David Loyn (@DavidLoyn) header
David Loyn (@DavidLoyn) profile picture

Tis nothing but a Magic Shadow-show, Played in a box whose candle is the sun, Round which we phantom figures come and go

London
Joined September 2011
Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)Photo by David Loyn (@DavidLoyn)
If you care about Afghanistan, watch this. Filmed before universities closed their doors to women. Women at War Afghanistan news.sky.com/video/women-at-…
6
27
4
85
24,426
Believe me, these visits do little to help. I worked with the UN in the 1990s and saw endless visits even then, when the problems were already clear. The same is true today. The UN has two clear priorities. 1. Implement existing UN Security Council resolutions to end the conflict through an inclusive political settlement. 2. Feed starving Afghans now and help a legitimate, inclusive government deliver basic services once it is in place. Use the money spent on these visits to feed orphans in Kabul. Now. @SR_Afghanistan @UNAMAnews @antonioguterres @AminaJMohammed
SRSG Rabab Fatima visited #Afghanistan’s Central Highlands from 2-4 Nov, where she met local communities and gained a deeper understanding of the opportunities and challenges facing communities across the region. Watch:
4
1
7
566
Stop insulting Afghans by telling us to negotiate with the Taliban. Women aren’t even considered worthy of sitting at the table. Peaceful dissent is met with imprisonment and torture. Girls are denied education. At what point do you admit that dialogue without leverage is surrender? War will be inevitable and that blood is on the hands of the Taliban and their blind supporters.
20
195
4
516
6,568
David Loyn retweeted
🗓️ Day 1,877 since the Taliban banned secondary age girls from getting an education. Their gender apartheid is destroying the hopes and dreams of millions of girls and young women. Everyone has a right to better themselves. You are not forgotten. #LetAfghanGirlsLearn #AfghanWomen
101
146
340
9,298
The essence of this is broadly correct: there has been creeping managerialism across the senior military; spreadsheet-handling gets you promoted, weapons-handling leads to enquiries; smiling along and being right in the moment rather than on the fundamentals is the necessary, performative vice. But it would be wrong to kneejerk to a reversion to pre-Levene, as that MOD was flawed too - compared to, say, the Admiralty of the 1900s, where political, financial and operational realities were squared away with a cold-eye on the genuine strategic requirements of the nation-state. We need the MOD today to resemble the Admiralty then, and that requires that cold-eyed realism to sit above the forces of all five domains and direct them in an integrated, and so coherent way. Otherwise we will continue horse-trading each service’s pipe-dreams inefficiently. The current problem is that the MOD leadership was allowed to reform itself during @JohnHealey_MP Defence Reform programme. The essential and vital changes, predictably, happened in name only, and the old structures and incentives with their associated clerisy attached still rule. It is a well-worn story: incoming administration has good intentions that get derailed by vested interests. Indeed, in many ways it has been a two-year long episode of Yes Minister. @StevenScrase
There was indeed a time when senior military commanders served a vital, unyielding constitutional function. During the Second World War, Field Marshal Alan Brooke (Chief of the Imperial General Staff) famously spent half his waking hours standing up to Winston Churchill, bluntly killing off catastrophic strategic whims with hard arithmetic. In 1982, Admiral of the Fleet Sir Terence Lewin was indispensable to Margaret Thatcher during the Falklands: providing unvarnished, lethal military counsel, establishing the War Cabinet’s operational parameters, and telling Downing Street exactly what was required to win—not what the Treasury wanted to hear. The creation of the unified Chief of the Defence Staff (CDS) role in 1959—championed by Lord Mountbatten and solidified in the 1964 creation of the unified Ministry of Defence—had an initially defensible purpose: stopping the Admiralty, War Office, and Air Ministry from fighting tribal turf wars over procurement and duplicating budgets in the Cold War nuclear era. What the role has degenerated into, however, is a corporate shock absorber for Whitehall. The decisive death blow came with the 2011 Levene Reforms. Those reforms stripped the individual service chiefs—the First Sea Lord, the Chief of the General Staff, and the Chief of the Air Staff—of their constitutional direct access to the Prime Minister. Instead, power was concentrated entirely in MoD Main Building, split between the civilian Permanent Secretary and the CDS. From that moment on, the CDS ceased to be a fighting commander and became a corporate executive in ceremonial dress: • Managing decline instead of deterrence: Rather than resigning on principle when sovereign capabilities are butchered, successive Chiefs of the Defence Staff have functioned as the Treasury’s compliance officers—signing off on shrinking the Army to 72,000, retiring frigates with no replacements, and gutting ammunition stockpiles. • The PR buffer: Their primary operational utility to Downing Street today is public relations. A politician cutting defence looks reckless; a four-star commander in gold braid sitting on a BBC sofa nodding along and calling for "efficiency and innovation" gives the cuts an institutional hall-mark. • Bureaucratic capture: They are steeped in civil service managerialism, promoted through Whitehall committee rooms rather than operational combat command, resulting in a culture where producing another glossy "Strategic Review" takes precedence over maintaining physical artillery barrels. We have created an administrative caste of peacetime generals who spend their tenures writing glossy Strategic Defence Reviews and absorbing political flak, while signing off on the hollowing out of our combat mass. If our military leadership refuses to resign on principle over an unpatrolled seabed, a hollowed-out surface fleet, and a regular army cut to 72,000, then having a Chief of the Defence Staff is purely ornamental. Abolish the Whitehall boardroom, restore independent authority to the individual service heads, and stop sending four-star managers to run PR for state failure.
16
17
7
82
9,800
David Loyn retweeted
Ahead of tomorrow’s Moscow Format meeting on Afghanistan, it is important to emphasize that no process concerning Afghanistan can be considered legitimate or sustainable without the meaningful participation and representation of Afghan women, political forces, and civil society organizations. Although many civil society actors are now dispersed around the world, they remain deeply engaged with Afghanistan and continue to contribute to its political, social, and humanitarian future. We hope the discussions will move beyond immediate concerns and project based approaches to address the central political question which is how to establish a credible and inclusive process that can restore constitutional order, pave the way for a government grounded in the will of the people of Afghanistan and ensure the full restoration of women’s rights and participation. Afghanistan needs a political process that reflects the voices, aspirations, and diversity of its people. The international community should likewise complement its project based engagement with sustained support for a genuine political process capable of addressing Afghanistan’s fundamental governance and legitimacy challenges. Only through an inclusive, nationally grounded, and equal and dignified political process can Afghanistan become a legitimate and sustainable partner in regional and international engagement. @Bahrami1962 @AmbassadorSadiq @RusEmbassyKabul @uzbekmfa @MOFA_Tajikistan @TC_KabilBE @HakanFidan @FM_Saidov @SMirziyoyeva
6
20
1
90
5,273
David Loyn retweeted
“The U.S. State Department has urged private companies interested in conducting business in Afghanistan to exercise utmost caution, as the "Taliban remain on the list of global terrorist groups." International companies doing business with the Taliban should also take note.
وزارت خارجه امریکا از شرکت‌های خصوصی که علاقمند فعالیت‌های تجاری در افغانستان‌اند خواست با نهایت احتیاط عمل کنند زیرا «طالبان همچنان در فهرست گروه‌های تروریستی جهانی قرار دارند». یک سخنگوی این وزارتخانه به رادیو آروپای آزاد گفت شرکت‌ها اطمینان حاصل کنند که معاملات‌شان با قوانین و مقررات قابل اجرای ایالات متحده مطابقت دارد.» این اظهارات در حالی انجام شد که سفر زلمی خلیلزاد، فرستاده ویژه پیشین امریکا به افغانستان در آستانه بیست‌وپنجمین سالگرد حملات ۱۱ سپتامبر، واکنش‌های حساس و بحث‌برانگیزی برانگیخته است. این سفر شامل دیدار با مقام‌های ارشد طالبان و حضور در مراسم امضای یک توافق بزرگ نفت و گاز بود. سخنگوی وزارت خارجه امریکا پس از این رویداد به افغانستان اینترنشنال گفت: «خلیل‌زاد کارمند دولت امریکا نیست. بنابراین، او نماینده دولت ایالات متحده نیست.» afintl.com/202609126914
3
874
David Loyn retweeted
Since the Taliban occupation in 2021, many have warned about this: “A quarter-century later — al-Qaeda is again operating training camps in Afghanistan, according to U.S. and Western intelligence and a United Nations organization responsible for monitoring terror networks.”
Al-Qaeda’s plans for the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks took root in compounds in Afghanistan that served as terrorist training camps. A quarter-century later, al-Qaeda is again operating training camps in Afghanistan, according to Western intelligence officials. wapo.st/4r4MBrv
1
3
853
Taliban apologists can deny this as much as they like. But the evidence is overwhelming: Afghanistan is once again the global HQ for al-Qaeda. See UN reporting: docs.un.org/en/S/2025/796
🚨 #Important_Clarification 🚫Claim: The Washington Post has claimed that al-Qaeda has regrouped in Afghanistan and established at least eight training camps over the past three years. ✅Fact: This claim is baseless and completely false. There is no group in Afghanistan that poses a threat to the security of other countries. Afghanistan assures all countries around the world that its territory will never be used against any country, and that Afghanistan will not pose a threat to the security of any other nation.
2
7
1
13
2,997
Yesterday, a meeting was held at the Taliban embassy in Qatar regarding 9/11. Speakers emphasized that true progress is not constructing buildings and roads, but shaping the Muslim mindset against infidels. This shows the Taliban and Al-Qaeda still pursue the same ideology.
3
11
2
66
10,439
IT’S OVER DUTY. “The Afghanistan United Front (AUF), have had their campaign blessed in a fatwa by a large group of Afghan Islamic clerics and scholars, who question the religious legitimacy of the Taliban.” Read more from @DavidLoyn @spectator Link: spectator.com/article/we-ris…
5
21
1
69
3,352
I helped start Afghan diplomacy with the Taliban in 2009—Taliban don’t do diplomacy They’ve been offered diplomatic solutions since 2001 —they don’t care You are legitimizing their illegitimate regime They only want international recognition-but they wont change to get it
This quoted post is unavailable.
8
12
1
47
4,191
David Loyn retweeted
This. 💔
We went inside a secret school in Afghanistan, where more than 30 girls risk being arrested for gathering in the basement of a private home to continue their education under Taliban rule. As we were leaving, their teacher handed CBS New's @ImtiazTyab 21 letters the girls wrote by hand for us. They called them “Letters to the World.” The girls poured their hopes, fears and dreams onto those pages, knowing they might never get the chance to share them with the outside world themselves. They wrote about the education they lost, the futures they still dream of and their simple wish to live freely as girls. They trusted us to carry their voices beyond that basement. And we promised them we would. These are their voices, in their own words. To read all 21 letters: cbsn.ws/4cGAdbj
1
3
1,740
یک مسئولیت ملی در برابر همه جبهات مخالف طالبان: ما هر روز شاهد نشر ویدیوهای عملیات نظامی علیه طالبان هستیم. ومردم افغانستان از تمام نیروهاسپاسگزاری می‌کنند. در کنار آن پیشنهاد می‌کنیم . که علمیات های نمادین پرچم ملی نیز در داخل افغانستان جدی گرفته شود. پرچم افغانستان در نقاط شاخص و قابل دید مردم برافراشته و ترسیم شود . و ویدیوهای آن با مردم شریک ساخته شود. مهم‌ترین بخش این عملیات ها واکنش طالبان است. طالبان پرچم ملی را پایین میاورند پاره میکنند و به آن بی‌احترامی میکنند. مردم داخل افغانستان خود شاهد خواهند بود و همین واکنش می‌تواند مخالفان را متحدتر و امید مردم به آزادی را بیشتر کند. @AmrullahSaleh2 @genyasinzia @AhmadMassoud @sayedsamisadat
5
2
1
47
2,150
David Loyn retweeted
General Donahue was one of the best US Generals and a Brother to me, wishing you all the very best in the next steps the world is s big place and needs good leaders like General Donahue. @CDonahue1792 nytimes.com/2026/09/06/us/po…
11
19
3
120
9,482
David Loyn retweeted
In the past 100 years Afghan Ulema’s issued two Fatwas one to take independence in 1919, second to retake our independence from the Soviet occupation in 1980 and now the third one to restore our freedom! We here at AUF got the call and YES we will fight in your name for the cause ordained by our God!
Replying to @afgunitedfront
Taliban so-called religious scholars and Mullahs have distorted Islamic law as they issue orders outside the permission of the Quran. The leader of the Taliban issues orders from his own desires, not from the direction bestowed by God, thinking his own orders superior to those of God. It is Shirk to doubt the oneness of God.
30
35
1
159
17,044
"The biggest misconception about Afghanistan is that many people around the world see social media images or videos shared by foreign tourists showing peaceful streets, busy markets, or historic landmarks and conclude that life in Afghanistan is normal. The reality for Afghan women is completely different." buff.ly/xmirN6t
2
11
1
13
4,013
David Loyn retweeted
Women are mindless ?This isn't isolated ignorance; it is the Taliban’s foundational doctrine. Reducing women to subhuman status exposes the regime's inherent illegitimacy. A system fundamentally built on gender apartheid cannot survive its own structural contradictions.
فوزيه كوفي گفته است: با گفتن زن بي عقل است: حتما مادران شما بي عقل بوده كه فرزنداني مثل شما را به دنيا اورده و چنين تربيت كرده… در غير ان اولين استاد انسان مادر است.
2
4
22
2,458