
Serial victim of Bluetooth. Finder of problems. Mastodon deets: ∙ @gingerbbm@boing.world ∙ https://teapaw.org/t.co/eIJb75TpVW
Joined August 2020
- Tweets814
- Following393
- Followers43
- Likes2.6K
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
Trillion dollar idea: a machine that breaks other machines. But it also causes unemployment. But it also breaks the spirit of artists. But it also convinces you not to take your medication. But it's also very vulnerable to being stolen by spies, depending on how horny you are.
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
I don't think I'm doing a good job communicating my view, so I will try to do better in this post.
My view is shaped by over 15 years of writing about fashion (including the effects of fast fashion), reading @wdavidmarx's book "Status and Culture," and private conversations with technologist @quintendf. I will incorporate each of these influences as I make my argument.
Let's put AI aside for now and talk about fashion, where I have better footing. We can start with a basic question: why were slim-fit pants considered good in the early 2000s, but bad today? The simple answer is because fashion moves through a lifecycle.
In the early 2000s, wearing slim-fit pants signaled that you were on the edge of culture. Perhaps you bucked gender norms, read Details Magazine, and drew inspiration from youthful European fashions. After all, this was a time when designers like Hedi Slimane and Raf Simons sent ectomorphic models marching down the runway in skin-tight clothes. And nands like The Strokes and The Libertines gave the style cultural relevance.
Over time, the meaning of that look changed as it spread through the market. In the early 2000s, skin-tight pants looked cool because they signaled gender rebellion and rock-and-roll. But as it got mainstreamed through Mad Men and J. Crew, it became increasingly normalized and sanitized. Today, it represents the opposite of what it did in the early 2000s — gender conformity, out of touch, corporate drone. Also whatever Andrew Tate represents.
This is the basic dynamic that drives fashion forward: people with low cultural capital copy people with high cultural capital, and then people with high cultural capital move on to distinguish themselves. This dynamic has been observed and remarked upon for hundreds of years, including by Bernard Mandeville (1714), Georg Simmel (1902), and Pierre Bourdieu (1979).
This is why we're seeing a swing back towards baggier pants. People who put a lot of effort into improving their cultural capital don't want to look like everyday office drones, political interns, or Andrew Tate.
Although, many astute fashion writers have remarked on a backlash to the backlash. Prada recently sent models back on the runway in slim-fit pants, probably because every male fashion influencer on Instagram nowadays is wearing the same look (e.g., cropped top, big pants, 70s hairstyle).
Now let's look at the fast fashion industry. Fast fashion isn't bad just because the clothing is low quality. It's bad because it speeds up the trend cycle. In the distant past (say, pre-20th century), styles used to last at least a generation, if not more, because production was slow and information moved slowly across geography. Over the 20th century, as fashion went from bespoke to ready-to-wear, the production cycle sped up. By the end of the century, a look would still last maybe a decade before it got old.
Today, developments in information technology and supply chain management have made it possible for a company to rip a look off the runway and put it into their stores before the original designer even has a chance to monetize their creation. So the criticism of companies like Shein, Zara, and H&M isn't just that they make crappy clothes (which they do), but that the minute you buy something, you realize the trend is already over. The people you tried to copy have already moved on, so you have to copy the next thing. Plus, as this copying process accelerates, designs can get more jumbled and ugly. Oh, double riders and fleece are trending? Let's make fleece double riders. It doesn't matter if it looks like ass — the thing won't stick around in the market long anyway.
In his book Status and Culture, @wdavidmarx talks about how people's pursuit of status moves culture forward. Much of the book draws from varoius fields, such as sociology, anthropology, media studies, and the like. But then the last part of the book deals with something curious: Why can various fashions define previous decades, but things have not changed much since the 1990s? Indeed, I would argue that the last big innovation in menswear happened in the 1980s/ 90s with Japanese designers like Yohji Yamamoto and Issey Mikaye. Menswear has been backwards looking every since — never forward.
Every era in the past had a distinct fashion. The 1960s had Mods and the Peacock Revolution, the 1970s had hippies and bohemian dress, the 1980s had power suits and the return of prep. Yet, if you watch a 1990s episode of Friends ... we kind of still dress the same. Yes, the silhouettes have changed a little, but the styles are mostly identical.
Marx suggests this is because status games mostly play out online, where cool things can become uncool in a matter of hours. As a result, nothing really takes hold, so we get fleeting fads instead of era-defining trends. Think of what happens with memes. Something starts funny, and then a corporation's social account uses it to seem relevant. Then the meme is decidedly uncool.
I once had a conversation with @quintendf about this. He suggested that we might be approaching a period where creative people seek to do things off the internet. Maybe that means returning to zines and cassette tapes that are passed around through a dub of a dub. Or maybe it's sensory experiences you can only have in person. During our conversation, I said that for this to happen, we need affordable housing in densely populated areas so creative people can interact with each other offline. And not feel pressured to maximize their income by selling themselves online.
Which brings us back to AI. That Yung Lean video originally went viral because people found it moving. I remember reposting it on Twitter, which led several people to question whether I was secretly paid behind the scenes to do so (I wasn't, as I don't do paid tweets). To me, their questioning only underscores how natural that viral moment was—the video moved lots of people, so they shared it on their socials.
Now that it has been endlessly copied in such trite, meaningless ways, the visual effect feels ever hollower. It has become a meme. As one person put it, "I now cringe when I see it."
If we look back on history, we can see distinct creative movements in art, music, furniture design, fashion, architecture, and more. Neoclassicism led to Romanticism; Art Deco eventually led to mid-century modernism; big-band swing music led to bebop. These movements all follow a familiar formula: a zeitgeist led to a backlash, which created yet another zeitgeist.
How can we have a creative zeitgeist when nothing is allowed to take hold? When every visual language is so easily replicated through AI tools and turned into memes? When visual language speeds from cool to cliché and then gets used by people with low cultural capital?
This is what I meant when I said that AI may contribute to our cultural stagnation. The issue isn't whether AI detracts from the original work. Indeed, it can elevate the original artist and bring them more attention. The question is whether this is good for people who care about creative integrity for its own sake — outside of notions of monetary rewards or fame. And whether this is good for culture.
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
🇨🇦 CANADIAN SHOPPING GUIDE 🇨🇦
Want to support Canadian companies? Here are some Canadian businesses that sell high quality menswear. Some also carry womenswear. 🧵
"people often romanticize forms of exclusivity while failing to recognize that their own access depends on the democratization they deplore" bravo!
I think this stems from two things, both of which go well beyond what we tell people to wear at airports.
First, people love to look down upon the masses as though they're not part of the group. For instance, men who are into traditional men's tailoring often lament the fall of Brooks Brothers, the oldest traditional men's clothier in the United States. Brothers Brothers is the company that put American men in sack suits, Oxford cloth button-downs, Shetland sweaters, rep striped ties, and penny loafers. Today we call that "Ivy Style."
During the first half of the 20th century, Brooks Brothers mostly dressed that upwardly mobile class of Americans who saw their fortunes rise with industrial capitalism. Until 1971, they operated eleven stores across the United States, all in urban, cosmopolitan centers such as Manhattan, Chicago, Philadelphia, Boston, and San Francisco. But starting in the early 1980s, the company went through a series of acquisitions, each time by an entity that wanted to make a profit on its investment by growing the business.
This meant expanding Brooks Brothers' retail footprint. The company went from having 11 stores in 1971 to 155 stores in 2001. By the time the company filed for bankruptcy in 2020, it operated 250 stores in the United States alone — half of them outlets.
This expansion meant the company had to keep watering down its offering to pay for its real estate. Instead of sticking to the sack suits and Shetland knits that enthusiasts love (and defined Old Money style), they increasingly followed trends. On their website today, they sell stretch polos, "performance" zips, and "dress sneakers." I don't fault them for that; it's what you need to do if you want to run a large clothing company.
However, many people who lament the fall of Brooks Brothers today don't recognize that they came into the store during this expansion. Without the expansion, they would have never had a Brooks Brothers location near them in the first place. Their involvement with the company as customers is part of the story of why Brooks Brothers isn't what it was before 1980.
I think the same is true of air travel. American writer and commentator Paul Fussell is best known for coining the term "prole gap" to describe a collar gap (when a tailored jacket's collar lifts from your neck). I don't like the term because I think it needlessly frames a tailoring issue as a matter of socio-economic class. He carried this snobbery into his other writing, such as his 1980 book "Abroad: British Literary Traveling Between the Wars," a literary-critical history of travel writing.
In this book, he treats the modern traveler as some unwashed animal, a degraded successor to the more "respectable" characters of the past (such as "gentleman travelers" and explorers, who came from the upper classes). I think it's perfectly fine to be snobbish and smug — God knows that I am, but at least I have no illusions about my class position. Fussell, the son of a schoolteacher in Pasadena, California, and an alum of Pomona College, seems unaware that he can travel for the same reason other "proles" can — it's more affordable now.
Whenever I see someone on here lamenting that air travel isn't like it was in the 1950s, I wonder why they don't just pay what it cost back then to travel, which would afford them a more premium experience. It seems that people often romanticize forms of exclusivity while failing to recognize that their own access depends on the democratization they deplore.
The second reason this debate comes up so often stems from a deeper conviction: the idea that people will behave better if they dressed like the bourgeoisie of the 20th century. Or, at least, some remnants of that look, such as a button-up shirt with tailored trousers or chinos (but ditching the parts that actually made the look appealing, like the tailored jacket and necktie).
Some of this is rooted in class prejudice, but some is rooted in what psychologists call "enclothed cognition," the idea that people can behave differently when they're made to wear certain clothes. For instance, some studies found people more analytical when they wore white lab coats. However, the literature is contested, with questions about replication and robustness.
I'm not totally convinced this applies to airport debate, as it's not clear to me that people will behave more courteously if they're wearing jeans or chinos, rather than sweatpants. A friend who works as a wedding photographer revels in telling me stories about how people get into fistfights at weddings — and these are suited guests.
But regardless, if the issue is about behaving courteously, it seems that proper behavior is to treat everyone respectfully, regardless of what they're wearing. That means policing your own behavior and not treating others with contempt simply because they're wearing something you don't like. Taking a photo of a fellow air traveler and posting it online for others to mock them seems like the very definition of rude and discourteous behavior. One wonders what the photographer was wearing and if they would have behaved better if they were made to wear a suit.
I think it's fine to wear whatever you want when traveling, whether that's sweatpants or a suit. Mindful, courteous behavior is always good, such as not putting your feet on someone's armrest and being polite to service staff. To me, these issues should not be conflated with dress; they should be address directly.
27
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
Love @gilescoren on the “bronze final”
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
In adults, limiting smartphone functionality to texting and calls and blocking all social media and mobile internet for 2 weeks significantly improved attention, self-reported well-being and mental health. 90% of participants experienced a benefit.
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
Shout out to everyone who takes the back off the remote control and rolls the batteries around instead of just replacing them.
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
Really like this project by Ari Versluis and Ellie Uyttenbroek. Titled Exactitudes, it's a series of portraits stretching back 20 years that shows how people style themselves to show they're part of a group and unique individual within that group.
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
Can anyone confirm if this is real?
Can relate.
I don’t want to connect my coffee machine to the wifi network. I don’t want to share the file with OneDrive. I don’t want to download an app to check my car’s fluid levels. I don’t want to scan a QR code to view the restaurant menu. I don’t want to let Google know my location before showing me the search results. I don’t want to include a Teams link on the calendar invite. I don’t want to pay 50 different monthly subscription fees for all my software. I don’t want to upgrade to TurboTax platinum plus audit protection. I don’t want to install the Webex plugin to join the meeting. I don’t want to share my car’s braking data with the actuaries at State Farm. I don’t want to text with your AI chatbot. I don’t want to download the Instagram app to look at your picture. I don’t want to type in my email address to view the content on your company’s website. I don’t want text messages with promo codes. I don’t want to leave your company a five-star Google review in exchange for the chance to win a $20 Starbucks gift card. I don’t want to join your exclusive community in the metaverse. I don’t want AI to help me write my comments on LinkedIn. I don’t even want to be on LinkedIn in the first place.
I just want to pay for a product one time (and only one time), know that it’s going to work flawlessly, press 0 to speak to an operator if I need help, and otherwise be left alone and treated with some small measure of human dignity, if that’s not too much to ask anymore.
12
Apropos of nothing
1
25
Stuart Jones ∙ @[email protected] retweeted
I sort of thought the quote couldn’t be that bad in context, but the accompanying video is actually somehow worse than expected
“It’s not really enjoyable to make music now… it takes a lot of time, it takes a lot of practice, you have to get really good at an instrument or really good at a piece of production software. I think the majority of people don’t enjoy the majority of time they spend making music.” Founder of @suno_ai_ @MikeyShulman
Always interesting to hear someone with a completely opposite view to me.
































