Henry_Wong (@wong417) header
Henry_Wong (@wong417) profile picture

香港人 Hoeng1 Gong2 jan4 // Conlanger // 渠/其 // East Asian linguist with a penchant to wander afield

Hong Kong
Joined November 2019
Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)Photo by Henry_Wong (@wong417)
ain’t no way they lexicalized ‘sigma’ as a regular masculine noun bro 😭 sigmā sigme sigme sigmõ i wouldn’t be surprised if they created a feminine ‘sigmī’ out of this afterwards
The Urdu I'm gonna start speaking with bro
4
3
1
54
2,721
If you want some fun verbs to bite into, may I suggest Kiranti languages as a potential look-in For example, below is the intransitive paradigm of Sindrang Bantawa, segmental in someways but opaque in many others!
The more I dig into linguistic typology I seem to be realizing that the layout of (noun-case.number) and (verb-tense-person.number), and the concept of paradigmatic "fusionality" beyond occasional contraction is basically unattested outside of IE, Uralic, Afroasiatic and Georgian
2
15
583
And that’s just the intransitive paradigm since Kiranti verbs are sensitive to both subject and object person/number so there’s even more craziness to get into once we involve transitive verbs
1
60
I can finally go back to posting linguistics memes
so i've often mentioned that there's an unspoken rule in the field of lingustics that example sentences have to be needlessly violent. "The farmer killed the duck.", and so forth. this very common example sentence is a perfect example of how that rule could perhaps be formulated in a sort of "ease of articulation" framework, because the original sentence was "Omne homo habens asinum videt illum." ("Every man who owns a donkey sees it."), but apparently linguists were like "Nope! not violent enough, gotta add some more beatin’"
3
42
5
254
7,221
Henry_Wong retweeted
Might I also say that the map is also terribly sloppily made. Even working within the map’s focus on national languages, Myanmar’s is just wrong (Burmese is SOV) and they coloured in the Andaman and Nicobar islands as blue when it’s a part of India…
1
2
9
151
If anything it’s the reverse, SVO clusters (Southeast Asia, Europe, West Africa), SOV fills in the gaps
It's interesting that the SOV languages cluster even though they're from multiple different language families.
2
3
29
932
Might I also say that the map is also terribly sloppily made. Even working within the map’s focus on national languages, Myanmar’s is just wrong (Burmese is SOV) and they coloured in the Andaman and Nicobar islands as blue when it’s a part of India…
1
2
9
151
… and they seemingly forgot about Luxembourg
4
81
When linguists refer to word order, they are usually referring to a language’s “basic word order” which is defined as the default order a languages used in a *transitive* sentence with two *overt* *noun phrases* (not pronouns) devoid of pragmatic (eg topic or focus) prominence
Replying to @Mochimkchiking
still wrong, multiple of these languages allow for all word orders
6
11
437
8,340
**declarative I forgot to include declarative sentences since English and other European languages do bullshit with them
1
8
701
Still wrong, German and Dutch are SOV
2
9
664
There is a lot of problematicse about this definition and certainly lakes of ink have been split about why this metric’s utility is dubious at best such as such sentences being an extreme minority in spoken speech and also stuff like rhemic sentences
1
28
921
But eitherway, just be noted than when linguist say language X has ABC order, they usually already have taken into account these discrepancies (tho ofc it is always good to remain critical)
24
858
Mongolic does seem in a few ways abherrant from Turkic and Tungusic. The main ones I have noticed are: - Grammatical gender which is attested in Middle Mongol as well in some verb forms
契丹語、漢字に似た独自の文字を使っていたのにアラビア語みたいに文法的な性(男性・女性)があって、名詞の性に応じて形容詞や動詞の語形変化もあって、それが文字の表記にも反映されるのヤバすぎるだろ。
1
1
27
892
- The other one is the otherwise absence of verbal agreement. The only feature marked on Mongolic verbs appeared to have been gender which stands in stark contrast to Turkic and Tungusic
2
8
167
Granted, some of this might be due to the well known Northeast Asian phenomena of replacing finite forms with participles but in Mongol this includes even imperative, which is otherwise normally immune to this, which suggests to me that agreement may have just never existed
6
115
Henry_Wong retweeted
I say similar phonetic pathways because this precise sound change of p t > ɓ ɗ is attested elsewhere, most notably in the traditional Wu dialects in Shanghai, including, in the 19th century, the city of Shanghai itself en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jinhui…
2
4
93