Pinned Tweet
One popular terf study sourced its transfem ppts from poverty stricken sex workers in the favelas, many of whom's only form of HRT was bumming their friends' spare bc pills, and it concluded that trans women retain male advantage in sport because hrt doesn't suppress testosterone
Replying to @Spinny_3000
If you argue that medical transition eventually eliminates the advantage from T, they respond with studies with findings of "skeletal advantage" (tall) and "increased muscle mass" (height -> volume -> mass), and surely you aren't claiming there's no difference at all?
Bae Blade retweeted
This is absolutely insane. The free internet is dead if a state court can pull a website offline worldwide simply because the registry for its domain is based in the United States.
That puts the world’s access to information at the mercy of state lawmakers and judges—in this case, in Texas.
Should Texas get to dictate what content the whole world can access on the open internet?
Of course not.
And I assume Texans would say the same if Russia, China, or even Australia claimed the same authority.
A Travis County judge just froze a web domain worldwide.
Not by blocking it in Texas, but by ordering Verisign to lock the .com domain itself so it resolves for no one on earth until a foreign company posts a $9.14 million bond and builds Texas-mandated digital ID check.
That's a single state court with a global kill switch.
AG Paxton calls it a "huge precedent." He’s right.
Bae Blade retweeted
this is very obviously them openly advocating for trans women and pointing out how fucked up the bills are and their double standards at immense personal risk. why are you framing it as if theyre the ones causing the problem.
Bae Blade retweeted
“I remember thinking, ‘If I don’t do exactly what I’m told for the next minute of my life, I’m going to die right now.'"
• A tactical vehicle slammed through Autumn Hill’s front entryway.
• FBI agents threw flash-bang grenades through the windows.
• She heard screams from other rooms.
• Police flew a quadcopter drone through the splintered doorway.
• A voice from the drone ordered residents to come out with their hands up.
• Hill edged out of the door and faced a wall of gun barrels.
• Masked agents screamed orders as the drone buzzed behind her.
More: rollingstone.com/politics/po…
Incarcerated for Life in Trump’s War on the Left
Autumn Hill had already gone home when a protest outside an ICE facility in Texas turned violent.
She was still sentenced to 50 years in prison, over twice as long as any Jan. 6 defendant.
Story: rollingstone.com/politics/po…
Bae Blade retweeted
imo there is some utility to situationally using these arguments - like the bathroom argument here - but as a resident of the UK i can tell you the results of allowing ourselves to be softly third-sexed and the results are very very bad
Bae Blade retweeted
i need the couple dozen cis people who follow me to understand that cassie, ari drennen, and dr laura produce content primarily for liberal, cis audiences. they’re not grifters but they are strongly incentivized to tell you what you want to hear.
they’re great resources if you’re just looking to learn about trans people - transsex women are a grouchy bunch and regrettably not many of us have the patience to educate cis people.
but if your goal is to take the pulse of the transfem community on a particular topic, you’re not going to get an accurate reading just by listening to those three.
Bae Blade retweeted
as a British trans woman, this is very unconvincing to me
most of the transphobia from legislators here has been couched in this faux respectful liberalism
Bae Blade retweeted
i get the political thinking here, but legally, this "we respect you and you are protected from discrimination" angle is precisely how the uk supreme court nuked trans people's rights
Bae Blade retweeted
I understand the impulse behind this argument, but it has two major flaws:
1) trans people taking the 'wrong approach' is not why transphobia has exploded
2) live and let live arguments barely work, and even to the extent they do, they are extremely fragile and so short lived
New, from me in @TheArgumentMag today: we need to move away from “respect me!” politics on trans rights, and towards an ethic of pluralistic tolerance.
Bae Blade retweeted
IMO Woke 1 really starts after the Obama 2012 victory because it was a mobilization-rather-than-persuasion victory. He lost the white vote by 20(!) points, lost the South, still won comfortably.
There was a great deal written about how this dominating coalition of minorities + urban/educated whites, with particularly good margins among young voters, was just the beginning of a long-term trend that would deliver, if not something quite as a durable and long-lived as the New Deal coalition, then close to it.
Dems needed to simply sit back and let demography work its magic, in time turning Sunbelt states reliably blue (even Texas would fall soon enough...), while older white voters high in racial resentment died out and new younger, diverse, progressive voters took their place.
This deranged absolutely everyone. On the Right, it led to a panicked abandonment of democratic principles altogether, and investment in a political movement that was premised on establishing and entrenching permanent GOP rule by hook or by crook--while simultaneously trying to reverse the demographic tide that was sure to overwhelm them (through e.g. stemming new immigration). I really believe their derangement was less about Obama himself being Black, and much more about their sense that the *electorate* could now overrule the supermajority preferences of the white vote--something wholly unprecedented in American political history. No one had won a national election while losing the white vote by 20 before. THAT is what made them go insane.
On the broad Left (meaning center-left Dems, liberals, progressives, and the actual Left, which was just starting to reemerge as a genuine force thanks to social media allowing heterodox beliefs to flourish amidst the collapse of the liberal elite's cultural hegemony), this deranged us in a mirror image of the Right: we, too, could abandon the arduous and persuasive work of democracy, and let our demographic destiny carry us into the brighter future. No more pandering to Bubba. Fuck Bubba! We could finally say it! No more of this humiliating Clintonian two-step to appease or at least anesthetize Middle American chuds. We could just fucking steamroll them with our Coalition of the Ascendant.
This, combined with the simultaneous rise of social media platforms as this urgently-contested space for normative cultural power, focused our energies inward: we'd won the Culture War, so now it was time to fight over who got to administer Cultural Reconstruction. The Chuds were doomed, powerless, flailing and moronic (just look at their flight to increasingly absurd and laughable figures like Trump!), and we would get to impose the new order over their Oxycontin-addled complaints. What, then, would that new order *be*? Who would run it? What would they accomplish?
What you see here is a parallel abandonment of basic democratic principles of persuasion and coalition-building; on the Right, the fascist drive to entrench themselves in unaccountable minority rule (clearly the much more serious and evil threat, particularly in a country where the Constitution makes this entirely feasible), and on the Left an intra-elite competition to see who would be in charge of this new coalition that could finally dispense with the debasing and grimy work of mass politics and persuasion.
Of course, we turned out to be completely wrong. Looking at the Obama coalition and projecting it out linearly into the future was a bad idea for many reasons--including that it was pretty tenuous to assume the massive turnout and insane margins among minority voters for the First Black President would simply reappear on demand for any Democrat--and it led to a lot of bad assumptions.
We ended up with a discourse that was honed for internal competition, and relied extensively on social pressure and ostracism--but in a modern, liberal democracy where people can simply leave your political community if they don't like it. And a lot of people did; we successfully ostracized them out of respectable liberal or progressive/leftist institutions and communities, and so they just found new homes on the Right.
And it turned out, of course, that minority groups are not just identity hive-minds which reliably allocate the same proportion of votes to one party or the other independent of any other concerns. "The Black vote," "the Hispanic vote"--even "the youth vote" turned out to be malleable, dependent on candidate quality, economic concerns, ideological fit, just like any other group of voters.
Trump 1 didn't really break the spell because it felt like a fluky, unlucky nightmare. He didn't win the popular vote, the margin was razor-thin in the midwestern Blue Wall, and Hillary was a bad candidate--and despite all that, Dems retained near-Obama margins with voters of color and young voters. Surely, the Coalition of the Ascendant was still on track; this was just a speedbump.
The closeness of the 2020 election and then Trump 2 (with his popular-vote win and the apparent "racial depolarization" of the electorate) fully shattered this narrative. Instead, people remembered we would in fact have to do politics. We would in fact have to compete for people's votes, and persuade them to share our values--and the articulation of those values in policies and behaviors. The center responded to this, as they usually do, by offering immediate capitulation wherever possible to chase the median voter (the center is actually quite bad at persuasion; their response to disagreement is generally to just concede and beg, rather than any attempt to move the audience towards their own positions).
The Left responded, thankfully, by showing a great deal of maturation--away from subcultural/counter-cultural criticism and attempts to pressure elites into adopting our values through social pressure campaigns, instead moving towards actual mass politics. DSA has proven this can work, and is working, even if we are still quite early.
We would be insane to retreat from that lesson; instead we have to double down on it. That's what Woke 2 needs to be--not cynical abdication of values/principles to chase the median voter, but a genuine persuasive attempt to build a Left mass politics. But persuasion, by definition, requires talking to people *who do not yet agree with you*. You can't *persuade* someone who is already *on your side*. It requires enticement, intellectual and emotional empathy (for people you really might dislike, and for legitimate reasons!), and discipline. It is not nearly so satisfying and immediate as putting people in the public stocks of social media for collective humiliation. It is not as simple as imposing your will over the objections of those who don't agree with you.
It requires a certain kind of humility--not "the voters rejected our ideas so we have to get new ideas"; you can still authentically believe what you believe--but a humility about *power*, and about *democracy*. You have to recognize that "I don't have the power to just impose my ideology; and frankly it's good that I don't, because democratic legitimacy is itself an intrinsic good and if we cultivate a democratic mass politics of the Left, that will be more durable and innovative and resistant to attack than anything imposed from above."
Bae Blade retweeted
New study finds no clear physical advantage for transgender women over cisgender women in sports.
A major review challenges the claim that transgender women hold a clear physical edge in women’s sports.
After pooling results from 52 studies and thousands of participants, researchers in Brazil reported that transgender women had greater lean mass than cisgender women, but not greater physical capacity.
Across the data they examined, they found no meaningful differences in upper-body strength, lower-body strength, or aerobic fitness between the two groups after hormone therapy.
That does not settle the political fight. It does, however, narrow the scientific one.
The paper, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, reviewed research on body composition and physical fitness in transgender people receiving gender-affirming hormone therapy. In their analysis, they covered 6,099 individuals overall. This included 2,566 transgender women, 2,646 transgender men, 442 cisgender women and 445 cisgender men. Forty-two studies were included in the meta-analysis.
Transgender women, the central result was striking in its contrast. Lean mass remained higher than in cisgender women, yet the performance measures most often cited in sports arguments did not show an advantage.
“This refutes the logic behind blanket bans on transgender women in sports,” said Bruno Gualano, a physician and researcher at the University of São Paulo in Brazil who co-authored the study. “Most of these policies are based on the assumption that transgender women retain inherent physical advantages and would therefore dominate women’s competitions. The data does not support this idea.”
The review found that transgender women had higher absolute lean mass than cisgender women, but similar relative lean mass.
It found no significant differences in upper-body strength, lower-body strength, or maximum oxygen consumption, a standard measure of cardiorespiratory fitness.
The authors also looked at how hormone therapy changed the body over time. In transgender women, one year of therapy was associated with increased fat mass, reduced lean mass, and lower upper-body strength. Over one to three years, the pattern pointed in the same direction, though not every measure could be tracked across every time span.
The paper argues that this matters because sports rules often treat muscle mass as a stand-in for performance. The new review suggests that assumption may be too simple.
thebrighterside.news/post/ne…
Bae Blade retweeted
sorry I only have one non binary friend to represent transgender and he I mean they are biblically chopped . Like it’s not my Fault I domt have access to queer community don’t be mad at me :(
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
Bae Blade retweeted
interesting case study in Solidarity Against Trans Women where TME queers in the quotes are calling her a narcissistic monster for thinking this piece has anything to do with her while transmisogynistic cls people go “lmfao that’s what all tr4nnies look like”
Bae Blade retweeted
Basically an admission it was never about toilets, or women's safety. Just getting rid of trans people.
This is a demand to tell vulnerable, dysphoric, often suicidal kids they have no future if they transition.
It's direct pressure on parents to stop supporting their kids.
Bae Blade retweeted
slowly realising when u ppl talk about intersectionality u think it means certain social identities outrank others in this "ladder" of oppression instead of compounding to create an experience unique to that individual & therefore cannot be understood by isolating single factors
Bae Blade retweeted
White TME queers using the spectre of the “white trans woman” to launder their transmisogyny does not mean that any critique of the role whiteness plays in the trans community should be automatically shut down.
Every trans person knows how aggravating it is to have a cis person dismissively believe they understand what it's like to face structural anti-trans oppression, and think that belonging to some other minority exempts them from responsibility for it.
Same principle!
Replying to @DomainDead
I’ve spoken extensively about this but your struggle as a trans person isn’t a competition for oppression. You can be trans and still benefit from being white. You cannot understand what it’s like to face the same structural oppression as a POC, ESPECIALLY a trans person of color
1
1
315











































