Lurking Commissar (@NeoPolemology) header
Lurking Commissar (@NeoPolemology) profile picture

Polemologist, gastronome, operational art aficionado, reads doctrine and SFF, opinions not to be taken too seriously. Not the fun kind. Twitter used for IPB.

I don’t even know anymore
Joined October 2013
Lurking Commissar retweeted
There is some obvious overlap between position & attrition; but even when 18th-c. operational dynamics resembled the Western Front—long, continuously-fortified fronts—its logic was not attritional, but focused on breaking into the enemy’s undefended rear. teapaw.org/bazaarofwar/status/175…
The Northern Front: Trench Warfare in the 18th Century The War of the Spanish Succession saw fighting along fortified lines over 100 km long, with striking tactical and operational similarities to WW1's Western Front. dispatch.bazaarofwar.com/p/t…
1
3
24
1,621
Lurking Commissar retweeted
But the think tankers of course still remain fond of using the term "Realist" because it makes them feel like the gritty old curmudgeon in the corner of the bar who is the only one who truly understands what's going on. It's a statement about aesthetics more than policy.
3
4
334
Lurking Commissar retweeted
Anybody with a Ph.D. in a bookish field, such as literature, theology, philosophy, or history OUGHT to be well-educated enough to teach (sometimes with some extra reading in preparation) a general Great Books course in an undergraduate core curriculum. I am well aware that many aren't, but they ought to be. (Is it not odd to expect our freshmen students to learn what we don’t expect our faculty to already know?)
26
32
15
427
58,251
The landing of A Company, North Shore Regiment on Juno Beach on D-Day on June 6, 1944 in France during WWII.
38
591
38
2,179
56,718
Lurking Commissar retweeted
Every war is a genocide if the defender is your ideological enemy and the attacker is a violent non-state actor that sheds its uniforms and embeds in densely built-up areas behind human shields. That’s the new critical school of genocide in a nutshell. It does not require specific intent to destroy a protected group as such in any Conventional sense. Intent is inferred from the structure and process of foreseeably destructive effects. It does not need to be the only reasonable inference. It only needs to be predictable enough, destructive enough and politically opposed enough to be read back from the outcome. In short, it just needs to be notably and foreseeably destructive and carried out by the country you disagree with or dislike.
2
16
1
42
945
Lurking Commissar retweeted
Canada imported a LOT of European immigrants after WWII who had regressive ideas on Jews. But it was made very clear to them that the price of admission to Canada was taking these views to the grave. The modern-day immigrant from the Islamic world, by contrast, encounters whole university departments endorsing every single Jew-hating grievance fantasy they can imagine.
97
341
36
2,162
101,555
Lurking Commissar retweeted
Replying to @clashreport
Oh? I find it morally sickening when supposed intellectuals use their platforms to provide cover for an adversary of the U.S. while it’s engaged in a war of aggression and threatening nuclear escalation.
11
26
2
433
10,547
Lurking Commissar retweeted
Given the demonic realities of October 7th, Israel acted with considerable restraint in its Gaza campaign, and should be commended for it.
Hamas forced sexual torture between family members on Oct. 7, investigation finds: 'You hear the screams and then silence' trib.al/OYTIovz
324
1,314
37
7,238
178,080
Lurking Commissar retweeted
If you want to know why all the deeply silly “dog rape” stories were published this week, it’s because the paid pro-Palestinian influencer squad were ordered to get ahead of this, genuine horror story.
592
4,906
251
14,311
354,914
Lurking Commissar retweeted
Can confirm, over 14 years in the Marine Corps, mostly in special operations, and I’ve never seen a Totenkopf tattoo on a Marine, ever. Platner pointing to Scout Sniper lightning bolts is misdirection. Platner was not a sniper and his tattoo is from concentration camp guards.
Re. Graham Platner and his Nazi tattoo: I knew more than a few infantrymen with tattoos. But I didn’t know any who had a tattoo honoring Nazi concentration camp guards like Platner. Graham Platner is a lying fraud.
50
622
13
3,623
247,872
Lurking Commissar retweeted
Yes. I sat down with Lt Gen John Coll last year (with whom I served in the Army) following his fact finding visit to Israel, and he confirmed from extensive personal observation that the IDF were much more impressive at avoiding collateral casualties than the British or American armies.
“The IDF have sought, albeit imperfectly, to minimise casualties. Hamas has worked to maximise them.” It’s as simple and as terrible as that. Brilliant piece.
21
90
6
442
25,373
Lurking Commissar retweeted
A student today at my elite university admitted to me today that she took a class so she could work on reading for more than 20 minutes at a time. She can't read. She mainly skims and summarizes, she says and still gets A's. This student is, by professional standards, illiterate. Gonna have high GPA when she graduates. This conversation was had after 6 of 22 students dropped my course because the maximum reading per week in one week was over 100 pages. What people aren't grasping is that this is literally *dangerous*. These people are going to be come doctors, engineers, etc. They are - by any metric - vastly less capable than prior generations. These effects are cumulative over a lifetime. This grade inflation is part of the problem, but not even close to the entirety. And the problem obviously starts in K-12. Students don't know history because, you can't actually become historically literate on the advice of 'never assign more than 30 pages a week'. You can't develop any of the skills that came with literacy. This is, quite honestly, a civilizational catastrophe.
79% of grades at Yale are A-range. Graduating summa cum laude requires a record high GPA OF 3.98.
510
3,180
398
20,335
3,228,537
In less than 5 days, Canada has seen 5 shootings plus several acts of vandalism against synagogues and Jewish-owned businesses. Prime Minister Mark Carney took time from combating Islamophobia to give this official statement:
210
726
38
2,071
35,302
Lurking Commissar retweeted
“Conservatism starts from a sentiment that all mature people can readily share: the sentiment that good things are easily destroyed, but not easily created.” Sir Roger Scruton
104
865
121
4,634
599,238
Lurking Commissar retweeted
“In 100 years we have gone from teaching Latin and Greek in high school to teaching remedial English in college.” Despite all the obsession with STEM things are no better on the math side .
494
2,844
219
15,416
325,427
Lurking Commissar retweeted
There is no moral equivalence. It is a fundamental error of framework to compare a civilian law-enforcement response to an active shooter in a kindergarten, governed by domestic criminal law, to combat operations in war, governed by the law of armed conflict and rooted in just war theory. War is judged by distinction, proportionality, military necessity, and feasible precautions, not by zero-casualty policing standards. This distinction matters because it explains outcomes. It is why Israel could conduct decisive operations against Hezbollah in southern Lebanon, where civilians were largely able to evacuate and the battlespace allowed separation of fighters from the population, but cannot operate in Gaza under the same conditions against Hamas, which embeds itself deliberately within dense civilian terrain. Confusing these frameworks does not clarify morality. It erases it. @ShawnRyan762
Replying to @ShawnRyan762
@ShawnRyan762 and John debate whether Israel or Hamas has the moral culpability for civilian casualties in the Middle East.
33
166
4
810
44,276
Lurking Commissar retweeted
If we're going to have any seriousness in this discussion, there has to be some recognition that activists said pre-war Gaza was "an open air prison" and now cast it as an idyll that was inexplicably destroyed after 7 October, where nobody seems to remember what happened.
When we still had a life… Gaza before October 7. Every time I pass by this image, I wish I had not lived to see this day. This city, the dearest to my heart—I would not have survived after this pain. The whole world is celebrating the end of the year, while Gaza is marking the end of life on its ruins. Give Gaza back to us, you lovers of destruction and death. 💔🇵🇸🥲
25
162
8
941
54,376