossed the 300 kilo stockpile cap and the 3.67 percent low enrich limit.
But it was only once Biden was elected that they began to aggressively install advanced centrifuge cascades and enrich to much higher levels. Two weeks before Biden’s inauguration Iran resumed 20% enrichment at Fordow. While the Biden admin was gearing up to revive the JCPOA, Iran was calculating that it can exploit their softer approach.
In the final analysis, it appears Trump didn’t let anything out of a Pandora’s box as Blinken and Sullivan allege. He made a policy judgement people can disagree on, but facts matter. Iran never gave up its clandestine nuclear weapons program. At the time that the Iran nuclear deal was negotiated and entered into, the details of that program remained unknown. They were pushing beyond the limits of the agreement the same year they signed it while still under Obama. None of that dealt with undeclared sites, the secret weaponization and research programs sitting in SPND workshops dispersed across the ministry of defense. None of it dealt with the way the sanctions relief enabled the Iranians to build a shield of missiles, drones and proxies to enable a breakout sprint.
But the JCPOA as framework did create visibility into their program and that ultimately improved our target bank and bolstered deterrence along the way. It undoubtedly helped to map their supply chains and established a clearer baseline for what breakout would look like. So Republicans are wrong that it was purely a mistake or counterproductive. At the same time, what Blinken has recently said about rolling the JCPOA at expiry into a new arms control agreement or militarily intervening if they refused is strategically blind. By that point, the costs of intervening would have been prohibitively high. Trump’s decision to walk away from the deal and pursue a maximum pressure campaign was critical for keeping them from achieving a zone of immunity to conventional intervention.
In sum, neither Democrats nor Republicans are fully correct on this issue and certainly neither are fully correct about each other’s positions. But this looks much more like the left foot kicking the right foot when they should be coordinating on how to move forward with respect to the real problem and the real culprit here, which is Iran.
Alex Fox retweeted
Last night, Internal Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir’s law mandating the execution of terrorists convicted of murder passed 62–48. Ben-Gvir attempted to propose a toast, but before he could pop the cork on his champagne, the Knesset speaker demanded he stop, and the ushers confiscated the bottle. The stunt was much like the law itself: all style, no substance.
Contrary to much of the rhetoric, Israel has had the death penalty for nearly 70 years. The original law was designed to execute Nazi war criminals but can technically apply to anyone who commits similarly genocidal crimes. Every prosecutor can request the death penalty, and under certain circumstances, judges may grant it. That’s why Ben-Gvir advertised his law as forcing left-wing prosecutors to request the penalty and left-wing judges to grant it for terrorists—particularly the Nukhba forces, who invaded Israel on October 7.
In reality, it does neither. The law explicitly excludes Nukhba terrorists from receiving the death penalty and provides no evidentiary infrastructure or procedural framework to secure convictions. Its wording actually helps judges avoid the penalty, mandating only “death penalty or life imprisonment” for convicted terrorists.
Those hoping this law would change the calculus of hostage deals should think again. Not only does it fail to reduce the number of terrorists in Israeli prisons, it does not abolish the president’s power of pardon—the primary mechanism for releasing terrorists in deals. Even if Ben-Gvir somehow manages to secure a death penalty, the law does nothing to prevent the conviction from being overturned or the terrorist from being handed over.
The law does more than fail in its objectives—it actively backfires. Despite being marketed as targeting Palestinian terrorists (raising its own legal problem of discrimination), it explicitly allows for the death penalty for Jews. The law defines terrorism as acts “to negate the existence of the state,” a definition that could apply to groups such as extremist Haredi factions and violent members of the “Hilltop Youth” (which Ben-Gvir supports).
Its most glaring flaw is that it mandates carrying out a sentence within 90 days—an explicit violation of the Geneva Convention’s mandatory 180-day waiting period. As a signatory, Israel could expose IDF officers to international lawsuits, with no tangible benefit. The IDF warned Ben-Gvir, but he disregarded their advice.
Its blatant illegality gives the Supreme Court clear grounds to strike it down, returning Israel to square one while damaging the country’s international reputation.
Had Ben-Gvir managed to keep his champagne, I would have proposed a toast—to a self-destructive law that makes Israel look terrible, benefiting no one but Ben-Gvir himself. L’chaim.
That said, while Ben-Gvir’s law is essentially a campaign stunt, a more responsible law is making its way through the system. Proposed by MKs Simcha Rothman and Yulia Malinovsky, the law establishes the practical mechanisms—procedural and evidentiary—to secure convictions of Nukhba terrorists, after which the death penalty could be imposed.
The Rothman–Malinovsky law was developed in consultation with all relevant authorities. The Shin Bet, IDF, and National Security Council have expressed similar concerns about Ben-Gvir’s law and consulted on this alternative.
The death penalty is a complex issue. Personally, I support executing terrorists who attempt to murder civilians—especially the monsters of October 7. Currently, these terrorists face one of two outcomes: spend the rest of their lives in prison at Israel’s expense, or eventually be released in a hostage deal and likely return to terrorism. Neither option is good for Israel.
What we can all agree on is that this issue demands a serious, responsible approach—one that prioritizes the security and best interests of the country over personal electoral ambitions.
To read the rest of today's newsletter click here.
amitsegal.substack.com/p/its…
Alex Fox retweeted
Replying to @NYCMayor
Your dishonesty has truly crossed the threshold into immorality.
First, there is absolutely no excuse for political violence, ever. I despise Nerdeen, but the plot to assassinate her on US soil is despicable. We are a society of law and order, and we aren’t turning this country into the Islamic republic.
Second, your confident naming of the Jewish group as well as their “known violent extremist organization”—which you made sure to quote and name—is slap in the face to how many Islamist terror plots take place near DAILY and you REFUSE to ever identify the aggressors as Islamists, let alone the ideology as “known to be dangerous,” which it very much is.
While this incident is atrocious, it is not the norm and never has been. It’s very clear you want to exaggerate the danger of one community and downplay the danger of the other, when it is well understood that jihadist/islamist groups are the real and persistent danger.
Please don’t fucking lie, Zohran.
Finally, you’ve made no mention about the Islamic regime targeting Iranian dissidents and human rights activists like myself, as well as Jews, which the FBI has actively foiled assassination attempts.
This is a form of transnational repression and is a serious and grave threat.
Instead, you steer the conversation to the targeting of Palestinian human rights activists. No mentioned of the Iranians and Jews who the FBI has repeatedly foiled assassination plots against? Including in NY?
No. Because that breaks narrative.
Again, there is absolutely no excuse for political violence, and thank god this plot was foiled—that’s not the American any of us should concede to living in.
But my god. You may be one of the most unethical and dishonest politicians in recent memory. There is no way you don’t know what you’re doing.
Alex Fox retweeted
If Iran was just trying to defend itself, people would care a lot less. They aren't though - they're radical, expansionist, imperialist, and destabilizing.
This Iranian government has boasted about having captured Beirut, Baghdad, Damascus, and Sanaa. Plus there was the Gaza Strip and Jenin.
The US assisted it's rise to power by pressuring the Shah and facilitating Khomeini's return. This Iranian regime proceeded to frame America as an intractable enemy anyway and the Great Satan. Death to America is what they cry.
The Israelis assisted this Iranian government's resistance against Saddam Hussein by brokering weapons purchases, maintaining the air force, supplying parts for the air force, and cooperating to destroy Saddam's nuclear reactor. This Iranian regime proceeded to frame Israel as an intractable enemy anyway and the Little Satan. Death to Israel is what they cry.
And their view of the rest of the west ain't much better. They despise the west's culture, prosperity, and and strength itself as arrogant and corrosive.
They demonstrated a willingness to screw with global oil supplies in order to exert international pressure in the Tanker Wars of the 1980s. And through the Houthis they demonstrated a clear willingness to choke the Bab el Mandeb.
They've repeatedly said that the Gulf States are a target of theirs.
This Iranian regime has organized terror cells in Europe, North America, South America, Australia, Malaysia, and Thailand. It has run in cooperation with Hezbollah and Assad drug rings and other criminal enterprises in South America, Africa, and the Middle East.
They sponsored the Polisario Liberation Front against Morocco and Muslim Brotherhood elements that want to overthrow the Jordanian Government.
They've allied with Chavez and Maduro's Venezuela against the US (several weekly direct flights between Caracas and Tehran, which are always completely booked with IRGC members). Talk of sticking Iranian missiles in Venezuela wasn't made up out of nowhere. And Venezuela issued passports to Iranian and Hezbollah (Iranian proxy) agents to operate throughout the Americas.
They've provided money and support to Al Shabaab in Somalia and partnered with some nasty factions in Sudan.
They blew up a random synagogue in Argentina just to show that they could. They tried to assassinate Trump twice. They tried to assassinate the Saudi Ambassador to the US on the street in Georgetown Washington DC. They routinely go around assassinating and kidnapping and intimidating Iranian dissidents abroad.
They've been a substantial factor in supporting Russia's war against Ukraine. And they have cooperated with North Korea in ballistic missile development.
This regime in Iran is an actor that is intent on being a threat and presence all over the place, and exerting what powers and capabilities it has in pursuit of their vision. It's destabilizing, destructive, and imperialist. They don't want self-defense, they want expansion and revolution.
Alex Fox retweeted
I'm shocked -- shocked! -- that Iran lies through its teeth at every turn.
And everyone who built their strategy on trusting the ayatollahs was handing us over -- Israelis, Gulf states -- as the sacrifice on the altar of appeasement.
Alex Fox retweeted
I’m going to say this clearly. My role, as an Iranian in the diaspora, is to amplify the suppressed voices inside Iran.
If they say “we need help,” I’m saying “we need help.”
If they say “keep the strikes coming,” I’m saying “keep the strikes coming.”
If they say “stop the war,” I’m staying “stop the war.”
It’s really that simple.
So if you hate my voice, you hate their voice.
And if you can’t stand the voices of those living the experience, then you’re probably prioritizing your narrative over truth.



































